Gutenberg EBook of Mental Defectives and Sexual Offenders, by W. H. Triggs, Donald McGavin, Frederick Truby King, J. Sands Elliot doc

The Project Gutenberg EBook of Mental
Defectives and Sexual Offenders, by
W. H. Triggs, Donald McGavin, Frederick
Truby King, J. Sands Elliot, Ada G.
Patterson, C.E. Matthews and J. Beck
This eBook is for the use of anyone
anywhere at no cost and with
almost no restrictions whatsoever. You
may copy it, give it away or
re-use it under the terms of the Project
Gutenberg License included
with this eBook or online at
www.gutenberg.org
Title: Mental Defectives and Sexual
Offenders
Report of the Committee of Inquiry
Appointed by the Hon.
Sir Maui Pomare, K.B.E., C.M.G.,
Minister of Health
Author: W. H. Triggs, Donald McGavin,
Frederick Truby King, J. Sands Elliot,
Ada G. Patterson, C.E. Matthews and J.
Beck
Release Date: July 29, 2006 [EBook
#18932]
Language: English
*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG
EBOOK MENTAL DEFECTIVES AND SEXUAL
OFFENDERS ***
Produced by Jonathan Ah Kit, Cori Samuel

and the Online
Distributed Proofreading Team at

1925.
NEW ZEALAND.
MENTAL
DEFECTIVES
AND SEXUAL
OFFENDERS.
REPORT OF THE COMMITTEE OF
INQUIRY APPOINTED BY
THE HON. SIR MAUI POMARE,
K.B.E., C.M.G., MINISTER OF
HEALTH.
Laid on the Table of the House of
Representatives by Leave.
CONSTITUTION OF THE COMMITTEE.
HON. W. H. TRIGGS, M.L.C.,
Chairman.
SIR DONALD MCGAVIN, KT., C.M.G.,
D.S.O., M.D. (LOND.), F.R.C.S.
(ENG.), DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF
MEDICAL SERVICES, DEFENCE
Department.
SIR FREDERICK TRUBY KING, KT.,
C.M.G., M.B., B.SC. (PUBLIC
HEALTH) (EDIN.), DIRECTOR
DIVISION OF CHILD WELFARE,
Department of Health.
J. SANDS ELLIOTT, ESQ., M.D., BAC.

SURG. (EDIN.), CHAIRMAN OF THE
COUNCIL OF THE N.Z. BRANCH OF THE
British Medical Association.
MISS ADA G. PATERSON, M.B., CH.B.
(N.Z.), L.M. (DUBLIN), DIRECTOR
DIVISION OF SCHOOL HYGIENE,
Department of Health.
C. E. MATTHEWS, ESQ., UNDER-
SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE AND
CONTROLLER-GENERAL OF PRISONS,
&c.
J. BECK, ESQ., OFFICER IN CHARGE
SPECIAL SCHOOLS BRANCH,
Education Department.
Secretary: J. W. BUCHANAN, Esq.
CONTENTS.
PART I.—INTRODUCTORY AND
HISTORICAL.
PAGE
SECTION 1.—Origin and
Scope of Inquiry:
MENTAL DEFICIENCY,
INCREASE OF; NORTH
Canterbury
HOSPITAL BOARD AND
OTHERS SUGGEST
INQUIRY; COMMITTEE,
PERSONNEL; NATURE
OF INQUIRY; PLACES
VISITED AND

INSPECTED; SITTINGS,
DATE AND PLACE OF;
Witnesses
EXAMINED, AND
WORK DONE;
APPRECIATION OF
SERVICES RENDERED;
VALUE OF
Memoranda
SUPPLIED BY SIR
GEORGE NEWMAN,
SECRETARY OF STATE
FOR THE UNITED
STATES, DR. E. S.
MORRIS (TASMANIA),
DR. HELEN
MacMurchy
(OTTAWA), AND DR.
ERIC CLARKE
(Toronto);
Secretarial
Services 2
SECTION 2.—Two
Distinct
Questions: MENTAL
DEFECTIVES AND
SEXUAL PERVERTS,
Comments on 5
PART II.—PROBLEM OF THE
FEEBLE-MINDED.

SECTION 1.—A Menace
to Modern
Civilization:
Feeble-minded,
DANGER OF
Unrestricted
Multiplication;
LOTHROP STODDART'S
VIEWS; AMERICAN
Army,
PSYCHOLOGICAL TEST
OF; RESULTS AND
Deductions
5
SECTION 2.—Heredity v.
Environment:
GENETICS AND
HEREDITY; HEREDITY
AND ENVIRONMENT,
ASPECTS REVIEWED;
Degenerate
FAMILIES, LIFE-
HISTORIES; DR.
Macgregor,
Deductions from his
REPORT; DEGENERATE
STOCKS IMPORTED,
EFFECT OF;
Environmental

FACTOR, IMPORTANCE
OF; PRE-NATAL AND
POST-NATAL CARE,
VALUE OF; HOUSING
Problem;
RELATIONSHIP OF
IMPAIRED NUTRITION,
DEBILITY, AND
Disease to Impaired
CONTROL; DIETETICS
AND CHILD WELFARE;
Picture-shows,
EFFECT ON CHILDREN,
and
Recommendations;
VENEREAL DISEASE
COMMITTEES' REPORT
AS TO EFFECT OF
SYPHILIS, &C.;
DIRECTOR DIVISION
OF SCHOOL HYGIENE,
ATTENTION DRAWN TO
REPORT; EXCESSIVE
COMPETITION, EFFECT
on School-children
6
SECTION 3.—Illustrative
Cases of
Hereditary
Degeneracy: JUKE

FAMILY; KALLIKAK
FAMILY; NEW
ZEALAND CASES
CITED; SIR ROBERT
Stout's Comments
7
Section 4.—Elements of
the Problem: BASIC
Phases,
Registration,
EDUCATIONAL CARE
AND TRAINING OF
Feeble-minded
CHILDREN, OVERSIGHT
AND SUPERVISION;
Educational
CURRICULUM FOR
VARIOUS GROUPS;
Residential
SCHOOLS; FARM AND
INDUSTRIAL COLONIES
for Segregation
11
SECTION 5.—Estimates
as to Numbers of
Mental
Defectives:
Education
Department
Returns;

Retardation,
Problem of; Feeble-
MINDED AND
EPILEPTIC CASES,
Return showing 12
SECTION 6.—Study of
Feeble-minded and
Delinquent
Children: METHODS
EMPLOYED IN OTHER
COUNTRIES; UNITED
STATES OF AMERICA;
NEW ZEALAND; NEED
OF PSYCHOLOGICAL
EXPERTS; TREDGOLD,
Quotation from
14
SECTION 7.—Method of
dealing with
Mental Defectives
in New Zealand
Present Legal
Provision for
Notification and
Education of
Feeble-minded
Children and for
Care of Custodial
Feeble-minded
Adults and

Children:
EDUCATION ACT,
1914; PROVISION OF;
"Feeble-minded,"
DEFINITION OF;
MENTAL DEFECTIVES
ACT, 1911; ENGLISH
MENTAL DEFICIENCY
ACT; PUBLIC
SCHOOLS, SPECIAL
CLASSES; EPILEPTIC
CHILDREN, EDUCATION
OF; OTEKAIKE AND
RICHMOND SPECIAL
SCHOOLS; NATURE OF
INSTITUTIONS AND
TRAINING, WITH
Suggestions;
Caversham
INDUSTRIAL SCHOOL;
WERAROA BOYS'
Training-farm;
COMMITTAL, NATURE
OF; VALUE OF HOME
LIFE IN COMPARISON
with Institutional
14
SECTION 8.—Children's
Courts:
Committee's

Recommendations;
CLINICS FOR PHYSICAL
AND PSYCHOLOGICAL
Examination
17
SECTION 9.—Policy for
the Future:
Notification;
English
COMMISSION, 1908,
BASIC PRINCIPLES
LAID DOWN; REGISTER
OF FEEBLE-MINDED;
EUGENICS BOARD;
DR. GRAY'S
Suggestions;
Psychiatrists,
Suggested
Appointment;
EUGENIC BOARD,
PROPOSED DUTIES
AND POWERS;
DEPARTMENTS TO
CONTROL FEEBLE-
MINDED; MARRIAGE
AND CARNAL
KNOWLEDGE WITH
Feeble-minded;
PARENTS' AND
Guardians'

Responsibilities
17
SECTION 10.—The
Question of
Sterilization:
OPERATIONS, NATURE
OF; X-RAYS, USE OF;
AMERICAN LAWS;
DR. H. LAUGHLIN,
CHICAGO, VIEWS;
CENTRAL ASSOCIATION
FOR MENTAL WELFARE
OF GREAT BRITAIN,
OPINION ON
Sterilization;
EVIDENCE IN SUPPORT
OF STERILIZATION;
Committee's
OPINION AND
Recommendation;
EUGENIC BOARD'S
Powers
19
SECTION 11.
—Segregation 21
SECTION 12.—The
Question of
Expense: COST TO
STATE FOR WANT OF
SUPERVISION, CASE

CITED; HUMANITARIAN
AND NATIONAL
Aspects
21
SECTION 13.
—Immigration:
INTRODUCTION OF
FEEBLE-MINDED AND
UNDESIRABLES FROM
OVERSEAS; MEDICAL
INSPECTION OF
Intending
IMMIGRANTS; SYSTEM
IN FORCE;
Committee's
Suggestions;
Ordinary
PASSENGERS FROM
OVERSEAS, MEDICAL
SUPERVISION OF;
"Prohibited
Immigrants,"
Definition of
22
SECTION 14.—Summary
of Findings and
Recommendations 23
PART III.—SEXUAL
OFFENDERS.

SECTION 1.—Scope and
Origin of the
Inquiry: PRISONS
BOARD, RESOLUTION
PASSED; MEDICAL
AND SURGICAL
Reports;
Indeterminate
Sentence;
Segregation
24
SECTION 2.—Seriousness
of the Evil: SEXUAL
Offenders, Numbers
SERVING SENTENCE;
Government
STATISTICIAN'S RETURN
OF PERSONS
sentenced 25
SECTION 3.—Types of
Offences: SEXUAL
OFFENCES; VARIOUS
CLASSES, WITH
COMMENTS ON;
TYPES FOUND IN
PRISONS; INSPECTOR
OF PRISONS' OPINION;
SEXUAL PERVERTS,
Cure of
25

SECTION 4.—Suggested
Remedies:
Corporal
Punishment;
Inspector-General
OF MENTAL