Truth, lies and the internet a report into young people’s digital fluency docx
Bạn đang xem bản rút gọn của tài liệu. Xem và tải ngay bản đầy đủ của tài liệu tại đây (542.18 KB, 59 trang )
truth, lies and the
internet a report into
young people’s digital
fluency
Jamie Bartlett
Carl Miller
September 2011
!
!"#!$%&'()*&+,-&!$)&(,!)",)!&
"#$%&!'#()*&))!!
+#(*!,%**&( !
-&.)&$/&(!0122!
!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
2
!
3.&4!566&778!-9$&!(%:;)7!(&7&(<&=8!
57!);&!.>/*%7;&(!9?!);%7!@9(AB!C&$97!@#4)7!)9!&469>(#:&!);&!6%(6>*#)%94!9?!9>(!!
@9(A!#7!@%=&*D!#7!.977%/*&!@;%*&!(&)#%4%4:!);&!69.D(%:;)8!E&!);&(&?9(&!;#<&!#4!9.&4!!
#66&77!.9*%6D!@;%6;!&4#/*&7!#4D94&!)9!#66&77!9>(!694)&4)!94*%4&!@%);9>)!6;#(:&8!
54D94&!6#4!=9@4*9#=B!7#<&B!.&(?9($!9(!=%7)(%/>)&!);%7!@9(A!%4!#4D!?9($#)B!%46*>=%4:!!
)(#47*#)%94B!@%);9>)!@(%))&4!.&($%77%948!F;%7!%7!7>/G&6)!)9!);&!)&($7!9?!);&!C&$97!!
*%6&46&!?9>4=!#)!);&!/#6A!9?!);%7!.>/*%6#)%948!H)7!$#%4!694=%)%947!#(&I!
!
J! C&$97!#4=!);&!#>);9(K7L!#(&!6(&=%)&=!
J! F;%7!7>$$#(D!#4=!);&!#==(&77!@@@8=&$978698>A!#(&!=%7.*#D&=!
J! F;&!)&M)!%7!49)!#*)&(&=!#4=!%7!>7&=!%4!?>**!
J! F;&!@9(A!%7!49)!(&79*=!
J! 5!69.D!9?!);&!@9(A!9(!*%4A!)9!%)7!>7&!94*%4&!%7!7&4)!)9!C&$978!
!
N9>!#(&!@&*69$&!)9!#7A!?9(!.&($%77%94!)9!>7&!);%7!@9(A!?9(!.>(.97&7!9);&(!);#4!);97&!!
69<&(&=!/D!);&!*%6&46&8!C&$97!:(#)&?>**D!#6A49@*&=:&7!);&!@9(A!9?!+(&#)%<&!+9$$947!!
%4!%47.%(%4:!9>(!# (9#6;!)9!69.D(%:;)8!F9!?%4=!9>)!$9(&!:9!)9!@@@86(&#)%<&69$$94789(:!
!
!
.+"!,)"*&/")-(!*&
In collaboration with the Nominet Trust
;)).IOO@@@849$%4&))(>7)89(:8>AO !
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
P>/*%7;&=!/D!C&$97!0122!
Q!C&$978!-9$&!(%:;)7!(&7&(<&=8!
F;%(=!R*99(!
,#:=#*&4!S9>7&!
2TU!F99*&D!-)(&&)!
V94=94!-W2!0FX!
F!!1YZ[!Z[Y![\Z\!
R!!101!]TU]!Z012!
;&**9^=&$978698>A!
@@@8=&$978698>A!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
3
)0)/#!(1)&*#22+"3&
F;&!%4)&(4&)!%7!49@!#*$97)!6&()#%4*D!);&!:(&#)&7)!79>(6&! 9?!
%4?9($#)%94!?9(!.&9.*&!*%<%4:!%4!);&!X_!)9=#D8!E&!>7&!%)!)9!(&#=!>.!
94!@;#)!%7!;# &4%4:!%4!);&!@9(*=B!)9!:&)!#=<%6&!#/9>)!);%4:7!);#)!
@9((D!>7B!)9!#(:>&!#4=!69**#/9(#)&B!)9!=&6%=&!@;9!)9!<9)&!?9(!#4=!
@;9!)9!=#)&8
!
F;&!%4?9($#)%94!@&!#66&77!#4=!6947>$&!94!);&!
%4)&(4&)!%7!6&4)(#*!)9!?9($%4:!9>(!#))%)>=&7B!9>(!/&*%&?7B!9>(!<%&@7!
#/9>)!);&!@9(*=!#(9>4=!>7!#4=!9>(!7&47&!9?!@;9!@&!#(&!@%);%4!%)8!!!!
F;&!#$9>4)!9?!%4?9($#)%94!#<#%*#/*&!)9!>7!#)!);&!6*%6A!9?!#!$9>7&!
@;&4!$#A%4:!);&7&!=& 6%7%947!6#4!/&!/9);!*%/&(#)%4:!#4=!
#7.;DM%#)%4:8!5*);9>:;!);&(&!#(&!$9(&!&`/99A7B!)(>7)@9();D!
G9>(4#*%7$B!4%6;&!&M.&()%7&!#4=!#66>(#)&!?#6)7!#4=!?%:>(&7!#)!9>(!
?%4:&()%.7!);#4!&<&(!/&?9(&B!);&(&!#(&!&a>#**D!>4.(&6&=&4)&=!
#$9>4)7!9?!$%7)#A&7B!;#*?`)(>);7B!$%7)(>);7B!.(9.#:#4=#B!
$%7%4?9($#)%94B!=%7%4 ?9($#)%94!#4=!:&4&(#*!4947&47&8!!
,#A%4:!7&47&!9?!#**!);%7!!!A49@%4:!;9@!)9!=%76(%$% 4#)&!);&!:99=B!
(&*%#/*&B!)(>7)@9();D!9(!>7&?>*!%4?9($#)%94!?(9$!);&!/#=!!!%7!
);&(&?9(&!9?!)(&$&4=9>7!%$.9( )#46&8!F;&!#/%*%)D!)9!$#A&!);&7&!
=%??%6>*)!G>=:$&4)7!$#))&(7!)9!&<&(D94&!/>)!&7.&6%#** D!D9>4:!.&9.*&B!
?9(!@;9$!);&!%4)&(4&)!%7!#!$9(&!%$.9()#4)!$&=%>$!);#4!#4D!9);&(!
:(9>.8!!
3>(!(&7&#(6;!7;9@7B!;9@&<&(B!);#)!$ #4D!D9>4:!.&9.*&!#(&!49)!
6#(&?>*B!=%76&(4%4:!>7&(7!9?! );&!%4)&(4&)8!F;&D!#(&!>4#/*&!)9!?%4=!);&!
%4?9($#)%94!);&D!#(&!*99A%4:!?9(!9(!)( >7)!);&!?%(7)!);%4:!);&D!=98!
F;&D!=9!49)!# *D!?#6)!6;&6A7!)9!);&!%4?9($#)%94!);&D!?%4=8!F;&D!#( &!
>4#/*&!)9!(&69:4%7&!/%#7!#4=!.(9.#:#4=#!#4 =!@%**!49)!:9!)9!#!<#(%&=!
4>$/&(!9?!79>(6&78!57!#!(&7>*)B!);&D!#(&!)99!9?)&4!%4?*>&46&=!/D!
%4?9($#)%94!);&D!7;9>*=!.(9/#/*D!=%76#(=8
2
!F;%7!$#A&7!);&$!
<>*4&(#/*&!)9!);&!.%)?#**7!#4=!(#//%)!;9*&7!9?!%:49(#46&B!?#*7&;99=7B!
6947!#4=!76#$78!H4#66>(#)&!694)&4)B!94*%4&!$%7%4?9($#)%94!#4=!
6947.%(#6D!);&9(%&7!K7>6;!#7!);97&!@;%6;!7>((9>4=&=!);&!=&#);!9?!
37#$#!/%4!V#=&4L!#(&!# &#(%4:!%4!);&!6*#77(99$8!!!
F;&!.9)&4)%#*!6947&a>&46&7!9?!);%7!94!796%&)D!#7!#!@;9*&!#(&!
>4A49@48!34&!=#4:&(!%7!);#)!D9>4:!.&9.*&!#(&!$9(&!*%A&*D!)9!/&!
7&=>6&=!/D!&M)(&$%7)!#4=!< %9*&4)!%=N!57!@&!;#<&!#(:>&=!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
4
&*7&@;&(&B!$#4D!)&((9( %7)!:( 9>.7!#(&!?&=!/D!/9:>7!94*%4&!$#)&(%#*!
6%(6>*#)%4:!>46;#**&4:&=!94!94*%4&!&6;9!6;#$/&(78!54=&(7!'(&%<%AB!
);&!(&6&4)!37*9!)&((9(%7)B!%7!#!=&<#7)#)%4:!/>)!94*D!);&!$97)!(&6&4)!
&M#$.*&!9?!);&!.9@&(!9?!%4)&(4&)!$#)&(%#*!)9!(#=%6#*%7&8!!
F;&!#47@&(!%7!49)!:(&#)&(!6&479(7;%.!9(!#!)%:;)&(!694)(9*!9<&(!
%4)&(4&)!694)&4)8!F;&!)#7A!%7!)9!&47>(&!);#) !D9>4:!.&9.*&!6#4!$#A&!
6#(&?>*B!7A&.)%6#*!#4=!7#<<D!G>=:$&4)7!#/9> )!);&!%4)&(4&)!694)&4)!
);&D!@%**B!%4&<%)#/*DB!&469>4)&(8!F;%7!@9>*=!#** 9@!);&$!)9!/&))&(!
%=&4)%?D!9>)(%:;)!*%&7B!76#$7B!;9#M&7B!7&*&6)%<&!;#*?`)(>);7B!#4=!
$%7)#A&7B!#4=!/&))&(!4#<%:#) &!);&!$>(A%&(!#4=!:(&D&(!@#) &(7!9?!
#(:>$&4)!#4=!9.%4%948!!
F;&!#/%*%)D!)9!G>=:&!);&!$&(%)7!9?!=%??&(&4)!.%&6&7!9?!%4?9($#)%94!%7!
49)!4&@b!%)!%7!);&!/#7%7!9?!$>6;!9?!6*#77%6#*!. ;%*979.;D8!S9@&<&(B!
);&!#(6;%)&6)>(&!#4=!?>46)%94#*%)D!9?!);&!%4)&(4&)!$#A&7!);&!G9/!9?!
7&.#(#)%4:!);&!@;&#)!?(9$!);&!6;#??!&<&4!;#(=&(8!5!7.&6%?%6!/9=D!9?!
7A%**7!#4=!A49@*&=:&!%7!(&a>%(&=!)9!$#A&!%4?9($&=!G>=:$&4)78!E&!
"#$%&'$%&$()%*+,-,&./%0/"$1234!)9!=&76(%/&!);%7!69$.&)&46&I!);&!#/%*%)D!
)9!?%4=!#4=!6(%)%6#**D!&<#*>#)&!94*%4&!%4?9($#)%9 48!H) !%7!#!
25)6,1.&,51%50%*5/+4%2(,&,2./%&',17,1-%#7,//#8%#"2'%.#%#5"(2$%
9$(,0,2.&,518%.1+%*1$:4%715:/$+-$%.65"&%'5:%);&!=%:%)#*!@9(*=!
@9(A7B!7>6;!#7!>4=&(7)#4=%4:!7&#(6;!&4:%4&78!F;&7&!#(&!);&!/&=(96A!
7A%**7!4&6&77#(D!?9(!);&!%4=%<%=>#*!)9!>7&!);&!%4)&(4&)!)9!7&#(6;B!
(&)(%&<&B!694)&M)>#*%7&B!#4#*D7&B!<%7>#*%7&!#4=!7D4); &7%7&!
%4?9($#)%94!&??&6)%<&*D8!
E&!>4=&()99A!)@9!4&@!.%&6&7!9?!(&7&#(6;!)9!=&)&($%4&!);&!&M)&4)!9?!
=%:%)#*!?*>&46D!#$94:!D9>4:!.&9.*&!%4!);&!X_8!R%(7)B!@&!(&<%&@&=!
6>((&4)!*%)&(#)>(&!(&*#)%4:!)9!=%:%)#*!?*>&46DB!%46*>=%4:!2]!7>(<&D7!
#4=!9);&(!(&7&#(6;!.#.&(7B!7)>=%&7!#4=!(&.9( )7!>4=&()#A&4!/&)@&&4!
011[!#4=!01218!-&694=B!@&!694=>6)&=!#!7>(<&D!9?![1\!)&( 7!%4!
;1-/.1+%.1+%<./$#%.65"&%&' $%$= &$1&%50%&'$,(%>">,/#4%+,-,&./%0/"$123?%!
!
!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
5
45675689&
@"(%/,&$(.&"($%($9,$:%($9$./$+%&'.&%*+,-,&./%1.&,9$#4%ABC`2Y!D&#(!9*=7L!
#(&!<&(D!694?%=&4)!>7&(7!9?!);&!%4)&(4&)B!/>)!#(&!49)!.#()%6>*#(*D!
69$.&)&4)8!F;&(&!%7!79$&!&<%=&46&!)9!7;9@!);#)!79$&!D9>4:!.&9.*&!
#(&!=%76&(4%4:B!6#(&?>*!%4)&(4&)!>7&(7B!/>)!$>6;!&*7&!);#)!%4=%6#)&7!
);#)!);&!7A%**7!9?!=%:%)#*!4#)%<&7!=9!49)!$#)6;!);&%(!9@4!7&*?`
(&.9()#:&I!!
! !""#$%&'#()*)+%,#&%+) /#("#&"+#%00,'#12.13/#"&#+2.#
)&4"5$%+)"&#+2.'#%11.//6##(9>4=!94&!%4!?9>(!20`2[!D&#(!
9*=7!$#A&!49!6;&6A7! "#!"$$!@;&4!<%7%)%4:!#!4&@!@&/7%)&B!#4=!
*&77!);#4!94&!%4!)&4!#7A!@;9!$#=&!);&!7%)&!#4=!@;D8!
! 7./+2.+)1/#" 5#89%,)+'6#=&6%7%947!#/9>)!%4?9($#)%94!
a>#*%)D!%7!/#7&=!94!7%)&!=&7%:4B!(#);&(!);#4!$9(&!#66>(#)&!
6;&6A7!!!#(9>4=!94&`); %(=!9?!20`2[!D&#(!9*=7!/&*%&<&!);#)!%?!#!
7&#(6;!&4:%4&!*%7)7!%4?9($#)%94!);&4! %)!$>7)!/&!)(>);?>*b!#4=!
BD%>$(%2$1&%+514&%251#,+$(%&'$%9$(.2,&3%50%($#"/&#%6"&%E"#&%9,#,&%
&'$%#,&$#%&'$3%*/,7$%&'$%/557%504?!
! :%13#"4#+.%12)&*6#94*D!94&`);%(=!9?!\`2\!D&#(!9*=7!;#<&!
/&&4!)#>:;)!;9@!)9!G>=:&!);&!(&*%#/%*%)D!9?!94*%4&!
%4?9($#)%948!R%?)D`?%<&!.&(!6&4)!9?!)&(7!7>(<&D&=!%4!011Y!
0$/&%&'$,(%#&"+$1&#%*+,+%15&%'.9$%#"00,2,$1&%"1+$(#&.1+, 1-%50%
@;#)!.*#-,.(,#)%:.#%.1+%:'.&%25"1&#%.#%/$-,&,) .&$%($#$.(2'4?!
'&)@&&4!,#D!2U
);
!#4=!">*D!2U
);
!0122B!C&$97!694=>6)&=!#4!94*%4 &!
7>(<&D!9?!.(%$#(D!#4=!7&694=#(D!76;99*!)&(7!%4!W4:*#4=!#4=!
<./$#%.65"&%&'$,(%9,$:#%51%&'$,(%>">,/#4%+,-,&./%0/"$1238%.1+%'5:%,&%
$%:;)!/&!)#>:;)!%4!76;99*8!!H4!)9)#*B!@&!(&6&%<&=![1\!(&7.947&78!F;%7!
%7!);&!*#(:&7)!7>(<&D!9?!%)7!A%4=!&<&(!694=>6)&=8!!!
F;&!%4)&4)%94!9?!);&!7 >(<&D!@#7!)9!&<%46&!:&4&(#*!#))%)>=&7!@%);%4!
);&!)%4:!.(9?&77%9 4!)9@#(=7!7&<&(#*!);&$&7I!);&!%$.9()#46&!9?!
);&!%4)&(1$&%.1+%+,-,&./%0/"$123%#7,//#F%&'$%$ =&$1&%50%&'$,(%>">,/#4%
6>((&4)!=%:%)#*!?*>&46Db !#4=!); &!7)#)&!9?!=%:%)#*!? *>&46D!@%);%4!);&!
76;99*8!F9!);%7!&4=B!#! 7#$.*&!@%);!#!(̚#/*&!7.(&#=!9?!)&(7!
K/D!7&4%9(%)DB!7>/G&6) !#4=!6*#77`#:&L!#4=!76;99*7!K/D!:&9:(#.;%6#*!
*96#*&B!76;99*`)D.&!#4=!7&6)9(LB!(#);&(!);#4!#!69$.*&)&*D!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
6
(&.(&7&4)#)%<&!.(9?%*&!9?!#**!)&(7!#4=!76;99*7B!@#7!(&a>%(&=8!F;&!
(&7>*)7!9?!);&!7>(<&D!#(&!);&( &?9(&!49)!.&(?&6)*D!(&.(&7&4)#) %<&!9?!);&!
)%4:!.(9?&77%94!#7 !#!@;9*&8!F;&!94*%4&!7>(<&D!$&);9=9* 9:D!#4=!
.>/*%6#)%94!7)(#)&:D!@&!&$.*9D&=!=%=!49)!#**9@!?9(!#!)9)#**D!
(&.(&7&4)#)%<&!7&(%&7! 9?!=%7)(%/>)%947!#4=!.(9.9()%947!@%);%4!);&!
7#$.*&!69;9()8!S9@&<&(B!@&!=%=!# *D!.97)`7)(#)%?%6 #)%94!@&%:;)%4:7!
K#669(=%4:!)9!7>/G&6)7!)#>:;)B!#7!$>(&=!/D!);&!-6;99*!E9(A?9(6&!
+&47>7L!)9!%$.(9<&!(&.(&7&4)#)%<&4&778!H)!%7!@%);!);%7!6#<&#)!%4!
$%4=!);#)!@&!.(&7&4)!);&7&!=#)#8!5!?>**!$&);9=9*9:D!%7!#<#%*#/*&!%4!
);&!#44&M8!!
F;&!?%4=%4:7!%46*>=&I!!
! ;&+.5&.+#+.%12)&*#%&(#,.%5&)&*#)/#49&(%$.&+%,#+"#
!"!#$%&'%()**$'+&(#0.5/"&%,#,) /6#YY!.&(!6&4)!9?!
)&(7!7>(<&D&=!6947%=&(!%4)&(4&)`/#7&=!(&7&#(6;!)9! /&!
,)>5(&.1&%05(%&'$,(%>">,/#4%#2'55/ :5(7F##4=!\[!.&(!6&4)!
(&.9()!);#)!);&%(!.>.%*7!;#<&!/(9>:;)!%4?9($#)%94!%4)9!);&!
6*#77(99$!);&D!;#<&!?9>4=!94*%4&8!][!.&(!6&4)!/&*%&<&!);#)!
%4)&(4&)`/#7&=!694)&4 )!)9!/&!%$.9()#4)!%4!);&!?9($#)%94!#4=!
9./,+.&,51%50%&'$,(%>">,/#4%6$/,$0#?!
! ,-+() %'+ '/* #-0'+1*"2'2)-#.'!"!#$%&'0#3#2+$'
/3),,/6#\\!.&(!6&4)!9?!)&(7#7>( <&D&=#);%4A!);#)!=%:%)#*!
?*>&46D!%7!#4!%$.9()#4)!7A %** !?9(!.>.%*7!)9!.977&77B!/>)##6(977!
.%(.1-$%50%)$.#"($#8%&$.2'$(#%(.&$%&'$,(%>">,/#4%+,-,&./%0/"$123%
7A%**7!#7!/&*9@!#<&(#:&8!H 4!.#()%6>*#(B!);&!#. .*%6#)%94!9?!?#6)`
6;&6A7!9(!9);&(!79>(6&!<&(%?%6#)%94!94!);&!94*%4&!%4?9($#)%94!
);&D!6947>$&B!);&!#/%*%)D!)9!(&69:4%7&!/%#7!9(!.(9.#:#4=#B!
#4=!);&!<#(%&)D!9?!7%)&7!);&D!<%7%)B!#(&!(#)&=!$97)!.99(*D8!
! <)/)&4"5$%+)"&=#05"0%*%&(%=#%&(#1"&/0)5%1'#
+2."5)./#%5.#>.)&*#>5"9*2+#)&+"#+2.#1,%//5""$6#Z]!.&(!
6&4)!9?!)&(7!7>(<&D&=
0
!(&.9()!;#<%4:!&469>4)&(&=!
#(:>$&4)7!@%);%4!*&77947!9(!7>/$%))&=!76;99*@9(A!);#)!
694)#%4!%4#66>(#)&!%4) &(4&)`/#7&=!694)&4)!);&D!(&:#(=!#7!
=&*%/&(#)&*D!.#6A#:&=!/D!);&!.(9=>6&(7!)9!/&!$%7*&#=%4:!9(!
=&6&%)?>*!K?9(!&M#$.*&B!;9*96#>7)!=&4%#*!.#6A#:&=!#7!(#=%6#*!
;%7)9(%6#*!(&<%7%94%7$L8!2Y!.&(!6&4)!(&.9()!); %7!; # &47!94!#)!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
7
*)!#!$94);*D!/#7%78! P&(;#.7!$9(&!7>(.(%7%4:*DB!ZY!.&(!6&4)!
9?!)&(7!7>(<&D&=
T
!(&.9()!;#<%4:!;#=!#(:>$&4)7!%4!6*#77!
@%);!.>.%*7!#/9>)!6947.%(#6D!);&9(%&78!,9(&!);#4!94&!%4!?%<&!
(&.9()&=!);%7!;# &4%4:!94!#!$94);*D!/#7%78!!!
! !.%12.5/#>.,) #" 5?2.,$)&*,'#+2%+#()*)+%,#4,9.&1'#
& (/#+"#>.#*) &#$ "5.#05"$)&.&1.#)&#+2.#
1,%//5""$6#\\!.&(!6&4)!9?!)&( 7!7>(<&D&=!6947%=&(!
=%:%)#*!?*>&46D!)9!/&!#4!%$.9()#4)!7A%**!?9(!D9>4:!.&9.*&!)9!
.977&77b!#4=!YY!.&(!6&4)
Z
!);%4A!%)!7;9>*=!/&!:%<&4!$9(&!
.(9$%4&46&!%4!);&!4#)%94#*!6>((%6>*>$8!
+9$/%4%4:!9>(!7>(<&D!(&7>*)7!@%);!);&!/#6A:(9>4=!*%)&(#)>(&!
(&<%&@B!@&!/&*%&<&!%4?9($#)%94!*%)&(#6D!)%4:!%4!76;99*7!%7!
7)(>::*%4:!)9!A&&.!.#6 &!@%);!);&!(%7&!9?!);&!%4)&(4&)8!F; &!%4)&(4&)!
;#7!/&69$&!6&4)(#*!)9!*&#(4%4:B!/>)!);&!7A%** 7!)9!>7&!%)!# (9.(%#)&*D!
#4=!@&**!;#<&!49)!/&69$&!6&4)(#*!)9!*&#(4%4 :!;9@!)9!*&#(48!
!
":;<==:67>?5<6 9&&
E&!(&69$$&4=!#!$#G9(!6#$.#%:4!)9!.*#6&!=%:%)#*!?*>&46D!#)!);&!
;&#()!9?!*&#(4%4:8!H4!#! 694)&M)!@ ;&(&!D9>4:!.&9.*&!#(&!694?(94)&=!
@%);!7>6;!#!<#7)!#((#D!9?!%4?9($#)%94B!;#<% 4:!);&!7A%**7!#4=!
A49@*&=:&!)9!&<#*>#)&!#4=!#77&77!);#)!%4?9( $#)%94!%7!#!?>4=#$&4)#*!
7A%**!);#)!#**!6;%*=(&4!$>7)!.977&778!F;&!:9<&(4$&4)B!76;99*7B!
%4)&(4&)!69$.#4%&7!#4=!.(9<%=&(7B!6(&#)%<&!#:&46%&7B!*%/(#(%&7!#4=!
.#(&4)7!#**!;#<&!#!(9*& !)9!.*#D8!
@)*)+%,#A9(*$.&+#$9/+#>.1"$. #%#1"5.#0%5+#"4#+2.#B%+)"&%,#
C955)19,9$#%&(#+.%12.5#+5%)& )&*D#F;&!c9<&(4$& 4)!7;9>*=!
,12/"+$%+,-,&./%0/"$123%.#%.%*25($%25)>$&$1234%,1%&'$%G.&,51./%
+>((%6>*>$!=>(%4:!%)7!6>((&4)!(&<%&@8!C%:%)#*!?*>&46D!%7!#!
?9>4=#)%94#*B!69(&!7A%**!);#)!7;9>*=!>4=&(*%&!)%4:!#4=!*&#(4%4:!
#6(977!#**!7>/G&6)7B!#4=!%7!49)!694?%4&=!)9!#!7%4:*&!7>/G&6)8!57!#!
$%4%$>$B!#**!76;99*7!$>7) !)!.>.%*7!#/9>)!7&#(6;!&4:%4&7B!
.(9.#:#4=#!)&6;4%a>&7B!79>(6&!#))(%/>)%94!)&6;4%a>&7B!#4=!);&!(%7A7!
9?!=#)#`7;#(%4:8
[
!5*);9>:;!);&(&!#(&!79$&!.(9$%7% 4:!%4%)%#)%<&7!%4!
79$&!76;99*7B!69<&(#: &!%7!.#)6;D!#4=!)99!$#4D!76;99*7!=9!49)!)!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
8
%)8!c%<&4!);#)!#4!%46(% 4:!4>$ /&(!9?!76;99*7!@%** !/&!9.&(#)%4:!
9>)7%=&!);&!d#)%94#*!+>((%6>*>$B!);%7!%7!79$&);%4:!);#)!#6#=&$% &7!
#4=!?(&&!76;99*7!7;9>*=!#*79!)#A&!94!);&$7&*<&78!F;&!C&.#()$&4)!
?9(!W=>6#)%94!$>7)!#*79!&47>(&!);#)!);&7&!7A%**7 !#(&!)#>:; )!#7!.#()!9?!
)&(!)(#%4%4:!.(9:(#$$&78##
!2.#@.0%5+$.&+#4"5#.(91%+)"&#/2"9,(#A")"51./#?)+2#+2.#
05)-%+.#/.1+"5#%&(#+2)5(#/.1+"5#+"#15.%+.#%#/.+#"4#+.%12.5#
5./"951./D#F;&!$#G9(%)D!9?!)& #6;&( 7!@&!7>(<&D&=!@&(&!;# D!)9!
)!=%:%)#*!G>=:$&4)B!/>)!$#4D!7#%=!);&D!4&&=!);&!$#)&(%#*7B!
7> 9()!#4=!)(#%4%4:!)9!=9!798!-9$&!)&(7!$#D!*#6A!694?%=&46&!%4!
(&*#)%94!)9!);&%(!>7&!9?!H+F!#4=!=9!49)!#*@#D7!;#<&!);&!)%$&!)9!
(&6)%?D!%)8
U
!'9);!);&!C&.#()$&4)!?9(!W=>6#)%94!#4=!%4)&(4&)!
69$.#4%&7!7>6;!#7!c99:*&!#4=!N#;99e!7;9>*=!6(&#)&!$#)&(%#*7!);#)!
6#4!/&!>7&=!%4!);&!6*#77(99$B!#4=!@;&(&!.977%/*&B!)%4:!
#77%7)#46&8!5!/&7.9A&!@&/!.(&7&46&!7;9>*=!/&!6(& #)&=!)9!.(9<%=&!#4!
9<&(#(6;%4:!694)&M)!?9(!=%:%)#*!?*>&46D!)%4:B!9(:#4%7%4:!);&!
*%4A7B!$#)&(%#*7B!*&7794!.*#47!#4=!&M#$.*&7!4&6&77#(D!?9(!6*#77(99 $!
)%4:8!
,%7%4?9($#)%94!9?)&4!);(%<&7!/&6#>7&!%)!%7!$9(&!#))(#6)%<&*D!
.#6A#:&=!#4=!=%77&$%4#)&=!#7!7;#(#/*&B!796%#*!$&=%#`?(%&4=*D!
.(9=>6)78!F%4:!(&79>(6&7!$>7)!>7&!);&!7#$&!)&6;4%a>&7!)9!
)!#7!D9>4:!.&9.*& !>7&I!N9>F>/&!<%=&97B!@&/%4#(7B!%4)&(#6)%<&!
)#7A7!#4=!.9=6#7)78!,9(&9<&(B!%4)&(4&)`/9(4&!$%7%4?9($#) %94!9?)&4!
);(%<&7!94!#4)%`&7)#/*% 7;$&4)!A>=97B!#7!#!@#D!?9(!D9>4:!. &9.*&!)9!
#77&()!%4=&.&4=&46&!9?!$%4=8!5!=%:%)#*!?*>&46D!6#$.#%:4!$>7)!49)!
9<&(*D!%=&4)%?D!@%);!#>);9(%)DB!#4=!7;9>*=!#*79!%46*>=&!$#)&(%#*!); #)!
.(9<%=&!);&!9 9()>4%)D!)9!6(%)%a>&!#4=!=%76>77 !&7)#/*%7;$&4)!K/&!%)!
9??%6%#*B!:9<&(4$&4)!9(!76;99* L!=&6%7%947!9(!#6)%9478!!
E%5.&+/#& (#+"#+% 3.#%#$"5.#%1+) #5",.#)&#$%&%*) &*#%&(#
3"#0#43'2)-#.'()#$0 4&%'*4$#4-'(*4%"5!2#*46'+40'
.&1"95%*.#15)+)1%,#+2)&3)&*D#5!=&6#=&!#:9B!$97)!6;%*=(&4!?%(7)!
&469>4)&(&=!)&6;49*9:D!#)!76;99*! ! !49@!%)!%7!%4!);&!;9$&8
]
!F;%7!%7!#!
=(#$#)%6!6;#4:&B!/&6#>7&!%4)&(4&)!>7&! #)!;9$&!%7!(&*#)%<&*D!
>47>.&(<%7&=!?9(!D9>4:!.&9.*&I!9<&(!;#*?!9?!20` 2[!D&#(!9*=7!7#D!);&D!
*)5#&/3%"#$%&'$%,1&$(1$&%./51$48%.1+%HB%>$(%2$1&%50%>.($1&#%50%&',#% $%
:(9>.!7#D!);#)!);&%(!6;%*=!;#7!#66&77!)9!);&!% 4)&(4&)!%4!);&%(!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
9
/&=(99$B!#!(%7&!?(9$!T2!.&(!6&4)! %4 !011\8
Y
!,#4D!.#(&4)7!);%4A!);#)!
);&!=%:%)#*!@9(*=!%7!#*%&4!)9!);&$!! !#!$D7)&(%9>7!.*#6&!%4;#/%)&=!/ D!
&'$,(%*+,-,&./%1.&,9$4%2 ',/+($1?%I'$3%#'5"/+%15&?%@00/,1$%715:/$+-$%
#4=!6(%)%6#*!);%4A%4:!7 A%**7!.977&77&=!/D!.#( &4)7!#(&!9?!&49($9>7!
(&*&<#46&!%4!#4!94*%4& !7&))%4:B!)998!P#(&4)7!4&&=!)9!/&!.#()!9?!#4D!
6#$.#%:4B!#4=!7;9>*=!7)#()!/D!/&69$%4:!$9(&!?#$%*%#(!#4=!
694?%=&4)!@%);!<#(%9>7!#7.&6)7!9?!%4)&( 4&)!?>46)%94#*%)D!#7!.#()!9?!
&'$,(%2',/+47!:&4&(#*!& =>6#)%94B!#4=!%$.#()%4:!);&!%$.9()#46&!9?!
6#(&?>*B!);9>:;)?>*!&<#*>#)%9 4!9?!%4?9($#)%94B!@;#)&<&(!);&!79>(6&8!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
10
/$+.!)"&@&A&(,!"B-#/!(B,&&
!
,:C&?:;D6<E<8F&&
R&#(!#/9>)!69((>.)%4:!D9>4:B!%4496&4)!$%4=7!#*@#D7!# 669$.#4%&7!
4&@!)&6;49*9:D8!-96(#)&7!%4!J/.&54#%%&"'()*+!?#$9>7*D!@#(4&=!
,1#&%*/$&&$(#48%6$2."#$%'$%&'5"-'&%,&%:5"/+%>(5)5&$%05(-$&0"/ 1$##?%
J$5>/$8%'$%>($+,2&$+8%:5"/+%6$25)$%*&'$%'$ .($(#%50%).13%&',1-#%.1+%
:,//%'.9$%/$.(1$+%15&',1-4?
\
!E;&4!);&!.(%4)&=!/99A!7)#()&=!( 9**%4:!
9??!"9;#44&7!c>)&4/$ (-4#%>($##8%).13%#"#>$2&$+%,&%:5"/+%6$%
*2510"#,1-%.1+%'.()0"/48%59$(:'$/),1-%35"1-%>$5>/$%:,&'%+.&.?
21
!
d&@7.#.&(7B!69$%6!/99A7B!(#=%9B!)&*&<%7%94B!#4=!<%=&9!:#$&7!@&(&!
#**!6*97&*D!#))&4=&=!/D!$9(#*!.#4%67B!@;%6;!K$97)* DL!7>/7%=&=!946&!
.&9.*&!/&6#$&!>7&=!)9!);&$8!F;&!#=<&4)!9?!);&!=%:%)#*!#:&!%7!#7!
(&<9*>)%94#(D!#7!#4D!9?!);&7&!)&6;49*9:%&78 !!
V%A&!);&!.(%4)&=!/99AB!);&!.&(794#*!#4=!796%&)#*!/& 4&?%)7!9?!);&!
%4)&(4&)!#(&!%46#*6>*# /*&8!H)!;#7!=(#$#)%6#**D!@%=&4&=!#66&77!)9!
A49@*&=:&!#4=!%=N!P&9.*&!>7&!%)!)9!&M.97&!:9<&(4$&4)!
69((>.)%948!H)!%7!#!79>( 6&!9?!#=< %6&!#4=!:>%=#46&B!&<&4!69$?9()!#4=!
*9<&8!H)!;#7!/(9>:;)!.&9.*&!)9:&);&(!)9!69**#/9(#)&!%4! 4&@!#4=!
&M6%)%4:!@#D7I!&<&4!)9!;&*.!9<&();(9@!69((>.)!:9<&(4$&4)8!57!
#>);9(7!6&*&/(#)&!9>(!=%:%)#*!?>)>(&!#7!94&!<#(%9>7*D!$9(&!
=&$96(#)%6B!9 (&77%94`?(&&B!&<& 4!.7D6;9*9:%6#**D!>4%)&=!);#4!&< &(!
/&?9(&B!<&(D!?&@!9?!>7!69>*=B!9(!@9>*=!@#4)! )9B!%$#:%4&!#!@9(*=!
&4)%(&*D!9??*%4&8
22
!!
'>)B!*%A&!);&!.(%4)&=!/99AB!);&(&!%7!#*79!#!*9>=&4% 4:!6;9(>7!9?!<9%6&7!
(#%7%4:!);&!#*#($!#/9"&%.%*+.(7$(4%#,+$%50%&'$%,4)&(4&)8!,97)! 9?!);&7&!
6946&(47!(&*#)&!)9!D9>4:!.&9.*&B!7>6;!#7!);&!@%=&!#<#%*#/%*%)D!9?!
.9(49:(#.;DB!6D/&(`/>**D%4:B!%4)&(4&)!.(%<#6DB!#4=!94*%4&!7)#*A&(7!
#4=!:(99$&(78!-9$&!@ (%)&(7!;#<&!.9%4)&=!)9!.977%/*&!*94:`)&($!
=&)(%$&4)#*!'$./&'%$00$2&#%50%51/,1$%#& ,)"/.&,518%#"2'%.#%*&$2'15`
#&($##48%*+.&.%.#>'3=,.&,5148%*,105().&,51%0.&,-"$%#31+(5)$48%
*25-1,&,9$%59$(/5.+48%.1+%*&,)$%0.),1$4?
20
!d%6A!+#((B!?9(!&M#$.*&B!
@9((%&7!);#)!);&!%4)&(4&)!;#7!$#=&!9>(!);%4A%4:!7;#**9@&(!#4=!*&77!
(&?*&6&,9$8%:',/$%K"#.1%L($$10,$/+%#" $#&#%&'.&%&'$%6(.,14#%
Truth, Lies and the Internet
11
*1$"(5>/.#&,2,&34%!!%)7!#/%*%)D!)9!.;D7%9*9:%6#**D!6;#4:&!#669(=%4:!)9!
);&!&4<%(94$&4)!!!,#%.+.>&,1-%&5%&'$%*:5:%.1+%3"274%7&47#)%94#*%7$!
9?!);&!=%:%)#*!@9(*=B!( &7>*)%4:!%4!7;9()!#))&4)%94!7 .#47B!#4!%4#/%*%)D!
)9!&$.#);%7&!#4=!#!7;#AD!7& 47&!9?!%=&4)%)D8
2T
!F;&7&!=&/#)&7!694)%4>&!
)9!(#:&8
2Z
!!
F;&!:9<&(4$&4)!;#7!7)#()&=!) 9!)#A&!49)&B!69$$%77%94%4:!#!7&(%&7!9?!
(&.9()7!#4=!(&<%&@7!#/9>)!%4)&(4&)!7#?&)D8!,97)!49)#/*&!%7!P(9?&779(!
I.13.%M3(514#%CNNO%($9,$:8%:',2'%*&=!=%(&6)*D!)9!); &!7&))%4:!>.!9?!
&'$%PQ%R5"12,/%51%R',/+ ($14#%S1&$(1$&%K.0$&3?
2[
!3);&(!.>/*%6!#4=!
.2.+$),2%:5(7%05//5:$+8%,12/"+,1-%T(%U,1+.%J.>.+5>5"/5#4%($9,$:%
%4)9!);&!7&M>#*%7#)%94!9?!D9>4:!.&9.*&B!#4=!#!?>();&(!?9**9@`>.!
(&.9()!/D!P(9?&779(!'D(948!5!/(9#=!.9*%)%6#*!6947& 47>7!;#7!&$&(:&=!
%4!(&6&4)!D&#(7!);#)!);&!:9<&(4$&4)B!.#(&4)7B!#4=!%4=>7)(D!#**!4&&=!
)9!.*#D!#!(9*&!)9!&47>(&!6;%*=(&4!#(&!7#?&!94*%4&8!!
(6G<H=>?5<6&< I:HE<>7J&&
F;&(&!%7!#49);&(!#7.&6)!9?!);&!=%:%)#*!#:&!);#)!%7!*&77!(&$#(A&=!>.94B!
/>)!G>7)!#7!7%:4%?%6#4)I!; 9@!);&!%4)&(4&)!%7!6;#4:%4:!);&!@#D!.&9.*&!
?9($!/&*%&?7!#4=!$#A& !=&6%7%9478!
H4!011\B!)9!6&*&/(#)&!);&!Z1
);
!#44%<&(7#(D!9?!);&!%4)&(4&)B!);&!
C&?&47&!5=<#46&=!f&7&#(6;!P(9G&6)7!5:&46D!KC5fP5L!(&*&=!)&4!
(&=!@&#);&(!/#**9947!#6(977!4%4&!5$&(%6#4!7)#)&78!H)!9??&(&=!
gZ1B111!)9!@;%6;&<&(!)&#$!69>*=!*96#)&!);&$!#**!?%(7)8
2U
!5?)&(!G>7)!
4%4&!;9>(7!#!)&#$!?(9$!,HF!;#=!7699.&=!); &!.(%h&B!/D!&7)#/*%7;%4:!
#4!94*%4&!.*#)?9($!?9(!<%(#*!69**#/9(#)%94B!.(9$%7%4:!6#7;!?9(!!
.&(794!)9!:%<&!);&$!#!69((&6)!/#**994!*96#)%94B!#4=!7$#**&(!
%46&4)%<&7!?9(!);97&!@;9!;99A&=!);&7&!.&9.*&!%4)9!);&%(!4&)@9(A8!
F;&D!>7&=!R#6&/99A!#4=!F@%))&(!)9!7.(&#=!);&!.(9$%7&!9?!(&@#(=!
?#(!#4=!@%=&8!57!%)!%4)&4=&=B!);&!69$.&) %)%94!7;9@&=!);&!.9@&(!9?!
94*%4&!69**#/9(#)%9 4!@;&4!%)!69$&7!)9!79*<%4:!=%??%6>*)!.(9/*&$7!
a>%6A*D8!R(9$!69$.*&M !<%7>#*!(&69:4%)%94!#*:9( %);$7!)(#@*%4:!
$%**%947!9?!%$#:&7B!)9!796%#*!$&=%#!6#$.#%:47!:&4&(#)%4:!&49>:;!
*'3>$4%5(%*6"VV4%&5%,10/"$12$%&$1 #%50%&'5"#.1+#8%.//!);&!694)&4=&(7!
?96>7&=!94!94*%4&!7)(#)&:%&78!H)!@#7!);&!94*D!@#D!)9!/&!%4!);&!
(>44%4:8!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
12
F;&!.97)`$9()&$!(&<&#*&=!#4!%4)&(&7)%4:!*&77948!F;&!*&#=%4:!)&#$7!
#:(&&=!);&!$#%4!=%??%6>*)D!@#7!49)!:&))%4:!; 9*=!9?!:99=!%4?9($#)%94!
!!%)!@#7!;9@!)9!A49@!@;#)!%4?9($#)%94!)9!)(>7)8!F;&!,HF!)&#$!
(&6&%<&=!$9(&!);#4!011!7> /$%77%947!9?!/#**994!7%:;)%4:7B!94*D!T 1!
9(!Z1!9?!@;%6;!)>(4&=!9>)!)9!/&!#66>(#)&8
2]
!-9$&!@&(&!:&4>%4&!
$%7)#A&7!K9==*DB!#!*#(:&!(&=!494`C5fP5!/#**994!;#. .&4&=!)9!/&!
;#4:%4:!9<&(!f9D#*!3#AB!,%6;%:#4B!94!);&!7#$ &!=#DLB!@;%*&!9);&(7!
@&(&!=&*%/&(#)&!!!);&(&!@&(&!?#*7&!(&.9()7!#4=!?#A&=!.;9)9:(#.;7B!
$9$1%#5>',#&,2.&$+%*/$.7#4 %0(5)%5&'$(%&$.)#?
2Y
!!
F;&!%4)&(4&)!%7!%46(&=% /*D!.9@&(?>*B!#4=!6#4!/&!*&<&(#:&=!%4!
#7)94%7;%4:!@#D7!)9!79*<&!69$.*&M!.(9/*&$78!'>)!%)7!?>)>(&!%7!7)#A&=!
94!;9@!%*D!#4=!&??&6)%<&*D!%4?9($#)%94!#4 =!=%7%4?9($#)%94!6#4!/&!
=%7&4)#4:*&=8!F;&!A&D!)9!;#(4&77%4:!#4=!&M.*9%)%4:!);&!%4)&(4&)!49@!
%7!)9!7.9)!);&!?#A&7I!)9!A49@!;9@!)9!)&**!);&!)(>);!?(9$!);&!*%&7B!#4=!
;9@!)9!4&:9)%#)&!);&!:(&D!#(!9?!69$$&4)B!9.%4%94!#4=!
.(9.#:#4=#!%4!/&)@&&48!
B6E56:&:K59?:=<E<8F&
F;&!%4)&(4&)!%7!49@!#* $97)!6&()#%4*D!);&!:(&#)&7)!79>(6&!9?!
%4?9($#)%94!?9(!.&9.*&!*%<%4:!%4!);&!X_!)9=#D8
2\
!H4!011\B!\2!.&(!6&4)!
9?!.&9.*&!6;&6A&=!#!?#6)!94*%4&B!\1!.&(!6&4)!%4<&7)%:#)&=!)9.%67!9?!
.&(794#*!%4)&(&7)!#4=!]2!.&(!6&4)!*99A&=!>.!);&!=&?%4%)%94!9?!#!
@9(=8
01
!E&!>7&!%)!)9!(&#=!>.!94!@;#)!%7!;# &4%4:!%4!);&!@9(*=B!#4=!
&5%-$&%.+9,2$%.65"&%'$./&'%>(56/$)#%.1+%&',1-#%:$%+514&%)"2'%/,7$%
)9!)#*A!#/9>)!.>/*%6*D8
02
!E&!>7&!%)!)9!$#A&!=&6%7%947!#/9>)!@;9!)9!
<9)&!?9(8
00
!H)!%7!6&4)(#*!)9!?9($%4:!9>(!@9(*=`<%&@7B!9>(!#))%)>=&7B!
#4=!9>(!/&*%&?78!!
F;&!7;&&(!#$9>4)!9?!%4?9($#)%94!#<#%*#/*&!) 9!$#A&!);&7&!=&6%7%947!
%7!&4)%(&*D!49<&*8!E;&4!@&!?%(&!>.!#!/(9@7&(B!@&!6#4!6;997&!?(9$!
9<&(!0[1!$%**%94!=%??&(&4)!@&/7 %)&7B!#4=!2[1!$%**%94!/*9:78
0T
!3<&(!0[!
/%**%94!)@&&)7!@&(&!7&4)!%4!0121B!?9>(!/%**%94!%$# :&7!#(&!;97)&=!94!
R*%6A(B!#4=!0Z!;9>(7!9?!N9>F>/&!?99)#:&!%7!>.*9#=&=!&<&(D!$%4>)&8!
V#7)!D&#(!#*94&B!);&!694)&4)!6(&#)&=!@#7!7&< &(#*!$%**%94!)%$&7!$9(&!
);#4!);&!#$9>4)!9?! %4 ?9($#)%94!%4!&<&(D!/99A!&<&(!@(%))&4,
0Z
!
57!#4D94&!@;9!;#7!7.&4)!&<& 4!#!7$#**!#$9>4)!9?!)%$&! 94*%4&!@%**!
A49@B!);&!a>#*%)D!9?!);%7!%4?9($#)%94!6#4!/&!?#(!?(9$!.&(?&6)8!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
13
5*);9>:;!);&(&!#(&!$9(&!& ` /99A7 B!)(>7)@9();D!G9>(4#*%7$B!4 %6;&!
&M.&()%7&!#4=!#66>(#)&!?#6)7!#4=!?%:>(&7!);#4!&<&(!/&?9(&B!);%7!%7!
#669$.#4%&=!/D! &a>#**D!>4.(&6&=&4)&=!#$9>4)7!9?!$%7)#A&7B!
$%7)(>);7B!.(9.#:#4=#B!$%7%4?9($#)%94B!#4=!9);&(!:&4&(#*!
4947&47&8!54!&7)%$#)&=!Y\!.&(!6&4)!9?!);&!21]!)(%**%94!&$# %*7!7&4)!%4!
0121!@&(&!7.#$`(&*#)&=8
0[
!'D!011\B!);&!-%$94!E%&7&4);#*!+&4)(&!
@#7!#*(&#=D!@#(4%4:!#/9>)!);&!(%7&!9?!&M)(&$%7)!#6)%<%)D!94!);&!
%1&$(1$&%,1%*'.&$%C?N4?%I'$3%$#&,).&$+%&'.&%&'$%1")6$(%50%' .&$%.1+%
)&((9(%7)!@&/7%)&7!;#=! :(9@4!/D!#!);%(=!);#)!D&#(B!)9!9<&(!YB1118!
F;&D!&7.&6%#**D!.9%4)!9>)!);&!&M.*97%<&!:(9@);!#4=!.9)&4)%#*!
%4?*>&46&!9?!7>6;!:(9>.7!94!796%#*!$&=%#B!&7.&6%#**D!R#6&/99A!
:(9>.78
0U
!!
F;&(&!%7!49);%4:!4&@!%4!);&!6;#**&4:&!9?!79()%4:!);&!@;&#)!?(9$!);&!
6;#??8!F;&!#/%*%)D!)9!G>=:&!);&!$&(%)7!9?!=%??&(&4)!.%&6&7!9?!
%4?9($#)%94!%7!);&!/#7%7!9?!94&!9?!);&!9*=&7)!.;%*979.;%6#*!
=%76%.*%4&7!%4!);&!E&7)&(4!)(#=%)%94I!&.%7)&$ 9*9:D8!W.%7)&$9*9:D!
7)>=%&7!);&!4#)>(&!9?!)(>);!!!;9@!@&!#6a>%( &B!>4=&( 7)#4=!#4=!
<#*%=#)&!A49@*&=:&8!-%$.*D!.>)B!@;&);&(!9??*%4&!9(!94*% 4&B!@&!4&&=!
)9!=%7)%4:>%7;!:99=!?(9$!/#=!% 4?9($#)%94!#4=!);#)!( &a>%(&7!);&!
# *%6#)%94!9?!/9);!.&(794#*!)&6;4%a>&7!#4=!7A%**7!);#)!#**9@!94&!)9!
$#A&!#!6#(&?>*B!(̚&=!G>=:$&4)8!
F;&!6&4)(#*%)D!9?!);&!%4)&(4&)!%4!);&!?9($#)%94!#4=!69 47>$.)%94!9?!
%4?9($#)%94!$/!);#)!);&!#/%*%)D!)9!# *D!6#(&?>*!=%76&(4$&4)!#4=!
G>=:$&4)!%7!$9(&!%$.9()#4)!);#4!&<&(8!F;&!#(6;%)&6)>(&B!
?>46)%94#*%)D!#4=!>7#:&!9?!);&!%4)&(4&)!%)7&*?!.(&7&4)7!79$&!49<&*!
=%??%6>*)%&7!#4=!.%)?#**7!);#)!$#A&!G>=:$&4)!&<&4!$9(&!=%??%6>*)8!
F;&7&!%46*>=&I!!
! !2.#%>/.&1.#"4#*%+.F3 0.5/!
S9@!@&!.&(794#**D!=%76&(4!:99=!%4?9($#)%94!?(9$!);&!/#=!
>7>#**D!7)&$7!?(9$!#!7D7)&$!9?!69** &6)%<&*D!6947)(>6)&=!#4=!
7> 9()&=!%47)%)>)%947!#4=!49($78!H4=&&=B!94&!9?!);&!9*=&7)!
0"12&,51#%50%'").1%255>$(.&,51%,#%&5%2($.&$%.%*#52,./%
$>,#&$)5/5-34%&5%5(+$(8%2.&$-5(,#$%.1+%)$+,.&$%,105().&,51%
%4!9(=&(!)9!$#A&!);&!=%??%6>*)!=&6%7%947!#/9>)!@;#)!)9!)(>7)!#!
*%))*&!%&(8!F;&!.&&(`(&<%&@&=!#6#=&$%6!G9>(4#*B!);&!&=%)&=!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
14
76;99*!)&M)`/99AB!);&!7.&6%#*%7)!#4);9*9:DB!#**!#6)!#7!
:#)&A&&.&(7B!&M.&()*D! .97%4:!K#)!*)!%4!);&9(DL!6&()#%4!)&7)7!
9?!<&(#6%)D!#4=!#>);&4)%6%)D!);#)!4&&=&=!)9!/&!.#77&=!/&?9(&!
);&!694)&4)!%7!.&($%))&=!%4)9!);&!.>/*%6!7.;&(&8!,#4 D!9?!);&7&!
;&*.?>*!$&=%#)9(7!#(&!#/7&4)!94*%4&8!3?!69>(7&B!);&(&!#(&!
79$&!<&(D!&??&6)%<&!%4)&(4&)`/#7&=!?%*)&(78!34&!?#$9>7!)&7)!
694=>6)&=!/D!-"#*)'! $#:#h%4&!69$.#(&=!@; &);&(!E%A%.&=%#!
@#7!$9(&!#66>(#)&!); #4!W46D6*9.&=%#!'(%)#44%6#8!F;&!9*=!
$#7)&(!7#@!9??!);&!6;#** &4:&(!!!/>)!49)!/D!$ >6;8
0]
!5*);9>:;!
&'$($%.($%15()#8%#"2'%.#%<,7,>$+,.4#%$+,&,1-%>(52$+"($#8%&'$3%
#(&!$9(&!%4?9($#*!#4=!94!$#4D!7%)&7B!494`&M%7)&4)8!H 4!$#4D!
.*#6&7B!);&!%4)&(4&)!%7!#!*#(:&*D!*#@*&77!#4=!#494D$9>7!#(&4#!
);#)!%7!D!)9!&4)&(B!@;&(&!);&(&!%7!*%))*&!/#6A*#7;!?9(!
7.(&#=%4:!$%7%4?9($#)%94!K#*);9>:;!);%7!$#D!/&!6; #4:%4:L8
0Y
!
F;&!>7>#*!@#D!9?!#6a>%(%4:!*&:%)%$#6D!!!7*%6A!@&/7%)&!=&7%:4!
!!%7!%*D!%4!);&!(&7!9?!$97)!>7&(78!!!!
! 7&"&'$)+'#%&(#+2.#0.()*5 #05">,.$##
d9!7%4:*&!.&(794!A49@7!&49>:;!#/9>)!&<&(D!7>/G&6)!)9!$#A&!
=%(&6)!G>=:$&4)7!#/9>)!);&!)(>);!9(!?#*7&;99=!9?!&<&(D!6*#%$!
$#=&8!H4!#!69$.*&MB!7.&6%#*%7&=!#4=!&79)&(%6!@9(*=B!@&!$>7)!
)(>7)!,1%$=>$(&#?%W5'1%X.(+:,-%2.//#%&',#%&'$%*159,2$Y$=>$(&%
>(56/$)4?
0\
!54!%$.9()#4)!#4=!?>4=#$&4)#*!7)(>)!9?!
$>,#&$)5/5-3%&5+.3%,#%&'$($05($%&'$%.>>/,2.&,51%50%*>$+,-($$%
2(,&$(,.4?
T1
!E&!)(>7)!%4?9($#)%94!/&6#>7&!9?!.&/!.(9<%=&7!%)8!
F;&!%4)&(4&)!.97&7!79$&!7.&6%?%6!6;#**&4:&7!)9!>7%4:!.&=%:(&&!
6(%)&(%#8!,>6;!%4)&(4&)!=%76>77%94!966>(7!%4!.*#6&7 !@;%6;!#(&!
#494D$9>7B!9(!@;&(&!%=&4)%)D!K#4=!);&(&?9( &!#>); 9(%)DL!6#4!
/&!%*D!?#A&=8!P&9 .*&!%46(%4:*D!(&*D!94!<%7>#*!7%:47!9?!
#>);9(%)D8!E%);!#494D$%)DB!.>(<&D9(7!9?!$% 7%4?9($#)%94!
(.($/3%1$$+%&5%*#&.1+%63%&' $,(%63/,1$4?%<',/#&%.%).,1#&($.)%
.>/*%7;&(!$>7)!9/7&(<&!=&?#$#)%94!#4=!*%/&*!*#@B!*&:#*!
7#46)%94!(#(&*D!%4<#=&7!);&!=%:%)#*!?( &&`?9(`#**8!
!
!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
15
! !2.#*.&.5%+)"&%,#()-) (.!
P#(&4)7!#(&!)D.%6#**D!);&!$#%4!:>#(=%#47!9?!%4?9($#)%94B!)9!#!
:(&#)&(!9(!*&77&(!&M)&4)!&47>(%4:!);#)!);&!$#)&(%#*!6;%*=(&4!
6947>$&!%7!#:&`# (9.(%#)&B!69$.(&;&47%/* &B!#4=!#66>(#)&8!
E%);!);&!%4)&(4&)B!);%7 !7>.&(<%7%94!%7!9?)&4!#/7&4)8!ZY !.&(!
6&4)!9?!.#(&4)7!);%4A!);&%(!6;%*=!A49@7!$9(&!);#4!);&$!#/9>)!
);&!%4)&(4&)B!(%7%4:!)9!]1!.&(!6&4)!9?!.#(&4)7!9?!20`2[!D&#(`
9*=78
T2
!34*D!2U!.&(!6&4)!9?!.#(&4)7!69 47%=&(!);&$7&*<&7!
#=<#46&=!%4)&(4&)!>7& (7B!69$.#(&=!)9!T0!.&(!6&4)!9?!
6;%*=(&48
T0
!H4!011[B!#$94:!.#(&4)7B!94*D!94&!%4!);(&&!A4&@!
;9@!)9!7&)!>.!#4!&$#%*!#669>4)B!?&@&(!);#4!#!?%?);!A4&@!; 9@!
)9!7&)!>.!#!?%*)&(B!2\!.&(!6&4)!(&$9<&!#!<%(>7B!20!.&(!6&4)!
=9@4*9#=!$>7%6!#4=!02!.&(!6&4)!?%M!#!.(9/*&$8
TT
!5669(=%4:!)9!
#!(&6&4)!.9**!694=>6)&=!/D!F#*AF#*AB!6;%*=(&4!#(&!7.& 4=%4:!
94!#<&(#:&!9<&(!)@9!;9>(7!#!=#D!94!);&!%4)&(4&)!#4=!.#(&4)7!
.+),&&$+%&'.&%.(5"1+%'./0%50%&'$,(%2',/+($14# %&,) $%51/,1$%,#%
>47>.&(<%7&=8
TZ
!5!4>$/&(!9?!69$$&4)#)9(7!7&&!#!a>#*%)#)%<&!
+,#251&,1",&3%6$&:$$1%&'$%*T,-,&./%G.&,9$#4%.1+%*T,-,&./%
S)),-(.1?
T[
!
! !2.#0/.9("F/)+./#%&(#05"0%*%&(%!
,#4D!@&/7%)&7!#(&!49)!@;#)!);&D!7&&$8!-9$&!#(&!6(&#)&=!?9(!
4&?#(%9>7!&4=7!);#)!#(&!7.&6%?%6#**D!=&7%: 4&=!)9!# &#(!
)(>7)@9();D8!F;&!@&/7%)&B!;)).IOO@@@8$#()%4*>);&(A%4:89(:B!
>"(>5(&#%&5%>($#$1&%*.% &("$%',#&5(,2./%$=.),1.&,514%50%Z.(&,4!
V>);&(!_%4:!"(8B!#4=!%7!#%$&=!7.&6%?%6#**D!#)!7)>=&4)7!@(%)%4:!
&77#D7!?9(!);&!,#()%4!V> );&(!_%4:!C#D!W77#D!+94)&7)8!F;&!
:$6#,&$%,#%.%9$,/$+%.&&.27%51%Q,1-4#%($>"&.&, 51%. 1+%&'$%R,9,/%
f%:;)7!,9<&$&4)!%4!:&4&(#*B!#4=!%7!Ka>%&)*DL!;97)&=!/D!);&!
E;%)&!7>.(&$#6%7)!:(9>.!-)9($R(94)8!F;&!H 47)%)>)&!R9(!
S%7)9(%6#*!f&<%&@!K;)).IO O%;(89(:O[%2/.,)#%&5%6$%.%*151`
.#()%7#4B!494`%=&9*9:%6#*!#4=!494`#$2&.(,.14%05(%($9,#,51,#&%
;%7)9(%6#*!(&7&#(6;8!F;&!<&(D!.#()%7#4B!%=&9*9:%6#*!#4=!
7&6)#(%#4!.7&>=9`;%7)9(%6#*!6 94)&4)!.(9$9)&7!S9*96#>7)!
=&4%#*8!
!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
16
! !2.#9/.#"4#)$%*.5'!
E%);!N9>F>/&B!i%$&9B!R*%6A(!#4=!9);&(!796% #*!$&=%#!7%)&7!
;97)%4:!<%7>#*!694)&4)B!%$#:&!$#4%.>*#)%9 4!)&6;4%a>&7!#(&!
%46(%4:*D!#**9@%4:!$%7%4?9($#)%9 4!)9!/&!.9@&(?>**D!#4=!
#))(#6)%<&*D!.#6A#:&=8!F;&!6947.%(#6%7)!?%*$! 0//+'!1&"23'4!
:',2'%2/.,)#%&'.&%\YBB%:.#%.%*0./#$%0/ 4%.&&.27%>$(>$&(.&$+%63%
&*&$&4)7!9?!);&!X-!%4)&**%:&46&B!/&6#$&!#4!%4)&(4&)!
7&47#)%94B!#))(#6)%4:!$%**%947!9?!<%&@78!F; &!*%)#4D!9?!&((9(7B!
$%7#))(%/>)%947B!<#:>&!%47%4>#)%947B!7>/)*&!$%7a>9)&7!#4=!
9>)(%:;)!?#*7&;99=7!@&(&!$#7A&=!/D!#!699*!79>4=)(#6A!/D!C"!
-A99*DB!#)$97.;&(%6!4 #((#)%94!#4=!$&7$&(%7%4:!< %=&9!
$+,&,1-?%I'$%0,/)4#%9.(,5"#%/,6 $(&,$#%:,&'%&'$%&("&'%'.9$%15:%
/&&4!6#(&?>**D!6#)#*9:>&=B!D&)!%)!%7!49!#66 %=&4)!);#)!);%7!
=&6&.)%<&B!%?!7A%*?>**D!.#6A#:&=B!<%=&9!/&6#$ &!);&!?%(7)!
%4)&(4&)!/*96A/>7)&(8
TU
!,9(&!.(97#%6#**DB!%4&M.&47 %<&!D&)!
;>:&*D!&??&6)%<&!#4=!79.;%7)%6#)&=!%$#:&`&=%)%4:!79?)@#(&!!!
)9!6(9.B!&4;#46&B!9(!9>)(%:;)!#*)&(!%$#:&7!!!&M%7)78!
-9$&)%$&7!&<&4!4&@7.#.&(7!6#4!/&!?99*&=8!H4!">4&!0122B!);&!
d&@7!9?!);&!E9(*=!.#%=!j]1B111!%4!*%/&*!=#$#:&7!)9!
?99)/#**&(!5()>(!'9(>6!#?)&(!@(94:*D!(&.9()%4:!#4!# #(&4)!
%4?%=&*%)D8!5!?(#>=7)&(!?99* &=!);&!.#.&(!@%);!#!?#A&!R#6&/99A!
> $8%6"&%./#5%.%>,2&"($%50%.%).14#%&5(#5%>'5&5#'5>>$+%&5%.++%
#!$94A&D!)#))99B!7,),/.(%&5%M5("24#?
T]
!!
! !2.#.12"#12%$>.5#
F;&!%4)&(4&)!6#4!79$&)%$&7!#6)!#:#%47)!);&!.>( <&D9(7!9?!
$%7%4?9($#)%948!F;&(&!%7!#!<%/(#4)!69$$>4%)D!9?!94*%4&!
=&/>4A&(78!-%)&7!*%A&!;)).IOO@@@8=&/>4A%4:\22869$!#4=!);&!
94*%4&!"9>(4#*!9?!C&/>4A%4:!\O22!;#<&!.9@&(? >**D!6;#**&4:&=!
6947.%(#6%7)!4#((#)%<&78!,#4D!6%)%h&4!G9>(4#*%7)7!=9!);&!7#$&B!
*%4&!/D!*%4&B!?9(!.9.>*#(!#4=!694)(9<&(7%#*!/99A7B!#4=!?%*$78!
H4=&&=B!79$&B!7>6;!#7 !W*%7&!d%6A&(794B!#(:>&!);#)!; 9*96#>7)!
=&4%#*!;#7!/&&4!@&#A&4&=!%4!);&!)(#47?&(!?( 9$!/99A7!)9!);&!
@&/8
TY
!N&)!#7!%4)&(&7)!:(9>.7!#4=!69$$>4%)%&7!9?!?&**9@!
)(#<&**&(7!;#<&!69#*&76&=B!$>6;!9?!);&!%4)&(4&)!;#7!49@!
?9($&=!%7*#4=7!9?!7&:(&:#)&=!9.%4%94!(#);&(!);#4!?*9@7 !9?!
=%77&4)%4:!#(:>$&4)!#4=!&4:#:&$&4)8!E%);%4!);&7&!9?)&4!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
17
?#%(*D!6*97&=!69$$>4%)%&7B!);&!)@9`@#D!?*9@!9?!%4?9($#)%94!
+5$#14&%'.>>$1?%T5-) .&,2%:$6#,&$%.+),1,#&(.&5(#%.1+%05(")%
$9=&(#)9(7!9?)&4!694)(9*!694)&4)!@%);!#4!%(94!:(%.8!
F&6;49*9:%7)7!*%A&!W);#4!k>6A&($#4!#(&!49)%6%4:!);#)!
%4)&(4&)!>7&!%7!49)!&'$ %*0($$%.1+%5>$1%$=2'.1-$%50%
,105().&,514%05(%:',2'%,#%:.#%5(,-,1.//3%2512$,9$+?
T\
!H4)&(4&)!
>7&!%7!'#*A#4%7&=!!!%)!#6)>#**D!6947%7)7!9?!.(&))D!7%$%*#(!)D.&7!
9?!.&9.*&B!)#*A%4:!);&!7#$&!*#4:>#:&B!94!);&!7#$&!A%4=7!9?!
)9.%68!f&6&4)!(&7&#(6;!94!F@%))&(B!?9(!&M#$.*&B!?9>4=!);#)!
*&($1+,1-4%&5>,2#%:$($%$,&'$(%59$(:'$/),1-/3%<',&$%5(%
5?(%6#4!5$&(%6#4!!!#4=!(#(&*D!/9);8
Z1
!5!(&6&4)!7)>=D!
#77&77&=!);&!7)(#)&:%&7!.&9.*&!>7&!?9(!6;997 %4:!4&@7B!#4=!
?9>4=!);#)!);&(&!6&()#%4*D!%7!$9(&!4%6;&!)#(:&)%4:!9?!4&@78!
F;&D!?%4=!)'.&%*94&!6*&#(!$#44&(!%4!@;%6;!);&!%4)&(4&)!
# &#(7!)9!=%??&(!?(9$!9);&(!$#77!$&=%#!%7!);&!=&:(&&!9?!
4%6;&!)#(:&)%4:!9?!.9*%)%6#*!%4?9($#)%94`5(,$1&$+%:$6#,&$#?4
Z2
!!
-585?>E&GEL:6;F&&
F;%7!=9&7!49)!$!);#)!);&!%4)&(4&)!7;9>*=!/&!6&479(&=8!
+94)(9**%4:!);&!%4?9($#)%94 !);#)!.&9.*&!6#4!#66&77!%7!#)!);&!<&(D!
*)!&);%6#**D!=>/%9>7B!#4=B!?(9$!#!.(#6)%6#*!.9%4)!9?!<%&@B!.(9/#/*D!
%$.977%/*&8!,9(&!?>4=#$&4)#**DB!);&(&!#(&!<#(%9>7!#(6;%)&6)>(#*!
.(%46%.*&7!94!@;%6;!);&!@&/!%7!?9>4=&=!);#)! @&!)(#47:(&77!#)!9>(!
.&(%*I!!
! *256')+"$5#74!);&!#/%*%)D!)9!*%4A!)9!#4D);%4:B!);#)!694)&4)!%7!
#66&77%/*&!/D!#4D94&!
! ('8'2#)"$5+"#5/24!35"%+514&%1$$+%."&'5(,#.&,51%0(5)%.1351 $%
/&?9(&!#==%4:!#!.#:&!9(!$#A%4:!#!*%4A!
! #4=!2'#!2'*#)"$5#78%S1&$(1$&%K$(9,2$%J(59,+$(#%2.14&%>($0$(%
79$&!=#)#!)(#47?&(!!!#"2' %.#%&'$,(%2/,$1&4#%!!9<&(!9);&(7B!);>7!
7&(<&(7!;#<&!)9!)(&#)!# **!%4?9($#)%94!);&!7#$&8!!
P(9?&779(!'D(94!%4!;&( !011Y!%4=&.&4=&4)!(&<%&@!;#7!#*(&#=D!*#%=!
9>)!#!.9@&(?>*!&);97!?9(!$#4#:%4:!(%7A!&4)#%*&=!/D!:9%4:!94*%4&I!)9!
);%4A!*&77!#/9>)!);&!%4)&(1$&%*2."#,1-4%'.()8%.1+%)5($%052"#,1-%51%
@;#)!D9>4:!.&9.*&!/(%4:!)9!); &7&!)&6;49*9:%&7B!4#$&*D!&$.9@&(%4:!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
18
D9>4:!.&9.*&!@%);!);&!7A%**7!);&D!4&&=!)9!$#4#:&!);&!(%7A7!&4)#%*&=!
/D!%4;#/%)%4:!);&!=%:%)#*!@9(*=8
Z0
!F;&!94>7!$>7)!/&!94!% 4=%<%=>#*!
>7&(7!)9!# *D!6#(&?>*B!(̚&=!G>=:$&4)78!
F;%7!%7!@;D!);&!6946&.)!9?!=%:%)#*!*%)&(#6D!%7!&M)(&$&*D!%$.9()#4)8!
T,-,&./%/,&$(.23%'.#%6$$1%+$0,1$+%.#%*&'$%#7,//#8%715:/$+-$8%.1+%
>4=&(7)#4=%4:!);#)!&4#/*&7!6(%)%6#*B!6(&#)%<&B!=%76&(4%4:!#4=!7#?&!
.(#6)%6&7!@;&4!&4:#: %4:!@%);!=%:%)#*!)&6;49*9:%&7!%4!#**!#(!9?!
/,0$?4
ZT
!H)!69$.(%7&7!7&<&(#*!= %??&(&4)!&*&$&4)7B!?(9$!&`7#?&)DB!
6(&#)%<%)DB!)&6;4%6#*!7A%**7B!#4=!6>*)>(#*!>4=&(7)#4=%4:8
ZZ
!!
34&!%$.9()#4)!&*&$&4)!9?!=%:%)#*!*%)&(#6D!%7!@;#)!@&!;#<&!)&($&=!
(535#"$!9$*'287I!);&!#/%*%)D!)9!?%4=!#4=!6(%)%6# **D!&<#*>#)&!94*%4&!
%4?9($#)%948
Z[
!F;%7!(&a>%(&7!#!69$/%4#)%94!9?!4&@!#4=!9*=!
)&6;4%a>&7I!#!$%M!9?!);&!6*#77% 6!)(9.&7!9?!#4D!=%76&( 4%4:!;%7)9(%#4!9(!
G9>(4#*%7)!@%);!79$&!<&(D!7.&6%?%6!A49@*&=:&!#/9>)!;9@!);&!%4)&(4&)!
?>46)%9478!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
19
/$+.!)"&M&!&!$)&*!+!)&B4&-(N(!+'&4'#),/3&
<$%'.9$%"#$+%&'$%>'(.#$%*+,-,&./%0/"$1234%&5%+$#2(,6$%&'.&%
69$/%4#)%94!9?!6(%)%6#*!);%4A%4:B!&<#*>#)%<&!7A%**7!#4=!7.&6%?%6!
A49@*&=:&!#/9>)!94*%4&!?>4 6)%947!);#)!#(&!(&a>%(&=!)9!/&!#/*&!)9!
$&&)!;#h#(=7!.#()%6>*#(!)9!); &!94*%4&!(&#*$8!C%:%)#*!? *>&46D!(&?&(7!)9!
);&!7A%**7!4&6&77#(D!?9(!);&!%4=%<%=>#*!)9!>7&!);&!%4)&(4&)!)9!7&#(6;B!
(&)(%&<&B!694)&M)>#*%7&B!#4#*D7&B!<%7>#*%7&!#4=!7D4); &7%7&!
%4?9($#)%94!&??&6)%<&*D8!H)!;#7!);(&&!69$.94&4)7I!
! -'#:+"6652'++B!#!.(#6)%6#*!>4=&(7)#4=%4:!9?!); &!@#D!); &!
%4)&(4&)!@9(A7B!?9(!%47 )#46&!!!);&!/#7%67!9?!;9@!7&#(6;!
&4:%4&7!(&)>(4!(&7>*)7B!;9@!>7&(`:&4&(#)&=!?&&=/#6A!
?>46)%947B!;9@!@&/`7%)&7!#(&!=&7%:4&=!#4=!/>%*)B!; 9@!%=&4)%)D!
6#4!/&!&7)#/*%7;&=!#4=!?#A&=B!;9@!%$#:&7!#4=!<%=&97!6#4!/&!
#*)&(&=8!
! 1)5#58"$!'6"$*"#56'!#'8&25; *'+B!);&!A49@*&=:&!#4=!>7&!9?!
/#7%6!6;&6A7B!)&6;4%a> &7!#4=!.(%46%.*&7!);#)!6#4!/&!# *%&=!)9!
#77&77!);&!)(>7)@9();%4&77!#4=!#66>(#6D!9?!%4?9($#)%948!
F;&7&!#(&!/9);!:&4&(#*!6( %)%6#*!);%4A%4:!7A%**7!K7>6;!#7!
@;&);&(!>7&(7!?#6)`6;&6AB!)(%#4:>*#)&!79>(6&7B!>4=&(7)#4=!);&!
=%??&(&46&!/&)@&&4!a>#*%)D!9?!&<%=&46&B!7&#(6;!?9(!
.(9<&4#46&B!9(!=%7)%4:>%7; !/&)@ &&4!=%??&(&4)!a>#*%)%&7!9?!
%4?9($#)%94L!#4=!7.&6%?%6!94*%4&!7A%**7!7>6;!#7!;9@!?%*)&(!
>(5-(.))$#%:5(78%'5:%&5%).7$%9,+$5#%.1+%<,7,>$+,.4#%
.(96&77!9?!.&&(`&=%)%4:8!
! <56')+5#7B!&'$%$=&$1&%&5%:',2'%"#$(#4%51/,1$% 251#")>&,51%,#%
/(9#=B!<#(%&=!#4=!=%<&(7&8!C9!>7&( 7!#66&77!#4=!6947>$&!
=%??&(&4)!#4=!69$.&)%4:!.%&6&7!9?!%4?9($#)%94l!5(&!);&D!
#@#(&!9?!);&!69:4%)%<&!/%#7&7!); #)!@ &!#(&!&M.97&=!)9l!+#4!
>7&(7!%=&4)%?D!);&!"!=)5/)5!%=&9*9:%6#*!/#7%7!9?!#!.#()%6>*#(!
69$$&4)!9(!9.%4%94!.%&6&B!#4=!.*#6&!%)!@ %);%4!);&!@%=&(!
?#/(%6!9?!#!=&/#)&l!5( &!);&D!#@#(&!9?B!#4=!=9!);&D!>7&B!);&!
@&/7%)&7!);#)!;#<&!:(9@4!>.!7.&6%?%6#**D!)9!69>4)&(!);&!>(/#4!
*&:&4=7B!;9#M&7!#4=!76#$7!);#)!);&!%4)&(4&)!;#7!#**9@&= !)9!
/*99$l
ZU
!!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
20
!
E&!;#<&!694=>6)&=!#4!&M)&47%<&!( &<%&@!9?!&<%=&46&B!@; %6;!#**9@7!
>7!)9!7&)!9>)!);&!7)#)&!9?!=%:%)#*!?*>&46D!%4!);&!X_!)9=#D!#*94:!);&7&!
);(&&!69$.94&4)78!H4!79$&!#(B!);&(&!%7!#!*#6A!9?!(&* &<#4)!=#)#!/>)!
,1%5&'$(#%&'$($%.($%9$(3%-55+%+.&.8%#"2'%.#%,1%@02 5)4#%+,-,&./%
*%)&(#6D!7>(<&D78!H4!)9)#*B!@&!&M#$%4&=!2]!.%&6&7!9?!(&7&#(6;B!
694=>6)&=!%4!);&!X_!K @%);!79$&!7> *&$&4)#(D!.#.&(7!?(9$!);&!
X-L!/&)@&&4!011[!#4=!01228!!!
!
,:?A9>II56:99&&&
_49@%4:!;9@!);&!%4)& (4&)!@9(A7!%7!%$.9()#4)8!C%:%)#*!?*>&46D!(&*%&7!
94!>4=&(7)#4=%4:!;9@!@&/7%)&7!#(&!$#=&!K#4=!69.%&=LB!;9@!)9!
6;&6A!@;9!;97)7!#!@&/7%)&B!;9@!7&#(6;!&4:%4&7!# *D!494`4&>)(#*!
.(96&77&7!)9!?%4=!D9>!%4?9($#)%94B!);&!#/%*%)D!)9!(&69:4%7&!#>);&4)%6!
@&/7%)&7!?(9$!?#A&=!94&7B!;9@!.%6)>(&7!#4=!<%=&9!?99)#:&!6#4!/&!
$#4%.>*#)&=B!;9@!);&!.(9<&4#46&!9?!>7&(`:&4&(#)&=!694)&4)!6#4!/&!
)(#6&=8!!
-&#(6;!&4:%4&7!#(&!9?!.#()%6>*#(!%$.9()#46&B!/&6#>7&!9?!);&!6&4)(#*!
(9*&!);&D!.*#D!%4!.(%9(%)%7%4:!);&!%4?9($#)%94!); #)!.&9.*&!<%&@8!
-&#(6;!&4:%4&7!(#4A!(&7>*)7!%4!=%??&(&4)!@#D7B!#4=!%)!%7!%$.9()#4)!)9!
>4=&(7)#4=!#)!*)!);&!(>=%$&4)7!9?!;9@!);&D!@9(A8!R%(7)B!7&#(6;!
7A%**7!#(&!%$.9()#4)I!7>/)*&!=%??&(&46&7!%4!);&!7&$#4)%6!6947)(>6)%94!
9?!7&#(6;!a>&(%&7B!%46*>=%4:!);&!9(=&(%4:!9?!'99*!9.&(#)9(7B!);&!
>7&!9?!7D494D$7B!#4)94D$7!#4=!#//(&<%#)&7!6#4!(&)>(4!;>:&*D!
+,00$($1&%($#"/&#?%K$251+8%,&4#%,#%,)>5(&.1&%&5%715:%&'$%1.&"($%50%&'$%
(&)>(47!)9!);&7&!7&#(6;&78!F;&!$&6;#4%7$7!9?!7&#(6;!& 4:%4&7!6#4!/&!
!!#4=!9?)&4!#(&!/D!Pf!#:&46%&7!!!$#4%.>*#)&=!)9!%4?*#)&!); &!
(&*&<#46&!9?!@&/7%)&7B!#!*%))*&!*%A&!#4!#=<&()%7&(!;%G#6A%4:!);&!C&@&D!
C&6%$#*!-D7)&$8!F;&(&!%7!#*79!#!69$$&(6% #*!&*&$&4)!)9!@&/.#:&!
(.17,1-8%.1+%#$.(2'%$ 1-,1$#%50&$1%500$(%*#>51#5($+%/,17#4%&5%:$6#,&$#%
);#)!.#D!)9!/&!&*&<#)&=8!C%??&(&4)!7&#(6;!&4:%4&7!# *D!=%??&(&4)!
$&6;#4%7$7!)9!7&#(6;!=%??&(&4)!%4=&M&7!#4=!);&(&?9(&B!9?!69>(7 &B!
(&)>(4!=%??&(&4)!(&7>*)78
Z]
!d9!7&#(6;!&4:%4&!.(9=>6&7!#!4&>)(#*B!
=&?%4%)%<&B!9(!(&.(&7&4)#)%<&!(&?*&6)%94!9?!@;#)!%7!94!); &!%4)&(4&)8!!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
21
H)!%7!49)!6*&#(!);#)!);%7!25)>/$=,&3%,#%($0/$2&$+%,1%>$5>/$4#%
>4=&(7)#4=%4:!9?!7&#(6;!&4:%4&78!ZZ!.&(!6&4)!9?!20`2[!D&#(!9*=7!@;9!
>7&!7&#(6;!&4:%4&7!$#A&!79$&!)D.&!9?!6(%)%6#*!G>=:$&4)!#/9>)!
7&#(6;!&4:%4&!(&7>*)7B!);%4A%4:!);#)!79$&!9?!); &!7%)&7!(&)>(4&=!@%**!
/&!)(>);?>*!@;%*&!9);&(7!$#D!49)!/&8!S9@&<&(B!T2!.&(! 6&4)!/&*%&<&!
);#)!%?!#!7&#(6;!&4:%4&!*%7)7!%4?9($#)%94!);&4!%)!$>7)!/&!)(>);?>*!#4=!
BD%>$(%2$1&%+514&%251#,+$(%&'$%9$(.2,&3%50%($#"/&#%6"&%E"#&%9,#,&%&'$%
#,&$#%*&'$3%/,7$%&'$%/557%504?%I'$#$%>(5>5(&,51#%'.9$%15&%2'.1-$+%
7%46&!011\B!7>::&7)%4:!);#)!4&#(*D!;#*?!9?!20`2[!D&#(!9*=7!@;9!>7&!
7&#(6;!&4:%4&!@&/7%)&7!#(&!49)!6( %)%6#**D!#@#(&!9?!);&!.(9<&4#46&!9?!
,&#%251&$1&?]
ZY
!5!)&(!%4)&(<%&@&=!/ D!C&$97!?9(!);%7!(&7&#(6;!
69$$&4)&=!);#)I!
>#!."+!2/#58'"?$'!#&"#!#&'7!@#&'!8&5$()'2A!./*$ (!"$."7+!3/!9/)!.&"#'6')!
8"B'!*=!95)+#!/2!#&'!@+'")8&!'2352'A!&5 #!$5+#4!"2(!#"C'!#&"#!"+!"!#/#"$!9"8#,!!
KH+F!+9`9(=%4#)9(B!W4?%&*=L!
!
/H5?5;>E&:I>EL>?5I:&?:;D65OL:9& &
577&77%4:!94*%4&!%4?9($#)%94!?9(!#66>(#6D!9(!)(>7)@9();%4&77!
=&.&4=7!94!/9);!6*#77%6!)& 6;4%a>&7!9?!?#6)`6;&6A%4:! #4=!4&@B!
79$&)%$&7!a>%)&!7.&6%?%6B!7A%**7!);#)!# *D!);&7&!)&6;4%a>&7!)9!);&!
%4)&(4&)8!
H4!011\B!%4)&(4&)!>7&(7!(#)&=!);&!(&*%#/%*%)D!#4=!#66>(#6D!9?!);&!
%4)&(4&)!T8U!9>)!9?![8!F;%7!69$.#(&7!)9!#!T8[!?9( !)&*&<%7%94B!#!T8[!?9(!
(#=%9!#4=!#!08\!?9(!4&@7.#.&(7B!$#A%4:!);&!%4)&(4&)!);&!$97)!
)(>7)&=!$&=%>$8
Z\
!P(9<%=&(7!9?!%4)&(4&)!7&(<%6&7!#(&!$9(&!)(>7)&=!
);#)!);&!.&9.*&!(>44%4:!:9<&(4$&4)B!(>44%4:!4&@7.#.&(7!9(!
(>44%4:!$#G9(!69(.9(#)%9478
[1
!
C%:%)#*!4#)%<&7!#(&!&7.&6%#**D!<>*4&(#/*&!)9!9<&(`&7)%$#)%4:!);&%(!
6(%)%6#*!#/%*%)%&7!K#4=!);&(&?9(&!:&)!=>.&=L!/&6#>7& !&M.&(%&46&!#4=!
>7&!9?!);&!%4)&(4&)!7&&$7!)9!/&!);&!.(%$#(D!?#6)9(!%4!7; #.%4:!)(>7)!%4!
);&!%4)&(4&)8
[2
!R9(!=%:%)#*!4#)%<&7B!);97&!@;9!;#<&!:(9@4!>.!@%);!);&!
=%:%)#*!@9(*=B!)(>7)!%7!;%:;8!c&4&(#**DB!%4)&(4&)!>7&(7!)(>7)!%4!);&%(!
9@4!&<#*>#)%<&!7A%**7I!Y\!.&(!6&4)!?&*)!?#%(*D!9(!< &(D!694?%=&4)!%4!
);&%(!>7#:&8!!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
22
'>)!);%7!694?%=&46&!$%:;)!/&!$%7.*#6&=8!34*D!TT!.&(!6&4)!9?!\`2\!
D&#(!9*=7!;#<&!/&&4!)#>:;)!;9@!)9!G>=:&!);&!(&*%#/%*%)D!9?!94*%4&!
%4?9($#)%948
[0
!H4!011[B!T1!.&(!6&4)!9?!\`2\!D&#(!9*=!.>.%*7!(&.9()!
;#<%4:!(&6&%<&=!49!*&77947!#)!#**!94!>7%4:!);&!%4)&(4&)8
[T
!!
,#4D!D9>4:!.&9.*&!=9!49)!A49@!;9@!%*D!);&D!6#4!/&!
$#4%.>*#)&=B!#4=!=9!*%))*&!)9!&47>(&!);#)!);&D!#(&!49)8!3 4&!(&6&4)!
7>(<&D!#7A&=!@;#)!6;&6A7!6;%*=(&4!#:&=!20`2[ !@;9!>7&!);&!%4)&(4&)!
#)!;9$&!# *D!/&?9(&!<%7%)%4:!#!4&@!@&/7%)&8!5( 9>4=!#!a>#()&(!7#%=!
);&D!$#=&!49!6;&6A7!#)!#**8!34*D!Y!.&(!6&4)!9?!20`2[!D&#(!9*=!6;&6A!
@;9!6(&#)&=!);&!7%)&!#4=!@; Db!94*D!2]!.&(!6&4)!69$.#(&!%4?9($#)%94!
#6(977!7%)&7b!#4=!0U!.&(!6&4)!#7A!79$&94&!&*7&!%?!);&D!;#<&!/&&4!)9!
);&!@&/7%)&8
[Z
!
I'$%*2'$27#4%&'.&%.($%).+$%2.1%6$%#">$(0,2,./^ %#"2'%.#%:'$&'$(%&'$%
@&/7%)&!*99A7!#4=!?&&*7!*&:%)%$#)&8!f&7&#(6;!;#7!(&<&#*&=!
%4?9($#)%94!a>#*%)D!=9&7!49)!# &#(!)9!/&!9?!7%:4%?%6#46&!)9!$#4D!
=%:%)#*!4#)%<&7B!#4=!);#)!=&6%7%947!#/9>)!%4?9($#)%94!a>#*%)D!%7!
/#7&=!94!7%)&!=&7%:4B!(#);&(!);#4!$9(&!#66>(#)&!6;&6A78
[[
!!
F(>7)!%4!);&!%4)&(4&)!%7!49)!#/79*>)&!#4=!>4(&7&(<&=!9?!69>(7&8!5!
011[!7)>=D!7;9@&=!);#)!TY! .&(!6&4)!9?!.>.%* 7!#:&=!\`2\!)(>7)!$97)!
9?!);&!%4?9($#)%94!9?!);&!%4)&(4&)B!Z\!.&(!6&4)!)(>7)!79$&!9?!%)B!#4=!
94*D!21!.&(!6&4)!#(&!7A&.)%6#*!#/9>)!$>6;!9?!);&!%4?9($#)%94!
94*%4&8
[U
!34&!7)>=D!7;9@&=!);#)!@;%*7)!.&9.*&!(#)&=!);&%(!
694?%=&46&!%4!);&!(&*%#/%*%)D!9?!94*%4&!%4?9($#)%94!#7!U!9>)!9?!2 1B!
94*D!T!.&(!6&4)!9?!(&7. 94=&4)7!&M.(&77&=!)9)#*!694? %=&46&B!
7>::&7)%4:!(&69:4%)%94!9?!79$&!9?!);&!.977%/*&!/%#7&7!#4=!
%4#66>(#6%&78
[]
!
+;%*=(&4!#(&!#*79!#/*&! )9!(>=%$&4)#(%*D!=%76&(4!a>#*%)D!9?!
%4?9($#)%948!R9(!&M#$ .*&B!% 4!);&!Y`22!#4=!20`2[!#:&!:(9>.7B!
6;%*=(&4!#(&!$9(&!*%A&*D!)9!/&*%&<&!);#)!=96>$&4)#(D!9(!4&@7!
.(9:(#$$&7!#(&!#!/&))&(!(&?*&6)%94!9?!(&#*!*% ?&!);#4!(&#*%)D!Fi!
.(9:(#$$&7!7>6;!#7!'%:!'(9);&(8
[Y
!-9$&);%4:!7%$%*#(!966>(7!
94*%4&B!)998!20`2[!D&#(!9*=7!#(&!$9( &!*%A&*D!)9!/&*%&<&!);#)!$97)!9?!
);&!%4?9($#)%94!#<# %*#/*&!94!4&@7!7%)&7! %7!)(>&!KY]!.&(!6&4)L!#4=!
7%)&7!>7&=!?9(!;9$&@9(A!KYY!.&(!6&4)LB!);#4!/*9:7!9(!>7&(!:&4&(#)&=!
7%)&7!KZY!.&(!6&4)L8!F;&(&!#(&!49!=%??&(&46&7!%4! /&*%&?!/D!:&4=&(!9(!/D!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
23
796%9`&6949$%6!:(9>.!#4=!);&(&!;#7!/&&4!49!6;#4:&!%4!#))%)>=&7!
#$94:!20`2[!D&#(!9*=7!7%46&!011\8
[\
!
f&7&#(6;!694=>6)&=!/D!R>)>(&*#/!7>::&7)&= !);#)!)&(7!#(&!
,12($.#,1-/3%25)>/.,1,1-%50%*2"&%.1+%>.#&$%#31+(5)$4%!!@;&(&!
7)>=&4)7!#(&!7)(>::*%4:!)9!?%4=!%4?9($#)%94! 94*%4&B!#4=!#(&!7%$.*D!
69.D%4:!6;>4A7!9?!%4?9($#)%94!);#)!%7!94*D!<#:>&*D!(&*&<#4)B!#4=!
@%);!@;%6;!);&D!;#<&! 49)!&4:#:&=8
U1
!57%=&!?(9$!9);&(!%77>&7!!!);%7!
%7!#!$#G9(!.(9/*&$!%4!(&*#)%94!)9!.*#:%#(%7$8![[!.&(!6&4)!9?!)&( 7!
#"(9$3$+%,1%CNNO%0$/&%&'$,(%#&"+$1&#%*+,+%15&%'.9$%#"0 0,2,$1&%
>4=&(7)#4=%4:!9?!@; #)!.*#:%#(%7$!@#7!#4=!@;#)!69>4)7!#7!
/$-,&,).&$%($#$.(2'4?
U2
!!
F;&(&!#(&!#*79!7>::&7)%947!);#)!);&!=%??&(&4)!@#D!@&!6947>$&!
%4?9($#)%94!94!);&!%4)&(4&)!$%*%)#)&7!#:#%47)!);&!6(%)%6#*%)D!9?!=&&.B!
7%4:*&`#5"(2$%($.+,1-?%<$%*65"12$48%9,#,&,1-%51/3%51&!)9!);(&&!.#:&7!
?(9$!);&!);9>7#4=7!);#)!#(&!#<#%*#/*&B!.(9.&**&=!#*94:!/D!.9@&(?>*!
#$.(2'%$1-,1$#?%<$%./#5%*#7,&&$(48%9,$:,1-%)5($%&'.1%($.+,1-?%_1%
#()%6*&!%7!94!#<&(#:&!<% &@&=!?9(!#(9>4=!?%<&!$ %4>)&7B!#4=!7>$$#(%&7!
#(&!(&#=!$>6;!$9(&!);#4!);&!?>**!694)&4)8!F;&!>7&(!$9<&7!
;9(%h94)#**D!#6(977!);&!%4)&(4&)B!@%);!?(&a>&4)!# 4=!*%:;)!694)#6)7!
(#);&(!);#4!.(9:(&77%<&*D!=&& .&(!( &7&#(6;!9?!#!7%4:*&!79>(6&8
U0
!F;%7!
,#%*.##52,.&,9$4%(.&'$(%&'.1%*/,1$.(4 %&',17,1-?
UT
!!!
)I57:6;:P&75I:H95?F&>67&I>H5:?F&&
H)!%7!#4!&77&4)%#*!#4=!>4=&(*D%4:!)&4&)!9?!);&!.;%*979.;D!9?!76%&46&!
);#)!)9!&7)#/*%7;!#!(>*&B!@&!$>7)!)(D!)9!.(9<&!%)!?#*7&8!F;%7!%7!_#(*!
J5>>$(4#%0.)5"#%*0./#,0,.6,/,&34%&$#&?
UZ
!X5:$9$(8%>$5>/$%+514&%./:.3#%
@9(A!*%A&!);#)8!H4!?#6)B!@&!)&4=!)9!=9!);&!.(&6%7&!9 97%)&8
U[
!
d>$&(9>7!7)>=%&7!;#<&!7;9@4!);#)!@&!7&#(6;!? 9(!&<%=&46&!)9!.(9<&!
9>(!);&9(%&7B!#4=!@#4)!)9!/&*%&<&!@&!;#<&!?9>4=!%)b!);#)!@&!#(&!$9(&!
#@#(&!9?!?*#@7!%4!7)>= %&7!);#)!.(&7&4)!&<%=&46&!);#)!6;#**&4:&!9>(!
/&*%&?7!);#4!);97&!);#)!694?%($!);&$b!#4=!);#)!@&!#(&!% 4?* >& 46&=!
&49($9>7*D!/D!@;#)!.&9.*&!#(9>4=!>7!#(&!7#D%4:!#4=!=9%4:8
UU
!H4!
7;9()B!@;&4!%)!69$&7!)9!#77&77%4:!%4?9($#)%94!#4=!#((%<% 4:!#)!
=&6%7%947B!;>$#4!/&%4:7!#(&!<&(D!(#(&*D!&4)%(&*D!*9:%6#*B!=&=>6)%<&!
#4=!(#)%94#*8!
Truth, Lies and the Internet
24
I'$%'").1%>($+,/$2&,51%05(%*'5)5>',/34%!!) ;&!.(%46%.*&!);#)!
7%$%*#(%)D!/(&&=7!6944&6)%94!!!%4!796%#*!4&)@9(A7!:&4&(#**D!%7!@&**!
&<%=&46&=8
U]
!-96%#*!$&=%#!$#D!&M#6&(/#)&!);&!.(9/*&$8!!34&!9?!);&!
@#D7!%4!@;%6;!.&9.*&!$#4#:&!);&%(!%4)&(4&)!6947>$.)%94!%7!);(9>:;!
&'$%*#52,./%:$64%!!#!7&*&6)%94!9?!?%*)&(%4:B!:(#=%4:!#4=!9(=&(%4:!7%)&78!
F;&(&!#(&!$#4D!4&@!.(9:(#$$&7!#4=!?%*)&(7!);#)!;&*.!.&9.*&!)9!
=%7)%4:>%7;!/&)@&&4!% 4?9($#)%94!9?!<#(D%4:!a>#*%)D8 !+#77!->47)&%4!
;#7!#(:>&=!);#)!.&9.*&!%46(%4:*D!)#%*9(!);&%(!9@4!6947>$.)%94!)9!
$#)6;!);&%(!.(&?&(&46&7B!#!4&@!?9($!9?!4&@7.#.&(!;&!6#**7!);&!<"5$7!
D',
UY
!!
F;&!:&4&(#*!)(&4=!)9@#(=!%4)&(4&)!.&(794#*%7#)%94!$/!@&!#(&!
7&&%4:!);&!E/)$(!E5( '!D'!)998!;/,%J.(,#$(4#%/.&$#&%:5(78%0 5(%
%47)#46&B!%4=%6#)&7!);#)!#7!7&#(6;!&4:%4&7B! 94*%4&!(&)#%*&(7!#4=!796%#*!
$&=%#!%46(%4:*D!?%*)&(!#669(=%4:!)9!);&%(!%4)%$#)&!%47%:;)!9?!@;9!
@&!#(&!#4=!@;#)!@&!*%A&B!@&!%46(%4:*D!*%<&!%4!9>(!9@4B!6>7)9$`
).+$%*0,/&$(%6"66/$#48%5(%.%*"1,`"$%"1,9$(#$%50%,105().&,51%05( %$.2'%
50%"#4?
U\
!
'&%4:!7>((9>4=&=!/D!:#)& ` A&&.&(7!.(&`&$.)%4:!9>(!=&6%7%947!#/9>)!
);&!A%4=7!9?!%4?9($#)%94!@&!@#4)!)9!7&&!!!@ ;#)!P#(%7&(!6#**7!
*,19,#,6/$%."&5`>(5> 1+.4%!!;#7!7&(%9>7!6947&a>& 46&78!F;&!
.977%/%*%)D!9?!7&(&4=%.%)D!!!9?!?9()>%)9>7*D!7)>$/*%4:!#6(977!
#5)$&',1-%51$%+,+14&%$=>$2&%!!=&6(&78!c99:*&!%7!=&<&*9.%4:!#!
-&(&4=%.%)D!-&#(6;!W4:%4&B!#*);9>:;!);%7!7&&$7!)9!6947)%)>)&!
c99:*&!A49@%4:!&49>:;!#/9>)!9>(!.(&?&(&46&7!)9!A49@!#/9>)!
);%4:7!);#)!@&!=9!49)! A49@!/>)!@9>*=!*%A&!)98
]1
!,9(&!7&(%9>7*DB!#4=!
)#A&4!)9!&M)(&$&7B!49)!/&%4:!694?(94)&=!/D!#*)&(4#)%<&!4&@7B!%=B!
9(!<%&@.9%4)7!6#4!/&!=#4:&(9>7!!!*&#=%4:!)9!:(&#)&(!.9*#(%7#)%9 4B!
&<&4!(#=%6#*%7#)%94B!9?!.9*%)%6#*!<%&@78
]2
!+#77!->47)&%4!6#**7!);%7!
*-(5">%>5/.(,#.&,514%!!@;&(&!*%A&!$%4=&=`.&9.*&B!#?)&(!=%76>77%4:B!
694?%($%4:!#4=!<#*%=#)%4:!);&7&!.97%)%947B! #**!&4=!>.!)#A%4:!#!
.97%)%94!$9(&!&M)(&$&!);#4! #4D!7)#()&=!@%);8
]0
!_#%>$5>/$4#%9,$:#%
?%4=!796%#*!&469>(#:&$ &4)B!);&D!/&69$&!$9(&!694?%=&4)!;9*=%4:!#!
$9(&!&M)(&$&!.97%)%948!F;%7!;#7!/&&4!&<%=&46&=!);(9>:;!;>4=(&=7!
9?!7)>=%&78
]T
!,#4D!6#>)%94B!->47)&%4!%46*>=&=B!);#)!);&7&!.(96&77&7!
#(&!%46(%4:*D!;# &4%4:!%4!%4)&(4&)!?9(>$78!!!
