Báo cáo khoa học: Heme binding to the second, lower-affinity site of the global iron regulator Irr from Rhizobium leguminosarum promotes oligomerization potx

Heme binding to the second, lower-affinity site of the
global iron regulator Irr from Rhizobium leguminosarum
promotes oligomerization
Gaye F. White
1,2
, Chloe Singleton
1
, Jonathan D. Todd
2
, Myles R. Cheesman
1
, Andrew
W. B. Johnston
2
and Nick E. Le Brun
1
1 School of Chemistry, Centre for Molecular and Structural Biochemistry, University of East Anglia, Norwich Research Park, Norwich, UK
2 School of Biological Sciences, University of East Anglia, Norwich Research Park, Norwich, UK
Introduction
Iron is essential for almost all forms of life, fulfilling
functions ranging from respiration to DNA synthesis.
The metal occurs in cells as a protein cofactor in dif-
ferent forms: as the bare metal or, more commonly, in
heme and iron-sulfur clusters. Despite its abundance in
the biosphere, iron has poor bioavailability owing to
its propensity, in the presence of oxygen and water, to
form insoluble ferric oxy–hydroxide complexes [1],
such that cells of all types employ complex mecha-
nisms to recruit it from the environment. In addition,
Keywords
a-proteobacteria; fur; heme; iron;

transcriptional regulation
Correspondence
N. E. Le Brun, School of Chemistry,
University of East Anglia, Norwich NR4 7TJ,
UK
Fax: +44 1603 592003
Tel: +44 1603 592699
E-mail:
(Received 3 February 2011, revised 17
March 2011, accepted 1 April 2011)
doi:10.1111/j.1742-4658.2011.08117.x
The iron responsive regulator Irr is found in a wide range of a-proteobac-
teria, where it regulates many genes in response to the essential but toxic
metal iron. Unlike Fur, the transcriptional regulator that is used for iron
homeostasis by almost all other bacterial lineages, Irr does not sense Fe
2+
directly, but, rather, interacts with a physiologically important form
of iron, namely heme. Recent studies of Irr from the N
2
-fixing symbiont
Rhizobium leguminosarum (Irr
Rl
) showed that it binds heme with submi-
cromolar affinity at a His-Xxx-His (HxH) motif. This caused the protein to
dissociate from its cognate DNA regulatory iron control element box
sequences, thus allowing expression of its target genes under iron-replete
conditions. In the present study, we report new insights into the mecha-
nisms and consequences of heme binding to Irr. In addition to the HxH
motif, Irr binds heme at a second, lower-affinity site. Spectroscopic studies
of wild-type Irr and His variants show that His46 and probably His66 are

involved in coordinating heme in a low-spin state at this second site. By
contrast to the well-studied Irr from Bradyrhizobium japonicum, neither
heme site of Irr
Rl
stabilizes ferrous heme. Furthermore, we show that
heme-free Irr
Rl
exists as a mixture of dimeric and larger, likely hexameric,
forms and that heme binding promotes Irr
Rl
oligomerization. Bioanalytical
studies of Irr
Rl
variants showed that this property is not dependent on the
HxH motif but is associated with heme binding at the second site.
Structured digital abstract
l
Irr binds to irr by molecular sieving (View Interaction 1, 2)
l
Irr binds to irr by cosedimentation in solution (View interaction)
Abbreviations
EPR, electron paramagnetic resonance; HRM, heme regulatory motif; ICE, iron control element.
FEBS Journal 278 (2011) 2011–2021 ª 2011 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2011 FEBS 2011
the very properties that make iron essential also make
it toxic in oversupply, such that the amount and form
of iron in the cell must be carefully regulated [1,2].
In bacteria, several different iron regulatory systems
are now known. The best studied are the functionally
and structurally similar, but evolutionarily unrelated
global regulators, Fur and DtxR. Under iron-sufficient

conditions, both of these bind Fe
2+
, causing a confor-
mational change that increases the affinity of the pro-
tein for operator sequences located 5¢ of the regulated
genes, resulting (usually) in transcriptional repression
[3,4]. When iron is scarce, Fe
2+
dissociates, releasing
the protein from DNA, thereby switching on genes
involved in, for example, iron recruitment and uptake.
The subphylum a-proteobacteria contains important
pathogens of animals (e.g. Brucella, Rickettsia) and
plants (Agrobacterium), symbionts (the N
2
-fixing rhizo-
bia), many of the most abundant bacteria in the
oceans (the Roseobacters and the SAR11 clade, includ-
ing Pelagibacter) and some laboratory model organ-
isms (e.g. Paracoccus, Rhodobacter), as well as being
the source of mitochondria. The relatively few studies
on iron-responsive gene regulation in members of this
important group have shown that these bacteria are
very different from those that use the Fur regulator.
Although many a-proteobacteria contain a Fur homo-
logue [5], in those cases where this gene product was
studied directly, it was shown to have a minor regula-
tory role, repressing a few genes in response to manga-
nese (and not iron) availability; hence, it was renamed
‘Mur’ for mangenese uptake regulator [6,7].

Instead, many a-proteobacteria contain another
transcriptional repressor called Irr (iron responsive reg-
ulator) which, although a member of the Fur super-
family, has important features that distinguish it from
Fur sensu stricto (see below). Irr functions to repress a
wide range of genes under low iron availability by
binding to cis-acting regulatory sequences known
as iron control element (ICE) boxes that are 5¢ of the
target genes. It was first discovered in Bradyrhizobi-
um japonicum [8–12] and was also studied in Rhizo-
bium leguminosarum, where it represses a wide range of
genes in cells grown under iron-depleted conditions
[13,14], and in Brucella abortus, where it regulates
siderophore biosynthesis [15]. In addition to Irr, a-pro-
teobacteria that are closely related to Rhizobium, Agro-
bacterium, Brucella and Bartonella contain another
wide-ranging iron-responsive regulator called RirA
[16–19]. RirA belongs to the Rrf2 family of regulators,
which includes IscR and NsrR [20,21] and, similar to
them, is a predicted FeS cluster-binding protein. RirA
represses many genes under iron-replete conditions,
recognizing the cis-acting iron regulatory sequences
(RirA-boxes) that precede genes similar to those that
are commonly regulated by Fur in other organisms
[5,16–19]. Thus, RirA and Irr are ‘opposing’ regula-
tors, which repress different portfolios of target genes
in cells grown in sufficient (RirA) or deficient (Irr) lev-
els of iron. Because these two regulators respond to
the availability of iron in the form of iron-sulfur clus-
ters and heme, respectively, and exhibit regulatory

‘cross-talk’ in response to iron availability [14], they
may represent a combined regulatory system that
senses the physiologically relevant status of iron and
not just the concentration of the metal per se, as is the
case in those organisms that use Fur or DtxR [13].
Few Irr proteins have been studied in detail so far.
The first, from B. japonicum (Irr
Bj
), exhibits a highly
unusual regulatory mechanism. Under iron-replete
conditions, Irr
Bj
interacts with heme at two known
sites: an N-terminal heme regulatory motif (HRM)
and an internal, histidine-rich (HxH) motif [12], with
the heme being normally delivered to Irr
Bj
by ferroch-
elatase [22]. The heme-Irr
Bj
complex is extremely
unstable and is rapidly degraded. The mechanism by
which this remarkable response occurs is not known
but may involve heme- and oxygen-mediated oxidative
damage that acts as signal(s) for protease-mediated
degradation [23]. The end result is that, under iron-
replete conditions, Irr
Bj
is unavailable to act as a
repressor.

Another member of the rhizobia, R. leguminosarum,
which forms nodules on peas, clovers and beans, has
an Irr (Irr
Rl
) that is 57% identical to Irr
Bj
but lacks
the N-terminal heme regulatory motif. We recently
reported that Irr
Rl
functions by a very different mecha-
nism that does not involve degradation in response to
elevated iron. Instead of being degraded, the interac-
tion between Irr
Rl
and heme causes an allosteric
change in the protein, which prevents it from binding
to its cognate ICE box DNA sequences [24]. In vitro
studies showed that specific binding to DNA was abol-
ished by the direct addition of heme, and spectroscopic
studies of heme binding to wild-type Irr
Rl
and mutant
forms of the protein revealed two low-spin ferric
heme-binding sites. Substitution of the HxH motif
abolished one of these sites, with a concomitant loss of
DNA binding in vitro and regulatory function in vivo,
demonstrating a key role of this motif [24]. The prop-
erties and location of the second, lower-affinity heme-
binding site of Irr

Rl
have not been fully investigated,
although electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and
magnetic CD spectroscopic studies showed that the
heme bound at the second heme site is coordinated by
two His residues [24]. In the present study, we used
spectroscopic and bioanalytical methods to gain
Heme binding to Irr promotes oligomerization G. F. White et al.
2012 FEBS Journal 278 (2011) 2011–2021 ª 2011 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2011 FEBS
further insight into heme binding by R. leguminosarum
Irr, with a focus on the second heme-binding site.
These studies highlight important new features of Irr
that have relevance to Irr proteins from a wide range
of a-proteobacteria.
Results
Identification of the second heme-binding site of
Irr
Rl
: importance of His46 and His66
It was previously shown that the second heme-binding
site of Irr
Rl
is associated with low-spin S = ½ heme
with g-values of 2.95, 2.26 and 1.55, and a near-infra-
red magnetic CD band centred at approximately
1580 nm [24], demonstrating that the second heme iron
has bis-His ligation [25]. However, these previous stud-
ies did not establish which His residues are involved.
In total, Irr
Rl

has seven His residues (Fig. 1A), three
of which are at the HxH motif (His93, His94 and
His95). One or more of the remaining His residues
(His39, His46, His66 and His128) must therefore
supply the ligands for the second heme site. A set of
variants, in which each of these His residues was
substituted with alanine, had been previously generated
and their absolute heme spectra measured [24].
Although the spectra were similar in form to the wild-
type Irr
Rl
spectrum, indicating no change in the ratio
of high- to low-spin bound heme, the amounts of heme
bound differed according to which histidine had been
substituted. Thus, variants H39A and H128A were
essentially identical to the wild-type Irr
Rl
protein,
whereas H46A and H66A exhibited spectra with signif-
icantly lower heme intensity [24]. Consistent with this,
hemochromogen analyses revealed that, although
H39A and H128A Irr
Rl
proteins bound only margin-
ally less heme than wild-type ( 1.4 compared to
 1.5 heme per protein), H66A ( 1.1 heme per pro-
tein) and H46A ( 0.9 heme per protein) exhibited sig-
nificantly lower heme binding (not shown).
EPR spectra of each of the single His variants were
recorded. Previous studies showed that the heme that

binds at the HxH motif is EPR silent, very likely result-
ing from the magnetic coupling of HxH hemes within a
BA
DC
Fig. 1. Spectroscopic studies of Irr
Rl
His variants. (A) Amino acid residue sequence of Irr
Rl
, with His residues highlighted. (B) EPR spectra of
wild-type (black), H39A (green), H46A (blue), H66A (purple) and H128A (orange) Irr variants. (C) UV-visible absorbance and (D) EPR spectra
of H93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95A (red), His39 ⁄ 93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95Ala (olive green), His39 ⁄ 46 ⁄ 93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95Ala (dark cyan), His39 ⁄ 46 ⁄ 66 ⁄ 93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95Ala (magenta) and His-
free (grey) Irr variants. Note that UV-visible and EPR spectra of wild-type and H93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95A Irr were reported previously [24] and are included
here for reference. Excess heme was added to each protein and non- or weakly-bound protein was removed by gel filtration and the protein
concentrated as necessary. Proteins (10 l
M for absorbance, 100 lM for EPR) were in 50 mM Tris-HCl, 50 mM KCl (pH 8). EPR measurement
conditions were: temperature, 10 K; microwave power, 2 mW; modulation amplitude, 10 G.
G. F. White et al. Heme binding to Irr promotes oligomerization
FEBS Journal 278 (2011) 2011–2021 ª 2011 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2011 FEBS 2013
proposed Irr dimer [24]. Therefore, the low-spin heme
signals observed in the EPR spectrum are the result of a
heme bound at the second heme site. We noted that the
low-spin heme signal intensity was decreased in both
the H46A and H66A variants, although it was unaf-
fected by substituting His39 or His128 (Fig. 1B), sug-
gesting that His46 and His66 may be involved in
binding heme at the lower-affinity site. This raised the
question of why EPR-active low-spin heme binding was
not completely abolished in one or more of these vari-
ants. One explanation for this is that a minority of the
heme bound at the HxH site may not be magnetically

coupled, most likely as a result of incomplete occupa-
tion, which would result in a small component of the
HxH-bound heme being EPR-active. Alternatively, loss
of the second heme site ligands could interfere with cou-
pling of heme at the HxH site. In either case, inactiva-
tion of both heme-binding sites would be required to
abolish all low-spin heme binding.
To test this model, a further set of site-directed vari-
ants was generated. Beginning with the H93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95A
variant (in which the three His residues at the HxH
motif are substituted for Ala residues and previously
referred to as the HHH variant) [24], each of the
remaining His residues was substituted stepwise,
sequentially generating H39 ⁄ 93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95A, H39 ⁄ 46 ⁄ 93 ⁄
94 ⁄ 95A and H39⁄ 46 ⁄ 66 ⁄ 93 ⁄ 94⁄ 95A, as well as an
entirely His-free Irr
Rl
protein, H39 ⁄ 46 ⁄ 66 ⁄ 93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95 ⁄
128A (His-free Irr
Rl
). The far-UV CD spectrum of the
fully His-free variant indicated that the protein was
folded with a secondary structure content similar to
the wild-type protein (Fig. S1). UV-visible absorbance
(Fig. 1C) and EPR analysis (Fig. 1D) of this His-free
variant after the addition of heme revealed only weak,
nonspecific (adventitious) binding (Fig. S2). Having
established the baselines for the fully His-free form of
Irr
Rl

, we used UV-visible absorbance to examine heme
binding to the Irr
Rl
variants that retained at least one
histidine residue (Fig. 1C). The data obtained showed
that, as additional His residues were substituted, the
form of the spectrum changed, with that of H39 ⁄ 93 ⁄
94 ⁄ 95A being similar to the H93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95A variant,
whereas that of H39 ⁄ 46 ⁄ 66 ⁄ 93⁄ 94 ⁄ 95A more closely
resembled the His-free variant. This reflects a decrease
in the proportion of heme binding in the low-spin con-
figuration and is consistent with a progression towards
only low-affinity adventitious, high-spin heme binding
in the absence of His residues (Fig. S2). EPR spectra
of the multi-His variants were recorded (Fig. 1D).
These showed that the ability to bind low-spin heme
was significantly diminished in the H39 ⁄ 93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95A
variant, and was lost entirely in H39 ⁄ 46 ⁄ 93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95A
Irr
Rl
.
Irr
Rl
stabilizes heme in the ferric form
Previous studies of heme binding to Irr from B. japoni-
cum indicated that the protein has both ferric and fer-
rous heme-binding sites [12]. To investigate whether
Irr
Rl
has a specific ferrous heme-binding site, Irr

Rl
was
titrated with heme at pH 7 using reduced hemin under
anerobic conditions in the presence of a two-fold
excess of sodium dithionite. As shown by UV-visible
absorbance spectra, heme was bound in a reduced
state, almost all of which was in the low-spin form,
with the Soret band at 426 nm and resolved a ⁄ b bands
at 528 and 559 nm [24] (Fig. 2A). Measurements of
A
426
(converted to fractional saturation) fitted well to
a single site model, giving a K
d
of 1 ± 0.2 · 10
)6
m
(Fig. 2A, inset). This indicated that ferrous heme has a
significantly lower affinity than ferric heme
(K
d
=1· 10
)7
m) [24] (Fig. S3), and that ferrous
heme apparently binds at only one of the two heme-
binding sites of Irr
Rl
. Upon removing dithionite under
anerobic conditions, the UV-visible absorbance spec-
trum revealed that heme was bound only in the oxi-

dized state (not shown), consistent with a higher
affinity binding of ferric heme.
Heme binding to proteins is commonly pH-depen-
dent [26–28] and thus heme binding in both the oxi-
dized and reduced states was investigated at higher
pH. In the oxidized state, although the affinity was
found by absorbance and fluorescence titrations to
decrease somewhat with increasing pH (Doc. S1 and
Fig. S3A, B), the form of heme binding (as judged
from difference and absolute UV-visible spectra) was
unaltered (Doc. S1 and Fig. S3C). By contrast, at
pH 8, the reduced heme UV-visible difference spectrum
was quite different from that at pH 7, indicating that
only ferric heme was bound to the protein (Fig. 2B).
Even at a five-fold excess of dithionite, a mixture of
reduced and oxidized heme was observed, which again
was all converted to oxidized heme upon the anerobic
removal of excess dithionite (data not shown).
Although there is no indication that heme undergoes
redox cycling in Irr
Rl
, we attempted to determine the
reduction potential of Irr
Rl
-bound heme. Spectropoten-
tiometric titration experiments at pH 7 using dithionite
in the presence of mediators were unsuccessful because
a significant reduction of heme was not observed in
the accessible potential range (data not shown), consis-
tent with Irr

Rl
-bound heme having a very low reduc-
tion potential (i.e. similar to, or lower than, that of the
HSO
3
)
⁄ S
2
O
4
2)
couple of < )500 mV at pH 7) [29].
Thus, Irr
Rl
has a considerable preference for heme in
the ferric state, and strongly promotes the oxidation of
heme when it encounters this ligand in the ferrous
Heme binding to Irr promotes oligomerization G. F. White et al.
2014 FEBS Journal 278 (2011) 2011–2021 ª 2011 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2011 FEBS
form. Therefore, it is clear that Irr
Rl
does not contain
a ferrous heme-binding site.
Heme binding to Irr
Rl
promotes oligomerization
The pathogen B. abortus is a member of the Rhizobi-
ales that is more closely related to Rhizobium than it is
to Bradyrhizobium. Its Irr protein (Irr
Ba

) also more clo-
sely resembles Irr
Rl
(67% identical) than Irr
Bj
(56%
identical) and it lacks the N-terminal HRM. Gel filtra-
tion studies on purified Irr (Irr
Ba
) from this species
had shown that it is likely dimeric [30], as are other
members of the Fur superfamily [31,32]. To analyse
the association state of Irr
Rl
, analytical gel filtration
experiments were performed. For the ‘as isolated’,
heme-free protein, two distinct peaks were detected in
the chromatograph (Fig. 3A). Thus, the heme-free pro-
tein exists as an equilibrium mixture of two principal
association states, which must be in slow exchange,
such that they can be separated by gel filtration. Cali-
bration of the column suggested that the lower molec-
ular weight species corresponds to a dimeric form,
consistent with our previous proposal that heme bound
at the HxH motif of Irr
Rl
is EPR-silent as a result of
magnetic coupling between two closely located HxH-
bound hemes. The higher molecular weight species cor-
responded to a much larger, oligomeric form, although

this could not be precisely defined by gel filtration
alone. Interestingly, addition of heme to Irr
Rl
resulted
in significant changes in the elution profile: only one
major band was observed, corresponding to the higher
molecular weight species (Fig. 3A). Analysis of elution
data at different wavelengths confirmed that the
observed profile changes were the result of a change in
the distribution between higher and lower molecular
weight species and not the preferential binding of heme
to the larger species (Fig. S4). Heme binding, however,
did not cause major changes in the secondary structure
because far-UV CD spectra of Irr
Rl
before and after
the addition of heme were very similar (Fig. 3B).
To determine the mass of the oligomeric species
more precisely, analytical ultracentrifugation experi-
ments were run for heme-Irr
Rl
at five different concen-
trations, in the range 5–19 lm, at 15 000 and at
17 000 r.p.m. Figure 3C shows the data obtained for
one representative concentration of heme-Irr
Rl
(10 lm).
Fitting of the data, at both speeds and for all concen-
trations, to a single component model gave a mass of
96.6 ± 8 kDa for the heme-bound Irr

Rl
sample (resid-
uals for the fits are shown in the inset to Fig. 3C). The
data thus indicate that the higher molecular weight
species of Irr
Rl
corresponds to a hexamer.
To examine the role (if any) of the HxH motif in
the heme-dependent oligomerization, the association
state of the H93 ⁄ 94⁄ 95A mutant Irr
Rl
was also investi-
gated. The gel filtration profile (Fig. 3D) was very sim-
ilar to that of the wild-type protein, and the addition
of heme to the mutant polypeptide caused a similar
shift in equilibrium towards the larger (hexameric) spe-
cies. Therefore, the process of oligomerization is not
directly connected to heme binding at the HxH motif
and must be associated with heme binding at the
lower-affinity site. To test this proposal, Irr
Rl
variants
containing single substitutions of His residues consid-
ered to be involved in heme binding were examined by
analytical gel filtration. H46A and H66A Irr
Rl
proteins
AB
Fig. 2. Binding of ferrous heme by Irr
Rl

. (A) UV-visible difference absorbance spectra recorded upon titration of ‘as isolated‘ (heme-free) Irr
(17 l
M)in50mM Tris-HCl, 50 mM KCl (pH 7) with ferrous heme. The trend of absorption changes are indicated by arrows. The inset shows
a plot of fractional saturation (from DA
426
) as a function of reduced heme concentration. A fit of the data to a single site model is drawn.
Pathlength, 1 cm; temperature, 20 °C. (B) UV-visible difference absorbance spectra as recorded in (A), except that the pH of the Irr (18 l
M)
solution was 8. Note that the form of the difference titration was different from that observed for the oxidized heme titration (Fig. S3A),
although this is because hemin remained in the ferrous state in the reference cuvette, thereby imparting a different form on the difference
spectrum.
G. F. White et al. Heme binding to Irr promotes oligomerization
FEBS Journal 278 (2011) 2011–2021 ª 2011 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2011 FEBS 2015
exhibited somewhat different behavior to the wild-type
and H93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95A proteins; oligomerization was still
observed upon heme binding, although to a signifi-
cantly lesser extent, as judged by the more prominent
peak due to the dimeric protein remaining after the
addition of heme (Fig. 4A). A simple analysis of
absorbance changes indicated that oligomerization of
H46A and H66A Irr
Rl
in the presence of heme was
approximately 60% of that observed for the wild-type
protein (Fig. 4B, C). A decreased level of oligomeriza-
tion was also observed in the His-free variant,
although this was both before and after the addition
of heme. By contrast, H39A, H93A, H94A and H95A
all behaved similarly to the wild-type and H93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95A
proteins (Fig. 4).

Discussion
The transcriptional regulator Irr represents something
of a signature polypeptide for the a-proteobacteria,
being found in no other bacterial lineages [5]. How-
ever, it has only been studied directly in a few species,
namely B. japonicum, R. leguminosarum and, to a lesser
extent, B. abortus, all of which are in the same Order
(the Rhizobiales). These studies have shown that Irr is
a remarkable protein, sensing iron in the form of
heme, which, on binding to Irr, exerts unusual effects
on the protein that cause it to lose its repressive,
DNA-binding ability. It is clear that the Irr proteins of
different bacteria have much in common because they
recognize the same conserved ICE box sequences and
these cis-acting elements are found in the operators of
some genes (e.g. mbfA in R. leguminosarum corre-
sponds to blr7895 in B. japonicum strain 110) that are
equivalent in different species [14]. However, it is also
apparent that there are significant differences in the
behavior of Irr in different species. Thus, in B. japoni-
cum, the interaction with heme results in a rapid and
dramatic destruction of the Irr
Bj
, but, as we recently
found, this does not occur in Rhizobium. Rather, when
Irr
Rl
interacts with heme, this abolishes its DNA-bind-
ing ability, although this does not destroy the polypep-
tide [24].

This difference in behavior is at least partly a result
of the different ways in which the proteins interact
with heme. Although the proteins have a functionally
A
CD
B
Fig. 3. Bioanalytical studies of the association state of Irr
Rl
. (A) Analytical gel filtration plots of A
240
as a function of elution volume for sam-
ples of Irr
Rl
(17 lM)in50mM Tris-HCl, 100 mM KCl, 10% (v ⁄ v) glycerol (pH 8) in the absence (apo) and presence of heme (two per protein),
as indicated. (B) Far-UV CD spectra of wild-type Irr
Rl
with (grey line) heme (two per protein). The spectrum of Irr without heme (black line)
[24] is shown to aid comparison. Irr (10 l
M) was in 50 mM potassium phosphate (pH 8). Pathlength, 1 mm; temperature, 20 °C. (C) Analytical
equilibrium ultracentrifugation plots of A
280
as a function of the radius after equilibration at 15 000 and 17 000 r.p.m. at 25 °C of Irr (10 lM in
50 m
M Tris-HCl, 100 mM KCl, pH 8) containing two heme per protein, as indicated. A fit to a single component model is drawn on each plot
and the residuals for each are shown in the inset. (D) Analytical gel filtration plots as in (A), except that H93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95A Irr was analyzed in the
absence and presence of heme.
Heme binding to Irr promotes oligomerization G. F. White et al.
2016 FEBS Journal 278 (2011) 2011–2021 ª 2011 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2011 FEBS
important HxH motif in common that binds heme,
this analyte also binds elsewhere. In the present study,

we have focussed on understanding the nature of the
second heme-binding site and its importance for the
properties of Irr
Rl
. The most significant changes in the
Irr
Rl
-heme absorbance spectrum occurred on substitu-
tion of His46 or His66 [24], and the EPR low-spin
heme signal intensity was reduced in His46 and His66
variants. Substitution of His39 or His128 (i.e. the other
His residues present in Irr
Rl
outside of the HxH motif)
had no effect on the UV-visible or EPR spectra,
clearly indicating that these residues are not directly
involved in heme binding. Furthermore, low-spin heme
binding to Irr
Rl
already lacking the HxH motif was
totally abolished when His46 was substituted. Unex-
pectedly, substituting His39 in the H93 ⁄ 94⁄ 95A variant
background resulted in a significant decrease in low-
spin heme binding. Figure S5 shows that, in the previ-
ously generated Irr
Rl
model (based on the available
structures of Fur proteins) [24], His39 lies very close to
the HxH motif, and it is possible that the combination
of these substitutions, neither of which alone signifi-

cantly affects heme binding at the second site, causes a
conformational change that affects the second heme
site, resulting in a loss of low-spin binding and an
increase in high-spin heme (Fig. 1C, D).
Taken together, the UV-visible and EPR data indi-
cate that His46 is a key ligand at the second, lower-
affinity heme site and that His66 is also important.
Although not involved directly in heme binding, His39
is likely to play an important, but as yet undefined,
role in Irr
Rl
because it is absolutely conserved among
Irr proteins and in the wider Fur families, represented
by Fur itself, the Zur and Mur regulators, and PerR,
which respond to zinc, manganese and peroxide stress,
respectively [33,34]. In these proteins, it serves as a
ligand at a divalent metal ion binding site. By contrast
to His39, His128 is not conserved in the Fur superfam-
ily, nor in the Irr family, and therefore is unlikely to
be involved in heme binding in Irr
Rl
. We note that
His46 and His66 are conserved in the Irr proteins of
other members of the Rhizobiaceae family, including
the closely related Sinorhizobium and Agrobacterium,
as well as in strains of Mesorhizobium (in the family
Phyllobacteriaceae). Interestingly, all of these Irr pro-
teins lack the heme-binding HRM found near the
A
CB

Fig. 4. Analytical gel filtration studies of Irr
Rl
His variants. (A) Analytical gel filtration plots of relative A
280
as a function of elution volume for
samples of wild-type, H46A and H66A Irr (17 l
M), as indicated, in 50 mM Tris-HCl, 100 mM KCl, 10% (v ⁄ v) glycerol (pH 8) with no heme
(apo) and after the addition of excess heme per protein and removal of unbound heme by passage down a PD10 column (indicated by ‘+
heme’). (B) Histogram plot of the ratio of absorbance as a result of the higher (hexameric) and lower (dimeric) molecular weight forms of
Irr
Rl
, giving a quantitative indication of the extent of oligomerization in the apo- (grey bars) and heme-bound (black bars) forms. Data were
obtained from (A) and from equivalent experiments on additional Irr
Rl
proteins, as indicated. (C) Histogram plot of the ratio of ratios for apo-
and heme-bound Irr
Rl
proteins [i.e. the data in (B)], giving a direct quantitative indication of the extent of heme-induced oligomerization.
A value of 1 indicates no change in association state upon binding heme.
G. F. White et al. Heme binding to Irr promotes oligomerization
FEBS Journal 278 (2011) 2011–2021 ª 2011 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2011 FEBS 2017
N-termini in Irr proteins from Bradyrhizobium and
other members of the Bradyrhizobiaceae family, in
which His46 and His66 are not present.
On the basis of the Irr
Rl
model, we predict that
His46 and His66 are located in the DNA-binding
domain on consecutive a-helices that are connected by
a loop (Fig. S5). In the model, the two His residues

are not sufficiently close to cooperate in binding a sin-
gle heme, although a conformational rearrangement of
the helices could potentially align them appropriately.
Alternatively, the second, lower-affinity heme binding
may not be at an intrasubunit site but, instead, could
be at an intersubunit site involving His residues from
juxtaposed subunits.
Even though the Irr
Bj
and Irr
Rl
proteins both con-
tain an HxH motif, the binding characteristics of the
motif in the two proteins are different. Irr
Bj
binds fer-
rous heme at its HxH motif [12], whereas, in the pres-
ent study, we have shown that both heme sites of Irr
Rl
have a very significant preference for ferric heme and
do not bind ferrous heme in the absence of an excess
of reductant. It remains unclear why the Irr
Rl
and Irr
Bj
HxH motifs should exhibit different heme iron oxida-
tion state preferences.
The propensity of Irr
Rl
to oligomerize has also been

demonstrated in the present study, and this was
enhanced by heme binding at the lower-affinity heme
site associated with His46 and His66. Because Irr
Bj
lacks
an equivalent site, we anticipate that it might exhibit
different behavior, although the association state prop-
erties of the Bradyrhizobium Irr have not yet been inves-
tigated. Irr
Ba
was found to be a dimer and no evidence
of oligomerization was reported [30]. Irr is a member of
the Fur superfamily and it has long been known that
Fur itself can exist in oligomeric forms in solution, as
well as when bound to DNA [35,36]. Furthermore, we
noted that high molecular weight forms of Irr
Rl
occur in
whole cell extracts of R. leguminosarum [24].
Currently, the functional roles of the second heme
site and of oligomerization remain unclear because
variants disrupted in heme binding at this site were not
affected in their ability to bind DNA, nor were they
significantly affected in their ability to function in vivo
[24]. However, the conservation of the site ligands,
together with their importance for the properties of the
protein in vitro, in heme binding and in oligomeriza-
tion, suggests that this site has functional importance.
Clearly, further studies are required to understand bet-
ter the role of the second heme site and the functional

consequences of heme-induced oligomerization. For
example, it is not known whether the dimeric or hexa-
meric (or both) form of Irr
Rl
can bind ICE box DNA
sequences.
Given the remarkable variation in the properties of
the very few Irr proteins that have been studied
directly, it will be of interest to examine the somewhat
more distantly related versions of Irr in other Orders
of the a-proteobacteria, not least, members of the
Rhodobacterales and the SAR 11 clade, which form
the most abundant bacteria in the world’s oceans.
Despite this, we still know almost nothing about their
iron-responsive biology.
Materials and methods
Generation of sequential His variants of Irr
Rl
Mutagenesis on pBIO1632 (encoding wild-type Irr
Rl
)to
individually substitute H93, H94 and H95 with alanine resi-
dues was carried out using the primers listed in Table S1
and a QuikChange XL mutagenic PCR kit (Stratagene, La
Jolla, CA, USA) in accordance with the manufacturer’s
instructions, generating pBIO1839 (H93A), pBIO1840
(H94A) and pBIO1841 (H95A). Successive rounds of muta-
genesis on pBIO1819 (encoding Irr
Rl
in which the H93,

H94 and H95 residues are all substituted with the corre-
sponding alanines; termed H93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95A Irr
Rl
) and deriva-
tives were carried as described above, resulting in the
stepwise substitution of all of the His residues in Irr
Rl
with
Ala, generating pBIO1820 (H39 ⁄ 93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95A), pBIO1821
(H39 ⁄ 46 ⁄ 93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95A), pBIO1822 (H39 ⁄ 46 ⁄ 66 ⁄ 93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95A)
and, finally, pBIO1744, which encodes His-free
(H39 ⁄ 46 ⁄ 66 ⁄ 93 ⁄ 94 ⁄ 95 ⁄ 128A) Irr
Rl
. Verified mutated plas-
mids (Table S2) were used to transform Escherichia coli
BL21(DE3) for protein over-expression.
Purification of wild-type and variant forms of Irr
Rl
and in vitro heme additions
Wild-type and variant Irr
Rl
proteins were purified in a
heme-free form as previously described [24] and exchanged
into 50 mm Tris-HCl, 50 mm KCl (pH 7 or 8, as req-
uired). Protein concentrations were determined using an
e
280 nm
of 5800 m
)1
Æcm

)1
obtained from amino acid analy-
sis (Alta Biosciences, Birmingham, UK). For spectroscopic
and analytical studies, heme additions were made using a
micropipette (Gilson Inc., Middleton, WI, USA) or a mi-
crosyringe (Hamilton, Reno, NV, USA). For UV-visible
difference absorption titration experiments, Irr was added
to the sample cuvette and heme additions were made to
the sample and reference cuvettes. Heme solutions
( 1mm) were freshly prepared as described previously
[24]. Bound heme concentrations were determined using a
modified version of the hemochromogen method [37] as
described previously [24]. For ferrous heme titrations,
hemin was reduced using a two-fold molar excess of
sodium dithionite.
Heme binding to Irr promotes oligomerization G. F. White et al.
2018 FEBS Journal 278 (2011) 2011–2021 ª 2011 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2011 FEBS
Spectroscopic and bioanalytical methods
UV-visible absorption spectra were recorded using a Hitachi
U-4010 or U-2900 spectrophotometer (Hitachi Corp.,
Tokyo, Japan). EPR spectra were measured using an
X-band spectrometer (Bruker ER200D; Bruker, Rheinstet-
ten, Germany) with an EPS 3220 computer system (Bruker)
fitted with an ESR9 liquid helium flow cryostat (Oxford
Instruments, Abingdon, UK). Spin intensities of paramag-
netic samples were estimated by double integration of EPR
signals measured at 15 K using 1.25 mm Cu
2+
,10mm
EDTA as the standard. Binding isotherms obtained from

spectroscopic titrations of Irr
Rl
with heme were analyzed
using origin, version 7 (Microcal; OriginLab Corporation,
Northampton, MA, USA) employing a single binding site
model (where the free ligand concentration was unknown)
and ⁄ or the software dynafit (Biokin, Watertown, MA,
USA) for single-site and two-site binding models [38]. Sedi-
mentation-equilibrium experiments were performed using a
Beckman XL-I analytical ultracentrifuge in an AN50Ti
rotor (Beckman Coulter, Brea, CA, USA) at 25 °C, in
12 mm charcoal-filled Epon double-sector cells with quartz
windows. The sample volume was 110 lL and the reference
sector of the cell contained identical buffer. Samples of Irr
Rl
containing heme at five different concentrations were spun
at 15 000 or at 17 000 r.p.m. until equilibrium was reached,
as judged by cessation of changes in scans collected 4 h
apart. Data were collected at 280 nm and analyzed using ul-
traspin, version 2.5 ( />The density of the buffer was taken as 1.005 gÆmL
)1
and the
partial specific volume of Irr
Rl
was calculated to be
0.7421 mLÆg
)1
using the software sednterp [39]. Analytical
gel filtration of samples of Irr
Rl

utilized a Superdex 75 col-
umn (GE Healthcare), equilibrated in 50 mm Tris-HCl,
50 mm KCl, 10% glycerol (v ⁄ v) (pH 8.0) and operated at a
flow rate of 0.8 mLÆmin
)1
. The column was calibrated using
cytochrome c (12.4 kDa), carbonic anhydrase (29 kDa),
bovine serum albumin (66 kDa) and alcohol dehydrogenase
(150 kDa).
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the UK BBSRC through
the award of grant BB ⁄ E003400 ⁄ 1, to A.W.B.J. and
N.E.L.B., and the Wellcome Trust through an award
from the Joint Infra-structure Fund for equipment. We
thank Dr Tom Clarke for assistance with the AUC
experiments.
References
1 Aisen P, Enns C & Wessling-Resnick M (2001) Chemis-
try and biology of eukaryotic iron metabolism. Int J
Biochem Cell Biol 33, 940–959.
2 Andrews SC, Robinson AK & Rodriguez-Quinones F
(2003) Bacterial iron homeostasis. FEMS Microbiol
Revs 27, 215–237.
3 Hantke K (2001) Iron and metal regulation in bacteria.
Curr Opin Microbiol 4, 172–177.
4 Ding X, Zeng H, Schiering N, Ringe D & Murphy JR
(1996) Identification of the primary metal ion-activation
sites of the diphtheria tox repressor by X-ray crystallog-
raphy and site-directed mutational analysis. Nat Struct
Biol 3, 382–387.

5 Rodionov DA, Gelfand MS, Todd JD, Curson ARJ &
Johnston AWB (2006) Computational reconstruction of
iron- and manganese-responsive transcriptional net-
works in alpha-proteobacteria. PLoS Comp Biol 2,
1568–1585.
6 Diaz-Mireles E, Wexler M, Sawers G, Bellini D, Todd
JD & Johnston AWB (2004) The Fur-like protein
Mur of Rhizobium leguminosarum is a Mn
2+
-responsive
transcriptional regulator. Microbiology 150, 1447–1456.
7 Diaz-Mireles E, Wexler M, Todd JD, Bellini D, John-
ston AWB & Sawers RG (2005) The manganese-respon-
sive repressor Mur of Rhizobium leguminosarum is a
member of the Fur-superfamily that recognizes an
unusual operator sequence. Microbiology 151, 4071–
4078.
8 Hamza I, Chauhan S, Hassett R & O’Brian MR (1998)
The bacterial Irr protein is required for coordination of
heme biosynthesis with iron availability. J Biol Chem
273, 21669–21674.
9 Qi ZH, Hamza I & O’Brian MR (1999) Heme is an
effector molecule for iron-dependent degradation of the
bacterial iron response regulator (Irr) protein. Proc Natl
Acad Sci USA 96, 13056–13061.
10 Rudolph G, Semini G, Hauser F, Lindemann A,
Friberg M, Hennecke H & Fischer HM (2006) The iron
control element, acting in positive and negative control
of iron-regulated Bradyrhizobium japonicum genes, is a
target for the Irr protein. J Bacteriol 188, 2294–2294.

11 Sangwan I, Small SK & O’Brian MR (2008) The Brady-
rhizobium japonicum Irr protein is a transcriptional
repressor with high-affinity DNA-binding activity.
J Bacteriol 190, 5172–5177.
12 Yang JH, Ishimori K & O’Brian MR (2005) Two heme
binding sites are involved in the regulated degradation
of the bacterial iron response regulator (Irr) protein.
J Biol Chem 280, 7671–7676.
13 Johnston AWB, Todd JD, Curson AR, Lei S, Nikolai-
dou-Katsaridou N, Gelfand MS & Rodionov DA
(2007) Living without Fur: the subtlety and complexity
of iron-responsive gene regulation in the symbiotic bac-
terium Rhizobium and other alpha-proteobacteria.
Biometals 20, 501–511.
14 Todd JD, Sawers G, Rodionov DA & Johnston AWB
(2006) The Rhizobium leguminosarum regulator IrrA
G. F. White et al. Heme binding to Irr promotes oligomerization
FEBS Journal 278 (2011) 2011–2021 ª 2011 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2011 FEBS 2019
affects the transcription of a wide range of genes in
response to Fe availability. Mol Gen Genom 275,
564–577.
15 Martinez M, Ugalde RA & Almiron M (2006) Irr regu-
lates brucebactin and 2,3-dihydroxybenzoic acid biosyn-
thesis, and is implicated in the oxidative stress
resistance and intracellular survival of Brucella abortus.
Microbiology 152, 2591–2598.
16 Todd JD, Sawers G & Johnston AWB (2005) Proteomic
analysis reveals the wide-ranging effects of the novel,
iron-responsive regulator RirA in Rhizobium legumin-
osarum bv. viciae. Mol Gen Genom 273, 197–206.

17 Todd JD, Wexler M, Sawers G, Yeoman KH, Poole PS
& Johnston AWB (2002) RirA, an iron-responsive regu-
lator in the symbiotic bacterium Rhizobium leguminosa-
rum. Microbiology 148, 4059–4071.
18 Wexler M, Todd JD, Kolade O, Bellini D, Hemmings
AM, Sawers G & Johnston AWB (2003) Fur is not the
global regulator of iron uptake genes in Rhizobium legu-
minosarum. Microbiology 149, 1357–1365.
19 Yeoman KH, Curson ARJ, Todd JD, Sawers G &
Johnston AWB (2004) Evidence that the Rhizobium reg-
ulatory protein RirA binds to cis-acting iron-responsive
operators (IROs) at promoters of some Fe-regulated
genes. Microbiology 150, 4065–4074.
20 Schwartz CJ, Giel JL, Patschkowski T, Luther C,
Ruzicka FJ, Beinert H & Kiley PJ (2001) IscR, an Fe-S
cluster-containing transcription factor, represses
expression of Escherichia coli genes encoding Fe-S cluster
assembly proteins. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98, 14895–
14900.
21 Tucker NP, Hicks MG, Clarke TA, Crack JC, Chandra
G, Le Brun NE, Dixon R & Hutchings MI (2008) The
transcriptional repressor protein NsrR senses nitric oxide
directly via a [2Fe-2S] cluster. PLoS ONE 3, e3623.
22 Qi ZH & O’Brian MR (2002) Interaction between the
bacterial iron response regulator and ferrochelatase
mediates genetic control of heme biosynthesis. Mol Cell
9, 155–162.
23 Yang J, Panek HR & O’Brian MR (2006) Oxidative
stress promotes degradation of the Irr protein to regu-
late haem biosynthesis in Bradyrhizobium japonicum.

Mol Microbiol 60, 209–218.
24 Singleton C, White GF, Todd JD, Marritt SJ, Chees-
man MR, Johnston AWB & Le Brun NE (2010) Heme-
responsive DNA binding by the global iron regulator
Irr from Rhizobium leguminosarum. J Biol Chem 285,
16023–16031.
25 Gadsby PMA & Thomson AJ (1990) Assignment of the
axial ligands of ferric ion in low-spin hemoproteins by
near-infrared magnetic circular dichroism and electron
paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy. J Am Chem Soc
112, 5003–5011.
26 Doster W, Beece D, Bowne SF, Diiorio EE, Eisenstein
L, Frauenfelder H, Reinisch L, Shyamsunder E, Winter-
halter KH & Yue KT (1982) Control and pH-depen-
dence of ligand-binding to heme protein. Biochemistry
21, 4831–4839.
27 Esquerra RM, Jensen RA, Bhaskaran S, Pillsbury ML,
Mendoza JL, Lintner BW, Kliger DS & Goldbeck RA
(2008) The pH dependence of heme pocket hydration
and ligand rebinding kinetics in photodissociated car-
bonmonoxymyoglobin. J Biol Chem 283, 14165–14175.
28 Moore GR, Pettigrew GW, Pitt RC & Williams RJP
(1980) pH-dependence of the redox potential of Pseudo-
monas aeruginosa cytochrome c
551
. Biochim Biophys
Acta 590, 261–271.
29 Mayhew SG (1978) The redox potential of dithionite
and SO
2

)
from equilibrium reactions with flavodoxins,
methyl viologen and hydrogen plus hydrogenase. Eur J
Biochem 85, 535–547.
30 Martinez M, Ugalde RA & Almiron M (2005) Dimeric
Brucella abortus Irr protein controls its own expression
and binds haem. Microbiology 151, 3427–3433.
31 Pohl E, Haller JC, Mijovilovich A, Meyer-Klaucke W,
Garman E & Vasil ML (2003) Architecture of a protein
central to iron homeostasis: crystal structure and spec-
troscopic analysis of the ferric uptake regulator. Mol
Microbiol 47, 903–915.
32 Sheikh MA & Taylor GL (2009) Crystal structure of
the Vibrio cholerae ferric uptake regulator (Fur) reveals
insights into metal co-ordination. Mol Microbiol 72,
1208–1220.
33 Lee JW & Helmann JD (2007) Functional specialization
within the Fur family of metalloregulators. Biometals
20, 485–499.
34 Jacquamet L, Traore DAK, Ferrer JL, Proux O, Teste-
male D, Hazemann JL, Nazarenko E, El Ghazouani A,
Caux-Thang C, Duarte V et al. (2009) Structural char-
acterization of the active form of PerR: insights into the
metal-induced activation of PerR and Fur proteins for
DNA binding. Mol Microbiol 73, 20–31.
35 D’Autreaux B, Pecqueur L, de Peredo AG, Diederix
REM, Caux-Thang C, Tabet L, Bersch B, Forest E &
Michaud-Soret I (2007) Reversible redox- and zinc-
dependent dimerization of the Escherichia coli Fur pro-
tein. Biochemistry 46, 1329–1342.

36 Le Cam E, Frechon D, Barray M, Fourcade A &
Delain E (1994) Observation of binding and polymeri-
zation of Fur repressor onto operator-containing DNA
with electron and atomic-force microscopes. Proc Natl
Acad Sci USA 91, 11816–11820.
37 Falk JE (1964) Porphyrins and Metalloporphyrins. Else-
vier, Amsterdam.
38 Kuzmic P (1996) Program DYNAFIT for the analysis
of enzyme kinetic data: application to HIV proteinase.
Anal Biochem 237, 260–273.
39 Laue TM, Shah BD, Ridgeway TM & Pelletier SL
(1992) Computer-aided interpretation of analytical
sedimentation data for proteins. In The Analytical
Heme binding to Irr promotes oligomerization G. F. White et al.
2020 FEBS Journal 278 (2011) 2011–2021 ª 2011 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2011 FEBS
Ultracentrifuge in Biochemistry and Polymer Science
(Harding SE, Rowe AJ & Horton J eds), pp. 90–125.
Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge.
Supporting information
The following supplementary material is available:
Fig. S1. Folding properties of the His-free variant of
Irr
Rl
.
Fig. S2. UV-visible absorbance studies of heme bind-
ing to Irr
Rl
His-free variant.
Fig. S3. UV-visible absorbance and fluorescence stud-
ies of heme binding to Irr

Rl
.
Fig. S4. Gel filtration analysis of the association state
of heme-bound Irr
Rl
.
Fig. S5. Model of Irr
Rl
.
Doc. S1. pH dependence of ferric heme binding to
Irr
Rl
.
Table S1. Oligonucleotide primers used in the present
study.
Table S2. Plasmids used in the present study.
This supplementary material can be found in the
online version of this article.
Please note: As a service to our authors and readers,
this journal provides supporting information supplied
by the authors. Such materials are peer-reviewed and
may be re-organized for online delivery, but are not
copy-edited or typeset. Technical support issues arising
from supporting information (other than missing files)
should be addressed to the authors.
G. F. White et al. Heme binding to Irr promotes oligomerization
FEBS Journal 278 (2011) 2011–2021 ª 2011 The Authors Journal compilation ª 2011 FEBS 2021