Luận văn : NGHIÊN CỨU KỸ THUẬT VI GHÉP CÂY BƯỞI (Citrus grandis) part 10 pdf

78


denotes a statistically significant difference.
Bảng phân tích biến lượng về số lá cây ghép từ tuần 1 đến tuần 4
Analysis of Variance for Sola (tuần 1) - Type III Sums of Squares

Source of variation Sum of Squares d.f. Mean square F-ratio Sig. level

MAIN EFFECTS
A: Sola.GOC .0370370 1 .0370370 .115 .7390
B: Sola.CHOI .1666667 2 .0833333 .259 .7727
C: Sola.CACH 1.0555556 2 .5277778 1.638 .2001
INTERACTIONS
AB .4629630 2 .2314815 .718 .4903
AC .9074074 2 .4537037 1.408 .2500
BC 1.9444444 4 .4861111 1.509 .2064
ABC .0925926 4 .0231481 .072 .9904

RESIDUAL 29.000000 90 .3222222

TOTAL (CORRECTED) 33.666667 107

1 missing values have been excluded.
All F-ratios are based on the residual mean square error.
Table of Least Squares Means for Sola

95% Confidence
Level Count Average Stnd. Error for mean

GRAND MEAN 108 1.6111111 .0546218 1.5025710 1.7196512
A: Sola.GOC
1 54 1.5925926 .0772469 1.4390937 1.7460914
2 54 1.6296296 .0772469 1.4761308 1.7831285
B: Sola.CHOI
3 36 1.6388889 .0946077 1.4508920 1.8268858
4 36 1.5555556 .0946077 1.3675586 1.7435525
5 36 1.6388889 .0946077 1.4508920 1.8268858
C: Sola.CACH
6 36 1.5555556 .0946077 1.3675586 1.7435525
7 36 1.7500000 .0946077 1.5620031 1.9379969
8 36 1.5277778 .0946077 1.3397808 1.7157747
AB
1 3 18 1.6666667 .1337955 1.4007989 1.9325345
1 4 18 1.4444444 .1337955 1.1785766 1.7103123
1 5 18 1.6666667 .1337955 1.4007989 1.9325345
2 3 18 1.6111111 .1337955 1.3452433 1.8769789
2 4 18 1.6666667 .1337955 1.4007989 1.9325345
2 5 18 1.6111111 .1337955 1.3452433 1.8769789
AC
1 6 18 1.6666667 .1337955 1.4007989 1.9325345
1 7 18 1.6666667 .1337955 1.4007989 1.9325345
1 8 18 1.4444444 .1337955 1.1785766 1.7103123
2 6 18 1.4444444 .1337955 1.1785766 1.7103123
2 7 18 1.8333333 .1337955 1.5674655 2.0992011
2 8 18 1.6111111 .1337955 1.3452433 1.8769789
BC
3 6 12 1.8333333 .1638653 1.5077131 2.1589536
3 7 12 1.6666667 .1638653 1.3410464 1.9922869

3 8 12 1.4166667 .1638653 1.0910464 1.7422869
4 6 12 1.3333333 .1638653 1.0077131 1.6589536
4 7 12 1.8333333 .1638653 1.5077131 2.1589536
4 8 12 1.5000000 .1638653 1.1743798 1.8256202
5 6 12 1.5000000 .1638653 1.1743798 1.8256202
5 7 12 1.7500000 .1638653 1.4243798 2.0756202
5 8 12 1.6666667 .1638653 1.3410464 1.9922869
Multiple range analysis for SOLAT1 by SOLA

Method: 95 Percent DUNCAN
Level Count Average Homogeneous Groups

XV-NR-M 6 1.3333333 X
XV-DX-E 6 1.3333333 X
XV-DX-M 6 1.3333333 X
B-DX-E 6 1.3333333 X
B-ĐLC-E 6 1.3333333 X
B-NR-M 6 1.5000000 XX
XV-NR-T 6 1.6666667 XX


79


XV-DX-T 6 1.6666667 XX
XV-ĐLC-E 6 1.6666667 XX
XV-ĐLC-T 6 1.6666667 XX
XV-ĐLC-M 6 1.6666667 XX
B-NR-E 6 1.6666667 XX
B-NR-T 6 1.6666667 XX

B-DX-M 6 1.6666667 XX
B-ĐLC-M 6 1.6666667 XX
B-ĐLC-T 6 1.8333333 XX
XV-NR-E 6 2.0000000 X
B-DX-T 6 2.0000000 X

* denotes a statistically significant difference.
Multiple range analysis for Sola by Sola.Goc ghep

Method: 95 Percent DUNCAN
Level Count LS Mean Homogeneous Groups

1 54 1.5925926 X
2 54 1.6296296 X

contrast difference limits
1 - 2 -0.03704 0.21708

* denotes a statistically significant difference.
Multiple range analysis for Sola by Sola.Choi ghep

Method: 95 Percent DUNCAN
Level Count LS Mean Homogeneous Groups

4 36 1.5555556 X
3 36 1.6388889 X
5 36 1.6388889 X

contrast difference limits
3 - 4 0.08333 0.26587

3 - 5 0.00000 0.26587
4 - 5 -0.08333 0.26587

* denotes a statistically significant difference.
Multiple range analysis for Sola by Sola.Cach ghep

Method: 95 Percent DUNCAN
Level Count LS Mean Homogeneous Groups

8 36 1.5277778 X
6 36 1.5555556 X
7 36 1.7500000 X

contrast difference limits
6 - 7 -0.19444 0.26587
6 - 8 0.02778 0.26587
7 - 8 0.22222 0.26587

* denotes a statistically significant difference.

Analysis of Variance for Sola (tuần 2) - Type III Sums of Squares

Source of variation Sum of Squares d.f. Mean square F-ratio Sig. level

MAIN EFFECTS
A: Sola.GOC .2314815 1 .2314815 .592 .4517
B: Sola.CHOI 1.9074074 2 .9537037 2.441 .0928
C: Sola.CACH .9629630 2 .4814815 1.232 .2965
INTERACTIONS
AB .9074074 2 .4537037 1.161 .3178

AC 2.7407407 2 1.3703704 3.507 .0341
BC 1.9259259 4 .4814815 1.232 .3029
ABC 1.3703704 4 .3425926 .877 .4812

RESIDUAL 35.166667 90 .3907407

TOTAL (CORRECTED) 45.212963 107

1 missing values have been excluded.
All F-ratios are based on the residual mean square error.


80


Table of Least Squares Means for Sola (tuần 2)

95% Confidence
Level Count Average Stnd. Error for mean

GRAND MEAN 108 2.2314815 .0601496 2.1119570 2.3510059
A: Sola.GOC
1 54 2.1851852 .0850643 2.0161521 2.3542183
2 54 2.2777778 .0850643 2.1087447 2.4468109
B: Sola.CHOI
3 36 2.1111111 .1041821 1.9040887 2.3181335
4 36 2.1666667 .1041821 1.9596443 2.3736891
5 36 2.4166667 .1041821 2.2096443 2.6236891
C: Sola.CACH
6 36 2.3611111 .1041821 2.1540887 2.5681335

7 36 2.1388889 .1041821 1.9318665 2.3459113
8 36 2.1944444 .1041821 1.9874220 2.4014669
AB
1 3 18 1.9444444 .1473357 1.6516705 2.2372183
1 4 18 2.2222222 .1473357 1.9294483 2.5149961
1 5 18 2.3888889 .1473357 2.0961150 2.6816628
2 3 18 2.2777778 .1473357 1.9850039 2.5705517
2 4 18 2.1111111 .1473357 1.8183372 2.4038850
2 5 18 2.4444444 .1473357 2.1516705 2.7372183
AC
1 6 18 2.5000000 .1473357 2.2072261 2.7927739
1 7 18 2.1111111 .1473357 1.8183372 2.4038850
1 8 18 1.9444444 .1473357 1.6516705 2.2372183
2 6 18 2.2222222 .1473357 1.9294483 2.5149961
2 7 18 2.1666667 .1473357 1.8738928 2.4594406
2 8 18 2.4444444 .1473357 2.1516705 2.7372183
BC
3 6 12 2.4166667 .1804487 2.0580933 2.7752400
3 7 12 2.0833333 .1804487 1.7247600 2.4419067
3 8 12 1.8333333 .1804487 1.4747600 2.1919067
4 6 12 2.2500000 .1804487 1.8914267 2.6085733
4 7 12 2.0833333 .1804487 1.7247600 2.4419067
4 8 12 2.1666667 .1804487 1.8080933 2.5252400
5 6 12 2.4166667 .1804487 2.0580933 2.7752400
5 7 12 2.2500000 .1804487 1.8914267 2.6085733
5 8 12 2.5833333 .1804487 2.2247600 2.9419067
Multiple range analysis for SOLAT2 by SOLA

Method: 95 Percent DUNCAN
Level Count Average Homogeneous Groups

XV-NR-M 6 1.5000000 X
XV-NR-T 6 1.8333333 XX
B-DX-T 6 2.0000000 XXX
XV-DX-T 6 2.1666667 XXX
XV-DX-M 6 2.1666667 XXX
XV-ĐLC-M 6 2.1666667 XXX
B-NR-M 6 2.1666667 XXX
B-DX-E 6 2.1666667 XXX
B-DX-M 6 2.1666667 XXX
B-ĐLC-E 6 2.1666667 XXX
B-ĐLC-T 6 2.1666667 XXX
XV-DX-E 6 2.3333333 XXX
XV-ĐLC-T 6 2.3333333 XXX
B-NR-E 6 2.3333333 XXX
B-NR-T 6 2.3333333 XXX
XV-NR-E 6 2.5000000 XXX
XV-ĐLC-E 6 2.6666667 XX
B-ĐLC-M 6 3.0000000 X

* denotes a statistically significant difference.
Multiple range analysis for Sola by Sola.Goc ghep

Method: 95 Percent DUNCAN
Level Count LS Mean Homogeneous Groups

1 54 2.1851852 X
2 54 2.2777778 X

contrast difference limits

1 - 2 -0.09259 0.23905



81


* denotes a statistically significant difference.
Multiple range analysis for Sola by Sola.Choi ghep

Method: 95 Percent DUNCAN
Level Count LS Mean Homogeneous Groups

3 36 2.1111111 X
4 36 2.1666667 XX
5 36 2.4166667 X

contrast difference limits
3 - 4 -0.05556 0.29277
3 - 5 -0.30556 0.29277 *
4 - 5 -0.25000 0.29277

denotes a statistically significant difference.
Multiple range analysis for Sola by Sola.Cach ghep

Method: 95 Percent DUNCAN
Level Count LS Mean Homogeneous Groups

7 36 2.1388889 X
8 36 2.1944444 X

6 36 2.3611111 X

contrast difference limits
6 - 7 0.22222 0.29277
6 - 8 0.16667 0.29277
7 - 8 -0.05556 0.29277

denotes a statistically significant difference.
Analysis of Variance for Sola (tuần 3) - Type III Sums of Squares

Source of variation Sum of Squares d.f. Mean square F-ratio Sig. level

MAIN EFFECTS
A: Sola.GOC 2.6759259 1 2.6759259 2.632 .1082
B: Sola.CHOI 2.7407407 2 1.3703704 1.348 .2650
C: Sola.CACH 1.6851852 2 .8425926 .829 .4399
INTERACTIONS
AB .296296 2 .1481481 .146 .8646
AC .796296 2 .3981481 .392 .6771
BC 12.925926 4 3.2314815 3.179 .0172
ABC 16.148148 4 4.0370370 3.971 .0052

RESIDUAL 91.500000 90 1.0166667

TOTAL (CORRECTED) 128.76852 107

1 missing values have been excluded.
All F-ratios are based on the residual mean square error.
Table of Least Squares Means for Sola (tuần 3)

95% Confidence
Level Count Average Stnd. Error for mean

GRAND MEAN 108 3.0462963 .0970236 2.8534987 3.2390939
A: Sola.GOC
1 54 2.8888889 .1372121 2.6162319 3.1615459
2 54 3.2037037 .1372121 2.9310467 3.4763607
B: Sola.CHOI
3 36 3.0277778 .1680498 2.6938425 3.3617131
4 36 3.2500000 .1680498 2.9160647 3.5839353
5 36 2.8611111 .1680498 2.5271758 3.1950464
C: Sola.CACH
6 36 3.0555556 .1680498 2.7216203 3.3894908
7 36 3.1944444 .1680498 2.8605092 3.5283797
8 36 2.8888889 .1680498 2.5549536 3.2228242
AB
1 3 18 2.8333333 .2376583 2.3610775 3.3055891
1 4 18 3.1666667 .2376583 2.6944109 3.6389225
1 5 18 2.6666667 .2376583 2.1944109 3.1389225
2 3 18 3.2222222 .2376583 2.7499664 3.6944780
2 4 18 3.3333333 .2376583 2.8610775 3.8055891
2 5 18 3.0555556 .2376583 2.5832998 3.5278114


82


AC
1 6 18 2.9444444 .2376583 2.4721886 3.4167002
1 7 18 3.1111111 .2376583 2.6388553 3.5833669

1 8 18 2.6111111 .2376583 2.1388553 3.0833669
2 6 18 3.1666667 .2376583 2.6944109 3.6389225
2 7 18 3.2777778 .2376583 2.8055220 3.7500336
2 8 18 3.1666667 .2376583 2.6944109 3.6389225
BC
3 6 12 3.0000000 .2910708 2.4216071 3.5783929
3 7 12 3.5833333 .2910708 3.0049405 4.1617262
3 8 12 2.5000000 .2910708 1.9216071 3.0783929
4 6 12 3.5833333 .2910708 3.0049405 4.1617262
4 7 12 3.3333333 .2910708 2.7549405 3.9117262
4 8 12 2.8333333 .2910708 2.2549405 3.4117262
5 6 12 2.5833333 .2910708 2.0049405 3.1617262
5 7 12 2.6666667 .2910708 2.0882738 3.2450595
5 8 12 3.3333333 .2910708 2.7549405 3.9117262



Multiple range analysis for SOLAT3 by SOLA

Method: 95 Percent DUNCAN
Level Count Average Homogeneous Groups

XV-NR-M 6 2.1666667 X
XV-ĐLC-T 6 2.5000000 XX
B-ĐLC-E 6 2.5000000 XX
XV-ĐLC-T 6 2.6666667 XX
B-NR-E 6 2.6666667 XX
XV-DX-E 6 2.8333333 XXX
XV-DX-M 6 2.8333333 XXX
XV-ĐLC-M 6 2.8333333 XXX

B-NR-M 6 2.8333333 XXX
B-DX-T 6 2.8333333 XXX
B-DX-M 6 2.8333333 XXX
B-ĐLC-T 6 2.8333333 XXX
XV-NR-T 6 3.0000000 XXX
XV-NR-E 6 3.3333333 XXX
XV-DX-T 6 3.8333333 XX
B-ĐLC-M 6 3.8333333 XX
B-NR-T 6 4.1666667 X
B-DX-E 6 4.3333333 X
* denotes a statistically significant difference.

Multiple range analysis for Sola by Sola.Goc ghep

Method: 95 Percent DUNCAN
Level Count LS Mean Homogeneous Groups

1 54 2.8888889 X
2 54 3.2037037 X

contrast difference limits
1 - 2 -0.31481 0.38560

* denotes a statistically significant difference.

Multiple range analysis for Sola by Sola.Choi ghep

Method: 95 Percent DUNCAN
Level Count LS Mean Homogeneous Groups

5 36 2.8611111 X
3 36 3.0277778 X
4 36 3.2500000 X

contrast difference limits
3 - 4 -0.22222 0.47226
3 - 5 0.16667 0.47226
4 - 5 0.38889 0.47226

* denotes a statistically significant difference.

Multiple range analysis for Sola by Sola.Cach ghep

Method: 95 Percent DUNCAN


83


Level Count LS Mean Homogeneous Groups

8 36 2.8888889 X
6 36 3.0555556 X
7 36 3.1944444 X

contrast difference limits
6 - 7 -0.13889 0.47226
6 - 8 0.16667 0.47226
7 - 8 0.30556 0.47226

denotes a statistically significant difference.


Analysis of Variance for Sola (tuần 4) - Type III Sums of Squares

Source of variation Sum of Squares d.f. Mean square F-ratio Sig. level

MAIN EFFECTS
A: Sola.GOC 5.333333 1 5.3333333 7.742 .0066
B: Sola.CHOI 4.518519 2 2.2592593 3.280 .0422
C: Sola.CACH 17.240741 2 8.6203704 12.513 .0000
INTERACTIONS
AB 1.5555556 2 .7777778 1.129 .3279
AC 1.7222222 2 .8611111 1.250 .2914
BC 9.4259259 4 2.3564815 3.421 .0119
ABC 9.3888889 4 2.3472222 3.407 .0121

RESIDUAL 62.000000 90 .6888889

TOTAL (CORRECTED) 111.18519 107

1 missing values have been excluded.
All F-ratios are based on the residual mean square error.

Table of Least Squares Means for Sola (tuần 4)

95% Confidence
Level Count Average Stnd. Error for mean

GRAND MEAN 108 3.6296296 .0798661 3.4709260 3.7883333

A: Sola.GOC
1 54 3.4074074 .1129478 3.1829665 3.6318483
2 54 3.8518519 .1129478 3.6274110 4.0762927
B: Sola.CHOI
3 36 3.6111111 .1383322 3.3362283 3.8859939
4 36 3.8888889 .1383322 3.6140061 4.1637717
5 36 3.3888889 .1383322 3.1140061 3.6637717
C: Sola.CACH
6 36 3.7777778 .1383322 3.5028950 4.0526606
7 36 4.0277778 .1383322 3.7528950 4.3026606
8 36 3.0833333 .1383322 2.8084505 3.3582162
AB
1 3 18 3.2222222 .1956313 2.8334792 3.6109652
1 4 18 3.7777778 .1956313 3.3890348 4.1665208
1 5 18 3.2222222 .1956313 2.8334792 3.6109652
2 3 18 4.0000000 .1956313 3.6112570 4.3887430
2 4 18 4.0000000 .1956313 3.6112570 4.3887430
2 5 18 3.5555556 .1956313 3.1668125 3.9442986
AC
1 6 18 3.7222222 .1956313 3.3334792 4.1109652
1 7 18 3.7777778 .1956313 3.3890348 4.1665208
1 8 18 2.7222222 .1956313 2.3334792 3.1109652
2 6 18 3.8333333 .1956313 3.4445903 4.2220764
2 7 18 4.2777778 .1956313 3.8890348 4.6665208
2 8 18 3.4444444 .1956313 3.0557014 3.8331875
BC
3 6 12 3.9166667 .2395984 3.4405556 4.3927777
3 7 12 4.2500000 .2395984 3.7738890 4.7261110
3 8 12 2.6666667 .2395984 2.1905556 3.1427777
4 6 12 4.1666667 .2395984 3.6905556 4.6427777

4 7 12 4.3333333 .2395984 3.8572223 4.8094444
4 8 12 3.1666667 .2395984 2.6905556 3.6427777
5 6 12 3.2500000 .2395984 2.7738890 3.7261110
5 7 12 3.5000000 .2395984 3.0238890 3.9761110
5 8 12 3.4166667 .2395984 2.9405556 3.8927777


84



Multiple range analysis for SOLAT4 by SOLA

Method: 95 Percent DUNCAN
Level Count Average Homogeneous Groups

XV-NR-M 6 2.0000000 X
B-ĐLC-E 6 2.8333333 XX
XV-ĐLC-T 6 3.0000000 XX
XV-ĐLC-M 6 3.0000000 XX
XV-DX-M 6 3.1666667 XXX
B-DX-M 6 3.1666667 XXX
B-NR-M 6 3.3333333 XXXX
XV-DX-E 6 3.6666667 XXXXX
XV-ĐLC-E 6 3.6666667 XXXXX
XV-NR-E 6 3.8333333 XXXXX
XV-NR-T 6 3.8333333 XXXXX
B-ĐLC-M 6 3.8333333 XXXXX
B-NR-E 6 4.0000000 XXXX
B-ĐLC-T 6 4.0000000 XXXX

B-DX-T 6 4.1666667 XXX
XV-DX-T 6 4.5000000 XX
B-NR-T 6 4.6666667 X
B-DX-E 6 4.6666667 X

* denotes a statistically significant difference.
Multiple range analysis for Sola by Sola.Goc ghep

Method: 95 Percent DUNCAN
Level Count LS Mean Homogeneous Groups

1 54 3.4074074 X
2 54 3.8518519 X

contrast difference limits
1 - 2 -0.44444 0.31741 *

* denotes a statistically significant difference.

Multiple range analysis for Sola by Sola.Choi ghep

Method: 95 Percent DUNCAN
Level Count LS Mean Homogeneous Groups

5 36 3.3888889 X
3 36 3.6111111 XX
4 36 3.8888889 X

contrast difference limits
3 - 4 -0.27778 0.38874

3 - 5 0.22222 0.38874
4 - 5 0.50000 0.38874 *

* denotes a statistically significant difference.

Multiple range analysis for Sola by Sola.Cach ghep

Method: 95 Percent DUNCAN
Level Count LS Mean Homogeneous Groups

8 36 3.0833333 X
6 36 3.7777778 X
7 36 4.0277778 X

contrast difference limits
6 - 7 -0.25000 0.38874
6 - 8 0.69444 0.38874 *
7 - 8 0.94444 0.38874 *

* denotes a statistically significant difference.





85