Thí điểm đánh giá môn học tại trường Đại học Thủy Lợi

I HC QUC GIA HÀ NI
VIỆN ĐẢM BẢO CHẤT LƯỢNG GIÁO DỤC






Nguyễn Hương Giang






THÍ ĐIỂM ĐÁNH GIÁ MÔN HỌC TẠI
TRƯỜNG ĐẠI HỌC THỦY LỢI







LU

Hà Nội – Năm 2013
I HC QUC GIA HÀ NI
VIỆN ĐẢM BẢO CHẤT LƯỢNG GIÁO DỤC






Nguyễn Hương Giang





THÍ ĐIỂM ĐÁNH GIÁ MÔN HỌC TẠI
TRƯỜNG ĐẠI HỌC THỦY LỢI




Chuyên ngành: Đo lường và đánh giá trong giáo dục
m)

LU

Người hướng dẫn khoa học: PGS. TS. Phạm Văn Quyết





Hà Nội – Năm 2013

MỤC LỤC
Nội dung
Trang
Li c

L

Mc lc

Danh mc các ch vit tt

Danh mc các hình v

Danh mc các bng

Danh mc các hp

Mở đầu

1. Lý do ch tài
1
2. Mu
2
3. Gii hn nghiên cu
2
4. u
2
5. c và thc tin c tài nghiên cu
3
Chương 1: Cơ sở lý luận và tổng quan
4
1.1. Tng quan v nghiên cu
4
1.2.  lý lun
11
1.2.1. Các khái nim v chng
11
1.2.2. Mt s khái nim liê tài
16
Chương 2: Tổ chức và phương pháp nghiên cứu
23
2.1. Mu nghiên cu
23
2.1.1. Mu kho sát cho môn hc
23
2.1.2. Mu kho sát cho sinh viên
23
2.1.3. Mu kho sát ging viên
23

2.2. Tin trình nghiên cu
24
 pháp nghiên cu
25
u tài liu
25
u tra bng bng hi
25
ng vn sâu
26
p thông tin
26
2.4.1. Thm kho sát ly ý kin phn hi
26
2.4.2. Quy trình thc hin
26
 tin c hiu lc ca b công c 
27
u tra th nghim
27
 tin c
27
2.5.1.2. Kt qu kim tra theo mô hình Rasch bng cách s dng
phn mm Quest cho bng hi 




30
2.5.2 







33
2.5.2.1. 








34
2.5.2.2. Kt qu kim tra theo mô hình Rasch bng cách s dng
phn mm Quest cho bng hi .
36
Chương 3: Các kết quả thực nghiệm và thảo luận
40
 ng  tng ni dung
40
3.1.1. T
41
3.1.2. 

, 







47
3.1.3. 
54
3.1.4. 

, 










58


3.2. Phân tích m ng ca các nhân t n môn hc
64
3.2.1. Nhân t v vic t chc thc hin môn hc
64
3.2.2. Nhân t ni dung, cu trúc ca môn hc
65

3.2.3. Nhân t tài liu hc tp
66
3.2.4. Nhân t kit qu hc tp ca môn hc
66
3.3. Phân tích s khác bit v mc   gia sinh viên
các môn hc
67
Kết luận và đề xuất
71
1. Kt lun
71
 xut
71
3. Nhng m và hn ch ca nghiên cu
73
ng nghiên cu tip theo
73
Tài liệu tham khảo
74
Phụ lục
77
Ph lc 1: Phiu hi th nghim
77
Ph lc 2: Phiu hi chính thc (Dành cho sinh viên)
80
Ph lc 3: Phiu hi chính thc (Dành cho ging viên)
83
Ph lc 4: Thng kê mô t phiu hi chính thc (Phiu hi sinh viên)
86
Ph lc 5: Thng kê mô t phiu hi chính thc (Phiu hi ging viên)

87
Ph lc 6: 








88
Ph lc 7: 




89
8: Câu hi phng vo)
91
9: Câu hi phng vo)
92

1

M
1. 



 D có 

. C  
 
 và nó 

2. M 
 giá 
khái quát  nhóm   
    


3. 
- 5 
- 1-2012.
4. 
4.1  
 ?
4.2.  
4.3.1. 
-  51,52,53.
- 
-  
4.3.2. 
-   
.

: thêm 
nc.
 
 , 




2


1.1 
:
- 
- 
1.2 
1.2.1. 

- 
- 

 
xung quanh          
 t 
.










2.1. M



nhóm
Nhóm rút


nhiên

sinh viên


GV

12
N03
66
6
TTHCM
16
N11
62
6
TLCT
8
N06
62
7


7
N02
65
8
KT&TCXD
2
N01
43
7



298
34

3

2.1. 
2.2. 
2.3. 
2.4.  


2: 
STT
Môn
Nhóm
phát



sinh
viên

tham gia

1

N06
65
63
2

N01
60
58
3


N02
42
41



167
162
2.5.1.1. 









r = 0,907).


 . 
.


c

(1) Về tô
̉
chư
́
c thư
̣
c hiê
̣
n môn ho
̣
c -C9),
0,864. 08/09 






 
 0,3 (

05 


 0,834 


0,879 
(2) Về nô
̣
i dung, cấu tru
́
c môn ho
̣
c 16 0 25, C10-
C250,861. 11/16 




 0,829 (18) 


0,864 (17 21).
(3) Về ti liu hc tp 04 26 29, C26-C29
bá0,644. 03/04 





0,438 (29) 


là 0,680 
(4) Về kiê
̉
m tra, đa
́
nh gia
́
kết qua
̉
hc tâ
̣
p 07 30 36,
C30-C360,702. 06/07 





4

0,627 (31) 


0,755 

Như vâ
̣
y, 

















 04/04 


 , 

0,6.  23/36 


 0,3;  12/36  0,3 01 







(câu C35). âu Kết quả kiểm tra đánh giá khách quan”.
2.5.1.2






PHIEU LAY Y KIEN VE MON HOC

Item Estimates (Thresholds)
10/ 1/13 10: 9
all on giang (N = 162 L = 36 Probability Level= .50)

Summary of item Estimates
=========================
Mean .01
SD .88
SD (adjusted) .36
Reliability of estimate .85
Fit Statistics
===============
Infit Mean Square Outfit Mean Square
Mean 1.00 Mean 1.00
SD .20 SD .24

Infit t Outfit t
Mean .20 Mean .14
SD 2.44 SD 2.20
0 items with zero scores
0 items with perfect scores

PHIEU LAY Y KIEN VE MON HOC

Case Estimates
10/ 1/13 10: 9
all on giang (N = 162 L = 36 Probability Level= .50)

Summary of case Estimates
=========================
Mean .63
SD .61
SD (adjusted) .58
Reliability of estimate .89

Fit Statistics
===============
Infit Mean Square Outfit Mean Square
Mean .99 Mean 1.00
SD .42 SD .42
Infit t Outfit t
Mean 17 Mean 05
SD 1.54 SD 1.21

0 cases with zero scores
0 cases with perfect scores

- K, 
dữ liu phù hợp với mô hình Rasch.

PHIEU LAY Y KIEN VE MON HOC

Item Fit 10/ 1/13 10: 9
all on giang (N = 162 L = 36 Probability Level= .50)
INFIT
MNSQ .71 .77 .83 .91 1.00 1.10 1.20 1.30 1.40
+ + + + + + + + +
1 item 1 . * | .
2 item 2 . * | .
3 item 3 .* | .
4 item 4 .* | .
5 item 5 . | * .
6 item 6 * | .





 


5

7 item 7 . * | .
8 item 8 . * | .
9 item 9 . | * .
10 item 10 . * | .

11 item 11 . * | .
12 item 12 * . | .
13 item 13 . | * .
14 item 14 . * | .
15 item 15 . * | .
16 item 16 . * | .
17 item 17 . | * .
18 item 18 * . | .
19 item 19 . | * .
20 item 20 . * | .
21 item 21 . | * .
22 item 22 . | * .
23 item 23 . | * .
24 item 24 . * | .
25 item 25 . | * .
26 item 26 . * | .
27 item 27 . | * .
28 item 28 . | * .
29 item 29 . * | .
30 item 30 . | * .
31 item 31 . | * .
32 item 32 . | * .
33 item 33 . | * .
34 item 34 . | * .
35 item 35 . | . *
36 item 36 . | . *
89% , 32/36 
 [0,77; 1,30],  . 



04/36 











[0,77; 1,30]. : 12, 18, 35, 36
Như vâ
̣
y, 

























 



 32 










.
2.5.2. 









 SV)

 :
2.7: 









TT






(%)
1





Nam
195
68,7



89
31,3
2
Môn

  



 XD
41
14,4





60
20,4





1
63
22,2

58
21,1

62
21,8
2.5.2.1. 








r = 0,872).






 

 18.0 

c



6

(1) Về tô
̉
chư
́
c thư
̣
c hiê
̣
n môn ho
̣
c -C9),
0,824. 


 0,790 (7) 

 0,836 
C5).
(2) Về nô
̣
i dung, cấu tru
́
c môn ho
̣
c 16 0 25, C10-
C250,725. 0,680 (13) 



0,732 
(3) Về ti liu hc tp 04 26 29, C26-C29
0,669
0,515 (29) 

0,683 
C27).
(4) Về kiê
̉
m tra, đa
́
nh gia
́
kết qua
̉
hc tâ
̣
p 07  30 36,
C30-C360,702
0,728 (31 
cáo 

0,781 
Như vâ
̣
y, 


















 04/04 


. 



.
2.5.2.2      


PHIEU LAY Y KIEN VE MON HOC CHINH THUC

Item Estimates (Thresholds)
10/ 1/13 10: 8

all on giang2 (N = 284 L = 32 Probability Level= .50)

Summary of item Estimates
=========================
Mean .01
SD .88
SD (adjusted) .84
Reliability of estimate .91
Fit Statistics
===============
Infit Mean Square Outfit Mean Square
Mean 1.00 Mean .99
SD .16 SD .18
Infit t Outfit t
Mean .17 Mean .17
SD 1.83 SD 1.72
0 items with zero scores
0 items with perfect scores

PHIEU LAY Y KIEN VE MON HOC CHINH THUC

Case Estimates
10/ 1/13 10: 8
all on giang2 (N = 284 L = 32 Probability Level= .50)

Summary of case Estimates
=========================
Mean .70
SD .66
SD (adjusted) .62

Reliability of estimate .88
Fit Statistics
===============
Infit Mean Square Outfit Mean Square
Mean .98 Mean .99








7

SD .42 SD .42
Infit t Outfit t
Mean 16 Mean 07
SD 1.40 SD 1.13
0 cases with zero scores
0 cases with perfect scores
- và  .
dữ liu phù hợp với mô hình Rasch.


PHIEU LAY Y KIEN VE MON HOC CHINH THUC

Item Fit 10/ 1/13 10: 8
all on giang2 (N = 284 L = 32 Probability Level= .50)

INFIT
MNSQ .71 .77 .83 .91 1.00 1.10 1.20 1.30
+ + + + + + + +
1 item 1 . * | .
2 item 2 . * | .
3 item 3 . * | .
4 item 4 * | .
5 item 5 . | * .
6 item 6 . * | .
7 item 7 . * | .
8 item 8 . * | .
9 item 9 . | * .
10 item 10 . * | .
11 item 11 . * | .
12 item 12 . | * .
13 item 13 . * | .
14 item 14 . * | .
15 item 15 . * | .
16 item 16 . | * .
17 item 17 . | * .
18 item 18 . *| .
19 item 19 . | * .
20 item 20 . | * .
21 item 21 . | * .
22 item 22 . * | .
23 item 23 . | * .
24 item 24 . * | .
25 item 25 . | * .
26 item 26 . | * .
27 item 27 . * | .

28 item 28 . | * .
29 item 29 . | * .
30 item 30 . | * .
31 item 31 . | * .
32 item 32 . | * .
88% , 








 

Như vâ
̣
y, sau k

























 32 



















 .




3.1. 




















 3,63 
3,78.

Hình 3.1: 

8


3.70
3.78
3.67
3.63
3.55 3.60 3.65 3.70 3.75 3.80










3.1.1. T
a. 






và 3.3  và GV 
.

Hình 3.2: 








c tchc thc hin môn c
4.08
3.79
4.05
4.16
3.00
3.40
3.16
4.26
3.37
0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
2.50
3.00
3.50
4.00

4.50
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Ni dung










  nhau.  và tiêu
Môn hc xếp giảng dạy vo hc kỳ đó phù hợp”.
Hình 3.3: 

9



4.25
4.30
3.05
4.25
4.20
4.25
4.25
4.00
4.20

0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
2.50
3.00
3.50
4.00
4.50
5.00
C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 C6 C7 C8 C9
Tiêu chí


b. 

































(Independent samples T- 09/09 
> 0,05v

c. 
























  
môn 



  
T5 “Môn hc xếp giảng dạy vo hc kỳ đó
phù hợp”  ,
3.1.2. 

, 









a. 






Hình 3.4: 








i dung, cu c a môn c
3.43
3.81
3.88
3.27
4.10
4.19
4.12
3.98
3.52

4.02
4.21
4.21
3.40
4.21
0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
2.50
3.00
3.50
4.00
4.50
10 11 13 14 15 16 17 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Ni dung


Qua hình 3.4 và 3.5 và GV  

Hình 3.5: 












10


3.35
3.75
4.05
4.30
4.05
4.05
3.95
4.30
4.20
4.20
4.00
4.10
4.25
4.35
0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
2.50
3.00
3.50
4.00
4.50

5.00
10 11 13 14 15 16 17 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Tiêu chí


b. 

































-13/14  0,05
qua cách 

 
c. 




















  
, 





 môn 
Có 12/14 tiêu chí có giá tr

 
 





95%.
3.1.3. 
a. 






Hình 3.6:  



i liu c
2.97
4.22
4.12
3.35
0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
2.50
3.00
3.50
4.00
4.50
26 27 28 29
Ni dung


Nội dung giáo trình đầy đủ.  
giá 
Hình 3.7:  





11


3.60
4.15
4.20
4.50
0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
2.50
3.00
3.50
4.00
4.50
5.00
C26 C27 C28 C29
Tiêu chí


b. 

































- 04/04 0,05,
v


các tiêu chí .  
c. 
























 
   04/04 


  qua







95%.
3.1.4. 

, 












a. 






 













ý.
Hình 3.9:  











3.68
3.79
3.69
3.88
3.81
0.00
0.50
1.00

1.50
2.00
2.50
3.00
3.50
4.00
4.50
C30
C31
C32
C33
C34
Tiêu chí


12


3.70
3.95
4.15
2.75
3.45
0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
2.50
3.00

3.50
4.00
4.50
C30 C31 C32 C33 C34
Tiêu chí


b. 



















 
-04/05 
0,05




ít 
c. 























 
  




, 













 

3.2. 

MÔN H
3.2.1. 





















       , 






 1  , 















 56% 





 
. 



, 

   Mục
tiêu môn hc đáp ứng mục tiêu ngnh hc là 4,08) và (% SV l ).


2 

 C3, C4, C5, C6, C7, C8, C9 có . 
 . 
 Môn hc xếp giảng dạy vo hc kỳ
đó phù hợp 
3.2.2. 






, 
















  , 






 1  ba 






 , 





 


 54% 





 . Nhân  
 . 



 , 

 13 Môn tiên quyết có cần thiết” 
3,8878,7% 




 ).

13



 

 C14, C15, C16, C17, C19, C20, C21, C22, C23, C24, C25
. 



 
.    C21: Số tiết
được phân bổ hợp lí trong từng chương của môn hc %. 
3.2.3. 





















  , the






 1  





 , 









 51% 





 . Nhân  C26 (Nội dung giáo trình đầy đủ).




, 

này   cho SV 2,97) và (39,2%




).
N 

27, C28, C29 . 


liên  phân tích cho    
Ti liu tham khảo phong phú, cp nht (53
3.2.4. 






, 
























  , theo







 1  , 














 56% 





 C30 (Bi kiểm tra
của bạn được đánh giá rõ rng chính xác).
N 

31, C32, C33, C34 . 



 quá trình  
  Trng số giữa điểm quá trình v điểm thi được thiết kế phù
hợp (69,6.
3.3. 





 



















MÔN 
Qua phân tích  cho  
0,503 0,847
 
4 
T 
các môn 

viên ngành KT &TCXD 
Sig. = 0,000.
SV SV

g 3























 cho 












3,50. 
























.

14

, q























 . 










 .




































 50% 






 , 










 .
 

K
34 ti
Ngoài ra, y 

  Môn chuyên ngành
 .
2. 
a/ 
b/ 
c/  





4. 
 

