Publishing workshop (phuong pháp để đăng một bài báo khoa học)

Publishing Workshop
“How to publish your research in a top journal”

Dr. Elaine van Ommen Kloeke
Elsevier
Agronomy & Remote Sensing

1


2


What will we cover in this workshop?

•

Understanding scholarly publishing

•

How to get published:
•
•
•

•

3

Preparing

Structuring & writing
Using Proper Scientific Language

Publishing ethics


Understanding Scholarly
Publishing

4


Let’s Start at the Beginning
Journal publishing has thrived for over 340 years but the
fundamental role of Publishers remains unchanged

Registration
Timestamp

Certification
Peer review – validity & integrity

Dissemination
Medium to share findings
First scientific journals
published in 1665

Preservation
Preserve and archive records of science

5

Elzevirianas circa 1629


The Publishing Cycle
30-60%
by >
Solicit rejected
& manage
7,000 editors
submissions

10 million
articles
Archive
&
in archive
promote
use

Manage
peer
500,000+
review
reviewers

>480 million
Publishby& >30
downloads

disseminate
million
researchers
in >180 countries!

Nearly
½ million
Edit
&
articles
accepted
prepare

9.8 million articles
Production
available

6


Peer Review
Helps to determine the quality,
validity, significance and originality
of research

Helps to improve the
quality of papers

Publishers stand outside the
academic process and are not prone

to prejudice or favour
Publishers facilitate the review
process by investing in online review
systems and providing tools to help
Editors and Reviewers

7


rejection

Without it there is no
control in scientific
communication

OUT
rejection

Journal Editors evaluate
and reject certain articles
prior to external peer
review

Submission

Editor
(preliminary Assessment)

Reviewer 1

Reviewer 2

Editor: Decision
accepted

Print Proof
In Press
Branding, logos,
page numbers
Published

8

minor/major revisions required

A well understood
concept

Initial
changes

Principles of Peer Review

Typesetting,
copy editing


The Publishing Industry Over Time…

1665

1580

1880

1989

2000
1998-1999

9

Today


Global Expansion of Research
Compound Annual Growth Rate In Articles
2006-10

40%
35%

Malaysia

30%
25%

Iran
Romania
Saudi Arabia

20%

Pakistan

15%

Egypt
Thailand
India
Brazil
Turkey Taiwan
Republic of Korea
France Germany
United Kingdom

10%

5%
0%
-5%

10

China

United States

Japan

0

100

200

300

Articles 2010 (Thousands)

400

500


Publishing Innovations

Flow
Article
Transfer
Service

Interactive Plots
and Figures

Author
Experience

11

Article of the
Future
Google Maps

Your Paper,
Your Way


Get social!
• New ways to communicate
– Make sure the world knows you and your work

• New communities
– Connect and collaborate

12


‘How To Get Published’
Preparing Your Manuscript

13


Are You Ready To Publish?

14


Are you ready to publish? Guiding questions

• Have you done something new and interesting?
•

Have you provided solutions to any difficult problems?

•

Have you checked the latest results in the field?

•

Have you verified the findings?

•

Did you perform the appropriate controls?

•

Do your results fit - is the story complete?

15


Choosing the right journal
Find the journal that best suits your work:
Look at the Aims & Scope of a journal

Physiological and Molecular
Plant Pathology

Physiological and Molecular Plant
Pathology provides an International forum for
original research papers, reviews, and
commentaries on all aspects of the molecular
biology, biochemistry, physiology,ultrastru
cture, genetics and evolution of plantmicrobe interactions.
Papers on all kinds of infective pathogen,
including viruses, prokaryotes, fungi, and
nematodes, as well as mutualistic organisms
such as Rhizobiumand mycorrhyzal fungi, are
acceptable as long as they have a bearing on
the interaction between microbe and plant.
…


Read The ‘Guide for Authors’
• Find it on the journal homepage of the publisher, e.g. Elsevier.com
• Keep to the Guide for Authors in your manuscript
• Editors do not like wasting time on poorly prepared manuscripts

17


‘How To Get Published’
structuring & writing and your article

18


General structure of a research article

Title Abstract
Keywords

Introduction
Methods Results
AND Discussion

19

Conclusion
Acknowledgements
References
Supporting Materials


Titles

Fewest possible
words

Adequately
describes
content

Identifies main
issue

Effective manuscript titles

20

Does not use
rarely-used
abbreviations


Abstract
< 200 – 300 words
This is the advertisement of your article.
Make it interesting and understandable

Make it accurate and specific

A clear abstract will strongly influence
whether or not your work is considered

Keep it as brief as possible

21


Keywords

22

Highlights

Used by indexing and
abstracting services

Advertise your work

Are the labels of the
manuscript

3-5 bullet points

Use only established
abbreviations e.g. DNA

Key conclusions

Do not repeat words in
the title

Use full sentences


Introduction
Provide a brief context to the readers

Address the problem

Identify the solutions & limitations

What is hoped to be achieved

Consistent with the nature of the journal
23

Methods
Describe how the problem was studied

Include detailed information
Do not describe previously published procedures
Identify the equipment and describe materials used
Other researchers should be able to
reproduce your work using the
method description

24


Results
Be clear & easy to understand
Highlight the main findings

Feature unexpected findings
Provide proper statistical analysis
Include clear illustrations & figures

25