FMRI study of effects of sleep deprivation on attentional capacity

!"#$%&'()*%+!%,!!,-'&%+!%&.,,/%),/#$01'$+2%
+2%1'',2'$+21.%-1/1-$'*%
!
!
3+24%)12*124%
B.Sc.%(Hons.),%NUS%
%
1%'5,&$&%&(6"$'',)%
!+#%'5,%),4#,,%+!%)+-'+#%+!%/5$.+&+/5*%
%
2(&%4#1)(1',%&-5++.%!+#%$2',4#1'$0,%
&-$,2-,&%12)%,24 $2,,# $24%
%
21'$+21.%(2$0,#&$'*%+!%&$241/+#,%
789:%
%
%
%
%
;;%
%
"#$%&'&()*+!
%
$%<=>=?@%A=BCD>=%E<DE%E<=%E<=F;F%;F%G@%H>;I;JDC%KH>L%%
DJA%;E%<DF%?==J%K>;EE=J%?@%G=%;J%;EF%=JE;>=E@M%%
$%<DN=%AOC@%DBLJHKC=AI=A%DCC%E<=%FHO>B=F%HP%;JPH>GDE;HJ%%
K<;B<%<DN=%?==J%OF=A%;J%E<=%E<=F;FM%
'<;F%E<=F;F%<DF%DCFH%JHE%?==J%FO?G;EE=A%
PH>%DJ@%A=I>==%;J%DJ@%OJ;N=>F;E@%Q>=N;HOFC@M%
%
%

%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR%
3HJI%)DJ@DJI%
!=?>OD>@%89S%789:%
%
%
;;;%
%
Acknowledgements%
%
TH>L;JI%HJ%D%/<M)M%<DF%?==J%DJ%;JE=>=FE;JIS%KHJA=>POC%DJA%DCFH%HN=>K<=CG;JI%
=UQ=>;=JB=% PH>% G=M% '<>HOI<HOE% E<=% @=D>FS% E<=>=% D>=% GDJ@% Q=HQC=% K <H% <DN =% Q>HN;A=A%
IO;ADJB=S%=JBHO>DI=G=JES%DFF;FEDJEF%DJA%DCC%L;JAF%HP%FOQQH>ES%DJA%GDA=%G @%PHO>%@=D>F%
OJPH>I=EED?C=M%$%KHO CA %C;L=%EH%EDL=%E<;F%HQ QH >EO J ;E@%EH%BH JN =@ %G@%<=D>E;=FE%I>DE;EOA= %EH%
DCC%HP%E<=GM%%
!;>FE%DJA%PH>=GHFES%$% K HOCA% C;L=%EH% =UQ>=FF% G@%FQ=B;DC%DQQ>=B;DE;HJ%DJA% E<DJLF% EH%
G@%FOQ=>N;FH>%/>HP=FFH>%";B<D=C%-<==S%PH>%<;F%=UB=CC=JE%G=JEH>F<;Q%DJA%IO;ADJB=M%$E%<DF%
?==J% >=DCC@% DJ% <HJH>% EH% ?=% <;F% P;>FE% =N=>% /<M)M% FEOA=JEM% $% DG% A==QC@% I>DE=POC% EH% <;F%
BHJFEDJE% FOQQH>ES% =JBHO>DI=G=JE% DJA% ;JE=>=FE;JI% Q=>FQ=BE;N=FS% K<;B<% <DN=% ?==J%
;JFE>OG = JE DC% EHKD>AF% E<=% Q>HI>=FF % HP% G@ % /<M)M%>=F=D>B<M% 5=% DCFH% IO;A =A % G =% EH% E<;J L%
GH>=%FE>DE=I;BDCC@%>DE<=>% E<DJ %?=;JI%EHH%H?F=FF;N=%K;E<%;JA;N;AODC%Q >H?C=G FM%6=F;A=F%E<=%
I=J=>DC%FE>DE=I;B%E<;JL;JIS%<=%DCFH%<=CQ=A%G=%=N=>@%JHK%DJA%E<=J%K;E<%A=ED;C=A%C=D>J;JIS%

FOB<%DF%IH;JI%E<>HOI<%E<=%?>D;J %DJDEHG @%DJ A%<HK %EH%G DL=%IH HA%F=D>B< =FM%
$% < D N= % I>=DEC@% =JVH@=A% E<=% HQQH>EOJ;E;=F% EH% KH>L% BCHF=C@% K ;E<% )>M% &HHJ% -<OJ%
&;HJIM% 1% N=>@% G=E;BOCHOF% DJA% F<D>Q% Q=>FHJS% )>M% &HHJ% <DF% Q>HN;A=A% G=% K;E<% GDJ@%
;JNDCOD ?C= % BHGG=JEF% DJA% Q=>FQ=BE;N=F% HJ% ?HE<% FB;=JE;P;B% E<;JL;JI% DJA% Q>=F=JEDE;HJ%
%
%
;N%
FL;CCFM%%$%<DN=%?=J=P;E=A%D%CHE%P>HG%<;F%DAN;B=FM%%
TH>L;JI%BCHF=C@%K;E<%)>M%-<>;FEHQ<=>%1FQCOJA%PH>%FHG=%Q>HV=BEF%KDF%A=P;J;E=C@%D%
N=>@% P>O;EPOC% DJ A % =J>;B<;JI% =UQ=>;= JB =M% ->;E;BDC% @ =E% =JBHO> DI;J I S% <=% BHJ FED JEC@ %
=JBHO>DI=A%DJA%G HE;NDE=A%G=%EH%P;JA%K D@F%EH%FHCN=%E<=%Q>H?C=GF%K<=J=N =>%$%?=BDG=%
A;F<=D>E=J=AM%6=;JI%D%N=>@%LJHKC=AI=D?C=%DJA%DQQ>HDB<D?C=%Q=>FHJS%<=%Q>HN;A=A%CHEF%HP%
NDCOD?C=%FOII=FE;HJF%?HE<%DE%KH>L%DJA%HOEF;A=M%%
$% KHO CA % C;L=% EH% E< D JL % G@% BH G G;EE==% G=G ?= >FS% )>M% 1J J =EE% &B<;>G=>% DJA% )>M%
2;B<HCDF%5HJS%PH>%Q>HN;A;JI%N=>@%OF=POC%BHGG=JEF%DJA%FOII=FE;HJF%PHCCHK;JI%G@%/<M)M%
WODC;P@;JI%=UDGFM%
"@%E<=F;F%=UDG;J=>FS%)>M%1JJ=EE%&B<;>G=>S%)>M%5DJF%0DJ%)HJI=J%DJA%)>M%XHF<OD%
4HHC=@S% <DN=% Q>HN;A=A% G=% K;E<% GDJ@% ;JNDCOD?C=% BHGG=JEF% DJA% FOII=FE;HJF% PH>%
;GQ>H N;J I %G@%E<=F;F%;J%I =J => DC% DJ A %;J %A = ED ;CFM%' < = @%<DN=%EDL=J%=UE>DH>A;JD>@%=PPH>EF%DJA%
QDE;=JEF%;J% >=DA;JI%DJA%BHGG=JE;JI% HJ%G@% E<=F;FM% $%>=DCC@% DQQ>=B;DE=A% E<DE%DJA% $%KHOCA%
C;L=%EH %=UQ>=F F%G@%<=D>E ;=FE %E<DJL F%EH%E <= G %PH>%DI>==;J I %EH%? =%G@ %E<=F;F%=UDG ;J => F%DJA%
EDL;JI%E;G= %EH%>=D A%G@%E<=F;F%DJA%DBB=FF ;JI %G@%H>DC%A=P=JF=M%%
1CC%E<=%Q=HQC=%;J%E<=%CD?%<DN=%<=CQ=A%G=%;J%HJ=%KD@%H>%DJHE<=>M%$%KHOCA%C;L=%EH%
E<DJL%$NDJS%*NHJJ =%-<;D S%';PPDJ@%-<;DS%)==Q E;%"OC;BLS%0;JHA S%&;E;S%3 = Q %3== %DJA%2DEDC;%
T==%PH>%E<=;>%BHJFEDJE%FOQQH>EF%DJA%<=CQM%&Q=B;DC%E<DJLF%D>=%I;N=J%EH%Y<=JI%5 O;%DJA%
/D>;GDCS%K<HG% $% <DN=%?OII=A%BHOJEC=FF%E;G=F%PH>% E=B<J;WO=% FOQQH>EFM%$% DG%DCFH%I>DE=POC%
%
%
N%
EH%/H< % X;D% 5 H OS% G@%ZFOBB=FFH>[% D F% E<= % F= BHJ A % /< M) M% FEO A= JE% H P% / >HPM% - < == M%' < DJ LF % <;G % PH >%

<=CQ;JI%G=%Q>HHP>=DA%G@%GDJOFB>;QE%DJA%PH>%E<HF=%>DJAHG%@=E%N=>@%;JE=>=FE;JI%EDCL FM%%
6=F;A=FS% E<=>=% D>=% D% P=K% Q=HQC=% E<DE% A=F=>N=% FQ=B;DC% G =JE;HJFS% 0DJ=FFD% -<=JS%
/>DJ==E<%2DG ?>;S%XDBL%)=%5DNDFS%-<==%T=;%*DJ%DJA%.;JI%1;W;JIM%&HG=%HP%E<=G%<DN=%
GHN=A%HJ%EH%QO>FO;E%E<=;>%;JE=>=FEF%H>%PO>E<=>%FEOA;=F%;J%E<=%(&%H>%E<=%(3M%&HG=%HP%OF%
VH;J=A % E< = % CD? % DE% E< =% FD G=%Q=>;HAF% DJA%I>=K% EHI= E<=>%PH>% D% Q=>;HA% E;G=M%$%A;A% I>=DEC@%
=JVH@% E<=;>%FOQQH>ES% BHG QDJ;HJF< ;Q%DJA%P>;=JAF<;QM%)DJB;JIS% F;JI;JI%DJA%A>=FF%<OJE;JI%
K;E<%0DJ=FFD%DJA%T=;% *DJ\% C;FE=J;JI% EH%XDBL%>=DA;JI% <;F%QH=GF%]K<;C=%$%P=CC%DFC==Q%>;I<E%
;J% P>HJE% HP% <;G% DPE=>% D% P=K% C;J=F^S% B< DEE;J I % DJA% E>DN=C;JI % EHI=E<=>% K;E<% />DJ==E<S%
Q<HEHI>DQ<;JI% K;E<% 1;W;JIS% E<=F=% D>=% VOFE% D% P=K% HP% E<=% G =GH>D?C=% E<;JIF% K=% <DN=%
F<D>=AM%%'<DJL%@HO%DCC%PH>%=N=>@E<;JI%DJ A%<HQ =%EH%F==%@HO%D>HO JA %E<=%KH>CA M%
.DFES% DJA% A=P;J;E=C@% JHE% E<=% C=DFES% $% DG% I>DE=POC% EH% G@% QD>=JEFS% K<H% <DN=%
FOQQH>E=AS%CHN=AS%=JBHO>D I=A %DJA%IO ;A=A %G=%DCC%E<=F=%@=D>FM%
'<=%E<=F;F%GD>LF%DJ%=JAS%?OE%DCFH%D%?=I;JJ;JIM%%
%



%
%
N;%





%
%
N;;%
Contents
1?FE>DBE%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%U!

.;FE%HP%'D?C=F%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%U;;!
.;FE%HP%!;IO>=F%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%U;N!
9M%$2'#+) ( - ' $+ 2 %MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%9_!
9M9%-DQDB;E@%.;G;EF%HP%$JPH>GDE;HJ%/>HB=FF;JI%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%78!
9M9M9%.;G;EDE;HJ%;J%/=>B=QEODC%1EE=JE;HJDC%-DQDB;E@%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%79!
9M9M7%.;G;EF%HP%'=GQH>DC%1EE=JE;HJ`%'<=%&Q==A%HP%&;I<EMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%7:!
9M9M:%1EE=JE;HJS%D%BDQDB;E@aC;G;E=A%>=FHO > B= %DCCH BD EH >%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%7b!
9M7%2=O>HBHIJ;E;N=%,PP=BEF%HP%&C==Q%)=Q>;NDE;HJ%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%7_!
9M7M9%&OFED;J=A%1EE=JE;HJc0;I;CDJB=%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%7d!
9M7M7%&=C=BE;N=%1EE=JE;HJ%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%7e!
9M:%&Q=B;P;B%1;GF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%:8!
7M%&'()*%/#+-,)( #,&%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%::!
7M9%/D>E;B;QDJEF%&=C=BE;HJ%->;E=>;D%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%::!
7M7%&EDJAD>A%,UQ=>;G=JEDC%/>HB=AO>=F%PH>%/D>E;B;QDJEF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%:b!
:M%#,)(-,)%0$&(1.%/#+-,&&$24%-1/1-$'*%$2%&.,,/%),/#$0,)%/,#&+2&%MMMMM%:d!
:M9%$JE>HAOBE;HJ%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%:d!
:M7%"DE=>;DCF%DJA%"=E<HAF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%f8!
:M7M9%/D>E;B;QDJEF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%f8!
:M7M7%,UQ=>;G=JEDC%)=F;IJ%DJA %&E;GOC;%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%f9!
%
%
N;;;%
:M7M:%$GDI;JI%/>HB=AO>=%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%f:!
:M7Mf%$GDI;JI%1JDC@F;F%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%ff!
:M:%#=FOCEF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%fb!
:M:M9%6=<DN;H>DC%#=FOCEF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%fb!
:M:M7%$GDI;JI%!;JA;JIF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%fg!
:Mf%);FBOFF;HJ%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%b9!
:MfM9%&C==Q%)=Q>;NDE;HJ%#=AOB=F%-DQDB;E@%EH%/>HB=FF%'DFLa$>>=C=NDJE%) ;FE>D BEH >F%MMM%b7!
:MfM7%!OJBE;HJDC%(E;C;E@%HP%Z&OQ=>PCOHOF[%'DFLa#=CDE=A%1BE;N;E@%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%b:!

:Mb%-HJBCOF;HJ%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%bb!
fM%&.,,/%),/#$01'$+2%,h1-,# 61',&%',"/+#1.%.$"$'1'$+2&%$2%+6X,-'%
/#+-,&&$24%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%bg!
fM9%$JE>HAOBE;HJ%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%bg!
fM7%"DE=>;DCF%DJA%"=E<HAF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%be!
fM7M9%/D>E;B;QDJEF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%be!
fM7M7%,UQ=>;G=JEDC%)=F;IJ%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%g8!
fM7M:%!OJBE;HJDC%.HBDC;i=>%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%g9!
fM7Mf%$GDI;JI%/>HB=AO>=%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%g7!
fM7Mb%)DED%1JDC@F;F%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%g:!
fM:%#=FOCEF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%gf!
fM:M9%6=<DN;H>DC%#=FOCEF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%gf!
fM:M7%$GDI;JI%!;JA;JIF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%gb!
fM:%);FBOFF;HJ%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%g_!
%
%
;U%
fM:M9%&C==Q%)=Q>;NDE;HJ%&CHKF%'=GQH>DC%/>HB=FF;JI%1CHJI%E<=%0;FODC%-H>E;B=F%MMMMMMM%g_!
fM:M7%TH>F=J=A%E=GQH>DC%Q>HB=FF;JI%C;G;EF%DJA%D%>=AOB=A%J=O>DC%B;>BO;EF%PHCCHK;JI%
FC==Q%A=Q>;NDE;HJ%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%ge!
bM%!(2-'$+21.%$"1 4$2 4%-+##,.1',&%+!%$"/1$#,)%)$&'#1-'+#%
&(//#,&&$+2%!+. .+T $24 %&.,,/%),/ #$01' $+2%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%_9!
bM9%$JE>HAOBE;HJ%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%_9!
bM7%"DE=>;DCF%DJA%"=E<HAF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%_f!
bM7M9%/D>E;B;QDJEF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%_f!
bM7M7%,UQ=>;G=JEDC%)=F;IJ%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%_b!
bM7M:%$GDI;JI%/D>DG=E=>F%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%__!
bM7Mf%$GDI;JI%1JDC@F;F%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%_d!
bM:%#=FOCEF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%d8!
bM:M9%6=<DN;H>DC%#=FOCEF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%d8!

bM:M7%$GDI;JI%!;J A;JIF%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%d7!
bMf%);FBOFF;HJ%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%dg!
bMfM9%&C==Q%)=Q>;NDE;HJ%$GQD;>F%);FE>DBEH>%&OQQ>=FF;HJ%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%d_!
bMfM7%.HFF%HP%);FE>DBEH>%&OQQ>=FF;HJ%DJA%$JB>=DF=A%-Ha=JBHA;JI%HP%'D>I=EF%DJA%
);FE>DBEH>F%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%dd!
gM%4=J=>DC%);FBOFF;HJ%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%e8!
#=P=>=JB=F%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%eb!
%
%
%
U%
Abstract
%
T<;C=%HO>%?>D;J%;F%=UE>=G=C@%FHQ<;FE;BDE=A%DE%Q>HB=FF;JI%;JBHG;JI%;JPH>GDE;HJS%;E%
;F% I =J => DCC@ %FDP=%EH%QHF;E%E<DE%DCC%Q>HB=F F;J I %FEDI=FS%P>HG%F=JFH>@%Q>HB=FF;JI%EH%<;I < %C=N=C%
BHIJ;E;N=%BHJE>HC%POJBE;HJF%DJA%A=B;F;HJ%GDL;JIS%D>=%BDQDB;E@%C;G;E=AM%'<=F=%C;G;EDE;HJF%
F<HK%FEDE=%>=CDE=A%DCE=>DE;HJF%DJ%=UDGQ C=%HP%K<;B<%;F%FC==Q%A=Q >;NDE;HJ%]&) ^M%%
/>=N;HOF%FEOA;=F%;JN=FE;IDE;JI%A=P;B;EF%;J%ND>;HOF%BHIJ;E;N=%AHGD;JF%<DN=%PHOJA%
FC==Q% A=Q>;NDE;HJ% EH% DEE=JODE=% EDFLa>=CDE=A% QD>;=EDC% DJA% =UE>DFE>;DE=% N;FODC% DBE;ND E;HJS%
FOII=FE;JI% D% >=AOBE;HJ% HP% Q>HB=FF;JI % BDQDB;E@% ;J% E<;F% FEDE=M% 5HK=N =>S% <HK % A;PP=>=JE%
DFQ=BEF%HP%DEE=JE;HJDC%BDQDB;E@%C;G;EDE;HJ%D>=%K H>F=J=A%PHCCHK;JI%FC==Q%A=Q>;NDE;HJ%<DF%
JHE% K=CC% B<D>DBE=>;i=A M% (F;JI% POJBE;HJDC% ?>D;J% ;GDI;JI% BHOQC=A% K;E<% D% ND>;=E@% HP%
?=<DN;H>DC%EDFLFS% G@% K H>L% F<HKF% E<=% =UDB=>?DE;HJ% HP% N;FODC% Q>HB=FF;JI%C;G;EDE;HJF% DE%
GOCE;QC=%F;E=F%]N;FODC%D>=DF%DF%K=CC%DF%DEE=JE;HJDC%BHJE>HC%>=I;HJF^%;J%E<=%Q>HB=FF;JI%FEDI=F%
PHCCHK;JI%FC= =Q %A= Q> ;NDE;H JM%%
$%P;>FE%=NDCODE=A%A;>=BEC@%E<=%&)a;JAOB =A %B<DJI = %;J%N;FODC%Q>HB=FF;JI %BDQDB ;E@ %?@%
=GQCH@;JI% .DN;=[F% Q=>B=QEODC% CHDA% E<=H>@% HP% DEE=JE;HJ% DF% D% P>DG=KH>LM% #=Q=E;E;HJ%
FOQQ>=FF;HJ%;J%Q D>D< ;QQHBD G QDC%Q CDB=%D>= DF%]// 1^%K D F%OF=A %EH%;JA ;BD E= %Q > HB =F F;J I %H P%
OJDEE=JA=A%FB=J=F%K<;C=%QD>E;B;QDJEF%DEE=JA=A%EH% PDB=F%=G?=AA=A% ;J% PDB=aFB=J=% Q ;BEO>=FM%
1EE=JODE=A% >=Q=E;E;HJ% FOQQ>=FF;HJ% =PP=BE% PHCCHK;JI% FC==Q% A=Q>;NDE;HJ% ;JA;BDE=A% D%

>=AOBE;HJ%;J%EHEDC%N;FODC%Q>HB=FF;JI %BDQD B;E@%PHCCHK;J I%FC==Q%A= Q>;NDE;HJM%%
%
%
U;%
(F;JI%>DQ;A%F=>;DC%N;FODC%Q>=F=JEDE;HJ%]#&0/^%QD>DA;IG%HP%<HOF=F%Q>=F=JE=A%DE%
ND>;HOF%Q>=F=JEDE;HJ%P>=WO=JB;=FS%$% J=UE%F<HK=A% E<DE% E=GQH>DC% Q >HB=FF;JI%C;G;EDE;HJ%K DF%
=UDB=>?DE=A% PHCCHK;JI% FC==Q% A=Q>;NDE;HJS% =N;A=JB=A% ?@% K H>F=J=A% Q=>PH>GDJB=% DJ A%
>=AOB=A%DBE;NDE;HJ %DB>HFF%G O CE;QC=%BH>E;BDC%D>=DFM%%/D>E;BOCD>C@S%E<=%E=G Q H>D C%Q>HB=FF;J I%
;J%<;I<= >%N ;FO D C%D >= DFS%;J%E<;F%BDF =%E <= %Q D >D <;Q Q H BD GQDC%QCDB=%D> =D S%K = >= %GH>=%F=N=>=C@%
DPP=BE=A%?@%FC==Q%A=Q>;NDE;HJS%F<HK;JI%I>=DE=>%F=JF;E;N;E@%EH%FCHK=>%Q>=F=JEDE;HJ%>DE=FM%%
&=C=BE;N=% DEE=JE;HJ% ;EF=CP% DF% D% >=FHO>B=% DCCHBDEH>% ;F% DCFH% BDQDB;E@% C;G;E=A% DJA%
;GQD;>G=JE% ;J% E<;F% POJBE;H J % C=DAF% EH% Q=>PH>G DJ B =% A=B>=G= JE M% '<=% >=G D ;J A =>% HP% E<=%
A;FF=>EDE;HJ% PHBOF=A% HJ% <HK% FC==Q% A=Q>;NDE;HJ% DAN=>F=C@% ;GQD;>F% FO?% BHGQHJ=JEF% HP%
F=C=BE;N=%DEE=JE;HJS%J DG =C@%ED>I=E%=J<DJB=G= JE%DJA%A;FE>DBEH>%FOQ Q>=FF;HJ M%/D>E;B;QDJEF%
DEE=JA=A% EHS% QDFF;N=C@% N;=K=A% H>% ;IJH>=A% <HO F=% ;GDI=F% ;J% FOQ=>;GQHF=A% PDB=a<HOF=%
Q;BEO>=FM% " #% F;IJDC% =J<DJB=G=JE% H>% FOQQ>=FF;HJ% ;J% //1% KDF% =NDCODE=A% >=CDE;N=% EH%
QDFF;N=%N;=K;JIM%!HCCHK;JI%FC==Q%A=Q>;NDE;HJS%F=C=BE;N=%DEE=JE;HJ%DF%D%>=FHO>B=%DCCHBDEH>%
HJC@% Q>=F=>N=A% ;EF% D?;C;E@% EH% =J<DJB=% ED>I=E% Q>HB=FF;JIS% K<;C=% E<=% D?;C;E@% EH% FOQQ>=FF%
A;FE>DBEH>%KDF%F;IJ;P;BDJEC@%;GQD;>=AM%%
'<;F% >=F=D>B<% A=GHJFE>DE=F% E<DE% FC==Q% A=Q>;NDE;HJ% = UD B= >? D E=F % C;G;EDE;HJF% DE %
GOCE;QC=% Q>HB=FF;JI% FEDI=FS% >=FOCE;JI% ;J% QHH>% ?=<DN;H>DC% Q=>PH>GDJB=% DJA% FCHK=>%
>=FQHJF=FM%
%
%
U;;%
List of Tables
'D?C=%9`%&EDJAD>A%&BH>=F%PH>%"H>J;JIJ=FFa,N=J;JIJ=FF%&BDC=%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%:f!
'D?C=%7`%1EE=JE;HJDC%"HAOCDE;HJ%$JA=UM%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%_e!
%
%

%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
U;;;%
%
%
%
U;N%
List of Figures
%
!;IO>=%9`%&B<=GDE;B%HP%E<=%=UQ=>;G=JEDC%EDFLM%]1^%, DB <%E>;DC%BHJ F;FE=A %HP%D%F =>;=F %HP%F;U%
FB=J=jPDB=% BHG Q HF ;E=% Q;BEO>=F S% =DB<% F<HK J% PH>% b88% GFS% PHCCHK=A% ?@% D% b88% GF%
B<=BL=>?HD>A% GDFL% ]JHE% F<HKJ% ;J% P;IO>=^M% !DB=F% K=>=% =;E<=>% OJA;FEH>E=A% ]CHKaCHDA%
BHJA;E;HJ^%H>%A=I>DA=A%K;E<%FDCE%DJA%Q= QQ=>%JH;F=%]<;I<aCHDA %BHJA;E;HJ^M%&O> >H O J A ;JI %
=DB<% PDB=% K=>=% =;E<=>% DCE=>JDE=C@% >=Q=DE=A% ]CHK=>% F=>;=F^% H>% BHGQC=E=C@% JHJa>=Q=DE=A %
?DBLI>HOJA% FB=J=F% ]OQQ=>% F=>;=F^M% 1PE=>% DCC% P>DG=F% <DA% ?==J% Q>=F=JE=AS% QD>E;B;QDJEF%
K=>=%I;N=J%:888%GF% EH% ;JA;BDE=%K<=E<=>%DJ@%PDB=%KDF%>=Q=DE=A%]OQQ=>%F=>;=F^M%1%P;UDE;HJ%
B>HFF%KDF%F<HK J%PH>%e888%GF% ?=PH>=%E<=%J=UE%E>;DC%?=IDJM% ]6^%,UDGQC=F%HP%FB=J=%DJA %PDB=%
FE;GOC;% OF=A% ;J% E<=% POJBE;HJDC% CHBDC;i=>% EDFLM% '<=% FE;GOC;% <DA% E<=% FDG =% A;G =JF;HJ F% DF%

E<HF=%OF=A %;J%E< =%Q >;G D> @%EDFL M%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%f7!
!;IO>=%7`%6=<DN;H>DC%>=FOCEFM%!DB=%>=Q=E;E;HJ%A=E=BE;HJ%Q=>PH>GDJB=%DF%G=DFO>=A%?@%<;E%
DJA% PDCF=% DCD>G% ]!1^% >DE=F% AO>;JI% # T % DJA % &) % ;J% ? HE<% CHKaCH DA % DJA% <;I<aCHD A %
BHJA;E;HJFM%,>>H>%?D>F%;JA;BDE=%FEDJAD>A%=>>H>M%]kS%Q%l%8M8b\%kkS%Q%l%8M89^M%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%fg!
!;IO>=%:`%1BE;NDE;HJ%DJA%>=Q=E;E;HJ%FOQQ>=FF;HJ%=PP=BEF%;J%//1M%]1^%1BE;NDE;HJ %;J % E< =% // 1 %
BH>>=FQHJA;JI% EH% E<=% A ;PP=>=JE%EDFL%BHJA;E;HJF%;J%=DB< % HP% E<=%EKH% FEDE=F%]kS%Q%l% 8M8b\%kkS%Q% l%
8M89^M%]6^%# =Q = E;E;HJ %FOQQ>= FF;H J%;JA=U %AO>;JI %#T %DJA%&)%;J%E< =%//1 %DF%D%POJ BE;H J%HP%
Q=>B=QEODC%CHDAM%&;IJ;P;BDJE%FEDE=%?@%CHDA%;JE=>DBE;HJ%KDF%Q>=F=JE%]!9S%9_%m%_M:9S%Q%l%8M89^M%
]-^%4 >H O Q%DBE;NDE;HJ%GDQ%F<HK;JI%E<=%//1%]Q% l%8M8bS%6HJP=>>HJ;%BH>>=BE=A\%1N=>DI=A%
'DCD;>DB<%-HH>A;JDE=FS%C=PE% //1 `%n7e%nb8%n99\%>;I<E%//1`%7g%nf_%n_^M%2HE=%E<DE%E<=%P;IO>=%
;F% Q>;GD>;C@% PH>% ;CCOFE> DE;N = % QO>Q H F= F% DF% >=Q= E;E;H J% FOQ Q >= FF ;HJ % KD F% A=E= >G;J=A% P>HG%
;JA;N;AO D C%# + $F M%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%f_!
!;IO>=% f`% -H>>=CDE;HJF% ?=EK==J% !!1% DBE;NDE;HJS% ?=<DN;H>DC% Q=>PH>GDJB=% DJA% //1%
DBE;NDE;HJM% ]1^% &;IJ;P;BDJE% QHF;E;N=% BH>>=CDE;HJ% ]>% m% 8Mff\% Q% l% 8M8b^% ?=EK==J% &)a>=CDE=A%
>=AOBE;HJ%;J %! !1% ]1N=>DI=A%'DCD;>DB<%-HH>A;JDE=FS%C=PE%!!1`%n%f:%n%bg%n%9:\%>;I<E%!!1`%:d%
n% bf% n% 9f^% DBE;NDE;HJ% AO>;JI% E<=% GD;J% EDFL% DJA% E<=% GDIJ;EOA=% HP% Q=>PH>GDJB=%
;GQD;>G=JE%D B>H FF %FEDE=FM%]6 ^% &;IJ;P;BDJE%BH>>=CDE;HJ%? =EK== J%FEDE=a>=CDE=A%>=AO BE;HJ% ;J%
!!1%DBE;NDE;HJ%DJA%//1%>=Q=E;E;HJ%FOQQ>=FF;HJ%;JA=U%PHCCHK;JI%&)%]>%m%8M8b\%Q%l%8M8b^M%M%fd!
!;IO>=% b`% 1BE;NDE;HJ% ;J% !!1% DJA% BH>>=CDE;HJ% ?=EK==J% !!1% DBE;NDE;HJ% DJA% >=Q=E;E;HJ%
FOQQ>=FF;HJ% ;JA=UM% ]1^% 1BE;NDE;HJ% ;J% !!1% AO>;JI% E<=% PDB=% >=Q=E;E;HJ% A=E=BE;HJ% EDFL%
F<HK=A%D%FEDE=%>=CDE=A %B<DJ I=%]!9S%9_%m%b:MgbS%Q%l%8M8889^M%]6^%'<=>=%KDF%DCFH%D%F;IJ;P;BDJE%
BH>>=CDE;HJ%?= EK==J %E<=%&) a >= CDE=A%>=AOBE;HJ%;J%!!1%DBE;NDE;HJ%DJA%A=B>=DF=A %DBE;NDE;HJ%
DB>HFF%CHDA%BHJA;E;HJF%PHCCHK;JI%&)%]>%m%8Mf_\%Q%l%8M8b^M%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%fe!
%
%
UN%
!;IO>=%g`%!!1%DJA%//1%DBE;NDE;HJ%;J%E<=%POJBE;HJDC%CHBDC;i=>%>OJF%DJA%>=CDE;HJF<;Q%K;E<%
>=Q=E;E;HJ%FO QQ>= FF;HJ%;JA=UM%]1 ^%'<= >=%KDF %D%F ;IJ ;P;BDJ E%=PP=BE%HP%FEDE=%H J%DBE;NDE;H J %;J%
!!1%]E9_%o%fMbeS%Q%l%8M8889^%DJ A% //1 % ]E9_%o%:MeeS%Q%l%8M8889^% AO>;JI% CHBDC;i=>%>OJFM%]6^% &EDE=a
>=CDE=A% >=AOBE;HJ% ;J% !!1% DBE;NDE;HJ% ;J% E<=% POJBE;HJDC% CHBDC;i=>% >OJF% BH>>=CDE=A% K;E<%

>=AOB=A%//1 %>=Q =E;E;HJ%FOQ Q>=FF;HJ %]>%m%8Mg7\%Q%l%8M89^M%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%b8!
!;IO>=%_`%'DFLa>=CDE=A% DBE;ND E;HJ%;J% P>HJ EHaQD>;=EDC% BH>E;B=F%DJA%N;FODC%BH>E;B=FM%]1^%,PP=BE%
HP% CHDA% HJ% DBE;NDE;HJ% ;J% ?;CDE=>DC% !>HJEDC% ,@=% !;=CA% ]!,!^% DJA% ?;CDE=>DC% $JE>D% /D>;=EDC%
&OCBOF%]$/&^M%)O>;JI%#TS%<;I<=>%Q=>B=QEODC%CHDA%BHJA;E;HJ%=C;B;E=A%<;I<=>%DBE;NDE;HJ%;J%
?HE<%!,!%]E9_%o%7Mb8S%Q% l% 8M8b^% DJA%$/&%]E9_%o%9MedS%Q%l% 8M8b^M%1BE;NDE;HJ% ;J% !,!%]E9_%o% :M9bS%Q%l%
8M89^%DJA%$/&%]E9_%o%7MeS%Q%l%8M89^%KDF%F;IJ;P;BDJEC@%>=AOB=A%PHCCHK;JI%&)M%]6^%F<HK F%E<=%
P>HJEHaQD>;=EDC%DJA%N;FODC%D>=DF%>=B>O;E=A%?@%E<=%EDFL%DB>HFF%DCC%f%BHJA;E;HJFM%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%b9!
!;IO>=% d`%&B<=GDE;B%F<HK;JI%E<=% Q>=A;BE=A%P"#$%>=FQHJF=F%DF%D% POJBE;HJ%HP%Q>=F=JEDE;HJ%
P>=WO=JB@ %;J%A;PP=>=J E%N;FOD C%D>=DF %PHCCHK ;JI %FC==Q %A=Q> ;NDE;H J M%]1^%$J%//1M%]6^%$J%09%j%
0:M%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%be!
!;IO>=%e`%&B<=GDE;B%HP%E<=%=UQ=>;G=JEDC%EDFLM%,DB<%QD>E;B;QDJE%Q=>PH>G=A%98%>OJF%HP%E<=%
EDFLM% $J %=DB<%>OJ S%:f% faF%#&0/%F= WO=J B=F%HP%<H OF=%;GDI=F%K=>=%Q>=F=JE=A%DE%F;U%A;PP=>=JE%
Q>=F=JEDE;HJ%P>=WO=JB;=FS%9S%7S%fS%gS%dMb%DJA% 9b%;GD I=FcFM%$J%E<=%ED>I=E%>=BHIJ ;E;HJ%EDFLS%
QD>E;B;QDJEF%>=QH>E=A% K<;B<%HP% E<=%EKH%QHFF;?C=%ED>I=EF%KDF% Q>=F=JE%DE% E<=%=JA%HP% E<=%
F=WO=JB=M%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%g9!
!;IO>=% 98`% 6=<DN;H>DC% >=FOCEFM% ]1^% /=>PH>GDJB=% DBBO>DB@ % KDF % ;GQD;>= A % ?@% ?HE<% FC==Q%
A=Q>;NDE;HJ%]!9S%9:%m%dMg9\%Q%l%8M8b^%DJA%<;I<=>%Q>=F=JEDE;HJ%P>=WO=JB@%]!9S%9:%m%d7M8f\%Q%l%
8M8889^M%]6^%&;IJ;P;BDJE%FEDE=%?@% >DE=%;JE=>DBE;HJ%]!bS%9:% m%fM9f\%Q%l%8M88b^%KDF%Q>=F=JE%PH>%
>=FQHJF=%E;G=S%;J%DAA;E;HJ% EH %E<=%G D ;J%=PP=BEF%HP%?HE<% FEDE=%]!9S%9:%m%bM::\%Q%l%8M8b^% DJ A%>DE=%
]!9S%9:%m%9eMe:\%Q%l%8M8889^M%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%gb!
!;IO>=% 99`%'=GQH>DC%>=FQHJF=%Q>HP;C=F% DB>HFF% FEDE=%DJA%Q>=F=JEDE;HJ% >DE=%;J% //1%DJA%0 9M%
1%F;IJ;P;BDJE%FEDE=%?@%>DE=%;JE=>DBE;HJ%KDF%Q>=F=JE%;J%//1%]!bS%9:%m%:Meb\%Q%l%8M88b^M%/=DL%
DBE;NDE;HJ% K DF% =C;B;E=A% DE% D% FCHK=>% Q>=F=JEDE;HJ% >DE=% PHCCHK;JI% &)M% $J% 09S% HJC@% >DE=%
F;IJ;P;BDJEC@% GHAOCDE=A% DBE;N;E@% ]!9S% 9:% m% 77Meg\% Q% l% 8M8889^M% $J% D% E<>==aKD@% >=Q=DE=A%
G=DFO>=% 12+01% K;E<% PDBEH>F% HP% ?>D;J% >=I;HJS% FEDE=% DJA% >DE=S% DCC% E<=% EKHaKD@%
;JE=>DBE;H JF %K => =%F;I J ;P;BD J ES%JD G=C@%>=I ;H J %?@ %FED E=%]! 9S%9:%m%eM:_\%Q%l%8M89^S%D>=D%?@%>DE=%
]!bS%9:%m%7bM:7\%Q%l% 8M8889^%DJA%FEDE=%?@%>DE=%]!bS%9:%m%:Mf7\%Q%l%8M89^M%'<=%>=FOCEF% FOI I=FE%E<DE%
//1%DJA%09%DBE;N;E;=F%D>=%A;PP=>=JE;DCC@%GHAOCDE=A%?@%FEDE=%DJA%>DE=M%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%gg!
!;IO>=%97`%&B<=GDE;B%HP%E<=%=UQ=>;G=JE%A=F;IJM%]1^%, U DG Q C=F % HP% =DB<% HP% E<=% PHO>% EDFL%
BHJA;E;HJF`%DEE=JA%PDB=%]1!^S%DEE=JA%PDB=%;IJH>=%<H OF=%]1 !$5^S%DEE=JA%< HOF=%]15^S%DJA%

%
%
UN;%
DEE=JA% <HOF=% ;IJH>=% PDB=% ]15$!^M% /DFF;N=% N;=K% BHJA;E;HJ% ]-'#. ^% ;F% JHE% F<HKJ M% ]6^%
,UDGQC=% HP% HJ=% EDFL% ?CHBLM% '<=% P;N=% BHJA;E;HJF% K=>=% ?CHBL=A% ;J% >DJAHG;i=A% H>A=>%
K;E<;J%=DB<%>OJM%,DB<%?CHBL%KDF% Q>=B=A=A%?@% DJ% DOA;EH>@% BO=S%;JPH>G;JI% QD>E;B;QDJEF% EH%
DEE=JA%EH%<HOF=S%PDB=%H>%EH%QDFF;N=C@%N;=K%E<=%Q;BEO>=FM%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%_g!
!;IO>=%9:`%6=<DN;H>DC%>=FOCEFM%]1^%'D>I=E% A=E=BE;HJ%Q=>PH>GDJB= %AO>;JI%#T%DJ A %&)%;J%
=DB<%BHJA;E;HJM%'<=>=%K =>=%F;IJ;P;BDJE%G D;J%=PP=BEF%HP%FEDE=%]!9S%79%m%7:M9S%Q%l%8M889^%DJA%
;JE=>P=>;JI % A ;FE>D BEH >F%]!9S%79%m%_:M9S%Q%l% 8M889^M%]6^%"D;J% =PP=BE%HP%FEDE=%HJ% >=FQHJF=% E;G=% ]!9S%
79% m% 78M8S% Q% l% 8M889^M% '<=% Q>=F=JB=% HP% ;JE=>P=>;JI% A;FE>DBEH>F% ]!9S% 79% m% 9ffMgS% Q% l% 8M889^%
>=FOCE=A%;J % FCH K= >% >= FQH JF=FM%]-^%/HFEa=UQ =>;G=JE% >=BHIJ;E;HJ% ;JA;B=FM%T<=J%K=CC%>=FE=AS%
QD>E;B;QDJEF% >=BHIJ;i=A% ;JE=>P=>;JI% A;FE>DBEH>% <HOF=F% F;IJ;P;BDJEC@% C=FF% E<DJ% DEE=JA=A%
<HOF=F%]E79%m%7MbgS%Q%l% 8M8b^S%K<;C=%DPE=>%&)S%E<=%A;PP=>=JB=%A;FDQQ=D>=A%]E79%l9S%JMFM^M%,>>H>%
?D>F%;JA;BDE=%FEDJAD>A%=>>H>M%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%d9!
!;IO>=%9f`%1BE;NDE;HJ%DJA%GHAOCDE;HJ%=PP=BEF%;J%//1M%]1^%4 >H OQ %DBE;NDE;HJ%GDQ%F<HK;JI%
E<=% // 1 % ]i% m% ag\% Q% l% 98
ag
S% OJB H >> = BE =A^M% 2HE=% E<DE% E< = % P;IO>=% ;F% HJC@% PH>% ;CCOF E> DE ;N = %
QO>QHF=F% DF% E<=% // 1 % OF=A% PH>% DJ DC@ F;F% KDF% A=P;J=A% F=QD>DE=C@% PH>% =DB<% ;JA;N;AODC%
]1N=>DI= % 'DCD;>DB<% -HH>A;JDE=FS% C=PE% // 1 `% a:8S% a fgS% ag\% >;I<E% //1`% 7gS% afbS% ab^M% ]6 ^%
1BE;NDE;HJ% ;J% E<=% //1% BH>>=FQHJA;JI% EH% A;PP=>=JE% EDFL% BHJA;E;HJF% ;J% =DB<% HP% E<=% EKH%
FEDE=FM%"D;J%= PP=BEF%HP%FEDE=%]!9S%79%m%99M_S%Q%l%8M89^%DJ A%EDFL%]!9S%79%m%ffgMdS%Q%l%8M889^%D>=%
Q>=F=JEM%]-^%,J<DJB=G=JE%DJA%FOQQ>=FF;HJ%;JA;B=F%AO>;JI%#T%DJA%&)M%&OQQ>=FF;HJ%]E79%
m% a7M_bS% Q% l% 8M8b^% KDF% F;IJ;P;BDJEC@% DEE=JODE=A% PHCCHK;JI% &)% K<;C=% =J<DJB=G=JE% KDF%
>=CDE;N=C@%Q>=F=>N=AM%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%df!
!;IO>=%9b`%$JE>DQD>;=EDC%FOCBOF%]$/&^%DBE;NDE;HJ%DB>HFF%EDFL%DJA%FEDE=M%]1^%4>HOQ%DBE;N DE;H J%
GDQ% E<>=F<HCA=A% DE% Q% l% 98
ag
S% OJ B H >> = BE =AM% 2HE = % E<DE% E<=% DBE;NDE;HJ % GDQ% ;F% HJ C@% PH>%

;CCOFE>DE;N= % Q O > Q HF =F% DF% E<=% $/ & % O F =A % PH>% DJDC@F ;F% KDF% A=P;J=A% F=Q D >D E= C@% PH>% =DB<%
;JA;N;AO D CM%]6^%' < = >= %D>=%F ;IJ ;P ;BD J E%GD;J%=PP=BEF %HP%FED E=%]!9S%79%m%eMfS%Q%l% 8M89^% DJA%EDFL%]!9S%
79%m%f:M:S%Q%l%8M889^%PH>%$/&%DBE;NDE;HJ%]1N=>DI=%'DCD;>DB<%-HH>A;JDE=FS% C=PE%$/&`% a:8S%abbS%a
f9\%>;I<E%$/&`%7_S%ab7S%f9^M%MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM%dg!
%
%
%
%
9_%
1. INTRODUCTION
%
$J%9e beS%/=E=>%'>;QQS%D%2=K%*H>L% )XS%K=JE%HJ%D% FC==QC=FFJ=FF%GD>DE<HJM%5=%FQ=JE%
GHFE%HP%<;F%E;G=%F;EE;JI%;J%D%ICDFF%?HHE<%;J%';G=F%&WO D>=%DJA%E<=%>=FE%;J%D%<HE=C%>HHG %
DB>HFF%E<=%FE>==ES%K;E<%G=A;BDC%Q=>FHJJ=C%GHJ;EH>;JI%<;F%<=DCE<%BHJA;E;HJFM%'<=%CHJI=>%<=%
K=JE%K;E<HOE%FC==QS%E<=%GH>=%DFF;FEDJB=%<=% >=WO;>=AM%6@%E<=% E<;>A%AD@S%<=%A=N=CHQ=A%
;JBHJI> O H OF % =GH E;H J DC% >=DBE ;HJ F% DJA % E<=J % FED>E=A % EH% FOPP=>% P>HG % <DCCOB ;J DE;H J % DJA %
QD>DJH;DM% ,N=JEODCC@% ;E% Q>HI>=FF= A % EH% POCCa?CHKJ% QF@B<HF;FM% 5=% F=E% D% 4O;JJ=FF% TH>CA%
#=BH>A%HP%FED@;JI%DKDL=%PH>%789%<HO>F%DJA%98%G ;JOE=F%]dMf%AD@F^S%?OE%<=%J=N=>%GDA=%D%
POCC% G=JEDC% >=BHN=>@M% '<;F% ;F% HJ=% HP% E<=% GHFE% PDGHOFS% H>% ;JPDGHOFS% BD F=F% HP% FC==Q%
A=Q>;NDE;HJM%
%'<=% DAN=>F=% =PP=BEF% HP% CHJIaE= >G % FC==Q% A=Q>;NDE;HJ% HJ% Q<@F;BDC% DJA% G=JEDC%
<=DCE<%D>=%OJWO=FE;HJD?C=\%E<=>=PH>=S%E<=%4O;JJ=FF%TH>CA%#=BH>AF%JH%CHJI=>%>=BHIJ;i=A%
E<;F%BDE=IH >@M%6=;JI%A=Q>;N=A%HP%FC==Q%PH>%BHJF=BOE;N=%AD@F%;F%>D>=\%<HK=N=>S%C=FF%=UE>=G=%
PH>GF%HP%FC==Q%A=Q>;NDE;HJ%H>%FC==Q%>=AOBE;HJ%D>=%Q>=NDC=JEM%%
&C==Q%A=Q>;NDE;HJ%BDJ%?=%=;E<=>%DBOE=%H>%B<>HJ;BM%$J%HO>%GHA=>J%E=B<JHCHI @a>;B<%
7fa_%FHB;=E@S%K;E<%CHJI%KH >L ;J I %<HO>FS%F<;PE%KH>LFS%PDG ;C@%A=GDJ A FS%E< = %D AN =J E%HP%J=K %
PH>GF% HP% BHG G O J ;BDE;H JS% =UQDJA=A% C=;FO>=% DJA% =JE=>ED;JG=JE% HQQH>EOJ;E;=FS% FC==Q%
A=Q>;NDE;HJ%;F%?=BHG;JI%;JB>=DF;JIC@%BHGGHJM%'<=%DJJODC%Sleep%in%America%QHCC%?@%E<=%
2DE;HJDC% &C==Q% !HOJADE;HJ% ;J% E<=% (J;E=A% &EDE=F% F<HK=A% E<DE% FC==Q;JI% <HO>F% <DN=%
%

%
9d%
I>DAODCC@% A=B>=DF=AM% '<=% G=DJ% <HO>F% HP% FC==Q% <DN=% AK;JAC=A% P>HG% DJ% DN=>DI=% HP% e%
<HO>F%CDFE%B=JEO>@%EH%_%<HO>F%;J %7889%DJ A %gM9%<HO>F%;J%788eM% 5=D>E%A;F=DF=FS%>;FL%HP%FE>HL=S%
A;D?=E=FS%H?=F;E@S%DJA%A=Q>=FF=A%;GG O J= %F@ FE= G %D >= %<= DCE< %;FF O =F%E< D E%I> =D EC@ %BH >>= CDE =%
K;E<%FC==Q%A=Q>;NDE;HJM%-HIJ;E;N =C @ S% Q>HCHJI=A%KDL=POCJ=FF%;GQD;>F%D%>DJI=%HP%POJBE;HJF%
C;L=% N;I;CDJB=% DJA% FOF ED;J = A % DEE=JE;HJ% ] )H>DJ% =E% DCMS% 7889S% .;G% DJA% );JI=FS% 788d^S%
KH>L;JI%G=GH>@%]'O>J=>%=E%DCMS%788_S%-<==%DJA%-<OD<S%788d^S%; J < ;? ;E ;H J %]-<OD<%=E%DCMS%
788gS%)>OGGHJA%=E%DCMS%788g^%DJA%=EBM%
&C==Q%A=Q>;NDE;HJ% ;F% JHE%VOFE%DJ% ;JA;N;AODC% <=DCE<%<DiD>A\%;E%;F%D%QO?C;B%HJ=M%'<=>=%
D>=% BHJF;A=>D?C=% DFFHB;DE;HJF% ?=EK==J% FC==Q% A=Q>;NDE;HJcPDE;IO=% DJA% <OGDJa=>>H>%
>=CDE=A%DBB;A =JEF%H>%HBBOQDE;HJDC%=>>H>F%DJA%;JVO>;=FM%$JFOPP;B ;=J E%FC==QS%K<;B<%C=DAF%EH%
FC==Q;J=FF% DJA% PDE;IO=S% ;F% HJ=% HP% E<=% GDVH>% BDOF=F% HP% GHEH>% N=<;BC=% DBB;A=JEFM% '<=%
2DE;HJDC%&C==Q%!HOJADE;HJ[F%Sleep%in%America%QHCC%F<HK=A%E<DE%g8p%HP%E<=%>=FQHJA=JEF%
<DN=% DAG;EE=A% A>HKF@%A>;N;JI% DJA%:_p%<DN=%PDCC=J% DFC==Q%DE% E<= %K<==CM% )>HKF@%A>;N=>F%
K=>=%>=FQHJF;?C=%PH>%GH>=% E< DJ% 98 8S888% G HEH >% B>DF<= F%D JJ ODCC@S% >=FOCE;JI % ;J% 9Sbb8%A =DE<F%
DJA% f8S888% ;JVO>;=FS% DF% ;JA;BD E=A % ? @% 2DE;HJDC% 5;I<KD@% '>DPP;B% &DP=E@% 1AG;J;FE>DE;HJ%
]25'& 1 ^%ADEDM%'<;F%BHG = F%DF%JH%FO>Q>;F =%DF%FEOA;=F %<DN=%F<H K J %9d%<HO>F%HP%FOFED;J=A%
KDL=POCJ=FF%BHGQ>HG;F=A% Q=>PH>G DJB=% FQ ==A% DJA %D BBO>DB@% N=>@%GO B<%C;L=%?=;JI%OJA=>%
E<=%;J PCO =J B=%HP%D% ?CHHA% DCBH<HC% C=N=C% HP% 8M8bp%]T;CC;DGFHJ%DJA%!=@=>S%7888S%1>J=AE%=E%DCMS%
7889^M%$J% G=A;BDC%F=EE;JIFS%FOFED;J= A %KDL=PO CJ = F F%DJA%F<;PE%KH>L%HP%<=DCE<%Q>HP=FF;HJDCFS%
=FQ=B;DCC@%J=KC@%I>DAODE=A% ;JE=>JFS% <DN=% QHF=A%F;IJ;P;BDJE%>;FLF%HJ%E<=%WODC;E@%HP%QDE;=JE%
%
%
9e%
BD>=%D JA%FDP=E@%]X<D% =E%DCMS%7889^M %TH>F=%@=ES% <;I<aQ>HP;C=%A;FDFE=>F%>DJI;JI%P>HG%E<=%I ;DJ E%
H;C%FQ;CCDI=%HP%E<=%, U UH J %0 DCA =i S%E<=%A=FE>OBE;HJ %H P%E< =%F QD B=%F<OEEC=%-< D CC=JI =>S%EH%E<=%
JOBC=D>%G=CEAHKJF%HP%'<>==%";C=%$FCDJA%DJ A%- < =>J H? @ CS%K = >= %D CC%D F FH B ;D E= A %K;E<%FC==Q%
A=Q>;NDE;HJ% HP% E<=% Q=>FHJJ=C% ]-HCE=J% DJA% 1CE=NHIES% 788g^M% &C==Q% A=Q>;NDE;HJ% ;JAOB=A%
DBB;A=JEF% K =>=%=FE;GDE=A% EH%<DN=% DJ%DJJODC%=BHJHG;B% ;GQDBE%HP% qf:%EH% qbg%?;CC;HJ%;J%E<=%

(J;E=A%&EDE=FM%
5OGDJ%PDBEH>%DJA%=Q;A=G;HCHI;BDC%FEOA;=F%<DN=%D%CHJI%<;FEH>@%HP%B<D>DBE=>;i;JI%
E<=% =PP=BEF% HP% FC==Q% A=Q >;N DE;HJ % HJ % ND>;H OF% DFQ = BEF% HP% Q=> PH>GDJB=%DJA%A=FB>;?;JI% E<=%
Q<=JHG=JHJM%5HK=N=>S%E<=%OJA=>C@;JI%J=O>DC%G=B<DJ;FGF%K=>=%< D>AC@%OJBHN=>=A %?@%
?=<DN;H>DC%H>%H?F=>NDE;HJDC%FEOA;=FM%T ;E<%E<=%DANDJB=G=JE%HP%J=O>H;GDI;JI%G=E<HAFS%
FOB<% DF% QHF;E>HJ% =G;FF;HJ%EHGHI>DQ<@%]/,'^S% POJB E;HJ DC% GDIJ=E;B% >=FHJ DJ B= % ;GDI;JI%
]P"#$^S% =C=BE>H=JB=Q<DCHI>DQ<@% ],,4^ % DJA% HE<=>% JHJa;JN D F;N =% EHHCFS% ;E% ;F% QH FF;? C=% EH%
FEOA@% E<=% J=O>H?=<DN;H>DC% DCE=>DE;HJF% DFFHB;DE=A% K ;E<% FC==Q% A=Q>;NDE;HJ% DJA% E<=%
OJA=>C@;JI%J=O>DC%G=B<DJ;FGF%HP%BHIJ;E;N=%A=BC;J=M%%
1E% DJ@%I;N=J% E;G=S% E<=%=JN;>HJG=JE%Q>=F=JEF% PD >% GH>=% Q=>B=Q EOD C% ;JPH>GDE;HJ %
E<DJ%H J =%BDJ%=PP=BE;N=C@ % Q >H B=F FM% 1 EE=J E;H J%DCCHKF%OF%EH%DCCHBDE=% H O>%Q>HB=FF;JI% >= FHO >B =F%
EH% ;JPH>GDE;HJ % HP% I>=DE=>% >=C=NDJ B= % EH% HJIH;J I% ?=< DN ;H>M% 1EE=JE;HJ% ;F% DJ% DCGHFE%
;JA;FQ=J FD ? C=%DFQ=B E%HP%BH I J ;E;H J %DJA%;EF%=PP=BE%DJA%G=B<DJ ;FGF%<DN=%?==J%=UE=JF;N=C@%
FEOA;=A%;J%>=FE=A%;JA;N;AODCFM%+JC@%OJE;C%>=B=JE%@=D>FS%GH>=%J=O>H;GDI;JI%=UQ=>;G=JEF%
?=IOJ%EH%>=N=DC%<HK% DEE=JE;HJ%;F%;JPCO=JB=A%?@%FC==Q%A=Q>;NDE;HJM%1EE=JE;HJ%;EF=CP%;F%JHE%D%
%
%
78%
OJ;ED>@% BHJFE>OBE% DF% ;E% <DF% GOCE;QC=% BHGQHJ=J EFM% '<=% Q>=F=JE% A;FF=>EDE;HJ% PHBOF =F% HJ%
=UQCH>;JI%E<=%BDQDB;E@%C;G;EDE;HJ%DFQ=BEF%HP%DEE=JE;HJ%DJA%<HK%FC==Q%A=Q>;NDE;HJ%PO>E<=>%
=UDB=>?DE=F%E<=%DC>=D A@ %C;G;E=A%Q>HB=F F;J I%> =FH O >B =F M%%
$%K;CC% FED>E%K;E<%>=N;=K;JI%E<=%QDFE%FEOA;=F%HJ% E< = %A;PP=>=JE%BDQDB;E@%C;G;EDE;HJ%HP%
;JPH>G DE;H J % Q>HB=FF;JI% ;J% K=CC% >=FE=A% Q=>FHJS% PHCCHK=A % ?@% <HK% A;PP=>=JE% PDB=EF% HP%
DEE=JE;HJ%D>=%BHGQ>HG;F=A%PHCCHK;JI%FC==Q%A=Q>;NDE;HJ%DJA%=JA%K;E<%E<=% FQ =B;P;B%D ;G F% HP%
E<=%F=>;=F%HP%=UQ = >;G =J EFM%%
%
1.1 Capacity Limits of Information Processing
Z,N=>@H J = % LJHKF%K<DE%DEE=JE;HJ% ;FM%$E%;F% E<=% EDL;JI% QHFF= F F;H J % ?@% E<=% G;JAS% ;J%
BC=D>% DJA%N;N;A%PH>GS%HP%HJ =%HOE%HP%K<DE% F==G %F=N=>DC%F;GOCEDJ=HOFC@%QHFF;?C=% H?V=BEF%H>%
E>D;JF% HP% E<HOI< EM% !HBD C;iDE;H J S% BHJB= JE> DE;HJ F% HP% BHJ FB ;HO FJ=FF% D>=% HP% ;EF% =FF=JB=M% $E%

;GQC;=F%K ;E< A >D K D C%P>HG% F HG=%E<;JIF%;J%H>A=>%EH%A=D C%=PP=B E;N =C@ %K ;E< %HE<= >M[%j%T;CC;DG%
XDG=FS%The%Principles%of%PsychologyS%QQM%f8 : %j%f8fS%9de8%
$J%E< ;F% ;JF;I<EPOC%WOHE=%HJ %DEE=JE;HJS%T;CC;DG%XDG = F%QH;JE=A%HOE%HJ=% ;GQH>EDJE%
B<D>DBE=>;FE;B%HP%DEE=JE;HJ%j%BDQDB;E@%C;G;E=AS%?@%JHE;JI%E<DE%Z;E%;GQC;=F%K;E<A>DKDC%P>HG%
FHG=%E<;JIF%;J%H>A=>%EH%A=DC%=PP=BE;N=C@%K;E<%HE<=>F[M%%
+O>% ?>D;J% ;F% =UE>=G=C@% FHQ<;FE;BDE=A% DE% Q>HB=FF;JI% ;JBHG;JI% ;JPH>GDE;HJM%
5HK=N=>S%=N=J% K;E<% FOB<% FHQ<;FE;BDE;HJS%E<=>=% ;F% DCKD@F% PD>% GH>=% ;JPH>GDE;HJ% ;J% E<=%
FO>>HOJA;JI%=JN;>HJG=JE%E<DJ%HO>%F@FE=G%BDJ%<D JAC=M%1EE=JE;HJ%DCCHKF%O F%EH%DCCHBDE=%
%
%
79%
HO>%C;G;E=A%>=FHO>B=F%FOB<%E<DE%K=%BDJ%F=C=BE;N=C@%Q=>B=;N=%DJA%>=FQHJA%EH%D%FO?F=E%HP%
E<=F=% FE;G O C;% H P% <;I<=>% Q>;H>;E;= FM% / < @F;H CHI ;B DC% DJA% ;G DI ;J I % FEOA;=F% <D N =% F<HKJ% E<DE%
F=C=BE;N=%DEE=JE;HJ%?;DF=F% F=J FH>@%J=O>HJFS%;JB>=DF;JI%P;>;JI%>DE=F%HP%J=O>HJF%F=JF;E;N=%EH%
EDFLa>=C=NDJ E% FE;GOC;% ])=F;GHJ=% DJA% )OJBDJS% 9eeb^% H>% P=DEO>=F% K <;C=% BHJBO>>=JEC@%
>=AOB;JI%P;>;JI%>D E=F%HP%J =O >HJF%>=FQHJF;N=%EH%BHJBO>>=JE% ;>>=C=NDJE%FE;GOC;% ]4DiiDC=@% =E%
DCMS%788bD^M%
5OGDJ% Q=>PH>GDJB=% FOPP=>F% K<=J% ;JPH>GDE;HJ% HN=>CHDAFM% '<=% BDQDB;E@%
C;G;EDE;HJ % ;J% E<=% BH J E=J EaFQ=B;P;B% Q=>B=Q EODC% Q >HB=FF;JI % B<D JJ=CF% BHJFE>D;JF% ?HE<% E<=%
JOG?=>%HP%;E=GF%HJ=%BDJ%Q>HB=FF%DE%D%I;N=J%E;G=%DJA%DCFH%E<=%FQ==A%DE%K<;B<%HJ=%BDJ%
Q>HB=FF%;JBHG;JI% FE>=DGF% HP% ;JPH>GDE;HJM% 1E% E<=% FDG =% E;G= S% F=C=BE;N=% DEE=JE;HJ% H>% E<=%
BHIJ;E;N=%BHJE>HC%Q>HB=FF=F%DBE%EH%DCCHBDE=%E<=%C;G;E=A%>=FHO>B=F%HP%E<= %P>HJE%=J A %HP%E<=%
F=JFH>@% F@FE=GF% EH% Q>HB=FF% FE;GOC;% HP% <;I<=>% Q>;H>;E;=F% PH>% Q=>B=QE;HJ% DJA% DBE;HJM%
5HK=N=>S%DEE=JE;HJ%;EF=CP%<DF%DCFH%?==J%BHJB=;N=A%DF%D%BDQDB;E@aC;G;E=A%>=FHO >B =% DCCH B DEH > %
]"D>H;F%DJA%$NDJHPPS%788b^M%
$E%;F%I=J =>D CC@% FDP=%EH%QHF;E%E<D E% DCC%Q>HB=FF=F%DJA%Q>HB=FF;JI% FEDI=F%AO>;JI%E<=%
PCHK%HP%;JPH>GDE;HJ%P>HG%F=JFH >@ %;JQOEF%EH%A=B;F;HJ%H>%DBE;HJ%D>=%BDQDB;E@%C;G;E=AM%%
%
1.1.1 Limitation in Perceptual Attentional Capacity
0;FODC%Q=>B=QEODC%Q>HB=FF;JI%<DF%C;G;E=A%BDQDB;E@M% '<=%Q=>B=QEODC%CHDA%E<=H>@%HP%

DEE=JE;HJ%].DN;=S%9eeb^%Q>HN;A=F% FE>HJI%FOQQH>E%PH>%E<;F%BCD;GM%'<=%E<=H>@%FEDE=F%E<DE%E<=%
%
%
77%
=UE=JE% EH% K<;B<% ;>>=C=NDJE% A;FE>DBEH>F% BDJ% ?=% Q>HB=FF=A% A=Q=JAF% HJ% <HK% GOB<%
Q>HB=FF;JI%BDQDB;E@%E<=%Q>;GD>@%EDFL%BHJFOG=F%P>HG%E<=%EHEDCM%$E%Q>=A;BEF%E<DE%DF%GH>=%
Q=>B=QEODC% DEE=JE;HJDC%>=FHO>B=F%D>=% DCCHBDE=A%EH% E<=%ED>I=EFS% C=FF%?=BHG=F%DND;CD?C=%EH%
Q>HB=FF%E<=%EDFLa;>>=C=NDJ E%FE;GOC;M%- HJ N => F=C@ S%;P%E< =>= %D>=%=JHOI<%C=PEHN=>%Q>HB=FF;JI%
>=FHO>B=FS%E<=%;>>=C=NDJE%;JPH>G D E;HJ%K ;CC%?=%Q>HB= FF=A%DO EHGDE;BDCC@M%'<;F%QH;JEF%EH%E<=%
QDFF;N=%Q>HB=FF;JI%DFQ=BE%HP%DEE=JE;HJM%%
1%F=>;=F%HP%?=<DN;H>DC%=UQ=>;G=JEF%].DN;=S%7889S% .DN;=%=E% DCMS%788:S%-D>EK>;I<Ea
!;JB<%DJA%.DN;=S%788_S%!H>FE=>%DJA%.DN;=S%788d^%GDJ;QOCDE=A%Q=>B=QEODC%CHDA%?@%=;E<=>%
ND>@;JI% E<=% JOG ?= >% HP% EDF La>=C=NDJE% FE;GOC;% E<DE%J==A% EH%?=%Q>HB=FF=A% H>%GDL;JI% E<=%
Q=>B=QEODC% ;A=JE;P;BDE;HJ% HP% E<=% EDFLa>=C=NDJE% FE;GOC;% G H >=% H>% C=FF% A;PP;BOCE% DJA% E<=J%
=UDG;J=A% E<=% Q >HB=FF;JI% HP% E<=% A;FE>DBEH>FM% 4>=DE=>% Q>HB=FF;JI% HP% A;FE>DBEH>F% KDF%
H?F=>N=A% PH>% CHK=>% Q =>B=QEODC% A=G DJA;JI% Q>;GD>@% EDFL% BHJA;E;HJFM% '<=% FDG=% >=FOCEF%
DCFH% I=J=>DC;i=A% EH% A;FE>DBEH>F%HP% A;PP=>=JE% JDEO>=S% FEDE;B%NFM% GHN;JI% ;>>=C=NDJE % FE;GOC;%
]#==F%=E%DCMS%9ee_^S%=UE=>J D C%N F M%;J E => J D C%A;FE>DBE;JI%E<HOI<EF%]!H>FE=>%DJA%.DN;=S%788e^M%%
,PP=BEF%CHDA%DJA%BD QD B ;E@ %C;G ;E DE;H J %GDJ;P=FE=A%;J%F=N=>DC%N;FO D C%D> =D FM%& B< KD>Ei%
=E%DCM%]788b^%>=N=DC=A%E<DE%N;FODC%BH>E=U%DBE;N;E@%>=CDE=A%EH%E<=%A;FE>DBEH>%B<=BL=>?HD>A%DE%
E<=%Q=>;Q<=>@%A=B>=DF=A%;P%E<=%QD>E;B;QDJEF%K=>=%;JNHCN=A%;J%D%B=JE>DC%EDFL%HP%<;I<%CHDA%
]&B<KD>Ei% =E% DCMS% 788b^M% '<=% >=AOBE;H J % ;J% J=O>DC% >=FQHJF=F% KDF% H?F=>N=A% ;J% DCC% E<=%
>=E;JHEHQ;BDCC@aGDQQ=A%>=I;HJFS%P>HG%09%EH%0fS%DCE<HOI<%E<=%=PP=BEF%HP%CHDA%K=>=%CD>I=>%
;J%<;I < => %N;FODC%D>= DF M%"HN;JI%PO>E<=>%O Q %E<=%N;FO DC%<;=>D>B<@S%E<=%P"#$%>=FQHJ F=F%;J%E<=%
%
%
7:%
QD>D<;QQHBDGQDC%QCDB=%D>=DF%]//1^%EH%A;FE>DBEH>F%K=>=%DCFH%F<HKJ%EH%?=%GHAOCDE=A%?@%
CHDA%HP%E< =%B =J E>D C%ED FL M%T < ;C= %QD>E;B;QDJEF%GHJ;EH>=A%B=JE>DC%PDB=%;GDI=F%DJA%;IJH>=A%
E<=%?DBLI>HOJA %<HOF=%;G DI =F%E<DE%K =>= %>=Q=DE=A%AO>;JI%<DCP%HP% E<=%E>;DCFS% ;J B >= D F;J I %E<=%

A=GDJA% HP% E<=% PDB=% EDFLF% >=FOCE=A% ;J% >=AOB=A% Q=>B=QEODC% Q>HB=FF;JI% HP% E<=% <H OF= S%
;JA;BDE=A %?@ %DEE=J O D E=A %>=Q = E;E;H J %FOQ Q >= FF;H J %=PP=BEF%;J%E<=%//1%]*;%=E%DCMS%788f^M%,N=J%
K;E<% D% GHN;JI% A;FE>DBEH>S%E<=% BDQDB;E@% C;G;EDE;HJ% DJA% =PP=BEF% HP% CHDA% Q=>F;FE=AM% T<=J%
QD>E;B;QDJEF% Q=>PH>G=A% C;JIO;FE;B% EDFLF% HP% CHK% H >% <;I < % CHDA % K < ;C=% ;>>= C=N D JE% N;F O DC%
GHE;HJ% K=>=% ;J% E<=% Q=>;Q<=>@S% GHE;HJa>=CDE=A% DBE;N;E@% ;J% 0b% F<HK=A% >= AO B=A % GHE;HJ%
Q>HB=FF;JIM%%
%
1.1.2 Limits of Temporal Attention: The Speed of Sight
1CE<HOI<% H?F=>N=>F% BDJ% BDE=IH>;i=% D% ?>;=PC@% Q>=F=JE=A% ]r78GF^% H?V=BE% PD;>C@%
>DQ;AC@% DJA% DBBO>DE=C@% ]'<H>Q=%=E%DCMS%9eegS% 4>;CCa&Q=BEH>%DJA%3 DJK;F<=>S% 788b^S% K<=J%
FE;GOC;% D>=% Q>=F=JE=A % ;J% FO BB=FF;HJS% E<=% E;G =% >= WO;>=A % PH>% FO BB=FFPOC% >=BHI J;E;HJ%
C=JIE<=J = A M% +O>% N;FODC% F@FE=G% ;F% C;G;E=A% ?@% E<=% >DE=% DE% K<;B<% ;JPH>GDE;HJ % BDJ% ?=%
Q>HB=FF=AM%+?F=>N=>F%BHOCA%>=C;D?C@%;A=JE;P@%H?V=BEF%DE%Q>=F=JEDE;HJ%>DE=%HP%OQ%EH%=;I<E%
Q;BEO>=F% Q=>% F=BHJA%]/HEE=>%DJA% !DOCBHJ=>S%9e_b^S%K<;C=%E<DE%PH>%? D F;B %N;FODC%B<DJI=F%C;L=%
PC;BL=>;JI%H>%G H E;HJ %KDF% D >H OJ A %:8ab85i% AO=%EH%E<=%A;PP=>=JB=%;J%BHGQC=U;E@% HP%P=DEO>=F%
]3=CC@S%9eg9S%9e_e^M%'= GQH>DC%DEE=JE;H J S%;J%E<=F=%BDF =FS%E<= %N;FOD C%DEE=J E;HJ %HN= >%E;G= S%;F%
BDQDB;E@%C;G;E=AM%%
%
%
7f%
'<=% FEDJAD>A% E=B<J;WO=% PH>% FEOA@;JI% E=GQH>DC% DEE=JE;HJ% ;F% OF;JI% >DQ;AC@%
Q>=F=JE=A%F=WO=JB=F%HP%N;FODC%;E=GF%]#&0/^%DE%ND>;D?C=%Q>=F=JEDE;HJ%>DE=FM%'<;F%QOF<=F%
E<=%N;FODC%F@ FE=G%EH%;EF%C;G;ES%DCCHK;JI%OF%EH %=UDG ;J=%E<=%>DE=%DE%K<;B<%N;FODC%;JPH>GDE;HJ%
BDJ% ?=% =UE>DBE=A% P>HG% D% FE>=DG% HP% BHJFEDJEC@% B<DJI;JI% ;JQOEFM% )=FQ;E=% E<=% ?=<DN;H>DC%
=N;A=JB=%HP%D%E=GQH>DC%C;G;EDE;HJ%;J%;JPH>GDE;HJ%Q>HB=FF;JIS%J =O>H;GDI;JI%FEOA;=F%DCFH%
DEE=GQE=A% EH% P;JA% E<=% POJADG=J EDC% J=O>DC% G=B<DJ;FGF% OJA=>C@;JI% E<=% E=GQH>DC%
Q>HB=FF;JI%C;G;EDE;HJM%%
"B3==PP% ]788_^% OF=A% F;JIC=% ED>I=E% F=D>B<% #&0/% HP% PDB=% DJA% <HOF=% ;GDI=F% EH%
;JN=FE;ID E=%E<=%C;G;EDE;HJ%;J%D>=DF%DCHJI%E<=%N;FODC%QDE<K D@%]"B3==PP% =E%DCMS%788_^M%P"#$%
>=FQHJF=% Q>HP;C=F%EH%A;PP=>=J E% Q>=F=JEDE;HJ% >DE=F%K=>=%G=DFO>=A%PH>%E<=% >=E;JHEHQ;BDCC@%

GDQQ=A% >=I;HJFM%'<=%>=FQHJF=% >=N=DC=A% D%F@FE=GDE;B%A=BC;J=% ;J%Q=DL%DBE;NDE;HJ% EHKD>AF%
CHK=>%Q >= F= JE DE;H J %>D E=F %I H;J I %O Q %E< =%N ;F O DC%< ;=>D >B<@ S%FOII=FE;J I%D%Q>H I>=FF;N= %CHFF%;J%
E<=%E=GQH>DC%Q>HB=FF;JI%BDQDB;E@% H P%E<=%< OGDJ% N ;FO DC%F@FE=GM%'<=%>=FOCEF%;GQC@%E<DE%E<=%
<;I<=>aC=N=C%D>=DF%BHJ FE>D ;J %E<=%E=GQH>DC%Q>HB=F F;J I%G H >= %;J%BHGQD>;FHJ%EH%E<=%=D> C;=>%
FEDI=F%HP%N;FODC%Q>HB=FF;JIM%'<=%C;G;EDE;HJ%;J%E=GQ H >D C%Q>HB=FF;JI %BDQDB;E@%E;=F%B CHF= C@%
K;E<% E<=% C;G;EDE;HJ% ;J% Q= >B =Q EO D C% Q>HB=FF;JI% BDQDB;E@S% ?HE<% QH;JE;JI% EH% >=FHO>B=%
C;G;EDE;HJ %D E%E< =%P>H J E%=J A %H P%E< =%;J PH >GDE;HJ%Q>HB=F F;J I%F @F E=GM%
+?F=>N=>F%BDJ% >=BHIJ;i=%D% F;JIC=%ED>I=E%;J%D%#&0/%FE>=DG%WO;E=%>=C;D?C@%DE%D%>DE= %
HP% d% ;GDI=FcF% ]r97bGF% Q=>% ;GDI=^M% T<=J% DAA;JI% HJ=% GH>=% ED>I=E% EH% ?=% G HJ;EH>=A% ;J%
DAA;E;HJ%EH%E<=%F;JIC=%ED>I=E%F=D>B<%#&0/S%D%FE>HJI=>%C;G;EDE;HJ%;F%H?F=>N=AS%JDG=C@%E<=%
%
%
7b%
DEE=JE;HJDC%?C;JL%]16^%Q<=JHG=JHJ% ]#D@GHJA% =E%DCMS%9ee7^M% +?F=>N=>F%HPE=J%PD; C%EH% A=E=BE%
D%F=BHJA% FDC;=JE%ED>I=E% HBBO>>;JI%C=FF%E<DJ% b88G F%DPE=>% E<=%P;>FE%ED>I=ES%GO B<%FCHK=>%E<DJ%
E<=%>DE=%DE%K<;B<%H J= %BDJ%A =E=B E%D%F;JIC= %ED>I=EM%'< ;F% FOII=FEF%E<DE%16 %JHE%HJ C@ %D>;F=F%
P>HG% E<=% C;G;EDE;HJ% ;J%E=GQH>DC%Q>HB=FF;JI%;J%E<=%N;FODC% F@FE=G% ];J%E<=%BDF=%HP% N;FODC%
#&0/^S% ?OE% DCFH% P>HG% DAA;E;HJDC% BDQDB;E@% C;G;E=A% Q>HB=FF=FM% &=N=>DC% FEOA;=F% F<HK=A%
=N;A=JB=%FOQQH>E;JI%E<;F%;A=D%].OBL%=E%DCMS%9eegS%"D>H;F%=E%DCMS%7888^M%$J%D%FEO A @%?@%" D >H ;F %
=E% DCM% ]788f^S% QD>E;B;QDJEF% K =>=% ;JFE>OBE=A% EH% A=E=BE% D% PDB=% ED>I=E% DJA% D% F=BHJA% <HOF=%
ED>I=E%;J%DJ %# & 0 /%FE>=DG%H P%FB >DG ? C=A %;GDI=F%]"D>H;F%=E%DCMS%788f^M%'< = %F = BH J A%<H O F= %
ED>I=ES%E<H O I< %JHE%= UQ C;B;EC@%A=E=BE=A S%JHJ=E<= C=FF %DBE;NDE=A%E<=%Q D>D < ;QQ HB DG Q D C%QCDB=%
D>=D%]//1 ^M% $J%BHJE>DFES%E<=%P>HJEDCaQD>;=EDC%J=EKH>L%KDF% >=B>O;E=A%HJC@%K<=J% E<=% F=BHJA%
ED>I=E%KDF%A =E= BE=A M%%
'<=F=% P;JA;JIF% ;JFQ;>=A% OF% EH% CHHL% DE% BDQDB;E@% C;G;EDE;HJ% ?=@HJA% Q=>B=QEODC%
Q>HB=FF;JI%>=FHO>B=F%A=FB>;?=A%?=CHKM%%
%
1.1.3 Attention, a capacity-limited resource allocator
4HDCaA;>=BE=A% ?=<DN;H>% >=WO;>=F% GD;JE=JDJB=% HP% EDFL% IHDCFS% PHBOF;JI% HJ% EDFL%
>=C=NDJE%FE;GOC;%DJA%;IJH>;JI%;>>=C=NDJ E%A;FE>DBEH>FS%K<;B< %D>=%DCC%QD>EF%HP%E<=%BHIJ;E;N=%

BHJE>HC%Q>HB=FF=FM%'<=%BDQDB;E@aC;G;E=A%J DE O >=%HP%DEE=J E;H J %DF%DJ% D B E;N= %>=FHO>B=% D CCH BD EH >%
<DF%?==J%;GQC;=A%;J%D%JOG?=>%HP%FEOA;=FM%$JB>=DF;JI%E<=%CHDA%HJ%E<=%DEE=JE;HJDC%BHJE>HC%
Q>HB=FF=FS%E<=%ZDCCHBDEH>[%PD;C=A%EH%DCCHBDE=%DEE=JE;HJ%DF%K=CC%;J%BHGQD>;FHJ%EH%CHK%CHDA%