Minsky on the reregulation and restructuring of the financial system

!
!
MINSKY!ON!THE !REREGULATION!AND!RESTRUCTURING!OF!THE!FINANCIAL!SYSTEM!
Will!Dodd‐Frank!Prevent!“It”!from!Happening!Again?
1
!
!
!"#$%&'())&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
)
&*#+",#+-&.$/0&/0+&12""3#/&34&53#-&5326-,/$36&7#,6/&638&)(9(:)((;:)&36& 5$6,6 <$,%&=/,>$%$/?&,6-&@%3>,%&,6-&
A,/$36,%&BC+D#+72%,/$36&$6&E$70/&34&/0+&=2>:"#$F+&G#$1$18&
&
&
&
'&
CONTENTS!
!
Preface! ! ! !!;&
!
Introduction! ! ! !!H&
!
Chapter!1.!Will!Dodd‐Frank!Prevent!“It”!fr om!Happening!Again?! ! ! !!I&
&
Chapter!2.!Minsky!on!What!B anks!Sho uld!Do! ! ! ;'&
&
Chapter!3.!A!Minsky!Index!Measuring!Financial!Fragility! ! ! J'&
&
Appendix.!Indexes!with!Equal!Weight !for!All!Variables! ! ! HK&
&
References! ! ! H9&

&
Rel ated!Levy!Ins titute!Publications& & & K'
&
&
;&
PREFACE!
!
L0$ 1&F3637#,"0&$1&",#/&34&/0+&3673$67&E+M?&N61/$/2/+&#+1+,#<0&"#37#,F&36&5$6,6<$,%&N61/,>$%$/?&,6-&/ 0+&
C+#+72% ,/$36& 34& 5$6,6<$,%& N61/$/2/$361& ,6-& O,#P+/1& 426-+-& >?& /0 +& 53#-& 5326-,/$368& L0$1& "#37#,F& 0,1&
26-+#/,P+6&,6&$6M+1/$7,/$36&34&/0+&<,21+1&,6-&-+M+%3"F+6/&34&/0+&#+<+6/&4$6,6<$,%&<#$1$1&4#3F&/0+&"3$6/&
34&M$+.&34&/0+&%,/+&E+M?&N61/$/2/+&Q$1/$672$1 0+-&=<03%,#&R?F,6&*8&O$61P?8&
L0+&F3637 #,"0&-#,.1&36&O$61P?S1&+T/+61$M+&.3#P&36&#+72%, /$36&/3&#+M$+ .&,6-&, 6,%?U+&/0+&#+<+6/&Q3 :
5#, 6P& V,%%& =/#++/& C+43#F& ,6-& G3612F+ #& *#3/+</ $36& !</& +6,< /+-& $6& #+1"361+& /3& /0+& <#$1$1& $6& /0+& W=&
12>"#$F+& F3# /7,7+& F,#P+/X& ,6- & /3& ,11+11& .0+/0+#& /0$1& 6+.& #+72%,/3#?& 1/# 2</2 #+& .$%%& "#+M+6/& YN/Z[,&
-+>/& -+4%,/$36& 36& /0+& 3#-+#& 34& /0+& @#+,/& Q+"#+11$36[4#3F& 0,"" +6$6 7& ,7 ,$68& N/& 1++P1& /3& ,11+11& /0+&
+T/+6/&/3&.0$<0&/0+&!</&.$%%&>+&<,",>%+&34&$-+6/$4?$67&,6-&#+1"36-$67&/3&/0+&+6-37+6321&7+6+#,/$36&34&
4$6,6<$,%&4#,7$%$/?&/0,/&O$ 61P?&>+%$+M+-&/3&>+&/0+&#33/&<,21+&34&4$6,6<$,%&$61/,>$%$/?8&
\2/&O$61P?&,%13&>+%$+M+-&/0,/&#+72%,/$36&1032%-&>+& %$6P+-&/3&/0+&1/#2</2#+&34&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&1?1/+F8&]6+&34&
/0+&F,^3#&-#,.>,<P1&34&/0+&<2##+6/&%+7$1%,/$36&$1&/0,/&$ /&-3+1&63/&"#3"31+&, 6&,%/+#6 ,/$M+&/3 &/0+&4$6,6<$,%&
1/#2</2#+&/0,/&"#3-2<+- &/0+&#+<+6/&<#$1$18&N6-++-X&O$61P?&M $+.+-&/0+&Y-+<%$6+&34&/#,-$/$36,%&>,6P$67Z&,1&
36+&34&/0+&< ,21+1&34&4$6,6<$ ,%&$61/,>$%$/?X&,6-&0+ &0,-&M+#?&<%+,#&M $+.1 &36&.0,/&/0+&$-+,%&1/ #2</2#+&1032%-&
%33P& %$P+8& 53#& O$61P?X& ,6?& #+72%,/3#?& #+7$F+ & F21/& >+& <361 $1/+6/& .$/0X& ,6-& 1+61$/$M+& /3X& /0+& + M3%M$67&
6,/2#+&34&4$6,6<$,%&$ 663M,/$36X&,6-&1032%-&1++P&/3&431 /+#&/.3&<#$/$< ,%&1/#2</2#,%&3>^+</$M+1_&B)D&+6 12#$67&
/0+& %367:/+#F& 1 /,>$%$/?& 34& /0+& 4$6,6<$,%& 1?1/+FX& ,6-& B'D& "#3F3/$67& /0+& <,"$/,%& -+M+%3"F+6/& 34& /0+&
+<363F?8&&
L0+&F3637# ,"0&/021&>2$%-1&36&O$61P?S1&M$+.1&,1& +T"#+11+-&$6&0$1&"2>%$10+-&.3#PX&0$1&344$<$,%&/+1/$F36?X&
,6-&0$1&264$6$10+-&-#,4/&F,621<#$"/&36&/0+&12>^+</8&N6&",#/$<2%,#X&0$1&M $+.1&,#+&$6&<36<+#/&.$/0&/031+& .03&
>+% $+M+&/0,/&/0+&36%?&.,?&/3&F,P+&/0+&%,#7+X&Y/33&>$7&/3&#+72%,/+X&,6-&/33&>$7&/3&4,$%Z&>,6P1&$1&/3&>#+,P&
/0+F&-3 .6&$6/3&1F,%%+#&26$/18&L0+#+&$1&, &<%31+&<3##+%,/$36&>+/.++6&/0+&Y3#$7$6,/ +&,6-&-$1/#$>2/+Z&F3-+%&
34& >,6P$67& /0,/& " #3-2<+-& /0+& < #$1$1& ,6-& %,#7+ & >,6P& 1$U+8& =F,%%+#& >,6P1X& F3#+& <%31+%?& %$6P+- & /3& /0+$#&

>3##3.+#1& ,6-& /0+& <3FF26$/?X& .32%-& "#3M$-+& /0+& "311$>$ %$/?& 34& #+1/ 3#$67& /0+& Y3#$7$6,/+& ,6-& 03%-Z&
>,6P$67& F3-+%& /0,/& <36<+6/#,/+-& 36& /0+& <#+-$/.3#/0$6+11& 34& >3##3.+#1& #,/0+#& /0,6& F,T$F$U$67& /0+&
7+6+#,/ $36&34&-32>/42%&,11+/1&/3&>+&13%-&M$,&1+<2#$/$U,/$368&N/&.32%-&,%1 3&<0,67+&/0+&$6< +6/$M+&1/#2</2#+ &
,6-&/0+&%+M+%&34&+,#6 $671& 34&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&1+</3#8&&
N##+1"+</$M+& 34& /0+& +F+#7+6/& 4$6,6<$,%& 1/#2</2#+X& #+ 72%,/3#1& .$%%& 0,M+& /3& >+& F3#+& <376$U,6/& 34& /0+&
+6-37+6321&"#3<+11+1&/0,/X&$6&O$61P?S1&M$+.X&,#+&/ 0+&#33/&34 &/0+&$61/,>$%$/?&/0,/&"#3-2<+1&<#$1$18&N6 -++-X&
36+& 34& / 0+& /,1P1& 34& /0+& 6+.& 5$6,6<$,%& =/,>$%$/?& ] M+#1$70/& G326<$%& $1& /3& $-+6/$4?& ,6-& /,P+& F+,12#+1& /3&
"#+1+6/ & 4$6,6<$,%& $61/,>$%$/?8& L0$1& F3637#,"0& "#3M$-+1& 1277+1/$361& 36& 03.& O$61P?S1& ,6,%?/$<,%&
4#,F+.3#P&<,6&>+&21+-&/3&-+M+%3"&F+,1 2#+1&34&4$6,6<$,%&$61/,>$%$/?X&$6&/0+&43#F&34&4#,7$%$ /?&$ 6-$<+1&43#&
M,#$321&1+</3#1&34&/0+&+<363F?&/3&0+%"&#+7 2%,/3#1&- +/+</&+F+#7$67&<#$1+18 &
V0+/0+#& /0+& Q3 :5#,6P& !</& Y/3& "#3F3/+& /0+& 4$6,6<$,%& 1/,>$ %$/?& $6& /0+& W6$/+-& =/,/+1& >?& $F"#3M$67 &
,<<326/,>$% $/?&,6-&/ #,61",#+6<?&$6&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&1?1/+FX&/3&+6-&`/33&>$7&/3&4,$%XS&/3&"#3/+</&/0+&!F+#$<,6 &
/,T",?+#& >?& +6-$67& > ,$%32/1X& /3 & "#3/+</& <3612F+#1& 4#3F& ,>21$M+& 4$6,6<$,%& 1+#M$<+1& "#,</$<+1X& ,6-& 43#&
&
&
J&
3/0+#& "2#"31+1Z& .$%%& >+& ,>%+& /3& 42%4$%%& /0+& "#3F$1+& 34& $/1& /$/%+& $1& ,6& 3"+6& a2+1/$368& O$61P?& #+"+,/ +-%?&
"3$6/+-&32/&/0,/&,&4$6,6< $,%&<#$1$1X&#,/ 0+#&/0,6 &>+$67&,&"+<2%$,#&+M+6/X&$1&/0+ &6,/2#,%&#+ 1"361+&34&F,#P+/1&
/3&,&"+#$3-&34&#+%,/$M+&1/,>$%$/?&,6-&$663M,/$3 61&$6&#$1P&F,6,7+ F+6 /8&R+&,#72+-&/0,/&$112+1&34&4$6,6<$,%&
$61/,>$% $/?& .+#+& 63/& $F"3#/,6/& 1$F"%?& >+<,21+ & 34& /0+$#& $F" ,</& 36& /0+& 4 $6,6 <$,%& 1?1/+FX& >2/& >+<,21+& ,&
1/,>%+& 4$6,6<$,%& 1?1/+F& $1& <+6/#,%& / 3& / 0+& "#3-2</$M+& $6M+1/F+6/& 6++-+-& 43#& $6<3F+& 7#3./0& ,6-& 42%%&
+F "%3?F+6 /8&
N6-++-X & /0$1& .,1& /0+& F,$6&3>^+</& 34& O$61P?S1& #+1+,#<0& ,/& /0+& E+M?& N61/$ /2/+8&R$1&"#3"31,%& 43#& 4$6,6<$,%&
1/,>$%$/?&.,1&/3 & 10$4/& +F"0,1$1&4#3F& < ,"$/,%:$6/+61$M+& $6M+1/F+6/&$6&7#3./0& /3&$6M+1/F+6/&$6& ^3>1& ,1&,&
F+ ,61& 34& +612#$6 7& >3/0& 1/,>$%$/?& ,6-& ,6& +a2$/,>%+& $6<3F+& -$1/#$>2/$368& bF"%3?F+6/X& O$61P?& ,#72+-X&
1032%-& >+& /0+& F,^3#&3>^+</ $M+& 34& +<363F$<&"3%$<?X& .$/0&73M+#6F+6/& ,</$67&,1&+F"%3?+#& 34& %,1/& #+13#/&
BbECD8& !& -$#+</X& 4+-+#,%%?& 426-+-& +F"%3?F+6/& 72,#,6/++& "#37#,FX& 36+& "#3M$-$67& ,& ^3>& 3""3#/26$/?& /3&
,6?& $6-$M$-2,%& .$%%$67& ,6-& ,>%+& /3& .3#PX& .32% -& ,</& ,1& ,6& ,2/3F,/$<& +<36 3F$<& 1/,>$%$U+#X& +6,>% $67&
0321+03%-1& /3& F++/& /0+$#& 4$6,6<$,%& <3FF$/F+6/1 & ,6- & 12>1/,6/$,%%?& #+ -2<$67& /0+& $F",</& 34& 4$6,6<$,%&
103<P18&

!1&O $61P?&.#3/+&$6&0$1&%,6-F ,#P&.3#P&Stabilizing*an *Unstable*EconomyX&Y!&6+.&+#, &3 4&#+43# F&<,663/&>+&
1$F"%?& ,& 1+#$+1& 34& "$+<+F+,%& <0,67+18&C ,/0+ #X& ,& / 03#3270X& $ 6/+7#,/+-& ,""#3,<0& /3& 32#& +<3 63F $<&
"#3>%+F1&F21/&>+&-+M+%3"+-c&"3%$<?&F21/&#,67+&3M+#&/0+&+6/$#+&+<363F$<&%,6-1<,"+&,6- &4$/&/0+&"$+<+1&
/37 +/0+ #&$6 &,&<361$1/ +6/X&.3#P, >%+&.,?_&*$+<+F+,%&,""#3,<0+1&, 6-&",/<0.3#P&<0,67+1&.$%%&36%?&F,P+&,&
>,-&1$/2,/$36&. 3#1+Z&B'((9&d)e9KfX&; ';D8&L0$1&0,1&>++6& 36+&34& /0+&3#7,6$U$67&"#$6<$"%+1&34&/0+&"#3^+</&
/0,/&0,1&7+6+#,/+-&/0$1&F363 7#,"08&&
Q$F$/#$&\8&*,",-$F$/#$32*
President,*Levy*E conomics*Institute*
&
&
&
&
&
H&
INTRODUCTION!
!
L0+& -+F$1+& 34 & /0+& 6+.:F$%%+66$2 F& #+,%& +1/,/+& ,6-& <3 FF3-$/?& >33F& 0,1& <3F+& /3& >+ & P63.6& ,1& /0 +&
YO $61P?&F3F+6/8Z &b<363F$1/1&M+#1+-&$6&R?F,6&O$61 P?S1&1"+<$4$<,/$36&34&0+-7+X&1"+<2%,/$M+X&,6-&*36U$&
4$6,6<$67&1<0+F+1&a2$<P%?&$-+6/$4$+-&/0+&<36-$/$ 361&$ 6&/0+&F,#P+/&4 3#&1+ <2#$/$U+-&12>"#$F+&F3#/7 ,7+1&,1&
,&*36U$&1<0+F+&34&<3%311,%&"#3 "3#/$3618&L 031+&4,F$%$,#&.$/0& /0+&"#3<+11&>?& .0$<0&/0+&1<,#<$/?&34& %$a2$-$/?&
<,6&7+6+#,/+&,&-+>/&-+4%,/$36&.+#+&,%13&a2$<P&/3&1++&/0+&#,"$-&/#,61F$11$36&34&-$1/#+11&$6&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&
F, #P+/1& $6/3& /0+& 42%%:1<,%+& -+"#+11$36& 4#3F& .0$<0& .+& 0,M+& ?+/& /3& +F+#7+8& !1$-+& 4#3 F& /0+& F,^3#& %$4+&
12""3#/&F+,12#+1&BL!C*X&/0+&1/$F2%21&>$%%X&gNC*X&,6-&hbDX&/0+&F,^3#&#+1"361+&0,1&>++6&/0,/&.+&<,663/&
%+/&YN/Z[,63/0+#&@#+,/&Q+"#+11$36[0,""+ 6&,7,$68&O,6?&#+<376$U+&/0,/&#,-$<,%&<0,67+1&,#+&#+a2$#+-&$6&
/0+&#+72%,/$361&73 M+#6$67&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&1?1/+F&/3&F,P+&12#+&/0,/& 12<0&.$ -+1"#+,-&12""3#/&F+,12#+1&.$%%&
6+M+#&,7,$6 &>+&6+<+11,#?&/3&"#+M+6/&/0+&<3%%,"1+&34&/0+&4 $6,6 <$,%& 1?1/+F8&G367#+11&/021&F3M+-&#,"$-%?&/3&
.#$ /+& ,6-& ,""#3M+& ,& F,^3#& 3M+#0,2%& 34& 4$6,6<$,%& F,#P+/& #+72%,/$361X& .$/0& /0+& #,%%?$67& <#?& /0,/& /0+&
!F+#$<,6&/,T",?+#&.$%%&6+M+ #&,7,$6&>+&#+a2$# +-&/3&4$6,6 <+&/0+& >,$%32/&34 &V,%%&=/#++/&,6-&V,%%&= /#++/&.$%%&
6+M+#&,7,$6&>#$67&,>32/&/ 0+&<3%%,"1+&3 4&O,$6&=/#++/8&&
\2/& $6& /0$1& #+1"3 61+& /3& /0+& <#$1$1X& -$1<211$36& 34& R?F,6& *8& O $61P?& 0,1& M$#/2,%%?& -$1,""+,#+- X& /3& >+&

#+"%,<+-& >?&F3 #+&"#,7F,/$<&%3>>?$1/1&1++P$67&/3&-+4+6-&M+1/+-&$6/+#+1/18&!%/03270&"3%$/$<,%%?&+T"+-$+6 /X&
/0$1&$1&2643#/26,/+X&1$6<+&/0+&F,^3#$/?&34&O$61P?S1&.3#P&.,1&7+6+#,/+-&>?&,6&$6/+#+1/&$6&/0+&-+1$76&34&,&
4$6,6<$,%&1?1/+F&,6-&4$ 6,6<$,%&#+72%,/$36 1&/0,/ &.32%-&F,P+&12#+&/0 ,/&YN/Z&.32%-&63/&0,""+6&,7,$6&B1++&
O$61P?& )eKJX& )eI'D8& R$1& <36/$62,%& #+4#,$6& $6 & /0$1& .3#P & .,1& /0,/& /0+& 4$ 6,6<$,%& 1/#2</2#+& 1 032%-& >+&
-+1$76+-& $6& 12<0& ,& ., ?& ,1 & /3& +612#+& /0,/& $/& "#3M$-+1& /0+& 6+<+11,#?& 12 ""3#/& 43#& /0 +& 4$6,6< $67& 34& /0+&
"#3-2</$M+& $6M+1/F+6 /& 6++-+-& >?& /0+& +<363F?X& .$/032 /& 7+6+# ,/$67& +T<+11$M+& 4$ 6,6<$,%& 4#,7$%$/?& B1++&
V#,?&'()(D8&R+#+X&O$61P?&.,1&,&#+,%$1/8 &R+&> +%$+M+-&/0,/&/0+&63#F,%&<3F"+/$/$M+&"#34$/ :1++P$67&"#3<+11&
.32%-& %+,-& 4$6,6<$,%& $61/$/2/$361& /3& ,-3"/& $663M,/$361& $6& /0+$#& F,6,7+F+6/& 34& %$a2$-$/?& /0,/&
<$#<2FM+6/+-&+T$1/$67&#+72%,/$361X&. 0$<0&.32%-&%+,-&/3&,6&+6-37+6321&"#3<+11&34&$6<#+,1$67&$61/,>$%$/?8&
L021X& .0$%+& #+72%,/$361& /3 & 12""3#/& 4$6,6<$,%& 1/,>$%$/?& .32%-& >+& $F"3# /,6/X& /0+?& <32%-& 63/& 32/%$M+& /0+&
6,/2#,%&+M3%2/$36&34&4$6 ,6<$67&3"+#,/$361&/0,/&,<<3F",6$+-&.0,/&0+&<361$-+ #+-&/0+&63#F,%&"#3<+11&>?&
.0$<0&1/,>$%$/?&+67+6-+#1&4#,7$%$/?8&G0,"/+#&)&34&/0$1&F3637#,"0&/021&1++ P1&/3&"#3M$-+&,&O$61P?,6&M$+.&
36&/0+&<2##+6/&#+7 2%,/3#?&"#3<+118&N/&0$70%$70/1&/0+&4 ,</&/0,/&/0+&$6 /#3-2</$36&34&%,6-F,#P&%+7$1%,/$36&$1&
%+11&$F"3#/,6/&/0,6&$/1&$F"%+F+6/,/$3 6&,6-&F36$/3#$678&&
O$61P?&>+%$+M+ -&/0,/&/0+&A+.&Q+,%&%+7$1%,/$36&.,1&/0+&+T"#+11$36&34&,&%$,>$%$/?&1/#2 </2#+&/0,/&.,1&,%#+,-?&
32/F3-+-&.0+6&$/&.,1&$6/#3-2<+-&,6-&.,1&63/&, ""#3"#$,/+&/3&/0+ &$6<#+,1+-&$64%2+6<+&34&73M+#6F+6/&
/0,/&.32%- &12>1+a2+6/%?&+F+#7+&BO$61P?&)e9KX&9ID8&L0$1&7+6+#,/+-&+6-37+6321&43#<+1&/0,/&13270/&/3&
+#3-+& /0+& +44+</$M+6+11& 34& /0+& %+7$1%,/$36& /0#3270& ,-F$6 $1/#,/$M+& -+<#++X& %+7,%& $6/+#"#+/,/$36 X& ,6 -&
%+7$1%,/$M+&#+%$+4&B1 ++&i#+7+%&' ()(D8&N6&",#/$<2%,#X&/0+&"#3<+11&34&1+<2#$/$U,/$36&/0,/&%$+1&,/&/0+&0+,# /&34&/0+&
10$4/& 4#3F& Y3#$7$6,/+& ,6-& 03%-Z& /3& Y3#$7$6,/+& ,6-& -$1/#$>2/+Z& /0,/& "%,?+-& 12 <0& , 6& $F"3#/,6/& #3%+& $6&
12>"#$F+&%+6-$67&<32%-&63/&0,M+&3<<2##+-&.$/03 2/&,&1+#$+1&34&,-&03<&,-F$6$1/#,/$M+&,6-&%+7,%&-+<$1$361X&
+,<0& 34& .0$<0& ," "+,# +-& /3& #+1"36-& / 3& $6-21/#?& >+1/& "#,</$<+X& >2/& .0$<0& <2%F$6,/+- & $6 & "#3-2<$67& ,&
1/#2</2#,%& <0,67+& $6& 4$6,6<$ ,%& 3"+#,/$361& /0, /& ., 1& 0$70%?& 261/,>%+8& O2<0& 34& /0$1& 1,F+& "#3<+11X& >2$%/ &
,#326-& 7#,6/$67& >,6P1& Y,%%& 12<0& $6<$-+6/,%& "3.+# 1& ,1& 10,%%& >+& 6+<+11,#?& /3& <,##?& 36 & /0+& >21$6+11& 34&
&
&
K&
>,6P$67Z&B,1&$ /&.,1&+T"#+11+-&$6&1+</$36&)K&34 &@%,11:=/+,7,%%DX&"#3M$-+1&/0+&^21/$4$<,/$36&43#&/0+&$6<%21$36&
$6& /0+& Q3 :5#,6P& %+7$1%,/$36& 34& ,& 1+#$+1& 34& +T+F"/$361& 4#3F& #+72%,/$36& .0+6 & , 113<$,/+-& .$/0& /0+&
"#3M$1$36& 34& <%$+6/& 1+#M$<+1& /0,/& 10,#"%?& #+-2< +1& /0+& +44+</$M+6+11& 34& /0+& #+43#F18& L0+& +T"+-$+6/& 34&

F3M$67& 121"+</& ,</$M $/$+1& 4#3F&/0+&$612#+- & >,6P$67& +6/$/?&/3& ,#FS1 :%+67/0& ,44$%$,/+1& 1$F"%?&+6<32#,7+ 1&
,6-& <36< +6/#,/+1& /0+& 7#3./0& 34& 12<0& ,</$M$/$+1& $6& .0,/& 0,1& <3F+& /3& >+& <,%%+-& /0+& Y10,-3.& >,6P$67Z&
1+< /3#X&.$/0&,&M+#?&%3.&"#3>,>$%$/? &34&#+72%,/$368&
G0,"/+#&'& "#+ 1+6/1& , & 12#M+?& 34& O$61P?S1& <36/#$>2/$36 1& /3& / 0+& -+>, /+& 3M+#& /0+& #+43#F& 34& /0+& 4$6,6<$,%&
1/#2</2#+&/0,/&.,1&26-+#&.,?&$6&/0+&W6$/+-&=/,/+1&$6&/0+&)e9 (1&,6-&+,#%?&)ee(1X&-#,.$67&36&"2>%$<,/$361X&
/+1/$F36?X&,6-&,6&26<3F"%+/+-&F3637#,"0&/0,/&0+&.,1&.3#P$67&36&,/&/0+&/$F+ & 34&0$1&-+,/0&$6&)eeK8&
=$6 <+& , & /+6+/& 34& O$61P?S1& M$+. & 34& #+72%,/$36& $1& /0,/& 4$6,6<$,%& $663M,/$361& .$%%& ,%.,?1& P++"& 4$6,6<$,%&
$61/$/2/$361&36+&1/+"&,0+,-&34&#+72%,/3#1&,6-&12"+#M$13#1X&0+&>+%$+M+-&$6&/0+&$F "3#/,6<+&34&#+,< /$67&/3&
/031+&<0,67+1&>+43#+&/0+?&"#3-2<+-&4$6,6<$,%&4#,7$%$/?8&&
L0+& #+<+6/& 4$6,6<$,%& %+7$1%,/$36& <#+,/+1& ,& 5$6,6<$,%&=/,>$% $/?& ]M+#1$70/& G326<$%& <0,#7+-& .$/0& $-+ 6/$4?$67&
261/,>% +&"#,</$<+1&$6&4$6,6<$,%&$61/$/2/$3618&G0,"/+#&;&/021&"#3 M$-+1&,6&,// +F" /&/3&43#F2%,/+&,&4$6,6<$,%&
4#,7$%$/?& $6-+T& /0,/& F$70/ & >+& 34& 21+& $6& 1,/$14?$67& /0+& G326<$%S1& F,6-,/+& ,6-& /0,/& <32%-& >+& 21+-& >?&
#+72%,/3#1&/3&$6/+#M+6+&/3&F,P+&12#+&/0+&6,/2#,%&"#3<+11&34&4 $6,6 <$,%&$663M,/$36&-3+1&63/&,%%3.&YN/Z&/3&
0,""+6&,7,$6 8&L0$1& "#++F"/$M+&,""#3, <0&/3& 4$6,6<$,%& 1/,>$%$/?& ,%13&0$70%$70/1& /0+&#3%+&34& 12"+#M$13#1&$6&
/0+&$F"%+F+6/,/$36&34&#+72%,/$36 1&,6-&/0+&$-+6/$4$<,/$36&34&$6,""#3"#$,/+&4$6 ,6<$,%&"#,</$<+18&&
&
&
I&
CHAPTER!1. !Will!Dodd‐Fr ank!Prevent!“It”!from!Happening!Again?!
Two!Approache s!to!Financial!Regulation!
L0+& 1/,#/$67& "3$6/& 43#& R?F,6& O$61P?S1& ,""#3, <0& /3& 4$6,6<$,%& #+72%,/$36& .,1& /0+& 3>1+#M,/ $36& /0,/& /0+&
12>^+</&<32%- &63/&>+&-$1<211+-&36&/0+&>,1$1&34&,&/0+3#?&$6&.0$<0&4$6,6<$,%&-$1#2"/$36&.,1&$F"311$>%+8&L0+&
"#3>%+F&$1& /0,/& F,$61/#+,FX& $6/+# /+F"3#,%&+a2$ %$>#$2F& "31$/1&/0+&+T$1/+6<+&34&F,#P+/ 1&43#& <36/$ 67+6/&
<36/#,< /1&43#&+M+6/1&,/&,%%&42/2#+&-,/ +1&,6-&1/,/+1&34& /0+&.3#%-8&L021X&,%%&"311$>%+& #$1P1&<,6 &>+&0+-7+-&,6-&
<326/+#",#/ $+1& <,6& ,%.,?1& 0363#& /0+$#& <3 FF$/F+6/1& $6& ,6? & "311$> %+& 32/<3F+ 8& @$M+6& /0,/& ,%%& "311$>%+&
32/<3F+1&<,6&>+&$612#+-&,7,$61/X&/0$1&,""#3,<0&/3&+a2$%$>#$2F&$F"%$+1&/0+&,>1+6<+&34&$ 613%M+6< $+18&N/&$1&
/0+&+a2$M,%+6/&34&/0+&"26/+ #&"2//$67&F36+?&36&+M+#?&03#1+&$6&/0+&#,<+_&0+&.$%%&,%.,?1&0,M+&,&.$66+#8&N4&
#+, %:.3 #%-&+T"+#$+6<+&" #3-2<+1&-$44+#+6/&32 /<3F+1X&/0$1&$1&63/&/0+&#+12%/&34&F,#P+/&4,$%2# +X&>2/&#,/0+#&
/0+&,>1+6<+& 34& ,&#+a2$ #+F+6/&/0,/&F,#P+/1&,%%3.&,7+6/1&/3&+6/+#&$6/3&/0+&42%%&<3F"%+F+6/&34&<36/$67+6/&
<36/#,< /18&L021X&3#/03-3T?& + F>#,<+1& /0+&>+ %$+4&/0,/&/0+&F,#P+/&"#3-2<+1&+a2$%$>#$2F&,6-&+6 <32# ,7+1&

/0+&-+M+%3"F+6/&,6-&$6/#3-2</$36&34&,%%&6+. &4 $6,6 <$,%&$61/#2F+6 /1&,6-&<36/#,</1&/3&,%%3.&/0+&#+,%&.3#%-&
/3&344+#&<3F"%+/+&F,# P+/18&&
L0$ 1& .,1& / 0+& ," "#3,<0& 34& / 0+& 5+-+#, %& C+1+#M+& 26-+# & !%,6& @#++61",6& ,6- & /0+& >+%$+4& /0,/& ,& .$-+#&
-$1/#$>2/$36 &34&#$1P&,<#311&F,#P+/&",#/$<$",6/1X&$6/+#F+-$,/+-&>?&/0 +&+T<0,67+&34&/0+1+&6+.&$61/#2F+6/1&
$6&6+.&F,#P+/1X&.32%-&"#3M$-+&,&F3#+ &1/,>%+&4$6,6<$, %&1?1/+F8 &L0+&6+.&$61/#2F+6/1&.32%-&/#,614+#&#$1P&
F3#+&+44$<$+6/%?&/3 &/ 031+&F31/&.$%%$67&,6-&,>%+&/3&03%-&$/8&\2/&/0+&+F"0,1$1&.,1&36&/0+&<#+,/$36&34&/0+1+&
6+.&$61/# 2F+ 6/1&#,/0+#&/0 ,6&36&/0+&<#+,/$36 &3 4&6+.&F,#P+ /1&,6-&/0+&<36-$/$361&#+a2$#+-&/3&F,P+&/0+&
F, #P+/1&F3#+&+44$<$+6/&,6-&<3F"+/$/$M+8&L0+&"#3-2</&$663M,/$36&/0,/&.,1&+6<32#,7+-&,6-&"#3-2<+-&>?&
<3F"+/$/$36& ,F3671/& 4$6,6<$,%& $6 1/$/2 /$361& .,1& $6 & 7+6+#,%& %$F$/+-& /3& 3M+#:/0+:<326/+#& B]LGD& > $%,/+ #,%&
/#,-$67&3#&/0+&<#+,/$36&34&>+1"3P+&1/#2</2#+-&%+6-$67&M+0$<%+1&/,$%3#+-&/3&/0+&6++-1&34&$6-$M$-2,%&<%$+6/18&
L0+&4$6,6<$,%&$6<+6/$M+1&/3&/ 0+&3#$7$6,/3#1&34&6+.&4$6,6<$,%&"#3-2</1&%+-&/3&,6&+F"0,1$1&36&/0+&1,%+&34&/0+ &
"#3-2</1&/3&/031+&.$%%$67&/3&>+,#&#$1P&B3#&/031+&26,>%+ &/3&#+<376$U+ &$/D&#,/0+#&/0,6&36&/0+&#+-$1/#$>2/$36&
34&#$1P&/3&/031+&F31/&,>%+&/3&>+,#&$/8&
N6& /0+& -+M+%3"F+6/& 34& /0+1+& 6+.& 4$6,6<$,%& "#3-2</1& >,6P1& $6$/$,%%?& "%,?+-& /0+& /#,-$/$36,%& #3%+& 34&
$6/+#F+-$,# ?&>+/.++6&<%$+6 /1&.$/0&3441+//$67&4$6,6<$,%&#+a2$#+F+6/18&\2/&/0+?& +M+6/2,%%?&4326-&/0,/&/0+?&
<32%-& "#34 $/& 4#3F& ,</$67& ,1& "#$6<$",%& $6& /0+1+& /#,-+1X& /,P$67& "31$/$36& .$/0& /0+$#& 3.6& <,"$/,%8 & !1& ,6&
+T,F"%+X&/0+&$6$/$,%&-+M+%3"F+6/&34&$6/+#+1/&#,/+&1.,"1&1,.&>,6P1&>#$67$67&/37+/0+#&0$70+#:<#+-$ /&4$T+-:
#,/+& , 6-& %3.+#:<#+-$ /& 4%3,/$67:#,/+& >3##3.+#1X& "#3M$-$67& #+-2<+-& $6/+#+1/& <31/1& 43#& >3/0& " ,#/$+1& ,6-&
+,# 6$67&,&<3FF$11$36 &4#3F&/0+&1,M $6718&\2/&/0+&4,$%2#+&/3&4$6-&F,/<0$67&<%$+6/1&1336&%+-&>,6P1&/3&344+#&
1.,"1&/3&36+ &<%$ +6/X&., #+0321$6 7&/0+&3/0+ #&1$ -+&34& /0+&/#,-+8&L0$1 &,%%3.+ -&>,6P1&/3&"#3M$-+&344:/0+:10+%4&
$6/+#+1/& #,/+1& 1.,"& 1+#M$<+1& /3& <%$+6/18& bM+6/2,%%?X& /0$1& /+F"3#,#?& 1+#M$<+& .,1& 1++6& /3& "#3M$-+&
3""3#/26$/$+1&43#&/#,-$67&"#34$/1X&,6-&/0+&>,6P1&>+<,F+&" #$6<$ ",%&<326/+#",#/$+1&43#&/0+$#&1.,"&<%$+6/18&
*#3M$1$36&34&<%$+6/&1+#M$<+1&,1&,&F,#P+/: F,P$67&-+,%+#&,6-&"#3"#$+/,#?&/#,-$67&/021&>+<,F +&$6+T3#,>%?&
%$6P+-8&
L0+&#+12%/&34&12<0&$6$/$,%&1.,"&<36/#,</1&.,1&,6&$6<#+,1+&$6&#$1PX&,1&/0+&%+6-+#S1&#$1P&34&#+" ,?F+6/&34&,&
/#,-$/$3 6,%&>, 6P&%3,6&.,1&#+"%,<+-&>?&/0+&#$1P&34&636"+#43#F,6<+&>?&>3/0&/0+&>2?+#&,6-&1+% %+#&34&/0 +&
&
&
9&
1.,"8& R3.+ M+#X& /0$1& $6<#+,1+-& #$1P& .,1 & ,27F+6/+-& .0+6& >,6P1& 10$4/+-& 4#3 F& /0+& #3%+& 34& F+#+ &

$6/+#F+-$,# $+1X&.$ /032/&#$1P&$6&/0+&/#,61,</$36X&/3&/,P$6 7&" #$6<$ ",%&"31$/$368&!6-&#,/0+# & /0,6&%+,-$67&/3&
/0+& -+M+%3"F+6/& 34& 6+.& F,#P+/1& /0,/& .+#+& /#,61", #+6/& ,6-& 1+%4:#+72%,/+-X& /0+& ,</$M$/?& #+F,$6+-&
>$%,/+#,%X& .$/0& $643#F,/ $36& 36%?& ,M,$%,>%+& 4#3F& "+#21,%& 34& /0+& ,77#+7,/+& -,/,& "#+1+6/+-& $6& 4$6,6<$,%&
1/,/+F+6/1&,6-& #+72%,/3#?&4$%$6718 &O31/&4$6,6<$,%&$663M,/$361&43 %%3.+-&/0$1&" ,/0X& %+,-$67&/ 3&,6&$6<#+,1+&$6&
"#3"#$+/,#?&/#,-$67&>?&>,6P1&/3&4,<$%$/,/+&/0+&344+#&34&>$%,/+#,%X&636F,#P +/&/#,61,</$3618&\2/&$6&/0$1&<,1+X&
/0+&F,#P +/1& .+#+& 4,#&4#3F& "+#4+</&3#& 636+T$1/+6/X&$643#F,/$36&4,#&4#3F&42%%X& ,6-& /0+&#+-2</$36& $6&#$1P&
F3#+&/0,6&3441+/&>?&/0+&$6<#+,1+&$ 6&<326/+ #",#/?&#$1 P&,6-&"#$6<$",%&/#,-$67&>?&4$6,6<$,%&$61/$/2/$3618&
O$61P?X&36& /0+&3/0+#&0,6-X&>+%$+M+-&/0,/&#+72%,/$36&<32%-&36%?&>+&-$1<211+-&.$ /0$6&,&/0+3#?&/0,/&,%%3.+-&
43#&4$6,6<$,%&-$1/#+11&,1&,6&+6-37+6321&3<<2##+6<+&$6 &/0+&63#F ,%&-+M+%3"F+6/&34&/0+ &+<363F$<&1?1/+F8&
bM+6&$6&/0+&"#+1+6<+&34&/0+&"+#4+</&3"+#,/$36&34&<3 F"%+/+&F,#P+/1X&O$ 61P?S1&,""#3,<0&1277+1/+-&/0,/&
/0+& 4$6,6<$ ,%& 1?1/+F& .32%-& >+<3F+& $6<#+,1$67%?& +T"31+-& /3& 4$6,6<$,%& -$1#2"/$36& ,6-X& +M+6/2,%%?X& ,&
1?1/+F$ <& >#+ ,P-3.6& $6& /0+& 43#F& 34& ,& 4$6,6<$,% & <#$1 $18& N/& .,1& /3& 4$%%& /0$1& 7,"& $6& +T$1/$67& /0+3#?& /0,/& 0+&
-+M+%3"+-& / 0+& 4$ 6,6<$,%& $61/,>$%$/?& 0?"3/0+1$1X& /3& "#3M$-+& ,& 4 #,F+.3#P& 43#& -$1<211$67& #+72%,/$36& /0,/&
F$70/& "#3M$-+& ,& F 3#+& 1/,>%+X& ,6-& F3#+& +a2$/,>%+X& 4$6,6<$,%& 1?1/+F8& Q+1"$/+& /0+& 43#F2%,/$36& 34& /0 $1&
,""#3,<0&$6&/0+&)eK(1&,6-&$ /1&<36/$62+-&, -,"/,/$36&,6-&,-^21/F +6/&/3&+M3%M$67&<36-$/$361&$6&4$6,6<$,%&
F, #P+/1X&$/&0,1&6+M+#&>++6&21+-&,1&/0+&>,1$1&43#&#+72%,/$36&34&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&1?1/+F8&A3. &/0,/&/0+&#+<+6/&
4$6,6<$,%& F+%/-3.6& 0,1& >++6& -2>>+-& ,& YO$61P?& F3F+6/XZ& "+#0,"1& $/& $1& / $F+& /3& #+<376$U+& /0,/& /0+&
7#+,/+1/&<36/#$>2/$36&34&0$1&/0+3#?&$1&"#3M$1$36& 34&,&>,1$1&43#&/0+&43#F2%,/$36&34&4$6,6<$,%&#+72%, /$368&
A.!Changes!to!the!re gulatory! structure!before!the!crisis!!
]6+&34&/0 +&F31/&$F"3#/,6/&<3 61+a2+6<+1&34&/0+&,""%$<,/$36&34&F ,$61/#+,F&7+6 +#,%&+a2$%$>#$2F&/0+3#?&
,1&/0+&4#,F+.3#P&43#&4$6,6<$,%&#+72%,/$36&.,1&/0+&-+<$1$36&/3&#+"%,<+&/0+&@%,11:=/+,7,%%&%+7$1%,/$36&.$/0&
/0+&5$6,6<$,%&=+#M$<+1&O3-+#6$U,/$36&!</&,/&/0+&+ 6-&34&)eee8&L0+&@#,FF:E+,<0:\%$%+?&B@ E\D&!</X&,1&$/S1&
<3FF36%?&P63.6X&,>3%$10+-&/0+&1+7#+7,/$36 &34&4$6,6<$,%&$61/$/2/$361&>?&4$6, 6<$,%&,</$M$/ ?&/0,/&0,- &>++6&
$F"31+-& 26-+#& @%,11:=/+,7,%%& ,6-& $61/+,-& ,%%3.+-& 43#& /0+& <# +,/$36& 34& $6/+7#,/+-& 4$6,6 <$,%& 03%-$67&
<3F",6$+1&/0,/&<32%-&"#3M$-+&,6?&<3F>$6,/$36&34&4$6,6<$,%&1+#M$<+18&L0$1&.,1&/0+&<2%F$6,/$36&34&,&%367:
/+#F&$6$/$,/$M+&3#<0+1/#,/+-&>?&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&1+#M$<+1&$6-21/#?&/3&#+"+,%&/0+&A+.&Q+,%&%+7$1 %,/$368&N/&.,1&
>,1+-&36&/0+ &,#72F+6 /&/0,/&/0+#+&.+#+&12>1/,6/$,%&+<363F$ +1&/3&>+&,<0$+M +-&>?&<#311:1,%+1&34&4$6,6<$,%&
1+#M$<+1& ,6-& /0+& #+12%/$67& "311$>$%$/?& /3& $6<#+,1+ & /0+& $6/+#6,%& <#311:0+-7$67& 34& #$1P1& .$/0$ 6& %,#7+&
F2%/$42 6</$36& 4$6,6<$,%& <367%3F+#,/+18& N/& .,1& <%,$F+-& / 0,/& /0+& 1?F>$31$1& , <#311& -$44+#+6/ & 4$6,6<$,% &
1+#M$<+1&.32%-&$6<# +,1+ &$6<3F+ 1&43 #&4$6,6<$,%&1 +#M$<+&"#3M$-+#1&,1&.+%%&,1&-+<#+,1+&/0+&#$1P1&>3#6+ &>?&/0+&

%,#7+#&$61/$/2/$3618&&
N6& , $/$36X& $/& . ,1& ,#72+-& /0,/& 63& 3/0+#& <326/#?& 0,-& %+7$ 1%,/$36& 1$F$%,#& /3& @%,11:=/+,7,%%X& ,6 -& 43#+$76&
$61/$/2/$361& .+#+& 7+6+#,%%?& ,%%3.+-& F2%/$426</$36& 4$6,6<$,%& $61/$/2/$3618& L021X& /0+& 6+.& %+7$1%,/$36& ., 1&
#+a2$#+-&/3&,%%3.&W=&$6 1/$/2 /$361&/3&<3F"+/+&36&,&%+M+%X&7%3>,%&"% ,?$67&4$ +%-8&L0$1&,#72F+6/&.,1&1"+<$ 321X&
1$6<+& W=& #+72%,/$361& -$-& 63/ & ," "%?& /3& W=& $61/$/2/$361S& 7%3>,%& 3"+#,/$361X& ,6-& 43#+$76& $61/$/2/$361&
3"+#,/$67&$6&/0+&W6$/+-&= /,/+1&.+#+&$6&7+6+#,%&12>^+</&/3&W=&#+72%,/$3618&
&
&
e&
L0+& $6/#3-2 </$36& 34& $6/+7#,/+ -& F2%/$426</$36& 4$6,6 <$,%& 1+#M$ <+& <3#"3#,/$361& 0,-& /.3& $F"3 #/,6/&
<361+a2+6<+18& 5 $#1/X& $/& $F"%$+-& /0,/& 4 $6,6 <$,%& 03%-$671& <3F",6$+1& .32%-& >+& F2<0& %,#7+#& /0,6& +$/0+#&
<3FF+ #<$,%&-+"31$/:/,P$67& >,6P1&3#&636$612#+-&$6M+1/F+6/&>,6P1&0,-&>++6&$6&/0+&",1/X&1$6<+&+T",61$36&
.32%-&63/&>+&%$F$/+-&/3& /0+&"#3M$1$36&34&,6?&",#/$<2%,#&1+#M$<+&,1&0,-&>++6&/0+&<,1+&26-+#&@%,11:=/+,7,%%8&
N6&/0+&<,1+&34&$6M+1/F+6 /&>,6P1X&1$U +&0,-&>++6&<361/#,$6+-&>?&/0+&"#30$ >$/$36&36&#,$1$67&<3#+&-+" 31$/1&
,6-&/0+$#&",#/6+#1 0$"&1/#2</2#+8&L0+&%,//+#&<361/#,$6/&.,1&#+F3 M+-&.0+6&$6M+1/F+ 6/&>,6P 1&<36M+#/+-&/3&
%$F$/+-:%$,>$%$/?& "2>%$<& <3F",6$+1& /3& #,$1+& <,"$/,%& $6& +a2$/ ?& F,#P+/18& W6/$%& /0+& -+#+72%,/$36& 34& <,"$/ ,%&
F, #P+/1& /0+& )eI(1X& /0+& Aj=b& 43# >,-+& 12<0& %$1/$67c& /0+& F3M+& .,1& $6$/$,/+-& >?& /0+ & > #3P+#,7+& 4$ #F&
Q36,%-136X&E24P$6&k&l+6#+//+X&/3&>+&43%% 3.+-&$6&/0 +&)e9(1&>?&/ 0+&%,#7+#&$6M+1/F+6/&>,6P1X&/0 +&%,1/&>+$67&
@3%-F,6&=,<01X&$6&"#+", #,/$36&43#&/0+&#+"+,%&34&@%,11:=/+,7 ,%%&$6&)ee98&
=+<36-X&/0+&+<363F$+1& 34&1<,%+&,6-&#$1P&#+-2</$36&/0,/&#+12%/+-&4#3F&$6/+#6,%&<#311:0+-7$67&34&"3 1$/$361&
F+ ,6/&/0,/&#$1P&.,1&F3#+&>#3,-%?&1" #+,- &,<#311&-$44+#+6/&,</$M$/$+1X&,6-&/021&$6<#+,1+-&/0+&<3##+%,/$36&
34&#$1P1&, <#311&-$ 44+#+6/&,</$M $/$+18&R3.+M+#X&,1&# +"3#/+-&>?&/0+&=+6$3#&=2"+#M$13#1&@#32"X
'
&+M+6&$4&/0$1&
-$-&3<<2#X&$/&,""+ ,#1&/0,/&/0+#+&.,1&M+#?&%$//%+&10,#$ 67&34&$643#F,/$36&<36<+#6$67&+T"312#+1&$6&-$44+ #+6/&
426</$361&34&/0+&<367%3F+#,/+&4$6,6<$,%&$61/$/2/$361[.0,/&0,1&<3F+&/3&>+&<,%%+-&/0+&Y1$%3 Z&F+6/,%$/?&34&
4$6,6<$,%&F,6,7+F+6/X&$6&.0$<0&$643#F,/$36&#+F,$61&$13%,/+-&$6&+,<0&1+",#,/+&,</$M$/?&34&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&
$61/$/2/$368& L0+& #+12%/& 34& <#311:0 +-7$67& ,6-& "#3-2</& $6/+ 7#,/$ 36& .,1& /0+& <#+,/$36& 34& 4$6,6<$,%&
<367%3F+#, /+1&/0,/&.+#+&>3/0&/33&>$7&,6-&/33&$6/+7#,/+-&/3&,%%3.&,6?&34&/0+F&/3&>+& #+13%M+-&.0+6&/0+?&
>+<,F+&$613%M+6/8&N6-++-X&#,/0+#&/0,6&-$1/#$>2/$6 7&# $1P&/3&/031+&F31/&,>%+&/3 &>+,#&$/X&#$1P&.,1&-$1/ #$>2/+-&

,6-&#+-$1 /#$>2/+-&26/$%&$/&>+<,F+&$F"311$>%+&/3&%3<,/+&.03&.,1&$6&4,</&/0+&<326/+#" ,#/?&#+1"361$>%+&43#&
>+,#$67 & /0+& #$1P8& G326/+#",#/?& #$1P& / 021& ^3$6+-&/0 +&F3#+& /#,-$/$36, %&426-$67m%$a2$-$/?&,6-&$6/+#+1/&#,/+&
#$1P1&4,<$67&4$6,6<$,%&$61/$/2/$3618&N/&#+"%,<+-&.0,/&.,1&$6$/$,%%?&/0 +&F31/&$F"3#/,6/&34&>,6P&#$1P1_&%+6-$67 &
3#&<#+-$/&#$1P8&
R3.+M+#X& %,#7+& 1$U+& -3+1& 0,M+& 36+& 26-+6$,>%+& >+6+ 4$/X& 7$M+6& /0,/& +M+6& #+72%,/3#1 & ,-F$/& /0,/& 12<0&
$61/$/2/$361&.$%%&63 /&>+&,%%3.+-&/3&4,$%8&]6&/0+&36+ &0,6-X&/0#3270&/0+&3"+ #,/$36&34&F3#,%&0,U,#-&$/&,%%3.1&
/0+& 21+& 34& #$1P$+#X& 0$70+#:#+/ 2#6& $6M+1/F+6/1 X& >3%1/+#$67& / 0+& /3":%$6+& +,#6$671c & ,/& /0+& 1,F+& /$ F+X& /0+ &
$F"%$<$/& 72,#,6/++& 34& 7 3M+#6F+ 6/& 12""3#/& F+,61& /0,/& >3##3.$67& <31/1& .$% %& >+ & %3 .+#X& >3%1/+#$67& /0+&
>3//3F & %$6+8&=F,%%+#&>,6P 1&.$%%&/021&4$6-&$/& F3#+& -$44$<2%/&/3&<3F"+/+X&,6-&/0+&#+12%/$ 67&<36<+6/#,/$36&
F, ?& ,%%3.& %,#7+#& >,6P1& /3& $F"31+& 0$70+#& <0,#7+1& 43#& <21/3F+#& 1 +#M$<+18& N6& O$61P?S1& 21+& 34& i+?6+1S1&
/+#F$63%37?X& >3/0& >3##3.+#1S& , 6-& %+ 6-+#1S& #$1P1& ,#+& #+-2<+-& 43#& %,#7+& < 367%3F+ #,/+& >,6P 1X& ,6-& /0+?&
0,M+&$6<#+,1+-&F363"3%?&"3.+#&3M+#&"#$<+18&L0$1&F,?&>+&/0+&#+,%&<,21+&34&/0+&4,M3#,>%+&"+#43#F,6<+&34&
%,#7+&>,6P&7#32"18&\2/&/0$1&$1&63/&/0+&#+12% /&34&/0+&+44$<$+6<?&34&%,#7+&>,6P1c &$/&$1&$6&#+ ,%$/?&,&73 M+#6F+6 /&
12>1$-? &/0,/&<,6&36%?&>+&.$/0-#,.6&.$/0&-$44$<2%/?8&
L0+& $F"+/21& 43#& %,# 7+& 1$U+& .,1& ,%13& /0+& #+12% /& 34& ,& <0,67+& $6& /0+& $61/#2F+6/1& 34& F36+/,#?& "3%$<?&
$6/#3-2 <+-& >?& /0+& 7%3>,%$U,/$36& 34& /0+& F,#P+/& 43#& "#3M $1$36&34& 4$6,6<$,%&1+#M$<+ 18& N6&/0 +&W6$/+-&=/,/+1X&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
'
&L0+&=+6$3#&=2"+#M$13#1&@#32"&.,1&43#F+-&/3&,11+11&03.&.+,P6+11+1&$6&#$1P&F,6,7+F+6/&,6-&$6 /+#6,%&<36/#3%1&
<36/#$>2/ +-&/3&$6-21/#?&-$ 1/#+11&-2#$67&/0+ &4$6,6<$,%&<#$1$1X&,6-&<3F"#$ 1+-&1+6$3#&12"+# M$13#1 &4#3F&1+M+6&4$6,6<$,%&
,7+6<$+1_&/0+&5#+6<0&\,6P$67&G 3FF$11$36 X&@+#F,6&5+-+#,%&5$6,6<$,%&=2"+#M$13#?&!2/03#$/? X&=.$11&5+-+#,%&\ ,6P$6 7&
G3FF$11$36X&Wi&5$6,6<$,%&=+#M$<+1&! 2/03# $/?X&,6-X&$6&/0+&W6$/+- &=/,/+ 1X&/0+&]44$<+&34&/0+&G3F"/#3%%+#&34&/0+&
G2##+6<?X&/0+&=+<2#$/$+1&,6-&bT<0,67+&G3FF$11$36X&,6-&/0+&5+-+#,%&C+1+#M+8&53#&/0+$ #&^3$6/&#+M$+.X&1++&==@&'((98&&
&
&
)(&
*,2%&n3%<P+#&0,-&$6/#3-2<+-&<36/#3%&3 4&/0+&F36+?&12""%?&,6-&,//+F"/+-&/3&$6/#3 -2<+&<,"$/,%&#,/$31&/3&
#+-2<+&>,6P&%+6-$67&$6&,6&+443#/&/3&1/3"&$6 4%,/$368&E,#7+%?&,1&,&#+ 12%/&3 4&n3%<P+#S1&"3%$<?&F3 M+1X&W=&>,6P1&
10$4/+-&13F+&%$,>$%$/?&3"+#,/$361&/3&/0+&b2#3"+,6&+2#3: -3%%,#&F,#P+/&/3&#+-2<+&/0+&<31/&34&426-$67&/0+$#&
%+6 -$678&L0$1 &%+-&/3&/0+&7%3>,%$U,/$36&34&W=&> ,6P$67X&.0$<0&2"&/3&/0,/&"3$6/&0,-&>++6&%,#7+%?&-3F+1/ $<8&

]6<+&$6&/0+&7%3>,%&F,#P+ /1X&/0+?&F+/&7 %3>, %&<3F"+/ $/$36X&$6&",#/$<2%,#X&4#3F&l,",6+1+&>,6P18&&
!4/+#&/0+&<3%%,"1+&34&/0+&R+#1/,//&\, 6P&$6&@+#F,6?&,1&/0+&#+12 %/&34&4,$%$67&/3&<3F"%+/+&,6&$6/+#6,/$36,%&
/#,614+#& /3& W=& >,6P1X& .0$<0& 12>1+a2+6/%?& <,21+-& /0+F& %311+1X& $/& >+<,F+& <%+,#& /0,/& ,%%& >,6P1& .+#+&
$6/+#%$6P+-& ,6-& 6++-+-& 13 F+& 43#F& 34& <3FF36& #+72%,/$368& L0+& \,1+%& G3 FF$//++& /021& "#3"31+-& /0+&
$6/#3-2 </$36&34&7%3>,%&#2%+1&43#&#$1P:,-^21/+-&<,"$/,%&,-+a2,<?&#,/$318&W"&/3&/0,/&/$F+X&F36+/,#?&"3%$<?&
0,-& >++6& "#$F,#$%?& $F"%+F+6/+-& /0#3270& ,-^21 /F+6/& 34& #+1+#M+& #,/$31X& ,6-& /0+6X& F3#+& +T<%21$M+%?X&
/0#3270&3"+6& F,#P+/& 3"+#,/$3618& V0$% +& /0+& <,"$/,%& #,/$31&.+#+& F+,6/& /3& F,P+&#$1P$+#& ,</$ M$/$+1&F3#+&
+T"+61$M+ &/3&426-X&,6-&/021&%+11&"#34$/,>%+&,6-&%+11&,//#,</$M+X&/0+?&0,-&,&#,/0+#&"+#M+#1+&#+12%/8&5$#1/X&
/0$1&+6<32#,7+-&>,6 P1&/3&+T",6-&/0+$#&,</ $M$/$+1&$6&/0+& #$1P$+1/X&0$70+1/:#+/2# 6&,</$M$/$ +1&$6&+,< 0&", #/$<2%,#&
#$1P&<,/+73#?8&=+<36-X&$/&+6<32 #,7+-&>,6P1&/ 3&F3M+&,1&F2<0&,1&"311$>%+&34&/0+$# & % +6-$ 67&/0,/&0,-& /0+&
0$70+1/&#$1P&.+$70&344&/0+$#&>,%,6<+&10++/1&,6-&$6/3&1"+<$,%:"2#"31+&M+0$<%+1&B=*n1D&/0,/&%,#7+ %?&+1<,"+-&
#+72%,/$36& ,6-& #+"3# /$678 & L0$1& <#+,/+-& , & 6+.& /?"+& 34&<326/+#",#/?&#$1 PX&,6-&1$6<+& /0+&<#+-$/1&.+#+& 6 3&
%367+#&43#F,%%?&/0+&#+1"361$>$%$/?&34&/0+&>,6PX&$/&/#,614+## +-&<#+-$/&#$1P1&/3&/0+&=*n1&.0$%+&,%13&#+F3M$67&
/0+&$6<+6/$M+1&/3&,"" %?&<#+-$/.3#/0$6+11&,6,%?1$ 1&34&/0+&%3,61&/0,/&.+#+&F,-+&,6-&/0+&1+<2#$/$+1&/3&>+&
13%-& /3& /0+& 344:>,%,6<+:10++/& +6/$/?8& R3.+M+#X& .0+6& /0+& <#$1$1& 0$/X& /0+& #$1P 1& <,F +& >,<P& /3& /0+& >,6P1X&
/0#3270&,&M,#$+/?&34&#32/+18&
!1&,&#+12%/&34&$6< #+,1+-&7%3>,%$U,/$36X&#+72%,/3#1& .+#+&<3 6<+#6+-&63/ &36%?&.$/0&/0+&1,4+/?&,6-&132 6-6+11&
34& 4$6,6<$,%& $61/$/2/$361& >2/& ,%13& .$/0& /0+& ,>$%$/?& 34& W=& >,6P1& /3& <3F"+/+& 36& ,& 7%3>,%& 1<,%+8& N6& /0+&
$6/+#6,/$36,%&#+72%,/3# ?&+6M$#36F+6/X& @%,11:=/+,7,%%& .,1&,6&,63F,%?X&,6-&$6& F,6?& <326/#$+1& 26$M+#1,%&
>,6P$67[,%%3.$67&>,6P1&/3&+67,7+&$6&,%%&/?"+1&34&4$6,6<$,%&1+#M$<+1 [.,1&/0+&63#F8&L021X&$6&<36-$ /$361&
34& #$1$67& W=& +T/+#6,%& ,<<326/& -+4$<$/1X& 12"" 3#/$67& 7%3>,%& +T", 61$36& 34& W=& >,6P1& >+<,F+& ,6& , $/$36,%&
3>^+</$M+&34&#+72%,/$3 68&N6-++-X&/0+&#+"3#/&"#3-2<+-&>?&W=&L#+,12#?&=+<#+/,#?&*,2%136&>+43#+&/0+&<#$1$1&
-+,%/&"#$F, #$%?&.$/0&/0+&<0,67+1&$6&#+72%,/$361 &#+a2$#+-&/3&+612#+&/0+&<3F"+/$/ $M+6+11&34&W=&F, #P+/1&$6&
/#,-$67& 7%3>,% & 1+<2#$ /$+1& ,6-& /0+& <3F"+/$/$M+6+11& 34& W=& >,6P1& $6& <3F"+/$67 & $6& $6 /+#6,/$36,%& F,#P+/1&
BW=QL& '((9D8&L0$1& .,1& 1$F"%?&,6&+T/+61$36& 34&/0+&"31$/$36& 12""3#/+-&>?&W=& L#+,12#?& W6-+#&=+<#+/, #?&
E,.#+6<+&=2FF+#1& /0,/& ,#72+-&$6&4,M3#&34& 3"+6& +6/#? & 43#& W=&4$6,6<$,%& 1+#M$<+1& " #3M$-+#1& $6/3& 43#+$76&
F, #P+/1X&#,/0+#&/ 0,6&43#&4#++&$6/+#6,/$36,%&<,"$/,%&4%3.18&&
B.!Reform!in!the!aftermath!of!the!crisis:!The!D odd‐Frank!Act!
L0+&<2##+6/& , ""#3,<0& /3&#+ 72%,/$36& +F> 3-$+-&$6& /0+& Q3 :5#,6P&%+7$1%,/$36& <36/$62+1 & /3&>+& >,1+-&36&
/0+& F,$61/#+,F& /0+3#+/$< ,%& 4#,F+.3#P& /0,/& 1++1& 1/,>$%$/?& $6& <3F"%+/+& F,#P +/1& ,6-& 1?6+#7?& $6& /0+&

"#3M$1$36&,6-&0+-7$67&34&4$6,6< $,%&1+#M$<+18
;
&N/&/021&,<<+ "/1&/0,/&W=&>,6P1&.$%%&<36/$62+&/3&>+&%,#7 +&,6-&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
;
&C+2/+#1&B'())D&63/+ 1&/0,/ &Y<#311:1+%% $67&>+/.++6&\,6P&34&!F+#$<,&,6-&O+##$%%&E? 6<0X&13F+/ 0$67&/0,/&F,6?&
/03270/&.32%-&>+&-$44$<2% /Z&$F"#3M+-&$6&'()(c& Y/0+&.+,%/0&F,6,7+F+6/&-$M$1$36X&F, $6%?&O+##$%%&E?6<0&,6-&W=&
L#21/X&/33P&$6&F3#+&/0,6&HX;((&#+4+##,%1&4#3F&3/0+#&-$M$1$361&,/&\,6P&34&!F+#$<,X&F3#+&/0,6&/0#++&/$F+1&/0+&
#+4+ ##,%1&$6&'(( e8&L0+&.+,%/0&F,6,7+F+6/&26$/&,%13&#+4+##+-&F3#+&/0,6&9X( ((&<%$+6/1&/3&/0+&<3FF+#<$,%&,6-&
&
&
))&
$6/+7#,/+-8& N6-++-X& L#+ ,12#?& =+<#+/,#?& @+$/06+#& 0,1& 12""3#/+-& /0+& M$+.& /0,/& /0+& <2 ##+6/& 1$U+& 34& W=&
>,6P1X& .0$<0&0,1&$6<#+,1+-& 12>1/,6/$,%%?& ,1&,& #+12%/&34 & /0+& #+13%2/$3 61& 26-+#/,P+6&-2#$67&/0+&<#$1$1X& $ 1&
-+1$#+-& ,6-& +M+6& 6+<+11,#?& $4& /0+?& ,#+& /3& <3F"+/+ & $6& 7%3>,%& F,#P+/18& !<<3#-$67& /3& ,& New* Republic&
$6/+#M$+.+#X & @+$/06+#& Y/3%-& F+& 0+& 12>1<#$>+1& /3& /0+& M$+.& /0,/& /0+& .3#%-& $1& 36& /0+& <21"& 34& ,& F,^3#&
`4$6,6<$ ,%& -++"+6$67 S_& !1 & -+M+%3 "$67& +<363F$+1& $6& /0+& F31/& "3"2%321& <326/#$+1& F,/2 #+X& /0+?& .$%%&
-+F,6-&F3#+&,6-&$6<#+,1$67%?&13"0$1/$<,/+-&4$6,6<$,%&1+#M$<+1X&/0+&1,F+&.,?&/ 0+?&-+F,6-&<, #1&43#&/ 0+$#&
7#3 .$67&F$- -%+&<%,11+1&,6-&$643#F,/$36&/+<063%37?&43#&/0+$#&<3 #"3#,/$3618&N4&/0,/S1&/#2+X&/0+6&.+&1032%-&
.,6/&W=&>,6P1&"31$/$36 +-&/3&<3F"+/+&,>#3,-8&8&8&8&`N&-36S/&0,M +&,6?&+6/021$,1F&43#&8&8&8&/#?$67&/3&10#$6P&
/0+&#+%,/$M+&$F"3#/,6<+&34&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&1?1/+F&$6&32#&+<363F?&,1&,&/+1/&34&#+43#F X&>+<,21+&.+&0,M+&/3&
/0$6P&,>32/&/0+ &4,</&/0,/&.+&3"+#, /+&$6&/0+&>#3,-+#&.3 #%-XS&0+&1,$-Z&B=<0+$>+#&'())D8&@+$/06+#&. +6/&36_&
YA3.&4$6,6<$,%&4$#F1&,#+&-$44+#+6/&>+<,21+&34&/0+&#$1PX&>2/&?32&<,6&<36/,$6&/0,/ &/0#3270&#+72%,/$368Z&L0$1&
.,1&/0+&"2#"31+&34&/0+&#+<+6/&4$6,6<$,%&#+4 3#FX&0+&1,$-8
J
&
L021X& /0+& >,1$<& /0+3#+/$<,%& ,#72F+ 6/& /0,/& %,#7+X& $6/+7#, /+-& 4$6,6<$,%& $61/$/2/$36 1& <#+,/+& 1?6+#7?& $6&
"#3M$-$67&,&>#3,-&#,67+&34&4 $6,6 <$,%&1+#M$<+1&,6-&#+-2<+&#$1P&>?&"33%$67&$1&F ,$6/,$6+-&>?&/031+&.03&,#+&
F31/&$64%2+6/$,%&$6&Y#+43#FXZ&.0$%+&/0+&-$44$<2%/ $+1&/0+1+&$61/$/2 /$361&<,21+-&$6&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&<#$1$1&.$%%&>+&
F, 6,7+-&>?&>+//+#&#+72%,/$36&,6-&"#3M$1$361&/3&+612#+&/0,/&$4&/0+?&-3&<3%%,"1+X&/0+?&.$%%&>+&,%%3.+ -&/3&

4,$%& .$/032/& #+a2$#$67& 1 2""3#/& 4#3F& "2>%$ <& 426- 18& L0+& /.3& F,^3#& "$%%,#1& 34& /0+& #+43# F& ",<P,7+& ,#+&
#+72%,/$361& /3& >+//+#& F,6,7+& /0+& #$1P1& 26-+#/,P +6& >?& %,#7+X& Y1?1/+F$<,%%?& 1$76$4$<,6/Z& 4$6,6<$,%&
$61/$/2/$361X&,6-&/0+&F+,61&/3&43#<+&/0+F& $6/3&>,6P#2"/<?&%$a2$-,/ $36&.$/032/&/0+ &6++-&4 3#&,6?/0$67&>2/&
/+F"3#,#?&"2>%$< & ,11$1/,6<+8&L0+& " #3>%+F1& 4,<+- & $ 6&/0+&%,1/&<#$1$1&,#+ & 63/&1+ +6&/3& #+12%/&4#3F& /0+&1$U+&
,6-& $6 /+7#,/$36& 34& F 2%/$426</$36& $61 /$/2/$361X& >2/& /0+& ,>1+6<+& 34& ,& F+<0,6$1F& /3& ,%%3.& ,%%& >,6P& ,6-&
636>,6P&4$6,6<$,%&$61/$/2/$361&/3 &4,$ %&.$/032/&"2>%$<&,11$1 /,6<+8&L021X&>,6P1&.$%%&>+&,%%3.+-&/3&426< /$36&
F3#+&3#&%+11&,1&>+43#+&/0+&<#$1$1X&.$/0$ 6&4$6,6<$,%&03%-$67&<3F",6$+1X&>2/&/3&>+&12>^+</&/3&<%+,#&#2%+1&36&
/0+$#&#,"$-&-$113 %2/$36&#,/0+#& /0,6&/0+$#&#+13%2/$368&&
O$61P?X& 36& /0+& 3/0+#& 0,6- X& >,1$67& 0$1& M$+.1& 36& ,& / 0+3#?& /0,/& 1,?1& 4$6,6<$,%& -$1#2"/$3 6& $1& ,& 6,/2#,%&
<361+a2+6<+& 34& /0+& 3"+#,/$36& 34& /0+& 1?1 /+FX & .32%-& 0,M+& ,#72+-& /0,/& $/& $1& $F"311$>%+& /3& 43#F2%,/+&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
>,6 P$67&,6-&F,#P+/1&-$M$1$361X&,&I)&"+#<+6/&$6<#+,1+&3M+#&'((e8Z&A3/+&/0,/&/0$1&# +4+#1&"#$F,#$%?&/3&F,#P+/$67&
#,/0+#&/0,6&<31/&+44$<$+6<?&$6&"#3M$1$36&34& 1+#M$<+1&3#&$6&#$1P&F,6 ,7+F+6/8&
J
&L0+&$6/+#M$+.& <36/$62+-_&YN&,1P+-&@+$/06+#&$4&0+&0,-&,&7#,6-&M$1$36&43#&/0+ &"31/:<#$1$1&%,6-1<,"+[43#X&1,?X&,&%+11&
>%3,/+-&4$6,6< $,%&1+</3#&.$/0&,&1F,%%+#&#3%+&$6&/0+&+<363F?[,6-&,&F,"&43 #&03.&/3&7+/&/0+#+8&G3 2%-&0+&>+&,&4$72# +&
%$P+&@+3#7+&O,#10,%%X&.03&0+%" +-&.$6&/0+&V3#%-&V,#&,6-&/0+6&#+F,-+&b2#3"+&13&/0,/&$/&<32%-6S/&0,""+6&,7,$6o&
&&&&Y@+$/06+#&026<0+-&0$1&1032%-+#1X&"#+11 +-&0$1&P6++1&/37+/0+#X &,6-&% $4/+-&0$1&0++%1&2"&344&/0+&7#326-[,6&,%F31 /&
<0$%-%$P+&+T"#+11$36& 34&7%+ +8&`V+S#+&73$67X&%$P+X&+T$1/+6/$,%XS&0+&1, $-8&R+&/3%-&F+&0+&12>1<#$>+1&/3&/0+&M$+.&/0,/&/0+&
.3#%-&$1&36&/0+&<21"&34&,& F,^3#&`4$6,6<$,%&-++"+6$67S_&!1&-+M+%3"$67&+<363F$+1&$6&/0+&F31/&"3"2%321&<326/#$+1&
F,/ 2#+X&/0+?&.$%%&-+F,6- &F3#+&,6-& $6<#+,1$67%?&13"0$1/$<,/+-&4$6,6<$,%&1+#M$<+1X&/0+&1,F+&.,?&/0+?&-+F,6-&<,#1&
43#&/0+$#&7#3.$67&F$ %+&<%,11+1&,6-&$643#F,/$36&/+<063%37?&43#&/0+$#&<3#"3#,/$3618&N4&/0,/S1&/#2+X&/0+6&.+&1032%-&
.,6/&W8=8&>,6P1&"31$/$36+-&/3&<3F"+/+&,>#3,-8&
&&&&YSN&-36 S/&0,M +&,6?&+6/021$,1F&43#&8&8&8&/#?$67&/3&10#$6P&/0+&#+%,/$M+&$F"3#/,6<+&34&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&1?1/+F&$6&32#&
+<363F? &,1&,&/+1/&34&#+43#FX&>+<,21+&.+&0,M+&/ 3&/0$6P&,>32/&/0 +&4,</ &/0,/&.+&3"+#,/+ &$6&/0+&>#3,-+#&.3#%-X S&0+&
1,$-8&`N/S1&/0+&1,F+&/0$67&4 3#&O$<#3134/&3#&,6?/0$ 67&+%1+8&V+&.,6 /&W8=8&4$#F1 &/3&>+6+4$/&4#3F&/0,/8S &R+&<36/$62+-_&
`A3.&4$6,6<$,%&4$#F1&,#+&- $44+#+6/&>+<,21+&34&/0+&#$1PX&>2/&?32&<,6&<36/,$6&/0,/&/0#327 0&#+72%,/$368Z&L0$1&.,1&/0+&
"2#"31+&34&/0+&#+<+6/&4$6,6<$,% &#+43#FX&0+&1,$-8 &N6&+44+</X&@+$/06+#&.,1&,#72$67&/0,/&.+&1032%-&>+&,1&<3F43#/,>%+&
%$6P$67&/0 +&4,/+&34&32#&+<363F?&/3&V,%%&=/ #++/&, 1&/3&,2/3F,P+#1&3#&=$%$<36&n,%%+?8SZ&
&

&
)'&
#+72%,/$361&/0,/&.32%-&+612#+&/0+&,>1+6<+&34&4$6,6<$,%&-$1#2"/$368&C+72%,/3#1 &1032%-&/021&>+&<36<+#6+-X&
63/&36%?&>?&/0+&1$U+&34&>,6P1X&>2/&,%1 3&>?&/0+$#&3"+#,/$36 1&,1&F2%/$426</$36&4$6,6<$,%&1+#M$<+&"#3M$-+#18&
5$6 ,6<$,%& $663M, /$36& .$%%& ,%.,?1& >+& -#$M+6& >?& #+72%,/3#?& ,#>$/#,7+X& ,6-& ,1& ,& #+12%/& /0+#+& <,6& >+& 63&
,112#,6<+& /0,/& #+72% ,/$361&<,6&F,P+& %,#7+& 4$6,6<$,%& $61/$/2/$361& 1 ,4+& 4#3F & <#$1$18&N6-++-X&/0+&M+#?& $-+,&
/0,/&%,#7+& >,6P1&.$%%& >+&,%%3.+-& /3&4, $%&F+,61&/0,/&>,6P1& .$%%& <36/$62+& /3& >+<3F+& +M+#& %,#7+#&1$6<+& ,&
>,6P&/0,/&$1&#+13%M+- &3#&.326-&2"&.$%%&0,M+&/3&0,M+&$/1&$612#+-& %$,>$ %$/$+1&,>13#>+-&>?&,6&+T$1/$67&>,6P&3#&
#+<361/$/2/+-&26-+#&6+.&F,6,7+F+6/&M$,&,&>#$-7+&>,6P8&N6&+$/0+#&<,1 +X&>,6P1&.$%%&<36/$62+&/3&7#3.&$6&
1$U+8&L0+&>+1/&+T,F"%+&34&/0$1&$1&/0+&7#3./0&$6&/0+ &1$U+&34&/0+&%,#7 +1/&>,6P1&,1 &,&#+12%/&34&/0+&#+13%2/$36&34&
4,$%+-& >,6P1&$6& /0+& #+<+6 /&<#$1$18& L0+& ,61.+#& /3&O$61P?S1&#0+/3#$<,%& a2+1/$36X & YG,6&`N/S& 0,""+6& , 7,$6oZ&
.32%-&36<+&,7,$6&>+&$6&/0+&,44$#F,/$M+8&
5$6 ,%%?X& /0+& ,""#3,<0& /3& #+43#F& <36/$62+1& /3& 12""3#/& /0+& $-+,& /0,/& F,#P+/1 & "#3M$-+& +44$<$+6/& "#$<+&
-$1<3M+ #?8&L0$1&$1&/0+&<,1 +&63/&36%?&43#&/0+&"#$<$67&34&4$6,6<$,%&,11+/1X&>2/&,%13&43#&<3F"+ 61,/$368&V 0$%+&
F, 6?&+<363F$1/1&0,M+&63/+-&/0+ &-$1/3#/+-&$6<+6/$M+ &1/#2< /2#+&-+/+#F$6$67&<3F"+61,/$36&43#&/#, -+#1&,1&
.+%%&,1&F,6,7+F+6/X&/0+ &#+1"36 1+&0,1&>++ 6&#+1/#$</+-&/3&"#3"31,%1&/3&$6/#3-2<+&%$F$/1&36 &/0+&1$U+&,6-&
43#F& 34& <3F"+61,/$368& N/& 0,1& 63/& 7+6+#,%%?& >++6& #+<376$U+-& /0,/& /0+1+& -$1/3#/+-& $6<+6/$M+1& ,#+ & /0+&
#+12%/&34&1/#2</2#,%&4,</3#1&%$ 6P+-&/3&/0+ &10$4/&$6&/0+&>21$6+11&F3-+%&+F"%3?+-&>?&4$6,6<$,%&$61/$/2/$3618&
L0+&10$4/ &$6&/0+&7+6+#,/$3 6&34&>,6P&"#34$/1&4#3F &6+/&$6/+#+1/&$6<3F+&7+6+#,/+-&>?&3#$7$ 6,/$67&%3,61&,6-&
+612#$6 7& /0,/& /0+?& -3& 63/& -+4, 2%/X& /3& /0+& 7+6+#,/$36& 34& "#34$/1& 4#3F& 4++1X & <3FF$11$361X& ,6-& /# ,-$6 7&
$6<3F+ 1&>?&3#$7$6,/$67&%3,61 &,6-&1+%%$67&/0+F&,1&#,"$-%?&,1&"311$>%+&B3#&/,P$67&"31$/$36&,6-&26%3,-$67&$/&
,/&,&"#34$/&,1&#,"$-%?&,1&"311$>%+DX&"#3-2<+1&,6&$6 <+6/$M+&/3&/,P+&36&0$70+#&#$1P&+T"312#+1X&#+-2<+1&/0+&
#$1P&34& %311& 43#& /0+& $61/$/2/$36&-2+& /3&$F"%$< $/&73M+#6F+6/&72,#,6/++1X&,6-& +44+</$M+%?&+%$F$6,/+1& $/&43#&
F, 6,7+F+6/8&&
L0$ 1&$1&F3#+&/0,6&/0+&$-+,&34&/0+&"#$M,/+&,""#3"# $,/$36&34&"#34$/&,6-&/0+&13<$,%$U,/$36&34&%311+18&!1&%367&,1&
"31$/$36&/,P$67&$1&4$6,6<+-&.$/0&+T/+#6,%&426-$67&/0+#+&. $%%&>+&,&<3F"+61,/$36&1/#2</2#+&.$/0&U+#3&#$1P& 34&
%311& ,6-& 36%?& /0+& "311$>$%$/?& 34& "#34$/8& N6& /0+& %+M+#,7+-& >2?3 2/& "+#$3-& $6& /0+& )e9(1X& <3#"3#,/+& #,$-+#1&
+,# 6+-& $6<3F+1& $##+1"+</$M+& 34& %311+1X& .0$<0& .+#+& /0+& #+1"3 61$>$%$/?& 34& /0+& >36-& 3#& +a2$/?& 03%-+#18&
O$<0,+ %& O$%P+6& ,%13& "#3M$-+ -& ,& 1 ?1/+F& $6& .0$<0& %311+1& .+#+& 63/& /0+& #+1"361$>$%$/?& 34 & /0+& ^26P& >36-&
$112+#1X&>2/&#,/0+#&10$4/+-&/3&<,"$/,%&F,#P+/18&L0+&< 2##+6/&+T",6 1$36&34&Y1+<2#$/ $U,/$36Z&,6-&.0,/&$1&63 .&

<,%%+-& Y10,-3.& >,6P$67Z& 426</$36& 36&/0+&1,F+& "#$6 <$"%+_&/0+&3#$7$6,/3#& +,#61&/0+&4++1&,6-&,6?&103#/:
/+#F&"# 34$/1 & .0$%+&<,"$/,%& F,#P+/&$6M+1/3#1& /,P+& / 0+& %311+18&N/& $ 1&/0+&1/#2</2#+&34& 4$6,6<$,%& /#,61,</$361&
/0,/& 7+6+ #,/+1& /0+& -$1/3#/+-& $6<+6/$M+1& ,6-& 1$F"%+& %$F$/1X& <,"1X& 3#& /+F"3#,%& 1/#2</2#+1& .$%%& 0,M+& %$//%+&
$F",</& 36& /0+& 1 2""3#/& /0$1& 1?1/+F& 7 $M+1& /3& $6<#+,1+-& # $1P& /,P$67& ,6-& 4$6,6<$,%& 4#,7$%$/?8& L0$1& 13#/& 34&
,</$M$/?&$1&.0,/&O$61P?&$-+6/$4$+-&,1&YF36+?&F,6,7+#Z&<,"$/,%$1F&B1 ++&V#,?&'((eX&'() )DX&$6&.0$<0&/0+&
F, 6,7+#&34&$61/$/2/$36,%&426-1&+,#61&,&#+/2#6&$##+1"+</$M+&34&#+12%/1&>2/&0,1&,6&$6<+6/$M+&/3&/,P+&0$70+#&
#$1P1& >+<,21+& 0+& -3+1& 63/& ",#/$<$",/+& $6& ,6?& %311+18& =$6<+& /0+& <2##+6/& ,""# 3,<0& /3& #+43#F& %+,M+1& /0+&
>,1$<&>21$6+11&F3-+ %&34&4$6,6<+&$6/,</X&$/&, %13&%+,M+1&/0+&-$1/3#/$361&36&$6<+6/$M+1&$6/,</8&&
C.!The!Financial! Stability!Oversight!Council!
L0+&<+6/+ #"$+<+&34&/0+&Q3 :5#,6P&%+7$1%, /$36&$1&/0+&<#+,/$36&34&/0+&5$6,6<$,%&=/,>$%$/?&]M+#1$ 70/&G326<$%&
B5= ]GD8&N/&0,1&/0+&3>^+</$M+&34&"#3M$-$67&<3%%+</$M+&,<<326/,>$%$/?&43#&$-+6/$4?$67&#$1P1&,6-&#+1"36-$67 &/3&
&
&
);&
+F +#7$67&/0#+, /1&/3&4$6,6<$,%&1/,>$%$/?8&L3&0+%"&F$6$F$U+&/0+&#$1P&34&,&636>,6P&4$6,6<$,%&4$#F&/0#+,/+6$67&
/0+& 1/,>$%$/?& 34& /0+& 4$6,6<$,%& 1? 1/+FX& /0+& G326<$%& 0,1& /0+& F,6- ,/+& ,6-& ,2/03#$/?& /3& $-+6/$4?& ,%%&
1?1/+F$ <,%%?&$F"3#/,6/&$61/$/2/$361X&>3/0&4$6, 6<$,%&,6 -&6364$6,6<$,%X&/0,/&<36/#$>2/+&+T<+11$M+&#$1P&/3&/0+ &
3"+#,/$36&34&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&1?1/+Fc&,6 -&/3&,M3$-&/0+&#+72%,/3 #?&7,"1&/0,/&+T$1/+-&>+43#+&/0+&#+<+6/&<#$1$18&
N/&,%13&0,1&/0+&,>$%$/?&/3&,""%?&#+72%,/$361&$6&, $/$36&/3&/031+&1/ $"2%,/+-&>?&/0+$#&,"" %$<,>%+&#+72%,/ 3#?&
,7+6<?8 &L0 $1&F+,61&/0,/&M$#/2,%%?&,6?&4$6,6<$,%&3#&6364$6, 6<$,%&$6 1/$/2 /$36&F,?&>+&-+1$7 6,/+ -&1?1/+F$<,%%?&
$F"3#/,6/&,%%3.$67&/0+&G326<$%&/3&$F"31+&<36-$/$361 &/3&+%$F$6,/+&,6?&/0#+,/&/3&4$6,6<$,%&$61/ ,>$%$ /?8&L0+&
5=]G&$1&,%13&F,6-,/+-&/3&$-+6/$4?&+F+#7$67&#$1P1&/3&4$6,6<$,%&1/,>$%$/?&M$,&-$#+</$36&/3X&,6-&#+a2+1/1 &43#X &
-,/,& ,6-& ,6,%?1+1& 4#3F& /0+ & ]44$<+& 34& 5$6,6< $,%& C+1+ ,#<0X& .0$<0& .,1& ,%13& <#+ ,/+- & >?& /0 +& !</c& ,6-& /3&
43#F2%,/+& ,6-& <3F"$%+& -,/,>,1+ 1& 34& 4$6,6<$,%& $643#F,/$36& 4#3F& ,%%& F ,#P+/& ",#/$<$",6/1X& / 3& , $-& $6& /0+&
$-+ 6/$4$<,/$36&34 &261/,>%+&4$6,6<$,%&"#,</$<+1&,6-&<36-$/$361 8&&&
Q+1"$/+&/0$1&<0,#7+X&L#+,12#?&=+<#+/,#?&@+$/06+#X&.03&0+,-1&/0+&G326<$ %X&0,1&1/,/+-&/0,/&$6&0$1&M$+.&$/&$1&
63/& "311$>%+& /3& <#+,/+& +44+< /$M+X& 3>^+</$M+& <#$/+#$,& 43#& +M,%2,/$67& /0+& #$1P& ,& 4$6,6<$,%& 4$#F& "31+1& /3& /0+&
1?1/+F8 & YN/& -+"+6-1& /33& F2<0& 36& /0+& 1/,/+& 34& /0+& .3#%-& ,/& /0+& /$ F+8& j32& .36S/& > +& , >%+& /3& F,P+& ,&
^2-7F+ 6/& ,>32/&.0 ,/S1& 1?1/+F$<& ,6-& .0,/S1&63/&26/$%& ?32& P63.&/0+&6,/2#+& 34&/0+&103<P8Z&L0$1& .32%-&
F, P+&/0+&$-+6/$4$<,/$36&34&1?1/+F$<,%%?&$F"3#/,6/&4$6,6<$,%&,6-&6364$6,6<$,%&4 $#F1&-$44$<2%/&,6-&F,P+&/0+&

$-+ 6/$4$<,/$36&34&+F+#7+6/&#$1P1&6+,#%?&$F"311$>%+8&@+$/06+#&,- -+-&/0,/&%+6-+#1&.32%-&1$F"%?&YF$7#,/+&
,#326-Z& .0,/+M+#& 3>^+</$M+& <#$/+#$,& 34& +F+#7+ 6/& #$1P1& 3#& 1$76$4$< ,6/& $61/$/2/$361& /0,/& "3%$< ?F,P+#1&
-+M+%3"+-&$6&,-M,6<+8&V$/0&#+4+#+6<+&/3&/0+&#+a2$# +F+6/&/0,/&#+13%2/$ 36&34&$613%M+6/&4$#F1&1032%-&> +&
26-+#/,P+6& .$/032/& 73M+#6F+6/& >,$%32/1& 3#& /,T ",?+#& 12""3#/& 43#& 10,#+03%-+#1& 3#& F,6,7+F+6/X&
@+$/06+#&/,P+1&/0+&<36/#,#?&M$+.&/0,/&YN6&/0+&42/2#+X&.+&F,?&0,M+&/3&-3&+T<+"/$36, %&/0$671&,7,$6&$4&.+&
4,<+& ,& 103<P& /0,/& %,#7+8& 8& 8& 8& j32& ^21/& -36S/& P63.& .0,/S1& 1?1/+F$<& ,6-& .0,/S 1& 63/& 26/$ %& ?32& P63.& /0+&
6,/2#+&34&/0 +&103<PZ&Ba23/+-& $6&=N@L!C*&'())D8&
L0+&$-+,&34&$-+6/$4?$67&1"+<$4$<&$61/$/2/$361&,1&1?1/+F$<,%%?&1$76$4$<,6/&1++F1&/3&F$11&O$61P?S1&+T"%,6,/$36&
34&/0+&+6-37+6321&<#+,/$ 36&34&1?1/+F$<&#$1P&/0,/&$/&$1&63/&1"+<$4$ <&/3&$61/$/2/$36 1X&>2/&#,/0+#&$1&/0+&#+12%/&
34&03.&/0+&1?1/ +F&+M3%M+1&3M+#&/$F+&,6-&$/1&1/#2</2#+&< 0,67+1&$6&#+1"361 +&/3&# +72%,/$36&,6-&$663M,/$368&
]6+&34&/0+&4 ,$%2#+1&34&/0+ &\N=&#+a2$#+F+6/1&$6&"#+M+6/$67&,&<#$1$1&$1&/0,/&/0+?&426</$36&36&/0+&"#$6<$"%+&
/0,/&$4&+,<0&$6-$ M$-2,%&>,6P&<,6&> +&F,-+&/3&43%%3.&<3FF36%?&,<<+"/+-&1 /,6-,#-1 &,6-&<3-+ 1X&/0+6&636+&
<,6&<36/,F$6 ,/+&,6 ?&3/0+ #&>,6P &$6&/0+&1?1/+F8&L0+&-+<$1$36&36&.0$<0&,6-&03.&F,6?&$ 61/$/ 2/$361&.$%% &> +&
<%,11$4$+-&,1 &1?1/+F $<,%%?&1$76$4$<,6/&$1&1/$%%&,&F,//+#&34&-+>,/+&>2/&F,?&>+&1$76$4$<,6/&$6&7+6+#,/$67&F3#,%&
0,U,#-& $4& $/& <#+,/+1& /0+& "+#<+"/$36& /0,/& /0+& , $ /$36,%& #+72%,/$36& ,6-& 3M+#1$70/& ,""%$+-& /3& -+1$ 76,/+-&
$61/$/2/$361& "#3M$-+& 13F+&13#/&34& $6<#+,1+-&72,#,6/++& 34&13%M+6<?8& L0+& #+,%& "#3>%+F& $1&/3 & $-+6/$4?& /0+&
+6-37+6321&,<<#+/$36&34&4#,7$%+&4$6,6<$67&1/#2</2#+1X&,6-&/3&#+<376$U+&/0+$#&"3/+6/$,%&$F",</& 36&1?1/+F$<&
1/,>$%$/?8&!6 &,//+ F"/&/3&"#3M$-+&,&F+<0,6$1F&/3&-3&/0$1& $1&"#+1+6 /+-&$ 6&<0,"/+#&;8&
D.!The!Volcker!rule!
O31/&34&/0+&#+72%,/3#?&,</ $361&$6&/0+&Q3 : 5#,6 P&!</&<,%%&43#&F+,12#+1&/3&<3##+</&-$44$<2%/$+1&/0,/&0,M+&
+F +#7+-&4#3F&/0+&F2%/$426</$36&>,6P$67&/0,/&.,1&"+#F$//+-&>?&/0+&@E\&!</8&L0+&5=]G&$ 1&#+1"361$>%+&43#&
$F"%+F+6/$67&/0+&F31/&$F"3#/ ,6/&34&/0+1+&F+,12#+1X&/0+&13:<,%%+-&Yn3%<P+#&#2%+Z&"#3M $1$361&1+/&32/&$6&
1+< /$36&K)e&34&/0+&!</&/0,/&<,%%1&43#&%$F$/,/$3 61&36&/0+&21+&34&"#3"#$+/,#?&426-1&43#&4$6,6<$,%&1"+<2%,/$36&
&
&
)J&
>?& >,6P$67& +6/$/$+1& /0,/& >+6+4$/& 4#3F& 4+-+#,%& $612#,6<+X& 3#& ,6?& +T"%$<$/& 3#& $ F"%$<$/& 73M+#6F+6/&
72,#,6/++18&L0+&1+",#,/$36&34&/0+&21+&34&-+ "31$/3#1S&426-1&43#&>,6P&> 21$6+11:%+6-$67&3"+#,/$361&,6-&/0+&
21+&34&-+"31$/1&43#&,6?&3"+#,/$ 361&$6&1 +<2#$/$+1&F,#P+/1&+T<+"/&/031+&"#3M$-+-&,1&,&<3F"%+F+6/&/3&<%$+6/&
1+#M$<+1& .,1& /0+& 42%<#2F& 34& / 0+& @%,11:=/+,7,%%& #+72%,/ $3618& L0+& $6/+6/$36& .,1& /3& "#+M+6/& >,6P1& 4#3F&

21$67&#+/,$% &-+"31$/&426-1X&72,#,6/++-&>?&/0 +&6+.&73M+#6F+6/&-+"31$/&$612#,6<+&426-X&43#&1"+<2%,/$M+&
/#,-$678&=2<0&,</$M$/?&.,1&/3&>+&%$F$/+-&/3&636$612#+-&$6M+1/F+6/&>,6P1&.031+&", #/6+#1&2 1+-&/0+$#&3.6&
<,"$/,%& #+132#<+1& /3& 7+6+#,/+& $6<3F+& >?& 26-+#.#$/$67& ,6-& /#,-$67& $6& 1+<2#$/$+18 & N6& /0+& )e9(1X& F31/&
$6M+1/F+6/& >,6P1& .+#+& /#,614 3#F+-& $6/3& %$F$/+-:%$,>$%$/?& <3#"3#,/$361& ,6-& +M+6/2,%%?& >+<,F+& >,6P&
03%-$67&<3F",6$+1X&+%$F$6,/$67&/0+&#+%,/$3 6&>+/.++6&/0+&P$6-&34&$6 M+1/F+6/&,</$M$/?&B<3FF+#<$,%&%3,61&
3#&1+<2#$/$+1D&,6-&/0+&P$6-&34&426-$67&B-+"31$/1&3#&3.6&<,"$/,%D&$6&-$1/$6</&/ ?"+1 & 3 4&4$6,6<$,%&$61/$/2/$36&
B<3 FF+#<$, %&3#&$ 6M+1 /F+6/&>,6P1D 8&&
=$6 <+& $/& $1& 6 3& %367+#& "311 $>%+& 26-+#& /0+& )eee& !</& /3& 1+",#,/+& /0+ & 21+& 34& -+"31$/& 426-1& 4#3F& /0+&
"#3"#$+/,#?&/#,-$67&4$6,6<+-&>?&>,6P&< ,"$/,%X&12<0&/#,-$67&<,6&"#3- 2<+&%311 +1&/0,/&^+3",#-$U+&/0+&>,6PS1 &
,>$ %$/?&/3&#+",?&-+"31 $/3#1 X&,6-&.32%- &/021&#+a2$#+&/0+&5+-+#,%&Q+"31$/&N612#,6<+&G3#"3#,/$36&B5QNGD&/3&
F+ +/& /0+& %311+1& <#+,/+-& >?& / #,-$67& #$1P1& /0,/& .+#+& 26-+ #/,P+6& ,6-& 1032%-& >+& >3#6+& >?& /0+& >,6PS1&
3.6+#1& ,6- & F,6,7+#18& L0+& n3%<P+#& #2%+& /021 & 1++P1& / 3& "#+<%2-+& /0+& 21+& 34& /0+& <,"$/,%& 34& /0+& 4$6,6<$,%&
$61/$/2/$36&4 3#&/0+&"2#"31+1&34&"#3"#$+/,#?&/#,-$67[/0, /&$1X&/#,-$67&$6&.0$<0&/0+&>,6P&,</1&,1&"#$6<$",%[$4&
/0+&>,6P&a2,%$4$+1&43#&,6?&73M+#6F+6/&12""3#/&43# &% 311+1&/3&$/1&-+"31$/3#18&L0+&$6/+6/$36&34&/0+&#2%+&$ 1&/3&
"#+M+6/&>,6P1&4#3F&21$67&,6?&3 4&$/1&-+ "31$/1&3 #&<,"$/,%&426-1&/3&/,P+&%+M+#,7+-&#$1P1&36&"31$/$361&.031+&
M,%2+& $1& -+/+#F$6+-& >?& <0,67+1& $6& /0+& "#$<+& 34& 4$6, 6<$,%& ,11+/1X& ,6-X& $6& ",#/$<2%,#X& /3& %$F$/& /0+& 21+& 34&
%+M+#,7+&/0,/& 0,1& >++6& ,& /#,-$/$36,%&",#/& 34& 12<0& ,</$M$/$+18& N6&7+6+#,%X& /0+& %+M+#,7+& /0,/& $1& ,113< $,/+-&
.$/ 0& 1"+<2%,/$M+& ,6-& ,#>$/#,7+& ,</$M$/$+1 & $1& $6& 636$612#+-& ,#+,1& 12 <0& ,1& #+"3& F,#P+/1& ,6-& 3/0+#&
<3FF+ #<$,%&>3##3.$67X&13&/0+&#2%+&$F "%$<$/%?&1++P1&/3&%$ F$/&/0+&%+M+#,7+&/0,/&<,6&>+&7+6+#,/+-&>?&4 26-$67&
"#3"#$+/,#?&/#,-$67&$6&#+"3&F,#P+/1&3# &$6&26-+#:F,#7$6+- &3#&636:F,#7$6 +-&3M+#:/0+:<326/+#&-+#$M,/$M+1&
1/#2</2#+18&
=$6 <+& /0+& #2%+& .32%-& +T<%2-+& >,6P& ,</$M$/$+1& /0,/& "#3M $-+& 1+#M$<+1& /3& <%$+6/1X& /0+#+& $1& ,%13& -$44$<2%/?& $6&
-+/+#F$6$67&.0+6&12<0 &"#+<%2-+-&,</$M$/$+1&,#+&#+a2$#+-&43#&12""3 #/$67&<%$+6/&#+a2+1/1&43#&1+#M$<+1&,6-&
.0+6&/0+ ?&,#+&1$F"%?&43#&/0+&>,6PS1&3.6&,</$M$/$+18&53#&+T,F"%+X&,&>,6P&"#3M$-$67&43#+$76&+T<0,6 7+&3#&
$6/+#+1/&#,/+&0+-7$67&1+#M$<+1&F,?&4$6- &$/&6+<+11,#?&/3&.,#+0321+&12<0&<36/#,</1&$6&3#-+#&/3&"#3M$-+&/0 +&
>+1/&+T+<2/$36&43#&<%$+6/1X&,6-&$/&.32%-&>+&-$44$<2%/&/3&-$44+#+6/$,/+&12<0&,</$M$/$+1&4#3F&"2#+&"#3"#$+/,#?&
1"+<2%,/$368& !1& 63/+-& ,>3M+X& ,%%& /0+1+& -$44$<2%/$+1& .+#+& ,M3$-+-& 26-+#& @ %,11:=/+,7,%%S1 & 1$F"%+&
"#31<#$"/$36&36&1+<2#$/$+1 &/#,-$67&>?&$612#+ -&-+"31$/:/,P$67&> ,6P1 8&L0+&-$44$<2%/$+1&$6&/0+&$6/+#"#+/ ,/$36&
34&/0+&n3%<P+#&#2%+&.32%-&/021&1+ +F&/3&1/+F&4#3F&,6&,//+F"/&/3&#+$ 6/#3-2<+&@%, 11:=/+,7,%%&1+",#,/$36& 34&
,</$M$/$+1&.$ /0$6&/0+&@E\&!</&$6&.0$<0&/0+?& ,#+&"+#F$//+-8&

=3F+& 34& /0+& -$44$<2%/$+1& #,$1+ -& >?& /0+& n3%<P+#& #2%+& ,#+& -+,%/& .$/0& $6& ,63/ 0+#& 3 4& /0+& F,^3#& ,#+,1& 34&
#+72%,/$36&$6&/0+&!</_&/0+&,>$%$/?&34&>,6P1&/3&3"+#,/+&,6-&,</&,1&-+,% +#1&$6&-+#$M,/$M +&<36/#,</1X&,6-&/0+&
43#F,%& /#,614+#& 34& -+#$M,/$M+1& <%+,#$67& ,6-& /# ,-$6 7& /3& #+72%,/+-& F,#P+/& $61/$/2/$3618& L0+& 43#F+#& -+,%1 &
.$/ 0&/0+&13:<,%%+-&YE$6<3%6&,F+6-F+6/Z&/0,/&13270/&/3&"#30$>$/&>,6P1&,</$M+&$6&/0+&1.,"1&F,#P+/1&4# 3F&
#+<+$M$67&M,#$321&43#F1&34&Y4+-+#,%&,11$1/,6<+XZ&$6<%2-$67&4+-+#,%&-+"31$/&$612#,6<+&,6-&,<<+11&/3&/0+&5+-&
-$1<326/&.$6-3.&3#&,6? &5+-&<#+-$/&4,<$%$/?8&R3.+M+#X&/0+&,F+6-F+6/&,%13&<#+,/+-&-$44$<2%/$+1&-2+&/3&/0+&
&
&
)H&
#+/+6/$36&34&+T$1/$67&@E \&%+7$1%,/$36&,6-&+F +#7+-&.$/0&,&"210:32/&"#3M$1$36&/0,/&,%%3 .+-&$612#+-&+6/$/$+1&
/3&<36/$62+&/0+$#&-+#$M,/$M+1&,</$M$/$+1&26-+#&<+#/,$6&<36-$/$3618&&
L0+&#+72%,/$36&43#>$-1 &4+-+#,%&,11$1/, 6<+&43#&,&7+6+#$<&<,/+73#?X&Y1. ,"1&+6/$/$+1XZ&/0,/&$1&-+4$6+-&,1&Y,6?&
1.,"& -+,%+#X& 1+<2#$/?:>,1+-& 1.,"& -+,%+#X& F, ^3#& 1.,"& ",#/$<$",6/X& d3#f& F,^3#& 1+<2#$/?:>,1+-& 1.,"&
",#/$<$",6/8Z& N6& /2#6X& 1., "& -+,%+#1& ,6-& 1+<2#$/?:>,1+-& 1.,"& -+,%+#1& ,#+& "+#1361& 3#& +6/$/$+1& /0,/& 03%-&
/0+F1+%M+1&32/&,1&1. ,"&-+,%+#1X&F,P+&F,#P +/1&$6&1.,"1X&#+72%,#%?&+6/+ #&$6/3&1.,"1&.$/0&<326/+#",#/$+1&
,1&,6&3#-$6,#?&<32#1+&34&>21$6+11&43#&/0+$#&3. 6&,<<326/1X&3#&+67,7+&$6&,6?&,</$M$/?&<,21$67&/0 +F&/3&>+&
<3FF36%?&P63.6&$6&/0+&$6-21/#?&,1&1.,"&-+,%+#1&3#&F, #P+/&F,P+#18&R3.+M+#X&+M +6&$4&,6&+6/$/ ?&$1&63/&
<%,11$4$+-&,1&,&Y1.,"1&-+,%+#XZ&$/&F,?&636+/0+% +11&>+&<%,11 $4$+-&,1&,&YF,^3#&1.,"&",#/$<$",6/p&3#&YF,^3#&
1+< 2#$/?:>,1 +-& 1. ,"& ",#/$<$",6/Z& 12>^+</& /3& /0+& #+72%,/$36& $4& $/& F,$6/,$6 1& Y12>1/,6/$,%& "31$/$361Z& $6&
1.,"1X& 3#& $4& $/& "311+11+1& 32/1/,6 -$67& 1 .,"1& /0,/& <#+,/+& 12>1 /,6/$,%& <326/+#",#/?& +T"312#+& /0,/& < 32%-&
0,M+&1+#$321&,-M+#1+ &+44+ </1&36&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&1/,>$%$/?&34&/0+&W=&>,6P$67&1?1/+F&3#&4$6,6<$,%&F,#P+/18&&
=$6 <+&/0$1&"#3M $1$36X&.0$< 0&$1&/3& <3F+& $6/3& +44+</&$6&l2%?& '()'X & .32%-&<#+ ,/+&12>1/,6/$,%&-$44$<2%/$+1&43#&
>,6P1& $6& "#3M$-$67& -+# $M,/$M+1:>,1+ -& <%$+6/& 1+#M$<+1X& 3#& $6& 21$67& 12<0& $61/#2F+6/1& /3& 0+-7+& /0+$#& 3.6&
#$1P1&M$,&/0+&21 +&34&-+#$M,/$M+&<36/#,</1X&/0+&Y"210&32/Z&"# 3M$1$36&.32%-&,%%3.&>,6P1& /3&#+/,$6&5+-+#,%&
$612#,6 <+&,6 -&12""3#/& $4&/0+$#& 1.,"& ,</$M$/$+1& ,#+&<,##$+-&32/&/0#3270&,6& ,44$%$,/+8& L0+&$6 12#+-&+6/$/$+1&
<32%-& /0+6& -$#+</%?& +67,7+& $6& /0+$#& 3.6& ,6-& <+#/,$6& <%$+6/:>, 1+-& 0+-7$67& ,</$M$/$+1& .$/032 /& >+$6 7&
<%,11$4$+-& ,1& 1.,"& -+,%+#18& L0+& ,44$%$,/+1& F,?& >+& <#+,/+-& >?& ,6?& -+"31$/3#? & $61/$/2/$36& /0,/& $1& ",#/& 34&
+$/0+#& ,& >,6P& 03%-$67& <3F",6?& 3#& 1,M$671:,6-:%3 ,6& 03%-$67& <3F",6?X& 36& <36-$/$36& /0,/& /0+& ,44$%$,/+&
<3F"%$+1& .$/0& 1+</$361& ';! & ,6-&';\& 34& /0+& 5+-+#,%& C+1+#M+& !</& ,6-& ,6?& 3/0+#& #+a2$#+F+6/1& /0,/ & /0+&
G3FF3-$/?& 52/2#+1& L#,-$67& G3FF$11$36& BG5LGDX& =+<2#$/$+1& ,6-& bT<0,67+& G3FF$11$36& B=bGDX& ,6-& 5+-&

F, ?& -+/+#F$6+& 6+<+11,#?8& N6& +44+</X& /0$1& $1& /0+& +a2$M,%+6/& 34& /0+& 1+</$36& '(& +T+F"/$36& 26-+#& @%,11:
=/+ ,7,%%&/0,/&"+# F$//+-&<3FF+#<$,%&>,6P1&%$F$/+-&1+<2#$/$+1:F,#P+/&,</$M$ /$+18&&
L0+&,</$M$/$+1&/0,/&<,6&>+&+67,7+-&$6&>?&/0+&$612#+-&+6/$/?&$/1+%4&$6<%2-+&,</$ 67&,1&" #$6<$ ",%&$6 &1.," 1&.$/0&
<21/3F+#1& $6& <366+</$36& .$/0& 3#$7$6,/$67& %3,61& 43#& /03 1+& <21/3F+#1c& +6 7,7$67& $6& Y-+& F$6$F$1Z& 1.," 1&
-+,%$67c& +6 /+#$67& 1.,"& ,7#++F+6/1& 43#& /0+& "2 #"31+1& 34& Y0+-7$67& ,6-& 3/0+#& 1$F$%,#& #$1P& F$/$7,/$67&
,</$M$/$+1&-$#+</%?&#+% ,/+- &/3&/0+&$612#+-&-+"31 $/3#?&$61/$/2/$36S1&,</$M$/$+1Zc&,6-&,</$67&,1&1.,"1&+6/$/$+1&
43#&,</$M$/$+1&$6M3%M$67&#,/+1&3#&#+4+#+ 6<+&,11+/1&/0,/&,#+ &"+#F$11$>%+&43#&$6M+1/F+6/&>?&,&6 ,/$36,%&>,6P8&
!7,$6X&/0+1+&F$##3#&+T+F"/ $361&/0,/&0,-&,%#+,-?&>++6&,""#3M+-&26-+#&@%,11:=/+,7,% %&,6-&-$-&F2<0&/3&
26-+#F$6+&$/1 &,""%$<,/$368&C+72%,/$361&1"+<$4?$67&/0+&43#F,%&<36/+6/&34&/0+1+&%$F$/1&,6-&-+4$6$/$36&,#+&/3&
>+&43#F2%,/ +-&>?&/0+&=bG&,6-&G5LG&,1&,""#3"#$,/+8&&
E.!Swaps!and!futures!reg ulation!
L0+1+&+T+F"/$361&-3&63/X&03.+M+#X&,""%?&/3& <#+-$/&-+4,2%/&1.,"1&BGQ=1D&26%+11& /0+?&,#+&<%+,#+-&/0#3270&
-+#$M,/$M+1:<%+,#$67&#+72%,/$ 361&/0,/&,#+&<,%%+-&43#&26-+#&/0+&!</ 8&L0+&4$6,6<$,%&$6-21 /#?&4 3270/&0,#-&/3&
%$F$/&#+43#F1 &36&/0+&/#,-$67&34&G Q=1&/3& /0+&#+a2$#+F+6/&/0,/&/0+?&>+&<%+,#+-X&,#72$67&/0,/&/0$ 1&.32%-&>+&
1244$<$+6/& /3& +612#+& 1,4+/?8& R3.+ M+#X& O$<0,+%& @#++6>+#7+#& B'()(D& 0,1& ,#7 2+-& /0,/X& .0$%+& <%+,#$67&
#+72%,/$361& .32%-& 0+%"& /3& +612#+ & <,"$/,%& ,-+a2,<?& 34& /#,-$67& ", #/6+#1X& /0$1& ,%36+& $1& 63/& 1244$<$+6/&
"#3/+</$368& 5 3#& +T,F"%+X& @#++6>+#7+ #& 1/,/+ 1& /0,/& /0+& 43% %3.$67& #+72%,/ $361& ,#+& 6+ <+11,#?& ,1& .+%%_&
&
&
)K&
/#,61", #+6<?& 3 4& "#$<$67& ,6-& 34& /0+& /#,-$67& ",#/?& $- +6/$/$+1X& "# 2-+6/$,%& ,6-& <3F"+/+ 6<?& #+72%,/$36& 34 &
$6/+#F+-$,# $+1X& ,-+a2,/+& 1+%4:#+72%,/$3 6& >?& /0+& $6-21/#? & /3& 0+%"& #+72%,/3#1X& <3F"%+/+& #+<3#-& P++"$67X&
"#30$>$/$361&36&4#,2-&,6-&F,6$"2%,/$36 X&42%%&-$1<%312#+&/3&#+72%,/3#1 &,6-&<326 /+#",#/$+1X&,6-&<3F"+/+6/&
"#$M,/+& +643#<+F +6/8& L0$1& .32%-& <#+,/+& ,& 1/#2</2#+& 1$F$%,#& /3& 1/3<P& F,#P+/& #2%+1X& #+72%,/$361X& , 6-&
3"+#,/$67& "#3<+-2#+18& bT<0,67+& /#,-$67X&1/ #$</& ,6/$4#,2-& #+a2$#+F+6/1& /0,/&,#+& +643#<+-&>?& 1/,/+& ,6-&
4+-+#,%&73M+#6F+6/1X&,6-&>,61&36&Y,>21$M+Z&GQ=1&/0,/&,#+&-+1$76+-&/3&<,21+&+<363F$<&$6^2#?&B/0#3270&
>,6P#2"/<?D&.+# +&1++6&/3&>+&6++- +-&/3&"#+M+6/&,&#+ "+,/ &34&/0+&"#3>%+F1&/0,/&%+-&2"&/3 &/0+&<#$1$18&&
N/& $1& $6/+#+1/$67& /0,/& ,& 6+ .& F,#P+/& $6& 1?6/0+/$<& <3%%,/+#,%$U+-& -+>/& 3>%$7, /$361& $1& #, "$-%?& -+M+%3"$67X&
>,1+-&36&/0+&10,#"&$6 <#+,1+&$6&^26P&>36-&$112,6<+1&/0,/&0,1&>++6&1/$F2 %,/+-&>?&/0+&%3.&$6/+#+1/&#,/+1&
,6-&1"#+,-1&$6&/0+&<3#"3#,/+&>36-&F,#P+/8&L0+&$61/#2F+6/1 &+ 6,>% +&$6M+1/3#1&/3&/,P+&,&"31$/$36&36&/0+&

^26P& >36-& F,#P+/& .$/03 2/& 03%-$67& ,& %367& "31$/$36& $6& /0+& 26-+# %?$67& $61/#2F+6/18& L0+?& ,#+& <#+,/+-&
/0#3270&-+#$M,/$M+ 1&36&^26P&>36-&$6-$<+1&,6-&# +1+F>%+& /0+&$61/#2F+6/1&/ 0,/&<#+,/+-&12<0&-$44$<2%/?&$6&
/0+&F3#/7,7+&F,#P+ /X&.0$%+&"#3M$-$67&+T"312#+&1$F$%, #&/3&,&<#+- $/&-+4,2%/&1.,"8&N/&$1&63/&<%+,#&/0,/&/0+&
6+.&#+72%,/$361&.$%%&>+&,>%+&/3& "#+M+6/&,&%$P+&<3%%,"1+&$6&/0+&+M+6/&34&,&#,"$-&$6<#+,1+&$6&"3%$<?& #,/+1X &
1"#+,-1X&3#&^26P& >36-&-+4,2%/&#,/+ 18&&
L0+&42%%&$F"%+F+6/,/$36&34&/0+&n3%<P+#& ,6-&E$6<3%6& ,F+6-F+6/1 &#+a2$#+1&"#3M$1$361&/3&10$4/&]L G& /#,-$67&
$6&-+#$M,/$M+1&36/3&4+-+#,%%?&F,6-,/+-&<%+,# $67&F+<0,6$1F1&,6-&#+72%,/+-&F,#P+/18&L0+&!</&/021&<,%%1&
43#&/0+& <#+,/$36&34&,&<3F"#+0+61$M+&4#,F+.3# P&43#&/0+&#+72%,/$36X&<%+,#$ 67X&,6-&+T<0,67+&/#,-$67&34&]LG&
-+#$M,/$M+18&A3.&-+4$6+-&,1&Y1.,"Z&<36/#,</1X&4+-+#,%&%+7$1%,/$36&0,1&,%.,?1 &+T<%2-+-&/0+F&4#3F&1$F$%,#&
43#F,%&#+72%,/ $361&/0 ,/& 3#$7$ 6,/+ -&$ 6&/0+&$6$/$,%&#+72%,/$36&34&42/2#+1&<36/#,</1&$6&)e''8&L0$1&$1&-2+&$6&",#/&
/3& /0+& 4,</& /0,/& 42/2#+1& <36/#,</1& .+#+& $6$/$,%%?& -+M+%3"+-& $6& /0+& ,7#$<2%/2#,%& 1+</3#& ,6-& /021& .+#+&
12>^+</& /3& <3FF3-$/?& 42/2#+1& /#,-$67& #+72%,/$36& F36$/3#+-& >? & /0+& G5LG X& .0$%+& 3/0+#& -+#$M,/ $M+1&
<36/#,< /1&.+#+&"#$F, #$%?&4$6,6<$,%&,6-&/0+#+43#+&26-+#&/0+&#+72%,/3#?&#2>#$<&34&/0+ &=bG8&L02 1X&,%/03270&
42/2#+1&<36/#,</1X&.0+/0+#&34&,&4$6,6<$ ,%&3#&<3FF3-$/?&6,/2#+X&<32%-&63/&>+&%+7 ,%%?&/#,-+-&32/1$-+&34&,&
43#F,%%?&#+72%,/+-&F,#P+/&.$/ 032/&,&1"+<$4$<&+T+F"/$36X&3/0+#&-+#$M,/$M+ 1&.+#+&,%.,?1&42%%?&+T+F"/&,6-&
/021&-+M+%3"+-&$6&/0+&]LG&F,#P+/8&L0+&<2##+6/&#+72%,/$ 36&/021&1++P1&/3&,""%?&/0+&+T<0,67+&,6-&<%+,#$67&
#+72%,/$361&34&42/2#+1&/3&M$#/2,%%?&,%%&1/,6-,#-$U+-&1.,"&<36/#,</18&&
V0$%+&1.,"1&,6-&42/2#+1&#+"#+1+6/&1$F$%,#&Y/$F+Z&<36/#,</1X&1.,"1X&26%$P+&42/2#+ 1X&.+#+&<21/3F$U+-&/3&
/0+&1"+<$4$<&<3FF+#<$,%&0+ -7$67&6++-1&34&>21$6+11+1&,6-&4$6,6<$ ,%&$61/$/2/$361c&,6-X&,1&63/+-X&4$6,6<$,%&
$61/$/2/$361& $6$/$,%%?& ,</+-& ,1& $6/+#F+-$,#$+1& >#$67$67& /37+/0+#& 1.,"& <326/+#",#/$ +1& $6& "#$M,/+& >$%,/+#,%&
6+73/$, /$3618& =$6<+& F31/& 34& /0+1+& <36/#,</1& .+#+& 6+7 3/$,/+-& .$/032/& +T<0,67+& 34& "#$6<$",%X& #$1P &
+T"312#+& .,1& %$F$/+-& /3& F,#7$6,%& <0,67 +1& $6& /0+& F,#P+/& "#$<+& 34& /0+& <36/#,</1& ,6-& "#+1<#$"/$M+&
#+72%,/$36& .,1& 63/& <361$-+#+-& 6+<+11,#?8& !1& >,6P 1& >+7,6& /3& /,P+& 36& "#$6<$",%& "31$/$361& ,1&
<326/+#",#/ $+1&/3&<%$+6/&#+a2+1/1X&/0+?&,%13&,<<+"/+-&#$1P&36&/0+&636" +#43#F,6<+&34&<326/+#",#/$+1X&>2/&
/0$1& . ,1& ,%13& <361$-+#+-& F$6$F,%8& L0+& F31/& "3"2% ,#& 1.,"1& <36/# ,</1& .+#+& $6/+#+1/& #,/+& ,6-& 53#+T&
1.,"1X&.0$<0&.+#+&7+6+#,/+-&>?&/0+&>#+,P-3.6&34&/0+&\#+//36&V33-1&1?1/+F&34&4$T+-&+T<0,67+&#,/+1&
,6-&0,M+&1$6<+&>+<3F+&,6&$6/+7#,%&", #/&34&/0+&0+-7$67&$6&/0+&4%+T$>%+&$6/+#+1 /&,6-&+T<0,67+&#,/+1&$6&/0+&
$6/+#6,/$36,%& 4$6,6<$,% & 1?1/+F8& !1& /0+?& $6<#+,1+-& $6& M3%2F+X& /0+& N6/+#6,/$36,%& =.,"1& ,6-& Q+#$M,/$M+1&
!11 3<$,/$36&"#3M$-+-&1/,6-,#-$U+-&/+#F1&,6-&-3<2F+6/,/$36X&#+- 2<$67&/0+&6++-&43#&1"+<$4$<&<36-$/$361&
,6-&>$%,/+#,%&6+73/$,/$36 8&

&
&
)I&
L0+&-+4$6$/$36&34&1.,"1&$6&/0+&!</&<3M+#1&F31/&<3FF36%?&/#,-+-&]LG&-+#$M,/$M+1X&$6<%2-$67&3 "/$361&36&
$6/+#+1/& #,/+1X& <2##+6<$+1X& <3FF3-$/$+1X& 1+<2#$/$+1X& $6-$<+1X& ,6-& M,#$321& 3/0+#& 4$6,6<$,%& 3#& +<363F$<&
$6/+#+1/1&3#&"#3"+#/?c&< 36/#,</1&$6&.0$<0&",?F+6/1&,6-&-+%$M+#$+1&,#+&-+"+6-+6/&36&/0+&3<<2##+6<+&3#&
6363<<2##+6<+&34&<+#/,$6&<36/$67+6<$+1&B+878X&,&<#+-$/&-+4,2% /&1.,"Dc&,6-&1.,"1&36&#,/+1&,6-&<2##+6<$+1X&
/3/,%&#+/2#6&1.,"1X&,6-&M,#$321&3/0+#&<3FF36& 1.,"&/#,61,</$3618&&
Q2+&/3&/0+&",#,%%+%&-+M+%3"F+6/&34&< 3FF3-$/?:>,1+-&,6-&4$6,6<$, %:>,1+-&<36/#,</1X&/0+ &!</&-+4$6+1&,6-&
"#3M$-+1& 4 3#& ,& <3FF36& ,""#3,<0& /3& Y1+<2#$/?:>,1+-& 1 .,"1XZ& .0$<0& ,#+& 7+6+#,%%?& 1.," & / #,61,</$361&
$6M3%M$67& ,& 1$67%+& 1 +<2#$/?& 3#& %3,6& 3#& ,& 6,##3.:>,1+-& 1+<2#$/?& $6-+T8& N6& >#3,-& / +#F1X& / 0+1+& .$%%& >+&
#+72%,/+-&>?&/0+&=bG&.0$%+&Y<3FF3-$/?&1.,"1Z&.$%%&>+&#+72%,/+-&>?&/0+&G5LGX&"#+1+#M$67&/0+&0$1/3#$<,%&
-$M$1$36&34&%,>3#&>+/.++6&/0+&/.3&,7+6<$+18&
!63/0+#&0$70:M3 %2F+&,#+ ,&34& /0+& F,#P +/&/0,/&F$70/& >+&<361$- +#+- & ,&"#$F+&+T,F" %+&34 & <36/#,</1& /0,/&
F$70/&>+6+4$/&4#3F&#+72%,/+-&F,#P+/&/#,-$67&,#+&43#+$76&+T<0,67+&1.,"1&,6-&43#.,#-&<36/#,</18&L0+1+&
<36/#,< /1&,#+&"#$F,#$%?&/0+&-3F,$6&34&>,6P1&,6-&,#+&<2##+6/%? &+T+F"/ &4#3F&#+72%,/3#?&3M+#1$70/8&L0+ ?&
.$%%&>+&12>^+</&/3&#+72%,/$36&26-+#&/0+&!</c&03.+ M+#X&7$M+6&/0+&F,^3#&",#/$<$",/$36&34&>,6P1&$6& "#3M $-$67&
<%$+6/& 1+#M$<+1 & ,6-& /0+& /#,-$/$36,%& ,>1+6< +& 34& #+72%, /$36& 1$6<+& /0+& >#+,P-3.6& 34& /0+& \#+//36& V33-1&
1?1/+FX&/0+&!</&"#3M$-+1&/0+&L#+,12#?&1+<#+/,#?&.$/0&/0+&"3.+#&/3&+T< %2-+ &/0+F&4#3F&#+72%,/$36&$4&/0+&
<36/#,< /1&6+73/$,/+-&0,M+&63/&>++ 6&1/#2 </2#+-&/3&+M,-+ &/ 0+&#+,<0&34 &/ 0+&%+7$1%,/$368&L0$1&+T+F"/$36&$1&
+T"+</+-&$6&/0+&6+,#&42/2#+8&&
\,6P1X& -+,%+#1X& ,6-& 3/0+#& 4$6,6<$,%& $61/$/2/$361& ,</$M+& $6& /0+ & -+#$M,/ $M+1& F, #P+/1& F, ?& >+ & <%,11$4$+-& ,1&
YB1+<2#$/?D& 1. ,"& -+,%+#1Z[/0,/& $1X& ,6?& "+#136& .03& 03%-1& 0$ F1+%4& 32/& ,1& ,& -+,%+#& $6& 1.,"1X& F,P+1& ,&
F, #P+/&$6&1.,"1X&#+72%,#%?&+6/+#1&$6/3&1.,"1&.$/0&<32 6/+#",#/$ +1&,1&,6&3#-$6,#?&<32#1+&34&>21$6+11&43#&
0$1&3.6&,<<326/X&3#&+67,7+1&$6&,6?&,</$M$ /?&< ,21$67&0$F&/3&>+&<3FF36%?&P63.6&$6&/0 +&/#,-+&,1&,&-+,%+#&
3#&F,#P+/&F,P+#&$6&1.,"1[,6-&.$%%&>+<3F+&12>^+</&/3& #+7$1/#,/$ 36&,6-&#+<3#-:P++"$67&#+a2$#+F+6 /18&&
@$M+6& /0+& "#3F$6+6/ & #3%+& $6& "#3M$-$67& <%$+6/& 1+# M$<+1X& ,& 62F>+#& 34& $61/$/2/$361& .$%%& >+& +T+F"/ & 4#3 F&
<%,11$4$<,/$3 6&,1&B1+<2#$/?D&1.,"&-+,%+# 1_&,6&$612#+-&-+"31$ /3#?&$61/$/2/$36X&/3&/0+&+T/+6/&$/&344+#1&/3&+6/+#&
$6/3&,& 1.,"&.$/0& ,&<21/3F+#& $6& <366+</$36& .$/0& 3#$7$6,/$67& ,&%3,6& .$/0& /0,/ & <21/3F+#c& ,6& +6/$/?&/0,/&
>2?1&3#&1+%%1&1.,"1&43#&12<0&"+#136S1&3.6&,<<3 26/X&+$/0+#&$6-$M$-2,%% ?&3#&$6&,&4$-2<$,#?&<,",<$/?X&,6-&63/&

,1&Y",#/&34&,&#+7 2%,#&>21$6+11Zc&,6-&,6&+6/$/? &/0,/&+67,7+1&$6 &,&Y-+&F$6$F$1&a2,6/$/?Z&34&1.,"&-+,%$67&$6&
<366+</$36& .$/0 &/#,61,</$361&.$/0&3#&36&>+0,%4 &34&$/1&<21/3F+#18&&
L0+&F,^3#& 3>%$7,/$36&34&1. ,"& -+,%+#1& .$%%& >+& /0+& ,""%$<,/$36&34&F$6$F2F& <,"$/,%&1/,6-,#-1& ,6-& $6$/$,%&
,6-& M,#$,/$36& F,#7$6& #+a2$#+F+6/1& 43#& 1.," 1& /0,/& ,#+& 63 /& <%+,#+-& ,1& #+a2$#+-& > ?& /0+& ,""#3"#$,/+&
"#2-+6/$,%&# +72%,/3#?&,7+6<?&3#&<3FF $11$3 68&&
F.!Deali ng!with!insolvent!insti tutions!
!1& 6 3/+-X& /0+& F,^3#& 1+</$3 61& 34& /0+& !< /& -3& %$//%+& /3& #+M+#1+& /0+& /#+6-& /3.,#-& %,#7+#& ,6-& %,#7+#&
F2%/$42 6</$36&>,6P&<367%3F+#,/+18&L0+&!</&,//+F"/1&/3&-+,%&.$/0&/0+&$6<#+,1+-&#$1P1&"#+1+6/+-&>?&12<0&
$61/$/2/$361X&.0+/0+#&<,2 1+-&>?&F3#,%&0,U,#-&3#&1$F"%+&F,6, 7+F+6/&-+4$<$+6<$+1X&>?&<#+, /$67&,&1?1/+F&
43#&/ 0+&-$113%2/$36 &34&12<0&$61/ $/2/$361&.0+6&/0+?&>+<3F+&$613%M+6/8&N6 -++-X&/0+&3M+#,#<0$67&/0+F+&3 4&
&
&
)9&
/0+&!</&$1&63/&13&F2<0&/3&"#+M+6/&<#$1+1&,1&/ 3&"#+<%2-+&/0+&"311$>$%$/?&34&21$67&"2>%$<&426-1&$6&F++/$67&
%311+1& 3#&#+1<2$67&$613%M+6/& $61/$/2/$3 618& L0$1& $1&26-+#1/,6-,>%+& <361$-+#$67&/0+&<#$/$<$1F& 34&/0+&21+&34&
/0+&L!C*&"#37#,F&/3&121/,$6&,6-&#+<,"$/,%$U+&$613%M+6/&4$6,6<$,%&$61/$/2/$361&.0$%+&$613%M+6/&0321+03%-1&
.+#+&43#<+-&$6/3&4 3#+<%312#+8&G367#+11&<%+,#%?&.,6/+-&/3&.,10&$/1&0 ,6-1&34&,6?&#+1"361$>$%$/?&43#&/0+&21+&
34&"2>%$<&426-1&$6&12""3#/&34&4$6,6<$,% &$61/$/2/$3618&
L0+&,>1+6<+&34&,&<3FF36&%+7,%&4# ,F+.3#P&43#&-+,%$67&.$/0&$613%M +6/&$61/$/2 /$361&.,1&36+&34&/0 +&F,$6&
-$44$<2%/$+1&63/+-&>?&#+72%,/3#1&$6&#+1"36-$67&/3&/0+&#+<+6/&<#$1$18 &53#&+T,F"%+X&/0+&5+-+#,%&C+1+#M+&0,1&
,#72+-& /0,/& $/& 0, -& 63& F, 6-,/+& /3 & ,</& $6& /0+& <,1+& 34& E+0F,6& \#3/0+#1X& . 0$%+& /0+& L#+,12#?& 0,-& 63&
F, 6-,/+& /3& $ F"31+& >,6P#2"/<?& 36& !F+# $<,6& N6/+#6,/$36,% & @#32"& B!N@D8& N6& /0+& ,>1+6<+& 34& < %+,#& 5QNG&
,2/03#$/?&/3&#+13%M+&636$612#+-X&636>,6P&4$6,6<$,%&$61/$/2/$361X&-$#+</&73M+#6F+6/&12""3#/&,""+,#+-&/3&
>+& /0+& 13%+& ,%/+#6,/$M+8& L$/%+ & NN& 34& /0 +& Q3 : 5#,6 P& !</& $1& F+,6/& /3& F++/& /0$1& -$44$<2%/?& /0#3270& /0+&
<#+,/$36&34&,6&Y3#-+#%?&%$a2$ -,/$36&,2/0 3#$/?Z&B]E!D &/0,/&7$M+1&/0+&5QNG&"3.+#&/3&1+$U+&<36/#3%&34&1 2<0&
$61/$/2/$361&3 6&/0+&-+/+#F$6, /$36&> ?&/0+&L# +,12#?&1+<#+/,#?&/0,/&/0+?&/0#+,/ +6&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&1/,>$%$/?&34&
/0+&W6$/+- &=/,/+18&N/&F,6-,/+1&/0+&5QNG&/3&%$a2$-,/+&12<0 &-+1$76,/+-&$61 /$/2/$361&13&,1&/3&F,T$F$U+&/0+&
M,%2+&#+<+$M+-&4#3F&/ 0+&-$1"31$/$36&34&/0+&<3F",6?S1&,11+/1X&F$6$F$U+&,6?&%311X&F$/$7,/+&/0+&"3/+6/$ ,%&
43#&1+#$321&,-M+ #1+&+44+</1&/3 &/0+&4$6,6<$,%&1?1/+FX&+612#+&/$F+%?&,6-& ,-+a2,/+&<3F"+/$/$36&,6-&4,$#&,6-&
<361$1/+6/&/#+,/F+6/&34&>$ +#1&36&,11+/1&,6-&-+"31$/1X&,6-&"#30$>$/&-$1<#$F$6,/$368&&

!<<3#-$ 67&/3&/0+&!</X&$F"%+F+6/$67&3# -+#%?&%$a2$-,/$36&#+a2 $#+1&/0,/&/0+&5QNG&-+/+#F$6+&/0,/&12<0&,</$36&
$1& 6+<+11,#? & 43#& "2# "31+1& 34& /0+& 4$6,6<$,%& 1/,>$%$/?& 34& /0+& W6$/+-& =/,/+1X& ,6-& 63/& 43#& /0+& "2#"31+& 34&
"#+1+#M$67&/0+&<3M+#+-&4$6,6<$,%&<3F",6?c &+612#+&/0,/&/0+&10,#+0 3%-+ #1&34&,&<3M+#+-&4$6,6 <$,%&<3F",6?&
-3&63/&#+<+$M+&",?F+6/&26/$%&,4/+#&,%%&3/0+#&<%,$F1&,6-&/0+&Q+"31$/&N612#,6<+&526-&,#+&42%%?&",$-c&+6 12#+&
/0,/& 261+<2#+-& <#+-$/3#1& >+,#& %31 1+1& $6& ,<<3#- ,6<+& .$/0& /0+& "#$3#$/?& 34& <%,$F1c & +612#+& /0,/& /0+&
F, 6,7+F+6/& ,6-& > 3,#-& 34& -$# +</3#1& #+1"361$>%+& 43#& /0 +& 4,$%+-& <36-$/$36& 34& /0+& <3M+#+-& 4$6,6 <$,%&
<3F",6?&,#+&#+F3M+-&B$4&1/$%% &"#+1+6 /&,/&/0+&/$F+&,/&.0$<0&/0+&5QNG&$1&,""3$ 6/+-&#+<+$M+#Dc&,6 -&63 /&/,P+&
,6& +a2$/?& $6/+#+1/& $6& 3#& >+<3F+& ,& 10,#+03 %-+#& 34 & ,6?& <3M+ #+-& 4$6 ,6<$,%& <3F",6?& 3#& ,6?& <3M+#+-&
12>1$-$,#?8&
!63/0+#& #+,136&43#&/0+&21+&34&-$#+</&73M+#6F+6/&$6/+#M+6/$3 6&$6&/0+&#+<+6/&<#$1$1&.,1&/0+ &6++- &43#&#,"$-&
,</$36&$6&3#-+#&/3&"#+M+6/&42#/0+#&-+/+#$3#,/$36&34&/0+&4$6,6<$ ,%&<36-$/$36&34&/0+&$61/$/2/$361&$6&-$44$<2 %/?&
,6-&/0+&#$1P&34&<36/,7$368&R3.+M+#X&26-+#&]E!X&/0+&-+/+#F$6,/$36 &>?&/0+&L#+,12#?&1+<#+/,#?&0,1&/3&>+&
F, -+&36&#+<3FF+6-,/$36&34&<+#/,$6&-+1$76,/+-&4+-+#,%&#+72%,/3#?&,2/03#$/$+1&B12<0&,1&/0+&5=]GD&,6-&
.$/ 0&,6&+M,%2,/$36&34&.0?&/0+&$61/$/2/$36&1032%-&63/&>+&-+,%/&.$/0&26-+#&/0+& \,6P#2"/<?&G3-+X&,6-&,4/+#&
<3612%/,/$36&.$/0&/0+&"#+1$-+6/8&L0+&!</&,%13&#+a2$#+1&/0,/&>+43#+&/0+&L#+,12#?&1+<#+/,#?&<,6&F,P+&/0+&
-+/+#F$6,/$ 36& /0,/& /0+& 5QNG& 1032%-& >+& ,""3$6/+- & #+<+$M+#X& 0+& F 21/& 4$#1/& F,P+& ,& #+a2$1$/+& 1+#$+1& 34&
1"+<$4$<& 26-+#%?$67& 4$6-$671X& $6< %2-$67& /0,/& /0+& <3F",6?& $1 & $6& -+4,2%/& 3#& $1& $6& -,67 +#& 34& -+4,2%/c& /0,/&
1032%-&/0+&<3F",6?&13&- +4,2 %/X&/0+&#+13%2/$36&34&/0+&<3F",6?&26- +#&/0+&3/0+#.$1+&,""%$<,>%+&4+-+#,%&3#&
1/,/+&%,.&.32%-&0,M+&1+#$321 &,-M+#1+&<361+a2+6<+1&43#&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&1/,>$%$/?&34&/0+&W6$/+-&=/,/+1c&/0,/&
/0+#+& ,#+& 63& "#$M,/+& 1+</3#& ,%/+#6,/$M+1& ,M,$%,>%+& /0,/& .32%- & ,M3$-& 12<0& ,-M+ #1+& <361+a2+6< +1c& /0,/&
/0+#+& ,#+&63&$6,""#3"#$,/+& "3/+6/$,%& +44+</1&36&/0+&<%,$F1& 3#&$6/+#+1/1& 34&<#+-$/3#1X& <326/+#",#/$+1X&3#&
10,#+03%-+#1&/0,/&.32%-&#+12%/&4#3F&12<0&,""3$6/F+6/c&,6-&/0,/&/0+&1+$U2# +&34&12<0&<3F", 6?&26-+#&, 6&
]E!&.$%%&"#+M+6/&3#&3/0+#.$1+&%$F$/&-,F,7+&/3&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&1/,>$%$ /?&34&/0+&W6$/+-&=/,/+1&B,6,%?1$1&F21/&
&
&
)e&
<361$-+#& /0+& +44+</$ M+6+11& 34& 12 <0& 1+$U2#+& $6& F$/$7,/$67& /0+& "3 /+6/$,%& ,-M+#1+ & + 44+</1& 36& /0+& 4$6,6<$,%&
1?1/+FX&/0+&< 31/&34&12<0&#+13%2/$36&/3&/0+&7+6+ #,%&426-&3 4&/0+&L#+,12#?X &,6-&/0+&"3/+6/$,%&34&1 2<0&1+$U2#+&
,6-&#+13%2/$36&43#&$6 <#+,1$67&+T<+ 11$M+&#$1P&/,P$67&73$67&43#.,#-D8&&
N6&/0+&M$+.&34&l3102,&C316+ #&B'())DX&/0+#+&$1&,&426-,F+6 /,%&4%,.&$6&/0+&]E!&"#3<+11&<,21+-&>?&/ 0+&4,</&

/0,/& $/& <#+,/+1& /.3& -$44+#+6/& #+7$F+1& 26-+#& .0$<0& ,& % ,#7+& 4$6 ,6<$,%& 4$#F& <,6 & >+& .3 26-& 2"_& /#,-$/$36,%&
>,6P#2"/<?&,6-&/0+&]E! 8&R+&63/+1&/0,/&/0+&M,%2+&34&, &4$#F&$6&$/1&Y73$67&<36<+#6Z&1/,/+ &$1&-+"+6-+6/&36&
/0+&#+13%2/$36&"#3<+11&+F"%3?+-&.0+6&$/&4,$%18&!%%&6364$6,6< $,%&4$#F 1&,6-&F31 /&4$6,6<$,%&$61/ $/2/$361&21+&
/0+&\,6P#2"/< ?&G3-+c&<3FF+#<$,%&>,6P1&21+&/0+&5+-+#,%&Q+"31$/&N612#,6<+&!</c &>#3P+#:-+,%+#1&21+&/0+&
=+<2#$/$+1&N6M+1/3#&*#3/+</$36&!</8&L0+#+&F,?&> +&-$44+#+6/&1?1/+F1 &43#&-$44+#+6/&/? "+1&34&4$#F1X&>2/&/0+#+&
,#+ &63/X&,6-&/0+#+&1032%-&63/&>+X&F 2%/$"%+&"#3<+11 +1&43#&/0+&1,F+&4$#F8&N6&12FX&/0+&, >13%2/+&.3#1/&/0$67&
/0,/&#+72%,/3#1& <,6& -3& $1& +T,</%?& .0,/& /0+?S#+& -3$67&63._& 1$76,%$67&/3&/0+& " 2>%$<&,6-& /0+& F,#P +/1X& +T&
,6/+X& .0$<0& 4$#F1& .$%%& <,21+& 1?1/+F$<& $61/,> $%$/?& ,6-& /0+6& "#3M$-$67& ,& W=& L#+,12#?q 426-+-& >,$%32/&
1<0+F+& /0#3270& /0+& ]#-+#%?& E$a2$-, /$36& !2/03# $/?8& V0+ #+& $6M+1/3#1& 0,M+& 7#+ ,/& <+#/,$6/?& ,6-& <%, #$/?&
,>32/&/0+&.3#P$671&34&/0+ &W=&>,6P#2"/<?&"#3<+11X&/0+&]E!S 1&-,67+#321&12>^+</$M$/?X&$6<#+,1+- &3",<$/?X&
"#+4+#+6<+& 43#& 103#/:/+#F& <#+-$/3#1X& ,6-& ,F>$72$/?&$6&03 .& $/&.$%%&/# +,/& 1$F$%,#%?& 1$/2,/+-& <#+-$/3#1& .$%%&
36%?&$6<#+,1+&/0+&26<+#/,$6/?&,F367&<#+-$/3#1&34&,&4,$%$67&$61/$/2/$36&,6-&<,21+&6+<+11,#?&#$1P&<,"$/,%&/3&
",21+&,/&"#+<$1+%?&/0+&/$F+&/0$1&<,"$/,%&$1&F31/& 6++-+-8&
L0+&]E!&"#3M$1$36&,%13&F,6-, /+1&/0,/&/0+&4$6,6 <$,%&$6-21/#?&",?&B,4/+#&/0+&4,</D&43#&/0+&<31/1&34 &,6?&12<0&
-$113%2/$36&,</$M $/?&26-+#/,P+6&>?&/0+&5 QNG8&L0+&"3.+#1&7#,6/+-&/3&/0+&5QNG&,1&/0+&%$a2$-,/3#&,#+&/021&
M+#?&1$F$%,#&/3&/031 +&<2##+6/%?&$6&21 +&43#&$612#+-&$61/$/2/$361 X&$6<%2-$67X&.0+#+&6+<+11,#?X&/0+&,> $%$/?&/3&
<36/$62+&/0+&3"+#,/$361&34&,&-+1$76,/+- &$61/$/2/$36&>?&F+,61&34&,6&26+6<2F>+#+ -&>#$-7+&>,6P8&L0+&!</&
+F "3.+#1& /0+& 5QNG& /3& +1/,>%$10& 12<0& #2%+1& ,6-& #+72% ,/$361& ,1& $/& -++F1& 6+<+11,#?& 3#& ,""#3"#$,/+& 43#&
$F"%+F+6/$67& ,6& ]E!8& L0$1& $1& 36+& ,#+,& $6& .0$<0& $/1& 3"+#,/$361& <36<+#6$67& $612#+-& ,6-& 636$612#+-&
-+1$76,/+-&$61/$/2/$361&.$%%&-$44+#8&N6&$/1&#+13%2/$36&34&63#F,% %?&$612#+-&-+"31$/,#?&$61/$/2/$361X&/0+&5QNG&
0,1&<361$ -+#+ -&/0+&,11+/1&/#,614+ ##+-&>?&,6?&$61/$/2/$36&/3&,6&,#FS1:%+ 67/0 &=*n&M$,&1/#2</2#+-&4$6,6<$67&
1+< 2#$/$U,/$36&,1&<% ,$F,>%+&>?&1+<2#+-&<#+-$/3#18 &R3.+M+#X &/0+&5QNG&0,1&$6-$<,/+ -&/0,/&$/&-3+1&63/&$6/+6-&
/3& ,""%?&/0$1& " #3<+-2#+&$6& $F"% +F+6/$67&/0 +&6+.& ]E!X& /021&"#3/+</$67& ,11+/1&/#,614+##+-&/3 & ,& 1"+<$,%&
+6/$/?&4#3F&/0+&% $a2$-,/$368&
]6+&34&/0+ &-$44$<2%/$+1&4,<+-&>? &/0+&5QN G&$6&-+,%$67&.$/0&/0+&#+13%2/$36&34&%,#7+&>,6 P1&$1&/0+&%$F$/+-&1$U+&34&
/0+&-+"31$/&$612#,6<+&426-18&Bl21/&% $P+&/0+&5+-+#,%&=,M$671&,6-&E3,6&N612#,6<+&G3 #"3#,/$36&$6&/0+&)e9(1rD&
V0$%+&/0+&2%/$F,/+&132#<+&34&42 6-1&$1&/0+&4+-+#,%&73M+#6F+6/X&,6-&/021&/0+&5+-+#,%&C+1+#M+X&/0+&$-+,&$1&
/0,/&$/&1032%-&>+&1+%4:4$6,6<$67X&>,1+-&36&$612#,6<+&"#+F$,&<0,#7+-&/3&/0+&$612#+ -&$61/$/2/$3618&@$M+6&/0+&
%+$/F3/$4& 34& /0+& !</& /3& +% $F$6,/+& /0+& 21+ & 34& "2>% $<& 426 -1& /3& #+1<2+& /0+& 4$6,6<$ ,%& 1?1/+FX& Q3 :5#,6P&
F, 6-,/+1&F+,12#+1&/3&$6<#+,1+&/0+&1$U+&3 4&/0+&$612#,6<+&426-X&,1&. +%%&,1&F+,12#+1&/3&,-,"/&/0+&"#+F$,&

/3&/0+&#$1P&/0,/&$61/$/2/$361&$6/#3-2<+&$ 6/3&/0+&1?1/+F8&&
L0+& !</X& $6& 1+</$36& ;;JX& /021& # ,$1+1& /0+& F$6$F2F& -+1$76,/+-& #+1+#M+& #,/$3& 34& 426-& ,11+/1 & /3& $612#+-&
-+"31$/ 1&BQCCD X&.0$<0&/0+&5QNG&F21/&1+/&+,<0&?+,#X&/3&)8;H&"+#<+6/&B4#3F&/0+&43#F+#&F$6$F2F&34&)8)H&
"+#<+6/DX& ,6-& #+F3M+-& /0+& 2""+#& %$F$/& 36& /0+& QCC& B.0$ <0& .,1& 43#F +#%?& <,""+-& ,/& )8H& "+#<+6/D& ,6-&
/0+#+43#+&36&/0+&1$U+&34&/0+&426-c&#+a2$#+-&/0,/&/0+&426-&#+1+#M+&#,/$3&#+,<0&)8;H&"+#<+6/&>?&=+"/+F>+#&
&
&
'(&
;(X&'('( &B#,/0+#&/0,6&)8)H&"+#<+6/&>?&/0+&+6-&34&'()KX&,1&43#F+#%?&1/$"2 %,/+-Dc&#+a2$#+-&/0,/X&$6&1+//$67&
,11+11F+6/1X& /0+& 5QNG& 34 41+/& /0+& +44+</& 34 & #+a2$# $67& /0,/& /0+& #+1+#M+& #,/$3& #+,<0& )8;H& "+#<+6/& >?&
=+"/+F>+#& ;(X& '('(X&#,/0+#& /0,6&)8)H& "+#<+6/& >?& /0+& +6-& 34& '()KX& 36& $612#+-& -+"31$/3#?& $61/$/2/$361&
.$/ 0&/3/,%&<3613%$-,/+-&,11+/1&34&%+11&/0,6&s)(X(((X(((X(((c&+%$F$6,/+-&/0+&#+a2$#+F+6/&/0,/&/0+&5QNG&
"#3M$-+&-$M$-+6-1&4#3F&/0+&426-&.0+6&/0+&#+1+#M+&#,/$3&$1&>+/.++6&)8;H &"+#<+6/&,6-&)8H&"+#<+6/c&,6-&
F, $6/,$6+-& /0+& 5QNGS1&,2/03#$/?& /3&-+<%,#+&-$M$-+ 6-1& .0+6& /0+& #+1+# M+& #,/$3& ,/&/0+&+6-&34&,& <,%+6-,#&
?+,#&$1&,/&%+,1/&)8H&"+# <+6/X&$6&, $/$36&/3&7# ,6/$67&/0+&5QNG&13%+&-$1<#+/$36&$6&-+/+#F$6$67&. 0+/0+#&/ 3&
121 "+6-& 3#& %$F$/& /0+& -+<%,#,/$36& 3#& ",?F+ 6/& 34& -$M$-+6-18 & L0+& 5QNG& 0,1& ,</+-& /3& +T<++-& /0+&
#+a2$#+F+6/1&34&/0+&!</X&#,$1$67&/0+&QCC&/3&'&"+#<+6/&$6& '())8&
L0+& !</& ,%13& #+a2$# +1& /0,/& /0+& 5QNG& ,F+6-& $/1& #+72%,/$361& /3& #+-+4$6+& /0+& ,1 1+11F+6/& >,1+& 2 1+-& 43#&
<,%<2%,/$67& -+"31$/& $612#,6 <+& ,11+11F+6/18& W6-+#& Q3 :5#,6PX& /0+& ,11+11F+6/& >,1+& F21/X& .$/0& 13F+&
"311$>%+& +T<+"/$361X& +a2,%& ,M+#,7+& <3613%$-,/+-& /3/,%& ,11+/1& F$621& ,M+#,7+& /,67$>%+& +a2$/?8& L0+& 5QNG&
0,1& "#3"31+-& +%$F$6,/$67& #$1P& <,/+73#$+1& ,6-& /0+& 21+& 34& %367:/+#F& -+>/& $112+#& #,/$671& 43#& %, #7+&
$61/$/2/$361X& 21$67& ,& 1 <3#+<,#-& F+/03-& /3& <,%<2%,/+& ,11+11F+ 6/& #, /+1& 43#& %,#7+& , 6-& 0$70%?& <3F"%+T&
$61/$/2/$361X& ,6-& #+/,$6$ 67& /0+& ,>$%$/?& /3& F,P+& ,& %$F$/+-& ,-^21/F+6/& ,4/+#& <361$-+ #$67& $643#F,/$36& 63/ &
$6<%2-+ -&$6&/0+&1<3#+<,#-8&L0+&4$6,%&#2%+&.$%%&-+4$6+&, &%,#7+&$61/$/2/$36&,1&,6&$612#+-&-+" 31$/3#?&$ 61/$/ 2/$36&
/0,/&0,-&,11+/1&34&s)(&>$%%$36&3 #&F3#+&,1&34&Q+<+F>+#&;)X&'((K&B26%+11X&>?&#+"3#/$67&,11+/1&34&%+11&/0,6&
s)(&>$%%$36&43#&432#&<361 +<2/$M+&a2,#/+#1&1$6<+& /0+6X&$/&0,1&>+<3F+&,&1F,%%&$61/$/2/$ 36Dc&3#&/0, /&0,-&,11+/1&
34&%+11&/0,6&s)(&> $%%$36&,1&34&Q+<+F>+#&; )X&'((KX&>2/&0,1 &1$6<+&0+%-&s)(&>$%%$36&3#&F3#+&$6&/3/,%&,11+/1&43#&
,/&%+,1/&432#&<361+<2/$ M+&a2,#/+#1X&.0+/0+#&3#&63/&/0+&$61/$/ 2/$36&$1&6+.8&N6&,%F31/&,%%&<,1+1X&,6&$612#+-&
-+"31$/ 3#?&$61/$/2/$36&/0,/&0,1&0+%-&s)(&>$%%$36&3 #&F3#+&$6&/3/,% &,11+/1&43#&432#&<361+<2/$M+&a2,#/+#1&.$%%&
0,M+&,&G!ObE= &#,/$ 67c&03.+M+#X &$6&/0+&#,#+&+M+6/&/0,/&12<0&,6&$61/$/2/$3 6&0,1&63/&?+/&#+<+$M+-&,&G!ObE=&

#,/$67X& $/& .$%%& >+& 7$M+6& ,& .+$70/+-& ,M+#,7+& G!ObE=& #,/$6 7& 34& '& 43#& ,11+1 1F+6/& "2#"31+1& 26/$%& ,</2,%&
G!ObE=&#,/$671&,#+&,11$76+-8&!6&$612#+-&>#,6<0&34&,&43#+$76&>,6P&$1&+T<%2-+-&4#3F&/ 0+&- +4$6$/$36&34&,&
%,#7+&$61/$/2 /$368
H
&&
]6&/0+&$612#, 6<+&"#3M$-+-&>?&/0+&Q+"31$/3 #1&N612#,6<+&526-X&/0+&!</&<,%%1&$6&/0+&5QNG&/3&42%%?&$612#+ &/0+&
6+/&,F326/&/0,/&,6?&F+F>+#&3#&-+"31$/3#&,/& ,6&$61 2#+-&<#+-$/&26$3 6&F,$6/,$61&$6&,&636$6/+#+1/:>+,#$67&
/#,61,</$36&,<<3 26/8&=2<0&,F326/&10,%%&63/&>+&/,P+6&$6/3&, <<326/&. 0+6&<3F"2/$67&/0+&6+/&,F326/&-2+&
/3& 12<0& F+F>+#& 3#& -+"31$/3#8& L0+& 63#F,%& $612#,6<+& %+M+%& #+F,$61& ,/& s'H(X(((& 43#& +,<0& 1+",#,/+X&
63#F,%&$6/+#+1/: >+,# $67&,<<326/8&
O,6?&<3FF+6/ ,/3#1&0,M+&1277+1/+-&/0,/&.0$%+&/0+&5QNG&.,1&26.$%%$67&/3&$6/+#M+6+&/3&#+13%M+&Y/33&>$7&
/3&4,$%Z&$61/$/2/$361X&$/&.,1& <+#/,$6%?&,> %+&/3&-3&138&L0$1&"31$/$36&0,1&>++6&F,-+&M+#?&43#<+42%%?&>?&L03F, 1&
R3+6$7& B'((eDX& "#+1$-+6/& 34& /0+& 5+-+#,%& C+1+#M+& Q$1/#$</& \,6P & 34& i,61,1& G$/?X& 36& /0+& >,1$1& 34& 0$1&
+T"+#$+6<+&$6&-+,%$67&.$/0&/0+&#+13%2/$36 &34&G36/$6+ 6/,%&N%%$63$1 &\,6P8&L3&4,<$%$/,/+&/0+&,>$%$/?&34&/0+&5QNG&
/3&-+,%&.$/0&/0+1+&M+#?&%,#7+&4$6, 6<$,%&$61/$/2/$361&B.0$<0X&,1&,%#+,-?&63/+-X&Q3 :5#,6P&<361$-+#1&,&4,</&
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
H
&W=& C+72% ,/3#1&21+&,&#,/$67&1<,%+&34&)&/3&H&>,1+- &36&,&1+#$+1&34&$6 -$<,/3#1&/3&,11+1 1&/0+&1326-6+11&34&,&>,6P8&L0+?&
$6<%2-+&BGD&<,"$/,%&,-+a2,<?X&B!D&,11+/&a2,%$/?X&B OD&F,6,7+F+6/X&BbD&+,#6$6 71X&&BE D&%$a2$-$/?X&,6-&B=D&1+61$/$M$/?&/3&
F,# P+/&#$1P8&
&
&
')&
34& %$4+DX& /0+& !</& F,6-,/+ 1&/0+&43#F2%,/$36& 34&13:<,%%+-& Y%$M$67&.$%%1Z& $6& /0+& 43#F&34& /0+& "#+",#,/$ 36& 34&
#+13%2/$36&"%,61 &,6-&<#+-$/&+T"312#+&#+"3# /18&&
L0+&!</&< ,%%1&2"36&/0+&\3,#-&34&@3M+#63#1&34&/0+&5+-&/3&#+a2$#+&636>,6P&4$6,6<$,%&<3F",6$+1&,6-&>,6P&
03%-$67& <3F",6$+1& /0,/& $/ & 12"+#M$1+1& /3& "+#$3-$<,%% ?& #+"3#/& /0 +& "% ,6& 34& 12<0& <3F",6?& 43#& #,"$-& ,6-&
3#-+#%?&#+13%2/$36&$6&/0+&+M+6/&34&F,/+#$,%&4$6,6<$, %&-$1/# +11&3# &4 ,$%2#+X&.0$<0&10,%%&$6<%2-+_&$643#F,/$36&
#+7,#-$67& /0+& F,66+#& ,6-& +T/+6/& /3& . 0$<0& ,6?& $612# +-& -+"31$/3#?& $61/$/2/$36& ,44$%$,/ +-& .$/0& /0+&
<3F",6?&$1&,-+a2,/+%?&"#3/+</+-&4#3F&#$1P1&,#$1$67&4#3F&/0+&, </$M$/$+1&34&,6?&636>,6P&12>1$ -$,#$+1&3 4&/0+&

<3F",6?c&42%%&-+1<#$"/$361&34&/0+&3.6+#10$"&1/#2</2#+X&,11+/ 1X&%$,>$%$/$+1X&,6 -&<36/#,</2, %&3>%$7,/$361 &34 &
/0+&<3F",6?c&$-+6/$4$<,/$36&34& /0+&<#311:72,#,6/++1&/$+-&/3&-$44+#+6/&1+< 2#$/$+1c&$-+6/$4$<,/$36&34&F,^3#&
<326/+#",#/ $+1c&,6-&,&"#3<+11 &43#&-+/+#F$6 $67&/3&.03F&/0+&<3%%,/+#,%&34&/0+&<3F",6?&$1&"%+-7+-8&&
N6& , $/$36X& / 0+& !</& <,%%1& 43#& <#+ -$/& +T"312#+& #+"3#/1& <3M+#$67& /0+& 6,/2#+& ,6-& +T/+6/& /3& .0$<0& /0+&
<3F",6?& 0,1& <#+-$/& +T"312#+& /3& 3/0+#& 1$76$4$<,6/& 636>,6P& 4$ 6,6<$,%& <3F",6$+1& , 6-& 1$76$4$<,6/& >,6P&
03%-$67&<3F",6$+1X&,6-&/0+&6,/2#+&,6-&+T/+6/&/3&.0$<0&3/0+#&1$76$4$<,6/&63 6>,6P&4$6,6<$,%&<3F",6$+1&
,6-&1$76$4$<,6/&>,6P&03%-$67&<3F",6$+1&0,M+&< #+-$/&+T" 312#+&/3&/0,/&<3F",6?8&
L0+&5+-&,6-&/0+&5QNG&.$%%&#+M$+.&/0+1+&#+"3#/1X&,6-&$4X&>,1+-&36&/0+$#&#+M$+.X&/0+&#+13%2/$36&"%,6&34&,&
636>,6P& 4$6, 6<$,%& <3F",6? & 12"+#M$1+-& >?& /0+& \3,#-& 34& @3M+#63#1& 3#& ,& >,6P& 03%-$67& <3F",6?& $1& 63/&
<#+-$>%+&3#&.32%-&63/&4,<$%$/,/+ & , 6&3#-+#%?&#+13%2/$3 6&34&/0+&<3F",6?X&10,%%&63/$4?&/0+&<3F",6?&34&/0+&
-+4$<$+6<$+1&$6&/0+&#+1 3%2/$36&" %,6c&/0+&<3F",6?&10,%%&#+12>F$/ &/0+ &#+13%2/$ 36&"%,6&.$/0$6&,&/$F+4#,F+&
-+/+#F$6+-&>?&/0+&5+-&,6-&/0+&5QNG&.$/0&#+M$1$361&-+F361/#,/ $67&/0,/&/0+&"%,6&$ 1&<#+-$>%+&,6-&.32% -&
#+12%/& $6& ,6& 3#-+#%?& #+13%2/$36X& $6<%2-$67& ,6?& "# 3"31+-& <0,67+1& $6& >21$6+11& 3" +#,/$361& ,6-& <3#"3#,/+&
1/#2</2#+&/3&4,<$%$/,/+&$F"%+F+6/,/$36 &34&/0+&"%,68&
L0+&Y%$ M$67&.$%%Z&$1&/ 021&-+1$76+-&/3&103.&+T&,6/+&/0,/&13F+&4$#F1&,#+&/33&>$7&/3&4,$%X&,6-&.$%%&<%+,#%?&"2/&
/0+&F,^3# &>2#-+6&36&%,#7+&F2%/$426</$36&> ,6P1 &.$/0&<3F"%+T&7%3>,%&3"+#,/$361X&12<0&,1&G$/$7#32"X&\,6P&
34&!F+#$<,X&l*O3#7,6&G0,1+X& @3%-F,6& = ,<01 X&,6-&O3#7,6&= /,6%+?8&L0+&0+,-& 34&/0+&5Q NG&0,1&#+<+6/%?&
1277+1/+-&/0,/&/0+&$6,>$%$/?&34&,&>$7&>,6P&/3&"#3M$-+&,&<#+-$>%+&#+13%2/$36&"%,6&.32%-&>+&,&<36-$/$36&43#&
#+a2$#$67&/0,/&$/&>+&># 3P+6&2"&>?&/0+&/#,6143#F,/$36&34&$/1&43 #+$76&3"+#,/$361 &$6/3&43#+$76&12>1 $-$,#$+1&
12>^+</&/3&43#+$76&#+72 %,/3#1X&$6&3#-+#&/3&#+,%$76&$/1&%+7,%&1/#2</2#+&,6-X&$4&6+<+11,#?X&F,P+&$/&+,1$+#&43#&
#+72%,/3#1&/3&%$a2$-,/+&/0 +&>,6P8&Y N4&/0+?&<,6t/&1 03.&/0+?&<,6&>+&#+13%M+-&$6&,&>,6P #2"/<?:%$P+&" #3<+11&8&8&8&
/0+6&/0+?&1032%-&>+&- 3.61$U+-&63.XZ&1,$-&5QNG&G0,$#F,6&=0+$%,&G8&\,$#&Ba23/+-&$6&G%,#P&'())D8&L0+&,$F&
34& 3#-+#%?& %$a2$-,/$36& $1& /3& ,M3$-& ,& #+"+,/& 34& '((9X& .0+6& /0+& \210& ,-F$6$1/#,/$36& >,$%+-& 32/& !N@& ,6-&
3/0+#&4$#F1&>2/&63/&E +0F ,6&\#3/0+#18&E+0F,6t1&>,6P#2"/<?&M$#/2,%%?&4#3U+&<,"$/,%&F,#P +/18&
!1&.$%%&>+&1++6&$6&<0 ,"/+ #&'X&O$61P?&,%.,?1&"#3F3/+-&1F,%%+ #&>,6P$67&$61/$/2/$361&,1&,&.,?&/3&+612#+&
%3<,%&F,6,7+F+6/&,6-&%3<,%&P63.%+-7+&<32%-&>+&21+-&$6&/0+ &,11+11F+6/& 34&<#+-$/ .3#/0$6+118&R+&4,M3#+-&
/0+& $F"31$/$36& 34& /0 +& 3#$7$6 ,/+:,6-:03%-& >,6P$67& F3-+%X& .0$<0& .32%- & 0,M+& $6<+6/$M+& 1/#2</2#+1& /0,/&
"#3F3/ +-& 4$6,6<$,%& 1/,>$%$/?& #,/0+#& /0,6& #$1P& /,P$678 & 5$6,%%?X& 0+& >+%$+ M+-& /0,/& "#3F3/$36& 34& 1F,%%:/3:
F+ -$2F:1$U+-& 4$6,6<$,%& $61/$/ 2/$361& .32%-& >+& F3#+& <361$1/+6/& .$/0& ,& 7+6+#,%& "3% $<?& >$,1+-& ,7,$61/&
<36<+6/#,/$36&34&+<363F $<&"3.+#[$6&>3/0&/0+ &4$6,6<$,%&,6-&6364$6,6<$,%&1+</3#18&R+&.32%-&/021&0,M+&

>++6&%+11&.$%%$67&/3&+F"0,1$U+&,6&]E!&,6-&#+13%2/$36&"%,61&,6-&F3#+&$6&4, M3#&34&>#+,P$67&2"&/0+&%,#7+&
&
&
''&
4$6,6<$,%& 03%-$67& <3 F", 6$+18& N/& $1& $6/+#+1/$67& /0,/& 26-+# & @%,11:=/+,7,%%X& >,6P1& .+#+& 7$M+6& 36+& ?+,#& /3&
-$M+1/& /0 +F1+%M+1& 34& /0+$#& 1+<2#$ /$+1& ,44$%$, /+1& ,6-& 3/0+ #& "#30$ >$/+-& ,</$M$ /$+1X& ,6-& /0+#+& .+#+& 63&
-$44$<2%/$+1&$6&F++/$67&/0$1&/$F+/,>%+8&
G.!Prov ision!of!li quid ity!
L0+&F, $6&$61/#2F+6/&34&5+-+#,%&C+1+#M+&12""3#/&-2#$67&/0+&<#$1$1&.,1&$/1&,2/03#$/?&/3&3"+6&/0+&- $1<326/&
.$6-3.&$6&2#7+6/&,6-&+T$7+6/&<$#<2F1/,6<+1X&,1&1/$"2%,/+-&$6&1+</$3 6&);B;D&34&/0+&5+-+#,%&C+1+#M+&!</X&/3&
M$#/2,%%?&,6?&4$6,6 <$,%&3 #&6364$6,6<$,% &$61/$/2/$3 6&,7,$61/&M$#/2,%%?&,6?&/?"+&34&<3%%,/+#,%8&!1&,&#+12%/&34& /0+&
+T"#+11&-+1$#+&34&G367# +11&/3&+612#+&/0,/&63&1 2""3#/&>+&7$M+6&/3&4,$%$67&4$6,6<$,%&$ 61/$/ 2/$361X&/0+&Q3 :
5#, 6P& !</& 1++P1& /3& +612#+& /0 ,/& /0+& 5+-S1& -$1<#+/$36& /3& "#3M$-+& +F+#7+6<?& 12""3#/& /3& $613%M+6/&
$61/$/2/$361&-3+1 &63/&<$#<2FM+6/&,6&]E!8&L0+&!</&/ 021&<,%%1&36&/0+&\3,#-&34&@3M+#63#1X&Y$6&< 3612%/,/$36&
.$/ 0& /0+& =+<#+/,#?& 34& /0+& L#+,12#?X& /3& +1/,>%$10& /0+& "3%$<$+1& ,6-& "#3<+-2#+1& /3& +612#+& /0,/& ,6?&
+F +#7+6<?&%+6 -$67&"# 37#,F&3#&4,<$%$/?&$1&43#&/0 +&"2#"31+&34&"# 3M$-$67&%$a2$-$/?&/3&/0+&4$6,6< $,%&1?1/+FX&
,6-& 63/& /3& ,$-& ,& 4,$%$67& 4$6,6<$,%& <3F" ,6?X& ,6-& /0,/& /0+& 1+<2#$/?& 43#& +F+#7+6< ?& %3,61& $1& 1244$< $+6/& /3&
"#3/+</&/,T",?+#1&4#3F&%311+1&,6-&/0,/&,6?&12<0&"#37#,F&$1&/+#F$6,/+ -&$6&,&/$F+%?&,6-&3#-+#%?&4,10$368&
L0+&"3%$<$+1&,6-&"#3<+-2#+1&+1/,>%$10+-&>?&/0+&\3,#-&10,%%&#+a2$#+&/0, /&,&5 +-+# ,%&#+ 1+#M+&>,6P&,11$76X&
<361$1/+6/&.$/0&1326-&#$1P&F,6,7+F+6/&"#,</$<+1&,6-&/3&+612#+&"#3/+</$36&43#&/0+&/ ,T",?+#X&,&%+6-,>%+&
M,%2+&/3&,%%&<3%%,/+#,%&43#&,&%3,6&+T+<2/+-&>?&,&5+-+#,%&#+1+#M+&>,6PZ&B=+<8&))( )d,fD 8&&
N6&, $/$36X&/0+&!</&#+a2 $#+1&/0+&5+-&/3&+1/,>%$10&"#3<+-2#+1&/3 &"#30$>$/&>3##3.$ 67&4#3F&"#37 #,F1&,6-&
4,<$%$/$+1&>?& $613% M+6/& >3##3.+# 18&52#/0+#X&$/& %$F$/1&/0+ & ,>$%$/?&34 & /0+& \3,#-&/3& +1/,> %$10& ,6?& +F+#7+6<?&
4,<$%$/?& .$/0 32/&/0+&"#$3#&,""#3M,%&34&/0+&L#+,12#?&1+<#+/,#?X&,6-X&$4&,""#3M,%&$1&3>/,$6 +-X&/ 3&#+"3#/& .$/0 $6&
1+M +6&-,?1&/3&/0+&=+6,/+&G3FF$//++&3 6&\,6P$67X&R321$6 7X&, 6-&W#>,6&!44,$#1&,6-&/0+&R321+&G3FF$//++&
36& 5$6,6 <$,%& =+#M$<+1X& "#3M$-$67& /0+& ^21/$4$<,/ $36& 43#& /0+& ,11$1/,6<+c& /0+& $-+6/$/?& 34& /0+& #+<$"$+6/1c& /0+&
-,/+X& ,F326/X& ,6-& 43#F& $6& .0$<0& /0+& ,11$1/,6<+& .,1& "#3M$-+-c& ,6-& <3F"%+/+ & ",# /$<2% ,#1& 34& /0+&
,11$1/,6<+8&L0+&",#/$<2%,#1&$6<%2-+&-2#,/$36c&<3%%,/+#,%&"%+-7+-&,6-&/0+&M,%2+&/0+#+34c&,%%&$6/ +#+1/X&4++1X&
,6-&3/0+#& #+M+62+& 3#&$/+F1& 34&M,%2+& /3&>+& #+<+$ M+-& $6&+T<0,67+& 43#& / 0+& , 11$1/,6<+c&,6?&#+a2$#+F+6/1&
$F"31+-& 36& /0+& #+<$"$+6/& .$/0& #+ 1"+< /& /3& +F"%3?++& <3F"+61,/$36X& -$1/#$>2/$36& 34& -$M$-+6-1X& 3#& ,6?&

3/0+#& <3#"3#,/+& -+<$1$36& $6& +T<0,67+& 43#& /0+ & ,1 1$1/, 6<+c& /0+& +T"+</+-& <31/1& /3& /0+& /,T",?+#1& 34& 12<0&
,11$1/,6<+c&,6-&1$F$%,#&$ 643#F,/$ 36&.$ /0&#+1 "+</&/3&,6?&32/1/,6-$67&%3 ,6&3#&3/0+#&4$6,6<$,%&,11$1/,6<+X&/3&
>+&#+"3#/+-&+M+#?&;(&-,?18&&
!6-&$4&12<0&#+"3 #/$67&.+#+&63/&1244$<$+6/X&/0+&!</&7$M+1&/0+&<3F"/#3%%+#&7+6+#,%&34&/0+&W6$/+-&=/,/+1&/0+&
"3.+#&/3&<36-2</&,2-$/1X&$6<%2-$67&361$/+&+T,F$6,/$361X&34&/0+&\3,#-&34&@3M+#63#1X&,&5+-+#,%&C+1+#M+&
\,6PX&3#&,&<#+-$/&4,<$%$/?X&$4&/0+&<3F"/#3% %+#&-+/+# F$6+1&/0,/&12<0&,2-$/1&,#+&,""#3"#$,/+X&13%+%?&43#&/0+&
"2#"31+&34&,11+11$67X&.$/0&#+1"+</&/3&,&<#+-$/&4, <$%$/?&3#&,&<3M+#+-&/#,61,</$36X&/0+&3" +#,/$36,%&$6/+7#$/ ?X&
,<<326/$67X&4$6,6<$,%&#+"3#/$6 7X&,6-&$6/ +#6, %&<36/#3%1&73M+#6$67&/0+&<#+ -$/&4,<$%$/?&3#&<3M+#+-&/#,61,</$36c&
/0+&+44+</$M+6+11&34&/0+&1+<2#$/?&,6-&<3%%,/+#,%&"3%$<$+1&+1/,>%$10+-&43#&/0+&4,< $%$/?&3 #& <3M+#+-&/# ,61,</$36&
$6&F$/$7,/$67&#$1P&/3&/0+&#+%+M,6/&5+-+#,%&C+1+#M+&\,6P&,6-&/,T",?+#1c&.0+/0+# &/0+&<#+-$/&4,<$%$/?&3#&/0+&
<36-2</& 34& ,& <3M+#+-& /#, 61,< /$36& $6,""#3"#$,/+ %?& 4,M3#1& 36+& 3#& F3#+& 1"+<$4$<& ",#/$<$",6/1& 3M+#& 3/0+#&
$61/$/2/$361& +%$7$>%+& /3& 2/$%$U+&/0+& 4,<$%$/?c& ,6-& /0+& "3%$<$+1& 73M+#6$67& /0+& 21+X&1+%+</$36X& 3#& ",?F+6/& 34&
/0$#-:",#/?&<36/#,</3#1&>?&3#&43#&,6?&<#+-$/&4,<$%$/?&3#&/3&<36-2</&,6?&<3M+#+-&/#,61 ,</$368&
&
&
';&
5#3F&0$1&M+#?&+,#%?&.3#P&36&/0+&#+43#F&34&/0+&5+-&- $1<326/&. $6-3.X&O$61P?&,#72+-&/0,/&/0+&+F+#7+6<?&
,</$361&"#3M$-+-&>?&1+</ $36&);B;D&1032%-&>+&F,-+&"+#F,6+6/&,6-&",#/&34&/0+&3#-$6,#?&3"+#,/$36&34&/0+&
-$1<326/&.$6-3.8&53#&O$61 P?X&/0+&#+ ,136&.,1&a2$/+&3>M$321_&/0+#+&$1&36%?&36+&4$6,6<$,%&$61/$/2/$36&/0,/&
-3+1& 63/& 4,<+& ,& %$a2$-$/?& <361/#,$6/X& ,6-& /0,/& $1& /0+& 5+-+#,%& C+1+#M+8& ! 1& G0,$#F,6& \+#6,6P+& 0,1&
#+$/+#,/+-X& /0+& 5+-& 0,1 & /0+& ,> $%$/?& /3& "#3M$-+ & %$a2$-$/?& ,/& /0+& "210& 34& ,& <3F"2/+#& P+?8& N6 & ,& <3F"%+TX&
%,?+#+-&4$ 6,6<$,%&1?1/+F&$6&.0$<0&+M+#?&$61/$/2/$36S1&%$,>$%$/$+1&F21/&0,M+&, &0$70+#&%$a2$-$/?&"#+F$2F&/0,6&
$/1&,11+/1X&,%%&$61/$/2/$361&2%/$F,/+%?&#+%?&36&/0+&>,6P$67&1?1/+F&43#&12""3#/&$6&/0+&<,1+&34&,&103#/4,%%&3 4&
<,1 0&$64%3. 1&,6-&/0+&6++-&/3&#+4$6,6<+&/0+$ #&%$,> $%$/$+18&!6-&/0+&>,6P$67&1?1/+F&#+%$+1&36&/0+&5+-8 &L021X&
%$F$/$67&-$1<326/&%+6-$67&/3&/0+&>,6P1&F+,61&,%%3.$67&,&%$a2$-$/?&<#$1$1&/3&F3#"0&$6/3&,6&$613%M+6<?&<#$1 $1&
$6& /0+& #+1/& 34& /0+& 4$6,6<$,%& 1?1/+F& >+43#+& $/& #+,<0+1& /0+& >,6P1& , 6-& ,< <+11& /3& /0+& - $1<326/& . $6-3.&
>+<3F+1&,6&3"/$368&\+/ /+#&/3&% +6-&-$#+</%?&/3&/0+&$61 /$/2/$361&4 ,<$67&%$a2$-$/? &-$44$<2%/$+18&N6-++-X&/0$1&$1&
.0,/&/0+&5+-&-$-&$6&/0+&<2##+6/&<#$1$1X&,6-&$/&$1&/0+&132#<+&34&/0+&<#$/$<$1F&/0,/&/0+ &,7+6<?&.,1&>,$%$67&32/&
$613%M+6/& $61/$/2/$3618& R3.+M+#X& /0+& "#3>%+F& .,1& /0,/& /0+& 5+-& +T/+6-+-& /0+& #+,<0& 34& /0+& -$1<326/&
.$6-3.&36%?& ,4/+#& ,& <#$1$1&> #3P+& 32/8& N/&"#3M$-+-&12""3#/&36%?&,4/+#&\+,#&=/+,#61&.,1&$6& - $44$<2%/?X& >2/&

/0+6&+T/+6-+-&12""3#/&/3&,%%&+a2$M,%+6/&$61/$/2/$3618&L0+&1,F+&.,1&/# 2+&$6&/0+&<,1+&34&E+0F,6X&.0$<0&
.,1&,%%3.+-&/3&4,$%[,6-&then&/0+&.$6-3.&.,1&3"+6+-&/3&3/0+#& >#3P +#:-+,%+ #&$6 1/$/2 /$3618&53#&O$61P?X&$/&
.32%-& 0,M+& >++6& F2<0&>+//+#&/3&3"+6&/0+&. $6-3.&/3& /0+1+&$61/$/2/$361&,1&,&F,//+#&34& <32#1+X&.0$<0&
F$70/&0,M+&"#+M+ 6/+-&/0+$#&-+<%$6+&$6/ 3&$613%M+6<?8&W1+&34&/0+&%$a2$-$ /?&4,<$%$/$+1&+,#%?&36&,%13&<32%-&0, M+&
>++6&F ,-+&/#,61",#+6/X&% +,M$67&/0+&5+ -&%+11&3"+6&/3&/0+&<#$/$<$1F&/0,/&$/&.,1&"$<P$67&.$66$67&,6-&%3 1+#18&
53#&O$61P?X&3"+6$67&/0+&.$6-3.&.32%-&0,M+&"#3 M$-+-&/0+&5+-&.$/0&,&Y.$6-3.Z&$6/3&/0+&3"+#,/$361&34&
/0+&$61/$/2/$ 361&1++P$67&1 2""3#/X&.0$<0&.32%-&0,M+&,%+#/+-& $/&F2<0&F3#+&a2$<P%?&/3&/0+&<36-$/$36& 34&/0+$#&
>,% ,6<+&10++/18& N61/+,-& 34& < 36/$62,%%?& ,#72$67& /0,/& /0+& <#$1$1& .,1& <36/,$6+-X& /0+& 5+-X& 0,-&$/& >++6& /0+&
%+6 -+#&/3&,%%&4$6,6<$,%&$61/$/2/$361X&.32% -&0,M+&P63.6&F2<0&+,#%$+#&03.&F2<0&/0+&-+<%$6+&$6 &0321+&"#$<+1&
,6-&/0+&F,#P+/1&43#&1+<2#$/$U+-&1/#2</2#+&0,-&$F",</+-&,%%&4$6,6<$,%&$61/$/2/$3 618&
H.!The!future!of !securitization:!Risk!re tention!
53#&F,6? X&,>21+&34&1+<2#$/$U,/$36&.,1&,/&/0+&#33/&34&/0+&4$6,6<$,%&<#$1$18&N/&.,1&<+#/,$6%?&,&<#2<$,%&",#/&34&
/0+&10$4/&/3&/0+&3# $7$6,/+:,6-:-$1/#$>2/+&>21$6+1 1&F3-+%&,-3"/+-&>?&F31/&%,#7+&4$6,6<$,%&$61/$/2/$361&,6-&
/0+&#$1+& 34&344&>,%,6<+&10++/& + 6/$/$+1&,6-&10,-3 .&>,6P18 & N/&,%13&.,1&,& 132#<+&34&1$76$ 4$<,6/&4#,2-2 %+6/&
,</$M$/?8&N/&$1&/0+#+43#+&63/&12#"#$1$67&/0,/& Q3 :5#,6P&!</&1032%-&"#3"31+ &#+72%,/$36&34& /0+1+&1/#2</2#+18&
R3.+M+#X&/0+&6+.&#+72%,/$361&,#+&63/&+T/+61$M+&,6-&,#+&%$F$/+-&/3&/ 0+&$F"31$/$36&34&#+a2$#+F+6/1&43#&
<#+-$/& #$1P& #+/+6/$36& #+a2$#+F+6/1& 34& 63/& %+11& /0,6& H& "+#<+6/& 43#& 1+<2#$/$U+#1& ,6-X& $6& <+#/,$6&
<$#<2F1/,6<+1X& 3#$7 $6,/3#1& 34& ,11+/:>,<P+-& 1+<2#$/$+18& N112+#1& 34& ,& h2,%$4$+-& C+ 1$-+6/$,%& O3#/7,7+& B/0+ &
<0,#,</+#$1/$<1&34&.0$<0&0,M+&?+/&/3&>+&-+4$6+-&>?&#+72%,/3#1D&3#&/0+&3#$ 7$6,/3#&34&/0+&,11+/ &/0,/&F++/1&
F$6$F2F& 26-+#.#$/$67 & 1/,6-, #-1& /3& >+& -+/+#F$ 6+-& >?& /0+& ,""# 3"#$,/+& #+72%,/3#?& ,7+6<$+1& .$%%& >+&
+T+F"/ &4#3F&/0+&#$1P&#+/+6/$36&#+ a2$#+F+6/8&L0$1&$1&>,1+-&36&/0+&"#+12F"/$36&/0,/&$4&>,6P1&0,-&#+/,$6+-&
13F+& #$1PX& /0+?& .32%-& 0,M+& >++6& F3#+& -$%$7+ 6/& $6& F36$/3#$67& /0+& a2,%$/?& 34& /0+ & F3#/7,7+1& /0,/& /0+?&
1+< 2#$/$U+-8&j+/X&$6&,</2,%&4,</X&36+&34&/0+&<,21+1&34&/0+ &%,#7+&%311+1&+T"+#$+6<+-&>?&$61/$/2/$361&+67,7+-&
$6& 1+<2#$/$U,/$36& .,1& /0,/& /0+?& 0,-& M3%26/,#$%?& #+/,$6+-& ,& 12>1/,6/$,%& , F326/& 34& $6M+1/F+6/:7#,-+&
&
&
'J&
/#,6<0+1&34&12>"#$F+&1+<2#$/$U,/$3 618&N6-++-X&$6&/0$1&<,1+X&0,M$67&1P$6&$6&/0+&7,F+&-$-&63/&%+, -&/3&7#+,/+#&
<36<+#6&43#&,11+ /&a2,%$/?& >2/&.,1X& #,/0+#X&,& <,21 +&34&$6<#+,1+-&$61/,>$%$/?8&
N6& ,& 1/2-?& "#+",#+-& 26-+#& /0+& F,6-,/+& $6& Q3 :5#,6PX& /0+& 5=]G&B'())D& 344+#1& 1+M+#,%& "#$6<$"%+1& ,6-&

#+<3FF+6-,/$361&/0,/&1032%-&$643#F&/0+&-+1$76&34&,&#$1P:#+/+6/$36&4#,F+.3#PX&13&,1&/3&1/#+67 /0+6&/0+&
1+< 2#$/$U,/$36&"#3<+11&, 6-&4,<$%$/, /+&+<363F$<&7#3./0&>?&,%%3 .$67&F,#P+/&",#/$<$",6/1&/3&"#$<+&<#+-$/&#$1P&
F3#+&,<<2#,/+%?&,6-&,%%3<,/+&<,"$/,%&F3#+&+44$<$+6/%?8&
L0+& 1/2-?& ,#7 2+1& /0,/&,& #$1P:#+/+6/$36& 4#,F+.3#P& 1032 %-& 1++P& /3& F++/&/0+& 43%%3.$67& 3>^+</$M+1_& ,%$76&
$6<+6/$M+1&.$/032/& <0,67$67&/ 0+&>,1$<&1/#2</2#+&,6-&3>^+</$M+1&34&1+<2#$/$U,/$36&/#,61,</$361c&"#3M$-+&43#&
7#+,/+#& <+#/,$6/?& ,6-& <364$-+ 6<+& ,F367& F,#P+/& ",#/$<$",6/1c& "#3F3/+& +44$<$+6<?& 34& <,"$/,%& ,%%3< ,/$36c&
"#+1+#M+& 4%+T$> $%$/?& ,1 & F,#P+/1& ,6-& <$#<2F1/,6<+1& +M3%M+ c& ,6-& ,%%3.& , & >#3,-& #,67+& 34& ",#/$< $",6 /1& /3&
<36/$62+&/3&+67,7+&$6&%+6-$67&,</$M$/$+1X&.0$%+&-3$67&13&$6&,&1,4+& ,6-&1326-&F,66+#8&&
!&#$1P:#+/+6/$36&4#,F+.3#P&<,6&>+&1/# 2</2 #+-&$6&,&62F>+#&34&.,?1&/3&F++/&/0+1+&3>^+</$M+18&L0+&43#F&34&
#$1P&#+/+ 6/$36X&,%%3<,/$36&34&#$1P&#+/+6/$36&/3&M ,#$321&", #/$<$",6/1&$6&/0+&1+<2#$/ $U,/$36&<0,$6X&,F326/&34&
#$1P&#+/+6/$36X&,%%3.,6<+1&43#&#$1P&F,6,7+F+6/X&,6-&+T+F"/$361&4#3F&#$1P&#+/+6/$3 6[,%%&,#+&$F"3#/,6/&
M,#$,>%+1& $ 6& /0+& -+1$76& 34& ,6?& 12<0& 4#,F+.3#P8& !%/03270& ,& #$1P& #+/+6/$36 & 4#,F+.3# P& <,6& 0+%"& ,%$76 &
$6<+6/$M+1& ,6-& $F"#3M+& 26-+#.#$/$67& 1/,6-,#-1X&/0+& F,<#3+<363F$<& $F"%$<,/$361& 34& #$1P& #+/+6/$36&,#+&
<3F"%+ T8& !& #$1 P:#+/+6/$36& 4#,F+.3#P& <,6& $6<+6/& >+ //+#& %+6-$67& -+<$1$361& , 6-& <361+a2+6/%?& 0+%"&
1/#+67/0+6& /0+& a2,% $/?& 34& ,11+/ 1& 26-+#%?$67& ,& 1+<2#$/$U,/$368& N/& F,?& ,%13& 0+%"& F$/$7,/+& 13F+& 34& /0+&
"#3<?<%$<,%& +44+</1& /0,/& ,11+/:>,<P+-& 1+<2#$/$U,/$36& <,6& 0,M+& 36& / 0+& +<363F?8& R3.+M+#X& $4& 3M+#%?&
#+1/#$</$M+X& # $1P& #+/+6/$36& <32%-& <361/#,$6& /0+& 43#F,/$36& 34& <#+ -$/X& .0$<0& <32%-& ,-M+#1+%?& $F",</&
+<363F$<&7#3./08&L0+&<0,%%+67+&$1&/3&-+1$76&,&#$1P:#+/+6/$36&4#,F+.3#P&/0,/&F,T$F$U+1&>+6+4$/ 1&.0$%+&
F$6$F$U$67&$/1&<31/18&&
N/& $1& $6/+#+1/$67& /0,/& /0+& ,<<326/$67& <36-$/$361& /0,/& -+/+# F$6+& .0+/0+#& 3#& 63/& 1+<2#$/$U,/$361& <,6& >+&
<361$-+#+-&344:>,%,6<+:10++/&636#+< 32#1+&1,%+1&34&,11+/1&F,P+&63&#+4+#+6<+&/3&Y#$1P&#+/+6/$36XZ&%+,-$67&
/3& /0+& "311$>$%$/?& /0,/& /0+& 4#,F+.3# P& .$%%& 63/& 6+<+11,#$%?& F,P+& /0+1+& 1/#2</2#+ 1& F3#+& /#,61",#+6/& 3#&
>+//+#& F36$ /3#+-8& !<<3#-$67& /3& /0+& 5+-+#,%& C+1 +#M+S1& #+"3#/& /3& G367#+11& 3 6& #$1P& #+/+6/$36& B\3,#-& 34&
@3M+#63#1& '()(DX& ,& #+<32#1+& ,7#++F+6/& #+a2$#$67& /0+& 3#$7$6,/3#& 3#& 03%-+#& 34& ,11+/1& /3& ,>13#>& ,&
"+#<+6/,7+&34&/0+&<#+-$/&%311&43#&/0+&,11+/1&,4/+#&1,%+&.32%-&6 3/&,""+,#&/3&6+7,/+&,6?&34&/0+&<36-$/$361&
#+a2$#+-& 43#& <3613%$-,/$36& 36& /0+ & $112+#S1& >,%,6<+& 10++/8& R3.+M+#X& $/& 73+1& 36& /3& 63/+& /0,/& $4& /0+& #$1P&
#+/+6/$36& #+a2$#+F+6/1& $6<#+,1+ & /0+& $61/,6<+1& 34& <3613%$-,/$36& 34& /0+& ,11 +/1& ,6 -& %$,>$%$/$+ 1& 34& ,6& !\=&
+6/$/?X&/0+&, 7+6<$+1&1 032%-&<3 61$-+#&/0 +&$6<+6/$M+1&/0,/&12<0 &,6&32/<3F+&.32%-&<#+,/+8&&
L0$ 1&#,$1+1 & , & 62F>+#&34&$112+18&5$ #1/X&#+72%,/3#?&<,"$/,%&#+a2$# +F+6/1&43#&>,6P$67&$61/$/2/$361&7+6+#,%%?&
1/,/+&/0 ,/&<3613%$-,/+-&,11+/1&F21/&>+ &#$1P& .+$70/+-&$6&/0+&1,F+& .,?& ,1&,11+/1&36&/0+&>,%,6<+&10++/&/0,/&

0,M+&63/&>++6&1+<2#$/$U+-8&N6&, $/$36X&$4&>,%,6<+:10++/&,11+/1&,#+&12>^+</&/3&+ $/0+#&$F",$#F+ 6/&,6,%?1$1&
36&,&"+#$3-$<&>,1$1&3#&4, $#:M,%2+&F+ ,12#+F+6/X&/ 0$1&.32%-&/0+6&,""% ?&/3&1+<2#$/$U+-&,11+/1&/0,/&-3&63/&
a2,%$4?& 43#&+T<%21$368&N 4&/0+1+& ,11+/1&#+a2$#+&,6&,%% 3.,6<+&43#&<#+-$/&%311+1X&$6<%2-$67& %3,61 & ,6-&%+,1+1X &
/0$1&.$%%&,44+</&+,#6$671&,6-&#+72%,/3#?&<,"$/,%8&!11+/1 &F+,12#+-&,/&4,$#&M,%2+X &$6<%2-$67&F,6?&1+<2#$/$+1X&
,%13& .$%%& ,44+</& +,#6$671& ,6-& #+72%,/3#?& <,"$/,%8& L0+& $F",</& 36& +,#6$671& ,6-& <,"$/,%& F,?& <36/$62+& /3&
&
&
'H&
+6<32#,7+& $61/$/2/$361& / 3& +67,7+& $6& -+,%& 1/#2</ 2#$67& 43#& /0+& "2#"31+& 34& ,<0$+M$67& 344:> ,%,6<+:10++/&
/#+,/F+6/8& L0$1& F,?& %+,-& /3 & /0+& 1,F+& ,#>$/#,7+& 34& ,</$M$/$+1& /0,/& "%,72+-& \,1+%& NX& <#+,/$6 7& ,& .+-7 +&
>+/.++6& +<363F$<&#$1P& ,6-& #+72 %,/3#?& # $1P& 34& /0+& >,6P& "3# /43%$38& W6-+#& \,1+%&N& #$1P& .+$70/1X& 4$6,6<$,%&
$61/$/2/$361&. +#+&+6<32# ,7+-&/3 &#+/,$6&/0+&#$1P$+1/&,11+/1&$6&+,<0&<,/+73#?8&N61/+,-&34&13%+% ?&+<363F$<&
4,</3#1& -+/+#F$6$67& ,6& ,""#3"#$,/+& %+M+%& 34& <#+-$/& ,6-& %$a2$-$/?& "#3/+</$3 6& 6+<+11,#?& 43#& ,11+/:>,<P+-&
1+< 2#$/?&B!\=D&$112,6<+1X &$61/$/2/$361&F$70/&-+1$#+&/3&#+/ ,$6&36%?&/0+&F$6$F2F&%+M+%&34&#$1P&#+a2$#+-&>?&
#+72%,/$36X&$4&/0+&F$ 6$F2F&%+M+%&+6,>%+-&/0+&$61/$/2/$36&/3&,M3$-&<3613%$-,/$36 8&=$F$%,#%?X&<3F",6$+1&F,?&
>+& +6<32#,7+-& ,1& ,& #+12%/& 34& /031+ & +,#6$671& ,6-& <,"$/,%& +44+</1& /3& ,M3$-& <3613%$-,/$67& ,11+/1& ,6-&
%$,>$%$/$+1& >?&<+-$67&"3.+#&3M+#&1 "+<$,%&+6/$/$+1&.0+6&$/& $1&63/&4+, 1$>%+&/3&%$ F$/&>+6+4$/ 1&/3&,6&,F3 26/&/0,/&
F+ +/1&#+72%,/3#? &#+a2$#+F+6/18&53#&+T,F"%+X&$61/$/ 2/$361&F,?&<+-+&"3.+#&3 M+#&!\=&$112,6<+&+6/$/$+1[
.0$<0&$6&13F+&<,1+1&#+12%/1&4#3F&/0+$#&, >$%$/?&/3&F,6,7+&,11+/1&0+%-&>?&/0+&$112,6<+&+6/$/$+1[>?&1+%%$67&
1+#M$<$67&#$70/1&3#&-$1/,6<$67&/0+F1+%M+1&4#3F&/0+$ #&<21/3F+#1&$6&3#-+#&/3&,M3$-&<3613%$-,/$67&/0+&,11+/ 1&
,6-&%$, >$%$/$+1&34&/0+&$112,6<+&+6/$/$+18&!1&,&#+12%/X& $/&$1&63/ &<%+,#&/0,/&/0+&-+&F$6$F$1&H&"+ #<+6/&Y1P$6&$ 6&/0+&
7,F+Z&/0#+103%-1 &$6<%2-+-&$6&Q3 :5#,6P&.$ %%&$60$ >$/&/0+& -$44$<2%/$+1&<,21+-&> ?&344:>,%,6<+:1 0++/ &+6/$/$+1&
$6&/0+&#+<+6/&<#$1$1 8&N /&$1&,%13&-32>/42%&/0,/&/0+1+&1/#2</2#+1&.$%%X&$6&4,</X&$13%,/+&/ 0+&$61/$/2/$361&4#3F&/0+&
$F",</&34&/0+&"+#43#F ,6<+&34&/0+1+&,11+/18&N6-++-X&$6&/0+&#+<+6/&<#$1$1X&M$#/2,%%?&,%%&34&/0+& #$1P&34&M,#$,>%+:
$6/+#+1/&+6/$/$+1&,6-&3/0+#&344:>,%,6<+:10++/&,</$M$/$+1&.+#+&+M+6/2, %%?&12>^+< /&/3&#+<32#1+&,6-&#+/2#6+-&
/3&>,6P&>,%,6<+&10++/1X&42#/0+#&,77#,M,/$67&/0+&<#$1$18&53 #&+T,F"%+X&$4&/0+&4++ 1&,6-&/#,-$67&"#34$/1&+,#6+-&
>?&1+ <2#$/$U$67&#$1P?&,11+/1&$1&>+%$+M+-&>?&>,6P1&/3&F 3#+&/0,6&3441+/&/0+&#$1P&/3&<,"$/,%&34&#+/,$6$67&,&H&
"+#<+6/&10,#+&34&Y1P$6 &$6&/0+&7,F+XZ &/0+6&/0+&#2%+1&.$%%&63/&<0,67+&>+0,M$ 3#8&!6-&/0+#+&$1&/0+&, $/$36,%&
-,67+#& /0,/X& -2+& /3& 344:>,%,6<+:10++/& <3FF$/F+6/1X& /0+& /#2+& 10,#+& <32%-& >+& F2<0& 0$70+#8& C+4 3#F1&
1032%-&63/&>+&>,1+-&36&/0+&"#+12F"/$36&/0,/&>, 6P1&.,6/&/3&,M3$-&#$1P18&52#/0+#X&"+#<+$M+-&#$1P&-+"+6- 1&

36&/0+&3"+#,/$67&+6M$# 36F+6/[/0+&Y7#+,/&F3-+#,/$36Z&%3.+#+ -&"+#<+$M+-&#$1P&,<# 311&/0+&1"+</ #2F&34&
,11+/18&L0,/&,%13&<0,67+-&>+0,M$ 3#X&>+<,21+&/0+&#+.,#-&43#&#$1P&4 +%%8&L0$1&.,1&"#3>,>%?&,&>$7&$F"+/21&/3&
>,6P&,</$M$/$+1&/0,/&,""+,#+-&/3&10$4/&#$1P&>2/&$6&4,</&-$-&63/8&
5$6 ,%%?X&$/&1032%-&>+&63/+-&/0,/&/0+&= bG&0,-&$61/$7,/+-&<0,67+1&$6&/0+&#+72%, /$36&34&1+<2#$/$U,/$36&>+43#+&
/0+& ",1 1,7+& 34& /0+ & Q3 :5#,6P& !</& ,6-& 0,1& <36/$62+-& /0+& "#3<+11& 34& <3612%/ ,/$36& "#$ 3#& /3& 4$6,%& #2%+&
F, P$67&$6&/0$1&,#+,8&=+<2#$/$U,/$36&0,-&>++6&"#,</$<+-&1$6<+&/0+&)eI(1&.$/032/&$6<$-+ 6/&26/$%&/0+&#+<+ 6/&
<#$1$18&L0+&3>^+</$M+&1032%-&>+&/3&"#+1+#M+&/0+&"#$6<$"%+&>?&" #3-2<$67 &#+72%,/$36&/0,/&"#+M+6/1&$61/,>$%$/?8&
I.!Capital!and!leverage !ratios!
=3F+&<3FF+6/,/3#1&>+%$+M+&/0,/&/0+&10$4/&/3.,#-&1+<2#$/ $U,/$36&.,1&-#$M+6&>?&/0+&$6/#3-2</$36&34&#$1P:
.+$70/+-& <,"$/,%& #,/$31& $ 6& /0+& \,1+%& #+a2$ #+F+6/1X& .0$<0& $ 6<#+,1+-& /0+& <31/1& 34& <+# /,$6& /?"+1& 34&
$6M+1/F+6/1&43#&>,6P18&L0+#+&,#+ & 3/0+# & +T"+#/1&.03&,# 72+& /0,/& /0+1+&#+a2$#+F+6/1 & 0,M+& >+<3F+& / 33&
-+/,$%+-& ,6-& /33& 36+#321X& ,6-& 1032%-& >+& #+"%,<+-& >?& 1$F"%+#X& /#, -$/$36,%& <,"$/,%:/3:7#311:,11+/1& ,6-&
%$a2$-$/?&#,/$318&Q+1"$/+&/0+1+&<#$/$<$1F1X&/0+&!</&F,6-,/+1&/0+&, ""#3"#$,/+&4+-+#,%&>,6P$67&,7+6<$ +1&/3&
+1/,>%$10& F$6$F2F& %+M+#, 7+& ,6-& #$1P:>,1+-& <,"$/ ,%& #+a2$#+F+6/1 & 3 6& ,& <3613%$-,/ +-& >,1$1& 43#& $612#+-&
-+"31$/ 3#?& $61/$/2/$361X& -+"31$/3#?& $61/$/2/$ 36& 03%-$67& <3F",6$+1X& ,6-& 636>,6P& 4$6,6<$,%& <3F",6$+1&
12"+#M$1+-&>?&/0+&\3,#-&34& @3M+#63#18&L0+&F$6$F2F&%+M+#,7+&<,"$/,%&#+a2$#+F+6/1&"#3"31+-&1032 %-&63/&
>+&a2,6/$/,/$M+%?&%3. +#&/0,6&/0+&7+6+#,%%?&,""%$<,>%+&%+M+#,7+&<,"$/,%&#+a2$#+F+6/1&/0,/&.+#+&$6&+44+</&