0
+ 5
- 5
0,5
0
π
π
!"#"$ % !&'()
ππ !"#$%&'()&)*$+))(, /0)
*123π
4
π
526+)2%7$)8(4 /±
+9(2:;0<=>?@,0/ππA2&B$C26D,)6+)
2AE!π
,9(2;?@,0/ππ45F26D,)6+)2GHB
!&I?>,$!B(,+)28JD! /KLM
LNO
-9(2/%38(
426+)38D
%27$)15P26+)28D
5F*6,3D&'()(,+)2Q /L0)
.9(2)(,R$S)>&'(.M$%5T27$)15P;R$?@,
5?@,0,)(,+)2 /Mππ
/9(2>&'(.D$%5:,3H,)%238(
D),
$!B(,,?UR$>R$?@,+)0<:)(5?@,0)(,+)2
/ππ
09(2)(,R$S)>*6,3ω
0)5VHB238(D32
6
5?@,0)(,+)2 /
π4
19(2>&'(.W*6XY:,6H,)8D8J238(ZV5?@,
0)(,+)2 /Wπ
29(2>$%5127$)15P>2645VHB&)*$27$)#0F
38(;R$[AE!π
\?@,0)(,+)2Q /ππ4
12Z]?U)(,0,H,)%7$)#0F[&^,326WMA2
?@,0)(,+)2:,6H,)8J238(ZV /π
*9(23?@,026πππWA2?@,0)(,+)2Q
/ππ4
+9(2$!B(,0SR$0'(?H,0S&"%FK0,27$)!?U(,3π
&IVHB&)*$23:)(,3&^,%_, /Kπ
,12>?@,0.ωϕT))(,8Dπ4238(26
4
A2?@,0)(,:,6H,)8J238(
4
D),$!B(,;R$
?@, /πW
-12326ZV&^,WD,)6ZV&^,M
A2?@,0)(,:
,6H,)8J238(D),R15P /Mπ4
.`a(]>$%54π:,6:)(8D15P)$%]&b*$)(,
?UK5/2G:)(
4
),;R$c7$dVD263,"0#1I
?@,0)(,+)] /πW
/ 9(23e#?
!82?@,0)(,
+)2 /ππ
09(23e#?A2?@,0)(,
+)2
/ππ
1 9(23(26H,)?f 1I
?@,0)(,+)2
"Where there is a will, there is a way" - Pauline Kael
π
π
π
3
"Where there is a will, there is a way" - Pauline Kael
* 45"6 78'"9 !:;"# 4'"6 <;$
5H,),bE2$!B(,g#0F.I.Q
*5H,),bE2$!B(,g#0FI±.Q
+5H,),bE2$!B(,g#0FI±
A
Q
,5H,),bE2$!B(,g#0FI±
A
Q
-5H,),bE2$!B(,g#0FI±
4A
Q
.12;?@,0.π
4
π
5HB27$)#0F[&^,;R$[
/%%h
/8b8S)(,>$%5M5FH,)2?Ug#0F.I#0F.Q
/∆4
012>?@,0
ππ5"HB27$)#0F;R$
?@,<=Q /%>%h
19(EB;?@,0ππ4F&^,F&^,,[!50,(,[!*$
'%Bg8JEB7$)#0F38(E!8*Q /8*
29(2)(,R$S)3?@,0Mi5HB27$)#0F8*Cj
%BgHB&b*$)(,8D/ W4
9(2k >?@,0πiW5HBCj27$)#0F%Bg
8DQ j
*9(2)(,R$S)3?@,0Mi5HB27$)#0F8*CM;
R$[%BgHB&b*$)(,8D/ 44
+9(EB0'0<=>$%51#0F[&^,+)EB0l,>,6:)(F%m,
H,),bEB3g#0F38(.I#0F38(.Q /5W
,9(2>?@,0/WππW5F260$,&+)2g15PI#0F
38(4Q /4W
-8b8Sn,C,;?@,0/ππo:9Dp8*8?U8D#0FE
ED)E+)7$m*$o:qDr8*8?U8D0$,B+)=9D=p !F260$,&+)7$m
*$0'VgqIrQ /
&
W
.\?@,0)(,+)2/ππ5H,),bEB2g#0F&)*$I
15PQ /
/9(2:;0<=;?@,0/ππ5H,),bE2g8J&b
*$a)(,I8J238(
4
Q /W
09(2:;0<=;?@,0/MππW5H,),bE2g8J&b
*$a)(,I8J238(Q /W
19(2:;0<=;?@,0/ππ5H,),bE2g8J&b
*$a)(,I8J2I8J2?U7$ ,?H,sWQ /
*29(2)(,R$S)3?@,0/Wii5H,)2g15PI8J7$)
B348*C8D/ W
+784"6 !() =(> 4'
t$ ,?H,?U+)20,$%5Q
*t$ ,?H,?U+)20,H,)5Q
+TBg15P7$ ,?H,?U)$%m,H,)55W5M5Q
,t$ ,?H,?UuE)$H,)&^,55455WQ
-t$ ,?H,?U8>E)$H,)&^,55455WQ
.12;?@,0/π
4
π
5F7$ ,?H,2?U0,*$'Q
/s
/9(2;?@,0/4ππWs)$%'g2 ?U7$ ,
?H,&^,&)'$Q /4
4
012;?@,0/ππt$ ,?H,?U0,Q /M
112;?@,0/πt$ ,?H,2?U0,4%BgQ
/
"Where there is a will, there is a way" - Pauline Kael 4
29(2;?@,0/.ωϕPI0,%m,H,)42g#0F
I
#0F.
4
;l,R$?@,$%)(,Q /
t$m*$8b8S;?@,0/π
π5F7$ ,?H,7$m*$?U0,
*$'Q /W
*EB3?@,0)(,Mππ5F7$ ,?H,?Ug
IQ
/M
+A(+)(23&B$C/Mππ5F(D7$ ,?H,D2?U0,
%m,H,)M4FgHB&b*$Q /sM
,12;?@,0/ππ5F7$ ,?H,2?U0,%m,H,)g
I
44Q /
4
-9(2;?@,0/ππ5F6(0$,&+)20,%m,H,)
g
I
WQ /jK
.9(2;?@,0/ππ5F6(0$,&+)20,%m,H,)
g
I
MKQ /M
/9(2;?@,0/ππ5F7$ ,?H,2?U0,%m,H
,)Fg8Ja)(,Q /W
09(2;0<=7$)#0F[&^,=>&'(.D$%550,%m,H,)5
7$ ,?H,8>ED23B?UQ /.
,;) ?@& A%
9(23?@,0/ππ45VHB238(4VHBI
)$3238(&)'$Q /4
*9(2;?@,0/π4πMPI8()(,+)2GHB8D
W !"#8(+)2VHBv /±M
+9(EB)(,:;0<=3?@,0)(,/ππW5VHB
238( !"#8(VHBv /
,9(EB3?@,0/ππW5VHB238(WD),
$!B(,;R$?@,)$3238(&^,&)'$Q /M
-12;?@,0/π456(+)2)$%?U7$ ,?H,%B
gQ /M
.12;?@,0/ππ45H,)2?U7$ ,?H,s%BgQ
/W
/12;?@,0/ππ5H,)2?U7$ ,?H,s%Bg
Q /
09(2;?@,04ππWF&^,DF&^,,[!50,(,[!*$'
gHBEB7$)#0F38(&)'$8*Q /8*
BC*DEDFG
!"#"$ % !&'()
9(8b8S,e8S3(C,pD'&3%68?U,%,5VHB26D
,)6+)'&8*8?U8DD
4
5&'()(,+)'&#Q /.
*9(88,e2w,3%68?U,,50,2Z]?U)(,AE!π
-(C+)8S&^,&)'$Q /p
+9(880;n,C,Z])(,0,AE!,π
5( 8SV#0F
[&^,Q /
,9(880;n,C,>2w,3%68?U,,9(,?H7$)"E!H,)27$)
15P,x)48*8'I8DAE!π
-(C,+)8S&^,Q /p
-9(8b8S,e(2u3%68?U,,8S3%68?U,%_,",%BD3(C,
p8b;?@,,),AE!π
k)(,+)8b3$%8D&)'$Q
/
.9(8b8S,e(23%68?U,D8S3(C,%pI$y,%8'8*D,m%6
8?U,M8*[6)(,+)2y,)!,m&)'$8*Q /5y,8*
/9(8S%%,b>
2>$%5
WD%,b>2
$%8D5
MpI$
3)2D8S$%)(,+)J,8D&)'$Q /
09(23%68?U,0;D8Sn,C,12>*6X
WYT0;'(,)0:,
∆,*6)(,X
Y5%68?U,D(C,%+)8S /,p
"Where there is a will, there is a way" - Pauline Kael
19(8b8S0;n,C,)(,R$S)>$%5T2G15P8S3(D
AE!,π
R$DZ'+)8bQ /
29(8b8S),;?@,,),>&'(
12u+)8b3%68?U,,
8S3(C,pT2u326
,)6+)33(8>Q /
9(8b8S^,),2w,>.5T68?U,+)2w,8D,
8E!π
AZDeZV"<,8'2w,3,"0#Q /p
*9(8S3(C,%p0;n,C,50;D8S(2w,3%68?U,,5g
15P[,28'(V0e&$_,zAE!,
R$?@,?>,$6,?>o"0#ZV
+)8Z<eD8ZDeQ /p4p
+9(23%68?U,%,;?@,,),>$%5127$)15P>26
4π:,6H,)%27$)15P;R$?@,5V8Ze<"
<,8'23,"0#&^,&)'$Q /p
,8b8S0;n,C,,eS3%68?U,,>$%5126+)S&
7$)15P8D4AE!,
π
AZDeZV+)8S"<,DS&Q
/p
-88,e2w,3%68?U,%,D8S3({,%R$DZ'8
8b
?Uw0'wn,,',α4
>wn,,),8b)(,>$%545F(
C,DR$D+)8SG15PPu7$))"8E!,
/Lp
.9(880;n,C,>&'(T2326
jjW
,)6+)28Dπ
AE!,
Lπ
-(&IV,+)8SG15P&^,&)'$Q /
/9(2,bD8S0;n,C,8D8S 0)5R$DZB$DZV+)8S%
)(,PI8ZDeZVDZB$+)8S%2)(,8*8?U8DWpDpR$DZ'
+)8S8D8
AE!,
/M
09(880;n,n,C,>2w,3%68?U,,>&'(D*6,3
0)V@3,
-(8>8Z%aR%8S&#a&^,&)'$Q /4p
19(8S3%68?U,%_,",%B(C%4p*$0'8S,x6#*$?>0;2w,
3%68?U,4,2)(,R$S);?@,n,C,D326ZV
)
WM
:,6H,)8D8J2G#0FEER$?@,n,C,?>,$6,AE!
smg ==
π
-(
8>8Z%aRGHB
=t
8D/ /Wp
*29(8S3(C,%pR$DZ'8
4*$0'6#
*$?>,b293%68?U,,]?Uw0'wn,,',(
,3
4=
α
>wn,^,),?Ta2$6,?>#0F[
&^,(V
0e0$!R3(26:0<8S?>,R#
0F[&^,AE!
smg =
5FR$D+)8S%2G#0F)E0,
7$"0)(, /
*9(8S,b>(23,;?@,,),>XYR$DZ'+)8S&^,
D&'()(,+)28D8E!π
5(8>26D,)6+)2%8S3R$D
/πL4
**9(88^,),,L%pL8E!,π
-?)2%u15P(V&^,>(
8S%2G15P0,0?H,U88?U0;n,C,0e&$_,2)(,:R$
?@,8D?>,?)20)%u15P,6H,)8D8J&$_,2 /π
*+9(88*$0'6#*$?>0;(23%68?U,,2;?@,n,C,
50,7$"0)(,R$D+)8S&I|gID%7$)15P236(&^,
AE!,
1I?@,0)(,:,6:)(G15PR$?@,?>,$6,8J
8S3R$DD),$6, /π4
*,9(8b8S,e(2w,3%68?U,,,bD*$8S3(C,%pp,?H
)%a2;R$[0)%u15P(V&^,0em3)(,:,6H,)8D8Jm
25?@,0)(,+)2Q /π
*H# ("CIB'(JKL(
9(8b8S3(C,%p>&'(.-(,y,+)2w,%8]%u
15P(V8D4Q /Mr
*9(88PI8S3(C,4WpD2w,3%68?U,,AE!π
-(,y,+)3
&I';H,)>*6Q /WY
+9(88;?@,^,),>&'(.A(+)2%(,y,&^,Iy,+)8SQ
/±.
"Where there is a will, there is a way" - Pauline Kael
,}#0FD(,y,+)8b3,"0#,E8*Iy,Q /±
+
n
A
-9(88,e(2w,3%68?U,%,,bD*$(8S3(C,pp,?H)%a7$m
w,0)%u15P(V0emz3)(,126ZV+)2w,Q /
.9(23%68?U,,,bD8S3(C,%p)(,0'7$dVDA(
+)2%33264Q /±
/9(88^,),>@y,~rAS3R$DZ'8D8
D(C,%
pR$DZVDZB$+)8S0,7$"0)(,Q /DM
09(883%68?U,2u8D,8b;0<6#^,),>?@,0.ω
C)$x,%m,H,)(,y,DIy,+)28V&^,)$AE!π
5(C,
+)8SQ /p
19(8S%68?U,%_,",%B(C,%p*$0'0;D(B6#*$?>0;
(2w,2>?@,0/
−=
4
π
tx
5Iy,D(,y,+)8bGH
B5>58D$%)(,8*8?U8D/ /rDr
29(883%68?U,,>(8S3(C,%Wpw^,),AJ*$a8S)
3V(D8
M)$3m0)%8S 0)DE(D8D8
Wπ
T2
"#0F[&^,(,y,+)8b&^,&)'$Q /jW
4
r
M*22N39(2)(,R$S)>&'(W96Iy,G#0F[&^,T23(,y,
&^,48*@y,2"#0F[&^,(VQ 4
*M*2N39(EB)(,R$S)0'0<=>&'($%96Iy,G#0F
[&^,56(0$,&+)EB0,%m,H,),bE%EBg#0F3(,y,
&^,48*Iy,I#0F3(,y,&^,48*Iy,8DQ jW
+M*2N39(EB)(,R$S)0'0<=50,H,)4EBZ]?U
)(,D*o6H,)8D8JEB7$)#0F38(;R$[>6(8D
4
AE!π4\?@,0)(,+)EB8D
4
π
= +
,M*2*N39(EB)(,R$S)>$%5o:
5P
8D6(0$,&+)EB0,(
$%8D @)CH+)EB50,($%%m,H,)D
TB
v v
π
≥
8D 54
-M*2*N39(2u3%68?U,,)(,R$S)?>"<,+)(8Z%aR3&B$C
•Mpk)(,+)23&'(8DQ
BC+DE
!"#"$ % !&'()B'"6
9(880;V@3,jM
Ta8b8]%u?@,n,C,(,3α0)R
F)&'m0e0$!R8b(26&^,;?@,$_,,3>U[!R15P5
&'()(,+)8b /
*9(838)(,V@3,π
5g15P?)2w,I#0F[!0;U>?@,
n,C,(,3α0e&$_,2s)$%Bg8J2&b*$$!B(,2?U7$ ,?H,
o"0#,3α&^,&)'$Q /0)
+9(8380;V@3,
Ta8b%u15P,3α
W
0em%_,26*$
56(2%7$)15PQ /K
,9(8b@3R$D[!0;8D8Ta8b8]%u#0F[&^,(,3α>α
Mj0e0$!R32642)(,AE!
smg
=
5F26ZV+)2w,
0,7$"03)(,Q /
-)8)(,0'l,wn,3]$R$D50,l,(%m,H,)/%8bq
Z]?U)(,8bqqZ]?U)(,5R$D+))8b
/4LM
.9(83$%pI$y,R$D8b'$%)(,8D5,)60:,
0?H,@8DF,] /jW
/9(83%68?U,2w,,)(,$*D>&'(,3α
4
AE!
smg
=
AZ
y,ZB$+)U[!0,7$"0)(,Q /
4
p
012w,+)(83%68?U,,Ta8b8]%u15P(,3α
W
0emz3)
(,AE!
smg
=
AZy,U[!%2w,7$)#0F[&^,Q /p
"Where there is a will, there is a way" - Pauline Kael W
19(83%68?U,2w,,R$D[!0;85g15P)0$!R2(26
;?@,,),AE!
smg
=
AZy,U[!%2w,7$)#0F)EQ
/p
29(8380;V(B6#Ta8b%u?@,n,C,(,3&^,0)R
&'m0e0$!R8b(26;?@,$_,,3>[!RF)15P8b
I?@,0)(,6>8(D8b:,6:)(G15PR$?@,?>,),
m,6H,)8D8J8b7$)15P8*CE,jM
/
Kπ
9(8/2w,3%68?U,,0;V@3,
Ta8b8]%u15P,3α
0)0em%_,26*$5F8Zy,[!%2w,7$)15P /p
*9(83R$D[!0;8D%68?U,2w,&^,4,)(,V@3,
8b
)(,>&'(,38>%7$)15P23264T[!0;U>?@,n,C,(
,34
8Zy,[!&^,&)'$Q /4Wp
+9(8>$%5AE!
smg
=
π
1I)(,+)8bPI0^,VH
B&)*$238(,3α0)D26K /
π
π
,9(8),^!'V15P50$!R2(26
WM;?@,,),)$4
2?)|R$$!B(,D3264AE!
smg
=
π
5*6)(,+)2Q
/XY
-8b@3550,7$"0)(,,38]ZV+)[!0;8D0)0^,7$dV
$!B(,8Dn,:,6H,)8J238(α0)D),R15P5?@,0)
(,+)2 /αππ4
W9(8)(,3R$D85VHBg15P8b?U0$!R26;
R$?@,+)0<:)(AE!,jM
\?@,0)(,Q /Kπ
/8),^!'V15P0$!R2(26
;?@,,),8b@
PI0^,V#0F38(,3α
4
0)3326AE!,
:,6H,)8D
8J0$!R262R$?@,l,R$>26&)*$+)25?@,0)(,+)
8bQ /Mπ
09(8>$%5πPI0^,GHB&)*$8bG#0F3&'(,3α
>α
jMAE!,
5?@,0)(,8b /α0)
18%,)(,V@3,
PICy,[!0;%8b7$)15P8Dp,3
8]ZV+)8b&^,&)'$Q /W
*28%,)(,V@3,
PICy,[!0;%8bG#0F&'8DpC
y,[!0;%8bG15P8D&)'$Q /Mp
*k[!0;8bfC%#$Cy,&^,)8*0:,8?U,+)7$mw,k[!C%27$)15P
%&'(,3α
&^,&)'$Q /W
*H# (O78'$IB'(J
9(83%68?U,2w,,)(,>@y,&^,rAE!,
-()ZV
+)2>15P8D&)'$Q /
*9(83,8Pu7$):)"8b>&'(&^,45F@y,+)
8bAE!,jMW
π
/M4
4
r
+9(8>$%5&'(s
456(0$,&+)8b%8bg#0F3
(,y,ZVI#0F3(,y,&^,48*Iy,€a8b0,H,),bE
/j
,9(8D0;V@3,jM
Ta8b8]%u15P,3α
4
0em%_,26
*$6(+)2%(,y,&^,8*Iy,/ /j
-9(8380:,8?U,+)2w,8DpPI8Zy,[!0;%8bU>?@,n,
C,(,3W
8Dppy,8?U,)(,+)8bQ /r
.9(8/%a8b8]%u15P,3α
M
0em%_,26*$5F,38]+)[!0;%
(,y,&^,Iy,Q /4
/9(8,e%,>@y,~
rPI0^,V#0F[!0;U>?@,n,C,,3
α0)7$m*$326πAE!,
π
5Q /
08;Wπ45x,HBDG3(,y,&^,48*Iy,Q
/%πDπK%π
"Where there is a will, there is a way" - Pauline Kael K
+H$A8=(J
[$8b+)(e,e?8-e,eV!J,%GwE}()4%I$$6e,e
•V!J,m)!|R$D!8b?IDQ&"%F0"E8DW% /,m‚
[$8b@R$D82w,%68?U,,),]F7
,
-w8bDl,]0?H,R$
E
3(8>ƒ15F$%8b%
E
3?>,
^,), /M
[$49(83$%8D8bG,)!wE7$m*$),]F7-w8bD]0?H,
R$
E
?>,$6,ƒjM1T3$%8b&^,$%8bGW%5,"0#DE$+)7
,jM
GwEL„W%L, /
K
[$9(83R$D0;DB=6#T)(,8b8$_#$"<,8Z
F
%_,
|3?@,$_,,3>0:,8Z
P
D3(8>&^,\
4
5#0F[&^,D$%8bAE!,
/4
[$8b3$%)(,5G](
PI]6GD+)[!0;8b8Dλ
T
$%)(,+)8bGl,@%](8D
Q /
[$W880;n,C,>$%50'wET?)8b8'D!8'()&^,„„8D&"
%F50"-E$%)(,R$S)+)8bQ /5
[$K9(82w,),]F7-w8bDl,%_,,)3]0?H,R$
E
?>,;
?@,,),>•
q
ƒ\$%8bQ /M5
[$M}wE8b3$%)(,8D5PI%68?U,50"-E,EM8*%68?U,9w50y,
D&"%F50"-E,E4K8*&"%F9w50y,-?)8b8'9w50y,$%8bf&^,Q
/MW
[$jp,?H)?)(e,e7$m8b?8gwE8'()%PI&"%F50"-E8D„
W%9…,D!'e,eV!))!2&)'$Q /2WK
[$9(e,e7$m8b?8V!J,,H0'wEG](
PI]6GD[!0;
8b8Dλ
TT](8D
)$(,D!'e,eV!))!2&)'$Q
† /)4
"Where there is a will, there is a way" - Pauline Kael M