A Secondary Literature Review Undertaken for
!" #$ %#&'
" (
#)*!%(" +,
"- .!" +/
%&# +0
$%!(1 +2
%(" +3
#% " %#!&"" ,+
%" ,4
!"" 1 //
2
#)*!%("
!!"##"""$""$""$#"#%
& "$ '# # " "" '(
"$ ) # "! ## ##
""*!#"""+,
"$)$""!"""!
"#"""-
#"&./012*
* &!.3$"$40!#11
2 ("#5"1
"#6122 "$7"8"
"&# 3$"$49"
""-#$""1"$#
$" 9"#"! 1
2&""""$$""6
"!1:")6*;&;2<96
""!##"!$
=#1
" 1
"!"""$3$4"$
4>9/,"#2
, ) :" " , ! *
4,","$3"3:$"
$""6"#"1
3
List of Tables Page
""$4"$,"":1 ?
""$)2"!"="" ?
""$)2"!"+""!#
""$)2"!""=""!
@)"#"+"$+4
A%+"#"$"#??6??
B%+.!0"$""
B
%+"$+<"
?%6#"$"!""1 A
4
%&#
4?A"$ ")""" #"$
" ###"$ ##
!!#!"" C#!1D
14#""E""$E"
"#!"14
!"$"" !"#"#
"#"$"=""1
"= % " $ "#! # $" #
"!""=!6""$
#""14 / )"""="
"#"$""(!
5 " " $" "
!!"$"1F$
#""$""#$
"$#1
!5$" =#$=#
#"# !" ??A # Our Stolen Future,
" ##1 "" " " "=
!!"$#$1"
6")""65!"$)"$"!!"
#"!#1
7G/1
4"G$"!"""1:)"""
" ! " " # "= "6#"1 "$
&##""!"$+" "+
)7#*;!#"""""5
"# $"!! $" $"" #"" 8 ,
"#" &" "= +<) # ! " "
""#!"$""#"
4 !#""##"#""
!"%"#"$4G"=#1
2#""#!E 1"#"
#""#""=$"#"""#"
""!""#"#"#$"=#"1
4 " "! "6 $ " "
!"!#""!("1" !)"#"1
3"" #"H
"! "1 2 #" =#$"
""""!"$$""-6
56$"""$""$ #1
"$"!""#.$I"$
4"!""0"!5
#"==#"!"#"1
3$""$!" "$$#"##"
#H
5
4G#""(!#!"
"$1 4$$"=#"!""#!
#"22!"' "
"!!!4H""!
"$"=""!!("
#!""!?1
"""$$"#
"!"$"1
8"!"#="$""!"5
"#"14""$!
"7"6!2"+$$"!!"
$1= "!
"64!#" "$#"1
5!!""#"$5
"""1
##5# "$=14"
"$4#!"#"$"="6
"61
="!"#1:""$
$ " " #"
!1 " " " $ 5
""1#!"$
"=#"#!# 5
"!"#""##!$"##""$12"!
!"$""$"""!""!
# #" "6" " #"
#""#""""1'
" +F+ .# "! #" 0 4
!"!#""
#""6""1
#"$#
#"1""$""
=# " " " "$ " #" " 1 4
#"""!"$#"
" +" +#
""$!=#"""
5#"1
) $" "! "
=#""="6
1=#""##14"#
"5!"#""#!"
" ##""""!"$"$1
7)
6
Methodology
5%-&%1
4 " " "#" " "
(""??@4"!
" "#" $" " 1 7 $ ??@ "
!"!"""$"=414"$
4" " "
? "=
#""6"$"
"#/1
.5 ("-6#"
3 " #6 # "$ "= "
""""!
!"1 !" #" 5!
17"# "!""
"!#"J1
#5%-7)
#"#"""$$"""!#
%
• 2 ! "$ 3$ 4 "$ 4
$" " 1 "$
"2=1"$5;"
"!2=1
• 4#" 6 " $"
$"" "" $" 1 2 "$
$2=1
• 4$"" " " "! #" ""
"$" !51
%5 "
$""$#$""%
• #""E"$$" $"14$ "
$""5$"18#"
$""""""#"K
1
• #"""#$"
K!"!#" "$1 :"=#"
#""7"8"".780"
2)$"F""!8" .2)F0"
K""E#18""
("""!#1
• "#""$ 5
" # "$ "= " "61 4 "
"#!"""#"1
7
1 " $"$$"""
" # " # #" $"
""$""#!18" ""
" " ##"!"5E""
""1
8
*)-$'
1 #""$""!#1
1 L"""!G""1
1 L:!G"";"5!$""$""!#%
1 ""$"!"";4
#!"#"=1
1 2"$ "$ 5"
$"=""!"#$"#""!
#"#""$"6"!"
"$"=!1
1 ""$" "!1
1 L*"" $" *G "# ""
" $ 5! "$ 1 4 "
""$"!#"
!#"L+"*""G1
@1 4L*$G$
"!#$"1
9
%("
5!"$"
F!"6"1F$
"B$"""$""$"= "6
41F$$"""$
"$"=#1$""!$"
"5""#"$1
:""#!"$"#"$
5"$$"5"$$""!
!"
1 ,"""51
1 ="" "!% =" " "!
"!1
1 +""!%#"$#""!"""=#
1
1 )!""$"="-!1:"
"="$#"""
"""#!#18""
""""$"#"
5 " #" " "" "$ "
"1
5 . 18#6#!(# !!%&%"
""$ ="=""!-"$#"
" # "" 1 !! ##" "$
! " " ""1 F "$B
".B0@I$""511@I.0
"".01
.!9".&-&%""- . 1 %!%
&%"5
55 1'"-&%" 5-&%"
: B
,""
,5 ! /2
.5 6# 1
44"="!"$#
#"-"$"=1!!"!
;""$5"
""!5#1" "$
5!"""##"$$""
"1
10
.!:".&- "&%"##%('#"
1"1 ) "$ 2
"1"$)
"
:
) B
@ 7
6 ! /2
"#"$"="1
"""1"18
""$"E"!?"AI
"$""1 #""
#""$"!"$#$"#
"$"=1
" " " " ! " !
#1!"#"$$"""#""$"
"$#"!#!"""
" "$1
#5$1"!(# !"'#"%
4 "$ #""!!"" "$
#""!#"="$"
"=1
.!,$1"!(# !".&-&%"5
55 $1"!(1 5- "
&%"
"
7""+
*#" @
, B
@ ""!
A *#"
B "# @
" " F
10
? .#0
="
"6
11
7
!
4
@ F=
A )"""2"
92 ! ;9
"K""=""41$##"
$"""""#"!"#"
=!"""1"K
$"""$"="=
#""##14#"$""6=
"!"$"="!"
" " ##"#
"1
%5$# !"
.!/6#!(# !".&-&%"5
55 6#(" 5 - "
&%"
1 F!"#"#
1 F!""
1 8
J
1 )
@1 +"
A1 "
2 " ;" "$
""11!!"="$J
=45 "-"$
"J"$1"""I"$
" " 1 8"
F!""F!"#"# "!"""
@I"$"""=-12#"!
"#"$#4
!"$"=1
5
F !! # #" "!
$" # #" $1 4 " " #
$!5"!"#
"$#1#"!"""!"#"#
#"1"!""#""$
"#""???1
!"#""$12"!$"!
12
##" " " $" # ##" !
""#$""-$"
##"1
.!0<"&' -"#%"%
"#%1' "&'= "
F!""
F!"#"#
) @
+"
F @ @
&#<> ""<""( #!!& "%
"$?6#")@.:+++
:"@""!"""
"" # 41 4 "= "$
$""!"$"$
#"$""1
.! ; <%" "#%" #"&' - '&.!#
$ !$.*9334?33
.B@I0
.@I
0
78).@I
0
".@
I0
?6? @ @@A
??6? A@B BA
??6? @ A
??6? B ??? B
??6? @@ B
??6? B@ BB?
??6?@ AB B
??@6?A @ B@ @
??A6?B BAA
??B6? B? @B@
??6?? @
! :@0++ 9;:@+24 ;2@,,; 4@2/3
&#< -% A"<$BA"-$
'@
"# ! . "5 - ## %
93335
#$"""6"!6#"
#"6"-1"$6$"
"5 12$""4"#"$
""#"" #"
"6"1="%
5( #$!"#%"
13
"!6 - "$ "= " #"
;""14" "
"$#""!#""$
"!"""#"!$""!#""$1
""$""#!#"
-#"$#
1"#"!5#"$5
"4"#"$"1 "
" # "$ " " - "$ "= #
"!""" $# M !!$"!""
" # " "
##"$#"#"13$"$
"$ " #6 -% #
= "#> " "> " >
#">"!#!"1#
!"!! "#
!""-"""$-
1
:""$5"$"#""$"""
#"??1
"" "!"!"""!N"
"! #"> " " "$ "$ "
"">"$6#6!"=12#
"=!=-""#"$#"
" 8"="$$"!"
""""#""="!!
"$ " !# " # "61 $
##" " =! # "$ "= "
""61
44"="!""#"$"
#"""$2"$,)"
1
!1
4"$""$$#"O"
6- "# "= "1
8"#"#! !
"= !"#"1
2#"!#"#""$
1"$#""#"""#="#
" ## "" 1 ! $" $
#"#""1<+ "$781*
&"" " + *; ?AI #"#" "$ 36
<Gyps bengalensis A""14
"$,"!6<!"$"?BI1"
#"#" " "$ 4 '-" Gyps 8
'-" Gyps himalayensis " # "$ ""
1 4
!!""6""$#11
4"$!"$#"#"*"
31*"!#"PF5""6
"1+ .780" "#"#"
14
"$"1###""> "$
#!12$##!" #"
$!14$$"1!
#""$""K"$
"!D
1
4"$"=""!*""!!!
#"!"!-"$18!!
L: "$ !! " ! !! ! "$
!!""$#
G
1
4#$""""#"$$"$
!!"1"$"! $"
"E "$ $"" "!1 " # #" "$
"""$#"""
#""$ 1
*"!$C#"$#"$"
" " - "$ "
""!"$"$#D
1
4."$#"$0)$"
" "# $"
$"7#*;/+$""1
"#44"$""!
! "$ # ""#
"" .0 ="" "= .8)80 1
="$#$"1A##".##01
="$8)8$""!M1?##-"
1B###! 12"! " $" "$8)8
""=$"#68)868)8$""!
"$"
1
4" ##"$""""$
""$QQ"$""
""!"!14""!"
#"#""#""!1
'%&#
%"
2#"!5"#""""$$
"" #"##"*
"";"$78??B5*"";.??B0"="6
"=""!!""-"$"!!!#"1
4 "$ ! ""! "$ #" 8
! 5! ! Ichthyophaga nana plumbea "$ )" "
+ $" L$" ??6??A ' :! !
$1 !! $" "" ! #" "
"$"
"## "$!G1 4"!!L"$
"!"" "#" 1 " #" "
"""#!1#
15
"#"!#1#6"AI"$
"#">""$"1#6"!
"! = I "$ "$ #1#6 #1
! " "$ " "#"
##"""1!"$"
- "$ ## " "$
" "#" " # #" $"
!G
1
!!!"""$"$$""
-"$"#"1
2"!""$" 4!!$"#"
!!!!"$$"!""!6
- "$ "!"" " $ .11 - "$ " ""=
!!!-K#"
012!"$"$="#5
""!6-"$"$#"#"1"$
" !"$"!!!
$"$"2
=
"!""1
!"
*#" ("$ "$ " "
=
" """$=#"!!"!!"$
.! #" "$ " #"!
#"!0#"!!1
"$
2"! " ! " # " "
E"""51
45-""!#"#""!1
!"$"""-"$"!""
"#""!"$E1#""!
"-$"5""$#1
"!"$#""-"
"1
"#-#"#""$5
"$"#""!"$""$-5=#""
#14$"""$"
"" . 5 # $" - "0
# $" #1 2 #
5!!#""=6!5#"$'!
#""#""$"$"$#1
28( .??0$"P!"""=#"$78)
" ! " " ""! "$ =# 5
81$" " - $ #" "$ 5
#"#"P
=
1
' " !6 "" 4 "$ $""
!!$""!$"#"6
"$""=#"
16
"$"""
1 8 "!"" " ! # ! "
#""!"1
' # "$ "$ 4
"=!" "!
""$#"1
$"&!"
##$""#"""#"$#""6
1
4 "$ 5 $" " " "
# " " 51 F!"#"#
) ! " "!""
$" #"14:
"$ "6$"" "$ 5 "! " "
# 1
=
2".2)0""$"(#""
#"$#51( $" #! #
"#$"";"14"$
"!"#"#""!("
"!"1
=
2+"(#14"!""
("#"""$51#"
""#"""$2+1""
"$2""#"##"11
=
2"$""="
"E"#"#$"!"*
1
6
? ##&&! -( #$!"#%"
3"" "$"!""#
#5#"!
"""$"#1
"!"="!""$"4
1 1 ??1 " !"
"#""$"!""""4
!"$8)8""!"$14
$"#"#"!"!4E"
""$8)8G
=
11
" $ L+ "!""
".0 =""= " .8)80 ""
"#".)8,0 =""( .8)70 #"" #
.+)70""""!"$!"
"$""4
=
1
F!"" "" # #! "
!""1*"!"""$
8)8.R1!N!0+)7""14"
17
!="""$+)7.R1!N!01
=-"""$"!""
#"" $ "! " 1 4
#" ! ! "" "$ 8)8
" #" " "# " ! " "$
+)714" L"$("
"!""!"4!!
#" " ! #" ## $"
=#""G
=
14"=""$"4#!
""#1
+ "= "$ " 6? " !"
" #"##""3""$
)+1+1""!"!
"! )" "$ /2 I1 2$
! " "$ " $!
$ "$#$"$!
14! ##"$ "
# 11 ")"""#" "" F
" :
==
!! K #
$ " "- ""
1C2"$""!$"K!
"""""" ""
="!"$""$";"$#"14$
##! # ! $! !"
#!#""" !1D
"""""$4
""=#""!"#"
"1:"=#""#4"="
"""!"1
4##C,"$F!""""!"#"!
G " 1 11 ! "
" # 51 4 # 6
, !+"8",!6=1##
""$"#""5
$"$"""""$"1
8"""$#""!-
"1!
==
"""=#""2
#" " "$ : )5 Heteropneustes
fossilis.
"#%"$ & !%
:"$"="!""$"
#"1""$*""
8!"1"$""!K"
" " $" #" #" #
1F="$#$""$"
"" ##1 # $ "#! -
! " $" "$
"N"#"
"1 "" #" $ $"
18
!"$"$'""+ 1
# ""$"#""$$"
! 1 + " "# # "$
!"$""6"""1
4#"2*"".4"!
'0"!$"-!!$"
"$ #"
-"E $"$"+
#""$""#"
3$ 7= !*
9# '" " + 1 3 "$
"!!!""6"6"#
"1
.! 2 <"#%" "%&" * % "%" %1 *($ -
'!:,?:0@:+++
,"" "$
7"
2 " "
"$
"
3
!N
!N
!
3
!N
!N!
3
!
N
!N!
3
!N
!N!
3
!N
!N!
* ""
N
!
B
1
@
1?
@1
@
@ ?B1
B@
""7
6 6
1@
6 6 6
* ""
""#
9"
6 1A
6 6 ?B1
?
6 A1A 6
* ""
*
+"
1B
B
1
A
A@1
@
1
@
1 1
*4"!
N " *
""
1
@@ B?1
@
A1@
?1
@
1@
* '
N " *
""
@
1
@
1A AB
1@
B1
@
1
@
1@
AA
1
1?A
*""
&# N "
*;
?
1@
1 A
A1B
@
1
A
B1
B@
1A 1
@
&#<" !&# @@ (%(
19
.!4<"#-"#%" &"%
5
7
(8!
%
"
(8(%1
*
"$
(8( - *
*
#'$1
"
(8( -
**5
$#
#?
.
" (8(
-**5
" 78)
"8)8
6
6
A@1@
@1
.A1B0
A1B.1
@0
1@
2 1BB @1.B1B0
B1.A10
1
1
"
"$
1
@
1 B1.A10
A1A@ .@10
1
@1
1A 1B.B1A0
1
@1A
@ " 1 @@1.?@10
?1.A1
0
?1?
&#<" !&# @@ (%(
2=#$6!-"$"!""
# "1 " " "
#5 $""!1
#"$$"
" "$ #" !
#"#"$1""!"##
"O"=#"$!#"1
""$#""!!##!"6
"$"##"
"#"" ""$=!!!
1
" " !" "- $" " #
"$"""1
$"""!""#"14$""$
/#"""$
K #1 # "! "$ "
"!#="!-"1:"=#
##"@I#3"
"#"@I1#""$$""
!$"""$"!$$"5"
#"$"$"!"$""1
==
4"#"""3"!!%!"!
"$ -"6!#""!#
"""1
==
?"#""$"
!""$#""##""
"#""#"1#$
"""!"#""
##="1
20
")"" !""" $""AI"$
#"!"$!##/11#""
#"N"#""$$1#
$#"""
"!5"".
xxiii
4$"#"$#"!
!"!###=""
! #" " $"
!!#1
F!"#"#""
1
F!"#"#!5";"
" # " "1 "$
"!"#"#=$"E"=""!1
4"##"".??B??0!"
""$=#""$#"#"!"#"#
==
"
"18"""$#"#"!#"#"#
" - " " ""
""14" 1.???0$"$
""""#""""$5
==
""1
1.??A0 #" " !
#" "$ 5 =#" " " "$ "
"!"#"#
==
1 4 " " $"
$"!!!##"=#"""$
"-"-1$"#"
###"
""1
2"! " !! " " "
#" $ #"1 S
"" " #" :
$" " "= " "" ;" "#" "$ (""# " $
# ("1 " "$
"!"""1"#"
"""""$$"";"$"""
"5#""#"
""12"1.??B0"C"
#"##"!"$!"#"
""!$""$5"E"#"
=#"D
==
1"!!"=#""
"" $ 5
=#"-#"1
4"&.??A0"C
#"$""E "=$"
"#""$"D
==
1
21
)# : "$
#"$"-"!!"$ Cyprinus carpio ,
!!14$"!!=#""-"""$
#!!"""##
6"$!!!51
8 +" " # #"
#"1
C
2"$5"$E"
-"$#"-#""!"#
"$E=!"$1"
"$"5!#$""$
-#""!#"#17"
" ""!!" "
""#"$1K
$$"$
"$"=$#1
"$ 2( " "" /11
#"" #"1
===
2("$=
" ! #" . "# "$ "
$="!0"!"#+"!"$
" 2 "$ 1 #" " !"
1:""""#
$"! #"#" " # "
=1+#"#!$"!#"#""#
"#13"
1/"$)$"7 "8
$" "=#"$%2(1
2("""
$" #" 1 4 /11 $"
1PT4U$" ""- !" 1
" " (6$ "P " 81
"$"#%""!"!"
#"1+2!$6$
"$(E"AB""$,
! 1 2( K" " $" $
##"# #""1+2
"(P"AI"$ $#
??@ $" ! ## 4"
"1P
3 # ( #"" /11 " /11
#$"!"$"
""$""#"$""-
"" 1 8" " "=""! !
"""$("" $"!""1 8Q"6"
"=""!6"
(1"$$"5#"
;" !"$""=""!"/1
22
2( " " #"1 " #"
"# = " " $! ""
!! #""#"$"!18Q"
!5=";1##".##066"
"+2$" !"
##+2!$"#"""$E$1
E"$(""=#""$
" " "" ! " $"! #"#" "
#" # "$ $"" " "!
"$$"!#"#""1
+2 #" 6 5(!
""! $"(1"!"##""
";"""!#"##"$"!
""8Q##"" "1
4$#"#!"""
"" 5 E #1 +2Q
"""KP#"-TU
"!""""=
" ##P66 " "" !5 =
" " 8Q 1 "! 8Q
" "
=#"$""$+2!""1
:" $!"( ' $" #" - "
"#""""-18"!""""$"
""$"!-""6""
!#"1
===
.2""$+"
2"! + "= ! = -"
+"+"5"$*#"$""*%'
1>"2"!%,"""$:!<"("2
=-""$*%'10
2"-"$)"Cirrhina mrigala &"
-"#"#"""$K
!""!#""$$C. mrigala1
===
C
3 =#"$" "$#""
" ""-#"-
E$"$" !1
#"$"$""""=-"$
!="$#"51""
"$5$!#"
"!#1 8"$"=!
5##""$ = "$"""#-
#"#""#$ !#""
#""#""E1)"#"
!-"$# !. *
""#M"),"
#""=!# """"!""$:
23
: """ " .+0 ! !
xxxii
.
C
2"#"$#"$$"#"$
7 " #""! !
# # ! !$"""$
1"6""5"!
""!#1
"#5#""#1
===
5 "#% "&!"
1 "$@I "$!
1
1 6#"
@I
7" 6"
"#
"1
1 V#"@I 4 " 6
" "
" "
!1
1 AI = ! "
! !
$""$#"
"# " "$
#"# "$
#
"1
4")#:"$
#" $" - " !! "$ Cyprinus
carpio,!!14$"!!=#""-""
"$ # !! " " " ##
6 "$ ! !
!51
1
===
7"""#$""$
"#1
2"#"$:+@"7*" #!"Columbia livia
' " !5 " ""!
# $ 8"!" " ""
!1
===
);"")"$B@7"
!!"#"$51
===
+#""!"$""#@
1 " " "$
"!"#"##."0"#""#2.
xxxvii
" "# " "
24
#">2#""#"""$"
"""6$""$"" #"
"""""$"
etc. As $6"K#"""$
"$#""!#"$E#"1
8 ) " #"" 7# *;
#" "#$"""$"#6
1 " " K #" "
" ! "= -" #
E14"!"$""$##"
"E"1
1 !"
,)"$
"""!14"$
#""6$#""!
"41
""":")
!"#"$"1
"$
7"" # "$ 5 -
""$"""145
*" .??0 " "" "$ S )"## ,
)-"!"$! Mugil cephalus
$!""$< #"
===
1
4"$) "#""="$!
!=#"""!""!
""$ "$)"")#Cyprinus carpio, #!
1
"")"-"$"
"$"#+"="5 Clarias batrachus "
"= " " $"! 5 " ""1
8#""=$""$"$"1
3""$"""#5"O
""1:"=###
""!! "" 1:
#6!!"$""#
""1"1<"$"$"
""""$1
"""""
!51:"
"$ M.Cephalus "#"$
" 1 2 $ "" "$
"""!"$5""
$""""!#!"
"= "$ " ""! $" "$ #5 "!
====
1
/$" " " " " # $
#1
25