4X\KRFKYTXQOìQJXQQầF
&KQJ
PKQKKRWURQJTX\KRFK
YTXQOìQJXQQầF
4XWUQKOảDFKÂQSK|{QJQTX\KRFKQJXÊQQ|ôF
/ềDFKẵQFFSKQJQFấDELWRQTX\KRFKYTXQOệQJXắQQặFWKQJ
ầFWKềFKLQWKHRFFWUQKWềVDX\
;FãQKPFWLXFấDELWRQTX\KRFKKRFTXQOệKWKQJ
;FOÔSWÔSFFSKQJQFẳWKơSKQJQFQJWUQKSKQJQFLWR
KWKQJSKQJQYÔQKQKKWKQJSKQJQVẽGQJQJXắQQặF
0SKQJKWKQJEQJPKQKPSKQJ
6ẽ GQJ P KQK P SKQJ QK JL SKQ ẹQJ FấD K WKQJ WKHR FF
SKQJQFẳWKơơ[FãQKFFSKQJQFKÊSQKÔQầF&FSKQJ
QFKÊSQKÔQầFOFFSKQJQWKRPQFFLôXNLQNếWKXÔWFF
LôXNLQUQJEXFYôPLWUQJYFFLôXNLQUQJEXFNKFLYặL
KWKQJ
7PSKQJQWLXQKÊWKRFSKQJQKầSOệWURQJVFFSKQJQ
FKÊSQKÔQầFEQJSKQJSKSPSKQJKRFSKQJQWLXKR
7UQKWềWUQFẳWKơPWWUQVắ
.KLSKQWảFKOềDFKẵQSKQJQTX\KRFKWKQJẹQJGQJKDLSKQJSKS
UÊW F WUQJ FấD Oệ WKX\đW SKQ WảFK K WKQJ ẳ O 3KQJ SKS WL X KR Y
SKQJSKSPSKQJ
3KQJ SKSPSKQJOSKQJ SKS VRVQK WUềF WLđSFF SKQJQ FKÊS
QKÔQơWPSKQJQFẳKLXTXNLQKWđFDRQKÊWYWKRPQFFLôXNLQNếWKXÔW
YFFUQJEXF
3KQJSKSWLXKRWPSKQJQWLXEQJFFKOÔSYJLLELWRQWL
XLYặLELWRQDQJ[HP[âW
&FSKQJSKSWL XKRVDX\ WKQJGẩQJWURQJ TX\KRFKYTXQOệ
QJXắQQặF
3KQJSKSTX\KRFKWX\đQWảQK
3KQJSKSJLLELWRQWLXSKLWX\đQFẳGẩQJYNKQJGẩQJRKP
&KQJ0KQKKẵD
3KQJSKSTX\KRFKQJ
3KQJSKSGáWPWLX
1KYÔ\ơSKQWảFKOềDFKẵQSKQJQTX\KRFKPWFFKKầSOệQKÊWFQ
SKLWKLđWOÔSFFPKQKWRQWKHRPFWLXNKDLWKFKWKQJ7DSKQELWKDLORL
PKQKWRQLYặLKWKQJQJXắQQặFPKQKPSKQJYPKQKWLXKẳD
7ƠSFFSKQJQFẵ
WKư SKQJ Q V
é
GẻQJQầFSKQJQ
FQJWUQKYYe
7ƠS FF JL WUá ĂX
YR FậD K
WKQJ
GạQJFK\VQJQJạL
WLOLXáDKQKYYe
0KQK
PSKằQJ
KWKQJ
%QJSKQJSKSPSKằQJ
7PSKQJQKẩSOìWURQJVFF
SKQJQFKÔSQKƠQẩFEQJ
SKQJSKSPSKằQJ
%QJSKQJSKSWLXKẵD
7PSKQJQKẩSOìWURQJV
FFSKQJQFKÔSQKƠQẩF
EQJSKQJSKSWLXKR
7ƠSFFSKQJQ
FKÔSQKƠQẩF
7PSKQJQWLX
;FƠQKPạFWLXFảDEệLWRQ
+ãQK6PWTXWUãQKODFKQSKQJQTX\KRFK
KRƯFTXQOíKảWKẩQJ
0KQKPSKQJPWTXWUQKYÔWOệYFFKRWQJFấDKWKQJầF
[\GềQJQKPQKÔQWKẹFKWKQJ[HP[âWQJWKLFấDKWKQJYSKQWảFKNK
QQJWầFFấDFFPFWLXNKDLWKFKWKQJWUD0KQKWLXầFWKLđW
OÔSQKPPFảFKWPSKQJQTX\KRFKWLXEQJSKQJSKSWLXKR
0zKQKPzSKQJKWKƯQJ
.KLQLPYơPSKằQJ
4XDQLơPKWKQJKLQLáLKLSKL[\GềQJFFPKQKKWKQJF
ELWLYặLQKéQJKWKQJOặQYSKẹFWS&FPKQKKWKQJQKPPWFF
TXWUQKYÔWOệFấDKWKQJFFKRWQJFấDKWKQJYFKđOPYLFFấDK
WKQJ
4X\KRFKYTXQOìQJXQQầF
0SKQJKWKQJOSKQJWKẹFPWPWKWKQJWKềFEQJPWKWKQJ
NKQJWKềFGRQJLQJKLQFẹXWRUD7UQKWKQJQKQWRFFTXWUQKYÔWOệ
FấDPKQKWKềFầFPWJQèQJKRFWQJWề&FTX\OXÔWYÔQQJFấDK
WKQJWKềFầFVX\UDWẻQKéQJNđWTXQJKLQFẹXWUQKWKQJGRQJLQJKLQFẹX
WRUD
&ẳQKLôXFFKPSKQJEDRJắP0KQKYÔWOệPKQKWRQYY&KQJ
KQTXWUQKWÔSWUXQJQặFWUQOXYềFFẳWKơPWEQJPKQKWQJWềLQ&F
TX\OXÔWFKX\ơQQJQặFWURQJOáQJGÂQFẳWKơPWEQJFFPKQKYÔWOệầF
[\GềQJWURQJSKáQJWKảQJKLPWKHRFFWLXFKXĂQWQJWề
.KLQJKLQFẹXFFKWKQJNếWKXÔWYKWKQJQJXắQQặFQJLWDVẽGQJ
PSKQJWRQKẵF
0SKQJWRQKẵFOVềELơXWFFTX\OXÔWYÔWOệYTXWUQKKRWQJFấD
KWKQJEQJFFELơXWKẹFWRQKẵFEDRJắPFFKPVFFFQJWKẹFWRQKẵF
FFELơXWKẹFORJLFFFEQJELơXYFFELơXắ
1KYÔ\FẳWKơUèWUDãQKQJKàD0KQKPSKQJOVềELơXWFFTX\OXÔW
FấDKWKQJEDRJắPFFTXWUQKYÔWOệYQJWKLFấDKWKQJEQJFFELơX
WKẹFWRQKẵF
&FPKQKWRQVẽGQJơPSKQJKWKQJWKềFNKQJWKơSKQQK\
ấFF WảQK FKÊWTX\ OXÔWFKX\ơQ QJ YYFấD K WKQJWKềF YFF TX WUQKWề
QKLQFấDKWKQJWKềFEãJLQKRKRFầFELơXWWKHRPWTXDQQLPQR
ẳFấDQJLQJKLQFẹXNKLKẵWKLđWOÔSFFPKQKPSKQJ7XểWKXFYRPF
ảFKQJKLQFẹXPELơXWYVềJLQKRWKHRFFGQJNKFQKDX7LXFKXĂQQK
JLFKÊWOầQJFấDPKQKPSKQJOVềVDLNKFJLéDJLWUãWKềFYJLWUãWảQK
WRQFấDFFFWUQJPQJLQJKLQFẹXTXDQWP
0KQKPSKQJLYặLKWKQJEÊWNểFẳGQJVDX
< +8;$
YặLUQJEXF*<;8$
d
WURQJẳ;YâFWFFELđQYRFấDKWKQJYOKPFấDWKLJLDQ; ;W
;W
[
W[
W[
M
W[
Q
W
-
Q
8YâFWFFELđQLôXNKLơQYFậQJOKPFấDWKLJLDQ8 8W
8W X
WX
WX
L
WX
Q
WL
P
<FFELđQUDFấDKWKQJ< <W
<W \
W\
W\
LS
W\
S
WLS
S
&KQJ0KQKKẵD
$YâFWFFWKQJVPKQKPSKQJKWKQJ
$ D
D
D
L/
D
/
L
/
/
*YâFWELơXWKãFFKPUQJEXFFấDKWKQJWDFẳWKơYLđW
*
MJ
<;8$
d
-
J
1J
+NệKLXELơXWKãGQJKPFấDPKQKPSKQJ
7KLWOƠSPKQKPSKằQJ
9LFWKLđWOÔSPKQKPSKQJầFWLđQKQKWKHRQKéQJEặFVDX\
7KXWKÔSWKQJWLQYôKWKQJ[FãQKPFWLXNKDLWKFYOÔSVắK
WKQJWKHRPFWLXãQK
;FOÔSFÊXWUèFKWKQJYPWEQJVắFFPLTXDQKJLéDFF
WKQKSKQWURQJKWKQJ
&KẵQFFWKQJVFấDKWKQJFWUQJFKRPLTXDQKJLéDFFWKQK
SKQFấDKWKQJYWKLđWOÔSFFELơXWKẹFWRQKẵFFFELơXWKẹFORJLF
FấDFFTXWUQKWUQ0KQKWRQFấDKWKQJEDRJắPFFPKQK
WKQKSKQYVềJKâSQLJLéDFKèQJ'RẳFQ[FãQK
3KQJWKẹFPWFFPKQKWKQKSKQEDRJắP
0SKQJFFTX\OXÔWYFFTXWUQKYÔWOệFấDKWKQJ
0SKQJFFTXWUQKWFQJYRKWKQJơWPFWLX
0SKQJKPPFWLXNKLPFWLXNKDLWKFLYặLKWKQJ[FOÔS
6ềOSJKâSFFPKQKWKQKSKQ
&FELơX WKẹFORJLF PW FKRFKLđQOầF LôX NKLơQK WKQJYWKR
PQFFUQJEXFFấDKWKQJ
.LơPWUDVềKầS Oệ FấDP SKQJY[F ãQKFFWKDPV FấDPKQK
WKHRWLOLXTXDQWUFầF
+LQQD\WắQWLNKQKLôXPKQKPSKQJầFVẽGQJUQJULWURQJTX\
KRFKYTXQOệQJXắQQặFLơQKQKOFFPKQKORL+(&+(&+(&
+(&+(&+06+(&5(6,0FFPKQKKẵ0,.(0,.(0,.(0,.(
%$6,1YUÊWQKLôXFFPKQKNKF
6é GẻQJ P KQK P SKằQJ [F OƠS PẻFWLXY SKQJ WKềF
NKDLWKF
\OEặFLXWLQWURQJSKQWảFKYWKLđWNđKWKQJQJXắQQặFLYặL
PWKWKQJEÊWNểYLF[FãQKPFWLXEDQXFKOãQKWảQKPẹFWầFFấD
PFWLXWUDFQầFNLơPWUDEQJWảQKWRQYặLFFPKQKPSKQJ[F
OÔS&ẩQJYặLPFWLXNKDLWKFKWKQJFQ[FãQKELQSKSFQJWUQKYTX\
PFFFQJWUQKFQầF[\GềQJ1JRLUDFậQJFQSKLNKQJãQKNKQQJ
4X\KRFKYTXQOìQJXQQầF
SẹQJFấDKWKQJLYặLFF\XFXNKDLWKFKWKQJ7ÊWFQKéQJYÊQôQ\
FKầFOPUằNKLVẽGQJPKQKPSKQJWURQJTXWUQKWảQKWRQYSKQWảFK
.đWTXWảQKWRQEQJPKQKPSKQJFKRSKâSVETX\đWãQKQKéQJYÊQô
FKảQKVDX\
ắ
4X\đWãQKPFWLXNKDLWKFKWKQJEDRJắPQKéQJ\XFXYôQặF
ầFFKÊSQKÔQYPẹFSẹQJLYặLPFWLXNKDLWKFWUD/ầQJ
KRPFWLXNKDLWKFEQJFFKPPFWLXYFFUQJEXFYôPFWLX
ắ
3KQJWKẹFNKDLWKFQJXắQQặFWUQKWKQJ
ắ
&ÊXWUèFKWKQJEDRJắPFÊXWUèFKWKQJFQJWUQKKWKQJFF\X
FXYôQặFYPLTXDQKFấDFKèQJWUQKWKQJ
ắ
7ÔSFFSKQJQFẳWKơFFSKQJQFQJWUQKYFFSKQJQNKDL
WKFVẽGQJQJXắQQặF
ắ
&FJLặLKQYUQJEXFFấD KWKQJầFPWEQJFFELơXWKẹF
UQJEXFWRQKẵF
&ẳWKơQẳLPKQKPSKQJOFQJFơQKÔQWKẹFKWKQJYãQKKặQJ
TX\KRFKYTXQOệKWKQJQJXắQQặF
0zKQKWƯL|XKRWURQJTX\KRFKQJXÊQQ|ôF
3KQJSKSWLXKRWURQJTX\KRFKQJXắQQặFầFVẽGQJNKUQJUL
WUQWKđJLặLYầFWUQKE\WURQJQKLôXWLOLXFẳOLQTXDQ
%LVZDV$.-HOODOL
0DQG6WRXW*(HGV:DWHUIRU6XVWDLQDEOH'HYHORSPHQWLQWKH7:HQW\
ILVW&HQWXU\R[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV,6%1'DQLHO3/RXNV-HU\5
6WHGLQJHU 'RXJLDV $ +DLWK :DWHU 5HVRXUFH 6\VWHPW 3ODQQLQJ DQG $QDO\VLV
,QWHUQDWLRQDO ,QVWLWXWH IRU +\GUDXOLF DQG (QYLURQPHQWDO (QJLQHHULQJ 'HOIW WKH
1HWKHUODQGV ,6%1 0D\V /: 7XQJ <.
+\GURV\VWHPV
HQJLQHHULQJ DQG PDQDJHPHQW
0F*UDZ+LOO,QF ,6%1 *ULJJ
16
:DWHU 5HVRXUFHV 0DQDJHPHQW 3ULQFLSOHV 5HJXODWLRQV DQG &DVHV
0F*UDZ
+LOO,6%1
3KQJSKSWLXKROSKQJSKS[FãQKOLJLLFấDKWKQJWKHRPF
WLXNKDLWKFKWKQJEQJFFKOầQJKRFKèQJWKQKFFKPPFWLX6DXNKL
[FãQKầFPFWLXFấDELWRQTX\KRFKWKYÊQôTXDQWUẵQJQKÊWFQWUDO
[\GềQJKPPFWLXFấDELWRQTX\KRFKFáQJẵLOWKLđWOÔSELWRQWLX0
KQKPWKPPFWLXầFJẵLOPKQKWLX9LF[\GềQJKPPFWLXWXể
WKXFYRQKLPYFấDELWRQTX\KRFKYWảQKSKẹFWSFấDKWKQJ7URQJWKềF
WđWKQJJSFFELWRQDPFWLXGRQKéQJPFảFKNKDLWKFNKFQKDX'ặL
\VăWUQKE\FFGQJFEQFấDKPPFWLXLYặLELWRQWKLđWNđKWKQJ
SKWWULơQKWKQJYTXQOệLôXKQKKWKQJQJXắQQặF
&KQJ0KQKKẵD
0WWQJTXWELWRQWLXKWKQJ
*LVẽFẳKWKQJFẳFÊXWUèFQRẳ*ẵL;WOYâFWFFWKQJWLQYR8W
OYâFWLôXNKLơQ<WOYâFWFFWKQJWLQUD=WOYâFWELđQWUQJWKL$O
YâFWWKQJVFÊXWUèFFấDKWKQJ7DFẳ
;W [
W[
W[
Q
W
8W X
WX
WX
Q
W
<W \
W\
W\
Q
W
=W ]
W]
W]
Q
W
$ D
D
D
Q
0KQKPSKQJKWKQJFẳGQJ
<W +;W8W=W$
&QWKLđWNđYLôXNKLơQKWKQJVDRFKRFềFWUãPWKPPFWLXQRẳ
);W<W=W8W$
o
FềFWUã
9ặLUQJEXF
*
M
;W<W=W8W$
d
E
M
M
P
7DFẳWKơFKLDUDOPEDORLELWRQNKFQKDX
D%LWRQWKLƯWNƯ
LYặLELWRQWKLđWNđWKQJTX\ãQKWUặFFKđOPYLFFấDKWKQJGR
ẳYâFW8WELđWWUặFYTX\OXÔWWKD\LFấDELđQWUQJWKL=W;WFậQJ
ELđW+PPFWLXNKLẳFKFáQPWORLELđQOYâFW$
1KYÔ\FFELơXWKẹFWẻđQFẳWKơYLđWGặLGQJJLQKRWẹFO
NKQJFQPWFFELđQELđWWURQJSKQJWUQKWQJTXW
7DFẳKPPFWLXVăO
)D
D
eD
Q
o
FềFWUã
$
9ặLUQJEXF
*
M
D
D
D
Q
d
E
M
M
P
7URQJẳ $ D
D
D
Q
OWKDPVFÊXWUèFWLXFấDKWKQJ
7DJẵLELWRQQ\OELWRQWKLđWNđ
4X\KRFKYTXQOìQJXQQầF
E%LWRQLÊXNKLÔQ
*LWKLđWKWKQJầFWKLđWNđWẹFOFFWKQJVFÊXWUèF$ELđWWUặF
1đXWDWKD\YRWDFẳGQJJLQKR
);W=W8W
o
FềFWUã
YặLUQJEXF <;W=W8W
d
E
M
M
P
7DFQSKLWPYâFW8WơOPWLXPFWLXQRẳDQJầF[HP[âW
%LWRQQKYÔ\FẳWQJẵLOELWRQLôXNKLơQKWKQJ
F%LWRQWKLƯWNƯWQJTXW
LYặLELWRQWKLđWNđWKềFUDYLFãQKUDWUặFFFJLWUãOPYLFFấDK
WKQJONKQJKầSOệYUQJFFWKQJVFÊXWUèFFấDKWKQJFẳPLTXDQKFKW
FKăYặLFKđOPYLFFấDQẳYTX\OXÔWWKD\LFấDFFELđQYR;W'RẳFQ
JLéQJX\QSKQJWUQKGQJWQJTXWđQ7X\QKLQWPQJKLPFấD
GQJELWRQQ\NKQJQJLQNKQJQKéQJGRWảQKSKẹFWSFấDQẳPFáQGRVề
EÊWãQKYôPFảFKNKDLWKFKWKQJQéD7URQJWUQJKầSẳFẳWKơGẩQJSKQJ
SKSPSKQJơWPQJKLPKầSOệ
9ÔQơWKLWOƠSKPPẻFWLXYFFUQJEXFFậDELWRQWLX
D0FWLXYKPPFWLX
&QSKQELWNKLQLPPFWLXYKPPFWLX
0FWLXNKDLWKFKWKQJFẳWKơầFOầQJKREQJPWLOầQJQRẳ
&ậQJFẳWKơNKQJầFOầQJKRLOầQJGẩQJơOầQJKRPFWLXFẳWKơQKÔQ
FFJLWUãNKFQKDXGRẳFẳWKơJẵLOPẹFFấDPFWLXôUD&KQJKQPW
NKRQặFầFWKLđWNđWặLWKWặLOPFWLXNKDLWKFFáQGLQWảFKFQWặLKRF
TXWUQKOầQJQặF\XFXWặLOPẹFWPFWLX
+PPFWLXOWLXFKXĂQQKJLFKÊWOầQJWầFPFWLXôUDYặLPẹF
ãQKFKRQQWURQJQKLôXWLOLXFáQJẵLOKPWLXFKXĂQKRFKPFKÊWOầQJ
LYặLELWRQWặLWUQ\FẳWKơFẳKDLFFKWKLđWOÔSKPPFWLX
+PPFWLXOPWKPVPQẳFQQKÔQJLWUãFềFWUãOặQQKÊWKRFQK
QKÊW1đX:WFKDãQKWUặFWẹFOGLQWảFKFQWặLFKDãQKUằWDFẳWKơW
KPPFWLXWKHRGQJ
- ) D D D PD[
Q
o
7URQJ ẳ - KLX ảFK PDQJ OL OặQ QKÊW 7URQJ EL WRQ SKQ SKL QặF QđX
ãQKWUặFWDFẳ
Q
D D D
-
):W PD[ o
&KQJ0KQKKẵD
YặL:WOYâFWOầQJQặFầFSKQSKLFKRFFNKXWặL
:W Z
WZ
WZ
Q
W
+PPFWLXầFQKÔQFFJLWUãWURQJJLặLKQQRẳ1đX\XFXYôWặL
:WãQKWDFQ[FãQKFÊXWUèFYWKQJVFấDKWKQJFQJWUQKVDRFKR
3^:FW
t
:W`
t
>3@
7URQJẳ3ONệKLX[FVXÊW:FWOOầQJQặFPNKRQặFFẳWKơSẹQJ
YặLOầQJQặFđQNKFQKDX%LơXWKẹFFẳQJKàDO[FVXÊWPERấQặF
SKLOặQKQPẹFFKRSKâSS
E5QJEXảFFẵDKĐWKàQJ
&F ELơX WKẹF UQJ EXF KRF P W JLặL KQ KRW QJ FấD K
WKQJNKLWKLđWNđYLôXNKLơQQẳ&FJLặLKQẳEDRJắPFFLôXNLQNếWKXÔW
FF\XFXNKDLWKFFấDKWKQJFQEQJQặFKWKQJYY
9ảGFQLôXNKLơQPWNKRQặFSKWLQYặLPFWLXWUDOWQJLQ
QQJFấDQKP\WURQJWKLNểYÔQKQKOOặQQKÊW7ẹFO
7
- (WGW PD[ o
7URQJẳ(WQQJOầQJLQQKÔQầFWLWKLLơPW
LôXNLQFQWKDPQYặLFFUQJEXFVDX
0ềF QặF WURQJ NKRQặFNKQJầF YầWTX PềFQặFGQJEQKWKQJ
+
WE
YNKQJQKKQPềFQặFFKđW+
R
\OUQJEXFYôNếWKXÔW
+
R
d
=W
d
+
EW
/XOầQJWKRTXDPWWP\NKQJYầWTXJLặLKQPD[PLQFấDQẳUQJ
EXFNếWKXÔW
T
PLQ
d
TW
d
T
PD[
/XOầQJWKR[XQJKOXNKQJầFQKKQPWOXOầQJFKRSKâSơ
PERWặLFKRYẩQJKOXYWKDPQ\XFXJLDRWKQJWKấ\UQJEXFGR\X
FXNKDLWKFKWKQJGQJ
T
[
W
t
T
FS
7KLWOSE~LWRQWƯL|XKWKƯQJQJXÊQQ|ôFY~SKxQORL
%LWRQWQJTXWTX\KRFKWLXKWKQJQJXQQầF
*LVẽWDOÔSTX\KRFKSKWWULơQQJXắQQặFWURQJWKLJLDQTX\KRFK7WURQJ
ẳ7OWKLJLDQOÔSTX\KRFKNơWẻWKLLơPOÔSTX\KRFKYảGQPWDOÔS