Tiểu luận tác động của FDI đến tăng trưởng kinh tế ở việt nam
Bạn đang xem bản rút gọn của tài liệu. Xem và tải ngay bản đầy đủ của tài liệu tại đây (323.84 KB, 23 trang )
TÁC ĐỘNG FDI ĐẾN TĂNG TRƯỞNG KINH TẾ
Ở VIỆT NAM
MÔN PHƯƠNG PHÁP NGHIÊN CỨU KINH TẾ
!"#!$%"
$&'()*!'+,%!$
$ !'$"/!,0(12345678!'&9!:;$-%<=
!$%!$'+,
'()*!$>$9?
$%!$>@.$A
'()*!B!'$?%
'()*!?C!'1%!
'()*!$>D#!$E,
(F!$$%!$E,$G
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
1
MNOPQR
STPUVWU
MỤC LỤC
I. ĐẶT VẤN ĐỀ
I"!$"X(Y(J,'"%6/!6$#'"2"SZ[!'\J!7 (6A6],6"#3!A2,!'?C"^O_7A`,ab.cC
.86!'(K!\J!Y(%!6+!'9!$$Ad!'6],6"#3\C'"e!6"#37#!6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#J"Y(%!
$f$%",$"X('"g%O\C6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#7hS7%!'\C&icC.866?!'!$g!'\5!7XY(%!
6+!'6?!'!X!;"!$6#,j%.k"Y(J,'"% ()!$"/!\X.l6cm6$()#6,n!'!$A6$],6"*!\o!6K!
6I"!$"X(Y(%!7"p.;$e,!$%(\X\%"6[,j%O6?!'6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#6I",e,Y(J,'"%6"#3
!$q!!'(K!\J!7 (6A$r!,$(!'SO,-9!$$Ad!'62"!X!;"!$6#d656,9,e,cs!$\],;"!$
6#S\B!$-%\Cah$8"()!$"/!S7J"\2",e,!A2,7%!'3$e66"p!!-",$(!'\C"f6%.!-"
"/!';F\+!'c2!!$56,j%6$($E6O,$j)#(!$t..u,6"/(6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#
v(%!$"X(!B.S6w;$"6$],$"f!,x!',(8,7y".2",z!'\2"\"f,6$x!'Y(%1(q67 (6A
!A2,!'?C"\C?6$e!'WU!B.WT{|S6"#!$C!$;m;#6,e,$"f37>!$6$AG!'.I"&?!'3$AG!'\C
7%3$AG!'"f6%.7h7I67A`,!$"X(6$C!$6](7e!';p-cCZ5($"f(cI,Y(%!,j%Y(e6r!$
,$()p!7y";"!$6#\C,e,,$L!$&e,$.C"f6%.7h\C7%!'6$],$"f!6A2,!$g!'6$%)7y"
!$%!$,$-!',j%!X!;"!$6#6$#'"2"
h,-!$"X(4C"!'$"/!,0(7>!$cA`!'\X.J"Y(%!$f'"g%O\C6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#
,j%!$"X(Y(J,'"%6/!6$#'"2"S7l,4"f6cC,e,!A2,7%!'3$e66"p!e,!'$"/!,0(7>!$cA`!'
6A2,7})6/!6$#'"2"7h&~Zu!'.x$r!$$K"Y()7%4"#!7p7e!$'"e6e,78!',j%O7J"\2"
6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#•C"\"#6!C)&~Zu!'.x$r!$$K"Y()7%4"#!6/!,G&d;#6$w%,e,.x$r!$
6/!6?!'!$"X(!'$"/!,0(7>!$cA`!'7h,-;#6$`3\2"&],$+!c+,,e,4"#!78,cq3\C4"#!
3$u6$(8,,$?3$z$`3\2"6r!$$r!$;"!$6#d"f6%.C4t!'3$AG!'3$e33$}!6L,$$K"
Y()7p7e!$'"e6e,78!',j%O7#!6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#S6w7-,-6$p3$e6$()!$g!'6e,78!'
6L,$,],S$I!,$#!$g!'6e,78!'6"/(,],\C,-6$p6r.7A`,!$g!''"9"3$e3\X.l6,$L!$&e,$
!$t.6$($E6\C&~Zu!'$"f(Y(9!'(K!\J!O'-33$ !6$E,7@)!X!;"!$6#"f6%.6B!'
6Ad!'$G!
I. MỤC TIÊU NGHIÊN CỨU
W Mục tiêu tổng quát
$q!4"#6\C7e!$'"e,e,)#(6J9!$$Ad!'\"f,6e,78!',j%O7#!6B!'6Ad!';"!$
6#"f6%.
U Mục tiêu cụ thể
€ •e,7>!$6e,78!',j%O7#!&]6B!'6Ad!',j%"f6%.6$x!'Y(%,e,cs!$\],;$e,
!$%(
?!'4C"!'$"/!,0(!C)S!$ &ia‚67#!<!'C!$,G;$L:7"f!6~SZf6.%):'"C)Z%S
cAG!'6$],:6$],3$@.
€ Xa(56,e,'"9"3$e36$($E6\C&~Zu!'!'(K!\J!O$"f(Y(9$G!d"f6%.
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
2
MNOPQR
III. CÂU HỎI NGHIÊN CỨU
]%\C?&Jc"f(6w"X(6%Z?%!$!'$"f3!B.UVVW,j%y!',u,$J!';/\XZ?%!$
!'$"f36?!'!A2,SZ?%!$!'$"f3,-\J!7 (6A!A2,!'?C"7pab.a‚6\X6e,78!'d,e,;/!$
;$e,!$%(S4%?6z.$ ($#6,e,$+%678!',j%!X!;"!$6#Y(J,Z}!p69cH"!$g!',}($ƒ"
&%(
€ O6e,78!'7#!6y!'Y(%!!X!;"!$6#!$A6$#!C?6$x!'Y(%,e,cs!$\],;$e,!$%(„
€ e,,$L!$&e,$,j%$C!A2,6?!'\"f,6$($E6\J!O6?!'6$H"'"%!Y(%7h6e,78!'
6$#!C?7#!!X!;"!$6#„
€ r.%.86&J7Xa(56\X.l6,$L!$&e,$!$t.6$($E6\C&~Zu!'$"f(Y(9!'(K!\J!
O
IV. PHẠM VI NGHIÊN CỨU
W Phạm vi không gian
•C"\"#67A`,!'$"/!,0(Z]%6/!6r!$$r!$6B!'6Ad!',e,\z!';"!$6#6$x!'Y(%,e,
&Jc"f(7"X(6%Z?%!$!'$"f36w7-;$e"Y(e6!/!6r!$$r!$6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#"f6%.
U Phạm vi thời gian
•C"\"#6!'$"/!,0(6?!';$?9!'6$H"'"%!6w!B.WT{{:UVV<
V. TỔNG QUAN TÀI LIỆU
1. Các khái niệm và cơ sở lý thuyết có liên quan:
WW Khái niệm
O^O?b"'!"b,6!\b&6.b!6_cC7 (6A6],6"#3!A2,!'?C" cI"O6I".86
Y(J,'"%cC\"f,!$C7 (6A,j%.86!A2,;$e,7A%\J!$?l,456;rc?I"6C"&9!!C?\C?Y(J,'"%
7-7p,-7A`,Y()X!&d$g(\CY()X!Y(9!cm$?l,;"p.&?e6.866$],6$p;"!$6#6I"Y(J,'"%
7-\2".u,6"/(6J"7%$-%c`"L,$,j%.r!$
B!'6Ad!';"!$6#cC&]6B!'c/!\X&JcA`!'S,$56cA`!'S6J,78\CY().x&9!cA`!'
,j%!X!;"!$6#6?!'.866$H";F!$567>!$]6B!'6Ad!'7A`,&?&e!$6$b?,e,6$H"7"p.'J,
&i3$9!e!$6J,786B!'6Ad!'-cC&]'"%6B!'Y().x&9!cA`!';"!$6#!$%!$$%),$q.&?
\2"6$H"7"p.'J,v().x\C6J,786B!'6Ad!'cC…,l37x"…6?!'!8"Z(!';$e"!"f.6B!'
6Ad!';"!$6#"f!!%)S6/!6$#'"2"!'AH"6%6$AH!'6L!$.0,'"%6B!'\X6y!''"e6>,j%,9"
,j%ah$8"4t!',e,7I"cA`!'6y!'&9!3$@.Y(J,Z}!$?l,6y!'&9!3$@.Y(J,!8"
J"Y(%!$f'"g%O\CB!'6Ad!';"!$6#O,-6$p9!$$Ad!'62"!#!;"!$6#d
.+"cs!$\],()!$"/!S7J"\2",e,!A2,7%!'3$e66"p!S!$56cC,e,!A2,!'$†?S;F\+!'c2!
!$56,j%\"f,6$($E6O,$j)#(cC!$t..u,6"/(6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#O 7A`, ,?" cC .86
!'(K!\J! 4y &(!'Y(%!6+!',$?\J! 7 ( 6A6?!'!A2,S!$t.7e3!$(, (7 (6A,$?3$e6
6"p!-!''-3,j%O6?!'7 (6Aah$8"4"#!78!'c2!S.863$ !3$9!e!$Z"*!4"#!6$56
6$AH!',j%!'(K!\J!!C)!$A7h3$}!6L,$d6/!S .863$ !6$p$"f!!$g!'6$%)7y"\X7 (
6A,j%,e,6$C!$3$ !;"!$6#6?!'!A2,
WU Cơ sở lý thuyết nghiên cứu
O6e,78!'62"6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#6$x!'Y(%!$"X(;/!$;$e,!$%($b?,e,$6"#3,q!
$‡3S6e,78!'7J"\2"6B!'6Ad!',j%O6$AH!'7A`,6$x!'Y(%;/!$7 (6A\C'"e!6"#36$x!'
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
3
MNOPQR
Y(%,e,6e,78!'6C!$b?,e,$6"#3,q!8!'SO'})e3c],4(8,!A2,&d6I"3$9"!}!',%?
!B!'c],,I!$6%!$'$"/!,0(!C),$ˆ6q36(!'3$}!6L,$6e,78!',j%O62"6B!'6Ad!'
6$b?,e,$6"#3,q!$‡3SZ]%\C?;$(!';$y3$}!6L,$7h7A`,\q!Zu!'6/!6$#'"2"
1.2.1. Cơ sở lý thuyết về tác động của FDI tới tăng trưởng thông qua kênh đầu tư.
p!'$"/!,0(.J"Y(%!$f'"g%O\C6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#S,n!'!$A7e!$'"e7A`,6e,
78!',j%!-S3$ !!C)6r!$4C).86;$(!';$ycm6$()#6&~Zu!'.x$r!$6B!'6Ad!'!8"&"!$
W
?!'.x$r!$!C)DcC&9!3$@.7 (%,j%!X!;"!$6#7A`,6I?%4d";$(\],&9!a(56&9!
3$@.,(J",z!'4t!',x!'!'$f&9!a(566y!'Y(e6S&~Zu!',e,)#(6J7 (\C?cC\J!\q6,$56
\C\J!,?!!'AH"
U
Y^t_‰A^t_f^K^t_SH^t__
"9&~6"#!48,x!'!'$f'+"cC^6_S6B!'6Ad!'\2"6J,78;$x!'7y"%^$%)
A^t_‰^V_
\2"^V_
cC.0,78,x!'!'$f6I"6$H"7"p.'J,_S6$r\2"$C.&9!a(56'"97>!$d6/!6r!$78
,x!'!'$f&i9!$$Ad!'6L,$,],62",9$%")#(6J7 (\C?
^6_S^6_
#6Y(9,j%,G,$#!C)cC
6"#!48,x!'!'$f&i6e,78!''"e!6"#362"&9!3$@.7 (%
D^6_
1E,!C)DcC6y!'&9!3$@.
Y(J,!8"6$p$"f!6J,786B!'6Ad!';"!$6#Y(%.x$r!$&%(
(1) g
y
= g
GDP
= [
Ω
(F(b,N/ N*))
-1
-
ρ
]
"X(Y(%!6+!'!$56E6%6w.x$r!$cC6K!6I".J"Y(%!$f6],6"#3'"g%O\C6B!'
6Ad!';"!$6#$x!'Y(%OS;$x!'!$g!'!$"X($C!'$?e\J!.2"7A`,6I?%^6B!'6C"&9!
\J!\q6,$56,j%!X!;"!$6#_.C,$"3$L7p&9!a(56%,$E!',[!'"9.7"SY(%7-6e,78!'6L,$
,],62"6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#'?C"%S6J,786B!'6Ad!',[!6Šcf!'$>,$\2".0,,$/!$cf,$\X
,x!'!'$f‹6?!'4C"!C)7A`,7?4t!'6Šcf'"g%&J$C!'$?e\J!.2"&9!a(566?!'!A2,\C
$C!'$?e\J!&9!a(56d,e,!A2,3$e66"p!‹'"g%!A2,!$q!O\C,e,!A2,3$e66"p!e,
78!'!C)4"p(6$>,$?$"f!6A`!'Œ4•6;>3Ž\X6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#,j%!A2,!'$†?$G!&?\2"
!A2,'"C($G!e,6e,78!'6/!7})cCcmZ?;$"#!656,9,e,!A2,7X(56!kc],6$($E6!'(K!
\J!7 (6A6],6"#3!A2,!'?C"S!$56cC,e,!A2,!'$†?\C.x$r!$d^W_cC,G&dcm6$()#67p
7e!$'"e6e,78!',j%O62"6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#d6 .\s.x
?7-!''-3,j%O62"6B!'6Ad!'7J"\2",e,!A2,7%!'3$e66"p!cC56,-m!'$s%
!/!,e,!$C3$}!6L,$,n!'$%)Y(%!6}.62"\"f,ae,7>!$,e,)#(6J6e,78!'7#!6$($E6\C
6$],$"f!Z[!'\J!!C)5!7X!C)&i7A`,ab.a‚6,u6$p6?!'3$ !3$}!6L,$7>!$cA`!'
!$t.4y&(!',$?.u,6"/(,$L!$.C7X6C"7h7A%%4%!7 (
1.2.2. G&dcm6$()#67e!$'"e6e,78!'6C!,j%O
% Cơ chế sinh ra tác động tràn
W$ !!C)6r!$4C).x$r!$cm6$()#6;$e"Y(e6Z]%6/!!$"X(6C"c"f(;$e,!$%(86.x$r!$cm6$()#6,u6$p
$G!\C&~Zu!'$C.&9!a(56?44‹?('c%&,-6$p6$%.;$9?!'$"/!,0(,j%•?b!&•6b"!b6%c^WTT•_
Up!'•!'+!d7})'+"6•6cC\J!\q6,$56?!'3$}!6L,$6B!'6Ad!'\C.x$r!$6B!'6Ad!'6$],,$56cC6C"
&9!\J!\C7A`,$r!$6$C!$Y(%Y(e6r!$7 (6A\C6L,$cn)!$A.e).+,S!$CaAd!'\\3$u,\u,$?Y(e6r!$&9!
a(56$e"!"f.\J!,?!!'AH"7A`,&~Zu!'56!$"X(6?!'cm6$()#6\C.x$r!$6B!'6Ad!'\C7h,-!$"X(7>!$
!'$s%;$e,!$%(?!',-6$p$"p(,$(!'cC\J!,?!!'AH"cC!B!'c],,j%,?!!'AH"7A`,&~Zu!'\C?Y(e6r!$
&9!a(567p.%!'cI"!B!'&(56,%?$G!\X.l6;"!$6#?\q)S\J!,?!!'AH"cC;#6Y(9,j%Y(e6r!$7 (6A\C
6L,$cn)!/!,[!7A`,'+"cC6C"&9!\J!,?!!'AH" (6A,$?'"e?Zu,S7C?6I?\C)6#&i'-33$ !cC.6B!'\J!
,?!!'AH"
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
4
MNOPQR
e,,$()/!'"%6$],$"f!!'$"/!,0(6e,78!',j%7 (6A!A2,!'?C"62"6B!'6Ad!';"!$
6#d"f6%.,$?t!'S;F\+!'c2!!$56,j%,e,!A2,7%!'3$e66"p!6?!'\"f,6$($E67 (6A
!A2,!'?C"cC!$t..u,6"/(6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#\2"$%"cmZ?,$L!$Thứ nhấtS7 (6A!A2,
!'?C"7A`,,?"cC.86!'(K!\J!Y(%!6+!'7p4y&(!'\J!7 (6A6?!'!A2,Thứ haiS7 (6A
!A2,!'?C"6I?,G$8",$?,e,!A2,!'$†?6"#3,q!,x!'!'$f6"/!6"#!$G!SZ*ZC!',$()p!'"%?
,x!'!'$f$G!S6$E,7@)Y(e6r!$3$y4"#!;"#!6$0,S!}!',%?;‘!B!'Y(9!cm\C6r!$78c%?
78!'e,78!'!C)7A`,ab.cC6e,78!'6C!,j%7 (6A!A2,!'?C"S'-33$ !cC.6B!'!B!'
&(56,j%,e,Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,\C,(J",z!'cC7-!''-3\C?6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#!-"
,$(!'
q)Stác động tràn là tác động gián tiếp xuất hiện khi có mặt của các doanh nghiệp FDI
làm cho các doanh nghiệp trong nước thay đổi hành vi của mình như thay đổi công nghệ, thay
đổi chiến lược sản xuất kinh doanhe,78!'!C)S,-’;/!$a(56$"f!6e,78!'6C!!$"X(!$56
;/!$Z",$()p!c%?78!'S;/!$3$y4"#!“,$()p!'"%?,x!'!'$fS;/!$c"/!;#6&9!a(56\C
;/!$,I!$6%!$
Kênh di chuyển lao động:
1%?78!',-;‘!B!',$()p!6wZ?%!$!'$"f3O62"Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,7A`,,?"
cC.86;/!$Y(%!6+!',-6$p6I?%6e,78!'6C!6L,$,],6e,78!'6C!a9)%!#(!$A&Jc%?
78!'!C)&~Zu!';"#!6$0,7h$+,7A`,6?!'6$H"'"%!cC.\"f,6I",e,Z?%!$!'$"f3O\C?
,x!'\"f,6?!'Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,-$%",e,$7p6I?%6e,78!'6C!-cC&Jc%?78!'
!C)6]6$C!$cq3x!'6)"/!'$?l,cC.6$(/,$?,e,Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,S!$56cC6?!'
,z!'!'C!$.CZ?%!$!'$"f3O7%!'$?I678!'
Kênh phổ biến & chuyển giao công nghệ:
})cC.86;/!$56Y(%!6+!'7p6I?%6e,78!'6C!6L,$,],,j%O$?7#!!%),$ˆ
6"/($%)7A`,Zz!'7p7?;$9!B!'$536$u,x!'!'$fcC6r!$78$+,\5!$?l,6r!$78,$()/!
.x!,j%c%?78!'6?!'Z?%!$!'$"f3\C,$ˆ6"/(4"p(6$>,$?7y".2",x!'!'$f,j%Z?%!$
!'$"f36$p$"f!Y(%,$ˆ6"/(,$?,e,$?I678!'“
86)#(6J;$e,9!$$Ad!'7#!\"f,a(56$"f!6e,78!'6C!cC;$9!B!'6"#36$(,x!'
!'$f.2",j%,$L!$,e,Z?%!$!'$"f3O$"X(!'$"/!,0(,$?t!',x!'!'$f.2",$j)#(
Z?,e,,x!'6).‡6I?%S6?!';$"7-,e,,x!'6),?!d,e,!A2,7%!'3$e66"p!$ (!$A,$ˆ
6q36(!'7#!;$}(&9!a(56,$"#.cs!$6$>6AH!'Z]%6/!,e,c`"6$#\X,x!'!'$fZ?,x!'6)
,(!',53?7-;$9!B!'6"#36$(,x!'!'$f,j%,e,,x!'6),?!$?I678!'d!A2,!$q!7 (6A
!'C),C!',%?S,C!',-c`",$?Y(e6r!$&"!$%6e,78!'6C!6L,$,],Y(%[ˆ,x!'!'$f
Kênh liên kết sản xuất
/!$c"/!;#6&9!a(56cC.86;/!$56Y(%!6+!'6I?%6e,78!'6C!e,78!'Œ!'A`,
,$"X(Œ,-6$pa(56$"f!!/!,e,Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,,(!',53!'()/!c"f($?l,3$}!3$J"
&9!3$@.,j%,e,Z?%!$!'$"f3!A2,!'?C"0,786e,78!',C!',%?!#(;$J"cA`!'&9!
3$@.3$}!3$J"$?l,!'()/!c"f(,(!',53,C!'!$"X(S60,cCY(%!$f6Šcf6$(q!
?!'c"/!;#6&9!a(566K!6I"ZA2"$%"$r!$6$0,7-cCc"/!;#6Z+,\Cc"/!;#6!'%!'
1"/!;#6Z+,cC&9!3$@.,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3!C)cC!'()/!c"f(7 (\C?,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3;"%
1"/!;#6!'%!'cC,e,Z?%!$!'$"f3,z!'&9!a(56.86c?I"&9!3$@.
Kênh cạnh tranh
]a(56$"f!,j%,e,Z?%!$!'$"f3O,-6$p6I?%e3c],,I!$6%!$c2!,$?,e,Z?%!$!'$"f3
6?!'!A2,S6A2,$#6cC7y".2"Z?%!$!'$"f36?!',z!'!$ !'C!$p6$(7A`,4"p($"f!
,j%;/!$6e,78!'!C),$E!'6%, !6$(!$q3!$g!'6$x!'6"!\X&0,‚3,I!$6%!$6$>6AH!',j%
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
5
MNOPQR
U
9!cA`!'
"e6$C!$W7G!\>&9!3$@.
Z?%!$!'$"f3Z?Z?%!$!'$"f36]7e!$'"e?!';$(\],Z?%!$!'$"f3O,$>(&0,‚3,I!$
6%!$c2!!$56'"g%,e,Z?%!$!'$"f3!C)\2"!$%(6$r,e,Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,cI",$?t!'
$+7%!',$>(&0,‚3,I!$6%!$.I!$!'%!'!$%(6w,e,Z?%!$!'$"f3O\C,$L!$,e,Z?%!$
!'$"f36?!'!A2,?!';$"Z?%!$!'$"f3O,$>(e3c],.I!$!$56\X&9!3$@.!$A,$j!'
c?I"S.o(.hS6$r,e,Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,cI"7e!$'"e,%?!$56\X,x!'!'$f,-6r!$78,%?
$G!6w,e,Z?%!$!'$"f3O
b. x$r!$A2,cA`!'
e!$'"e6e,78!'6C!,j%O,-6$p7A`,6$],$"f!4t!',9$%"3$AG!'3$e37>!$6L!$
\C7>!$cA`!'$?l,;#6$`3,9$%"()!$"/!S;#6Y(9,j%7e!$'"e7>!$6L!$,$j)#(.%!'6L!$
.x69Sae,7>!$;$9!B!',-$%);$x!',-,e,4"p($"f!,-6$p6I?%6e,78!'6C!S!$A!';$x!'
7e!$'"e7A`,6e,78!'6C!,-6$],&]a(56$"f!$%);$x!'\C.0,78,j%,e,6e,78!'7-
e!$'"e4t!'3$AG!'3$e37>!$cA`!';$•,3$u,7"p.)#(!C)6/!,G&de3Zu!',e,.x$r!$
;"!$6#cA`!'7A`,&~Zu!'!'C),C!'!$"X(w7-,-6$pE6%!$g!';#6Y(9,u6$p$G!\C\r
\q),-m!'$s%7J"\2",e,!$C$?I,$7>!$,$L!$&e,$
]a(56$"f!,j%O,-6$p&"!$%6e,78!'6C!6$x!'Y(%!$"X(;/!$;$e,!$%(()
!$"/!S,e,6e,78!'!C)6$AH!',$ˆ,-6$p!$q!4"#67A`,6$x!'Y(%6$%)7y"\X;#6Y(9&9!a(56S
,-6$p7?4t!'!B!'&(56,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3Xcm6$()#6S&]a(56$"f!,j%O,-6$pcC.6$%)
7y"!B!'&(56c%?78!',j%656,9Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,p;"p.7>!$&]6K!6I",j%6e,78!'
6C!, !6A2,$#6ab.a‚6.J"Y(%!$f'"g%.0,786$%.'"%,j%3$L%!A2,!'?C"\C&]6$%)7y"
!B!'&(56c%?78!',j%,e,Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,C.!B!'&(56Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,
!-",$(!'
(2) = F(,FDI
j
, trinhdo
ij
, quimo
ij
, nganh
j
)
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
Hộp1: Tác động cạnh tranh của FDI tới doanh nghiệp trong nước
vW vU
r!$6/!cC.86\LZu6$p$"f!3$9!0!'^$%)cC;#6Y(9,j%6e,78!'6C!_,j%Z?%!$
!'$"f36?!'!A2,6A2,&]a(56$"f!,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3O,z!'!'C!$6?!'!'•!$I!]
c5!e66$>6AH!',j%Z?%!$!'$"f3OcC.6$($‡36$>3$ !,j%Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,
\C7@),$"3$L,J7>!$c/!,%?A2,6e,78!'!C)SZ?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,,-a($A2!'
7"X(,$ˆ!$'"9.,$"3$L6(!'4r!$^6wWa(J!'U_$A!'!#(e3c],,I!$6%!$4%!
7 (6wZ?%!$!'$"f3O7j.I!$SZ?%!$!'$"f3&i4(8,3$9"'"9.&9!cA`!'^6wvWa(J!'
vU_\C6e,78!',(J",z!'cCcC.6B!''"e6$C!$6/!W7G!\>&9!3$@.^,$()p!Z>,$6w\>
6LWc/!U_
Nguồn: Aitken và Harrison (1999).
6
MNOPQR
?!'$C.!B!'&(566/!S trinhdo
ij
\Cquimo
ij
cC$%"4"#!4"p(6$>7l,6A!',j%Z?%!$
!'$"f3S\2"trinhdo
ij
7?cAH!'c%?78!',-6r!$78\Cquimo
ij
4"p(6$>,$?Y(".x$?l,\>6$#,j%
Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!'C!$,-6$p7?4t!'!$"X(,$ˆ6"/(;$e,!$%(-cC4"#!'"97l,6A!',$?
!$ !'C!$,u6$p6?!'!'C!$”"96$()#6, !;"p.7>!$6$x!'Y(%.x$r!$!C)cC6$%)7y"\X
.0,786$%.'"%,j%3$L%!A2,!'?C" FDI
ij
9!$$Ad!'!$A6$#!C?62"!B!'&(56c%?78!',j%
Z?%!$!'$"f3
x$r!$6/!,n!'7A`,&~Zu!'7pae,7>!$\C7e!$'"e6e,78!'6C!,j%O62",e,
Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,l,Zz&]a(56$"f!,j%O6?!'!'C!$!C),-6$p6e,78!''"e!6"#3
62";#6Y(9$?I678!';"!$Z?%!$,j%,e,Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!'C!$;$e,S!$A!'7J"6A`!',$>(
9!$$Ad!'6],6"#3\o!cC,e,Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,,z!'!'C!$?7-S6e,78!'6C!,-6$p
!$q!4"#6Y(%&]6$%)7y"\X!B!'&(56c%?78!',j%,e,Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,;$"a(56$"f!
7 (6A6],6"#3!A2,!'?C"\C?!'C!$.CZ?%!$!'$"f37%!'$?I678!'Q.x$r!$!C)
vitheFDI cC7I"cA`!'3$9!e!$\>6$#,j%3$L%!A2,!'?C"6?!'!'C!$
<
\CdicC;m$"f(,j%
Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,2"&]$"p!Z"f!,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3O6?!'!'C!$”S!B!'&(56c%?
78!',j%Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,6?!'!'C!$7-,-6$p3$u6$(8,\C?,e,)#(6J6$p$"f!d
3$AG!'6r!$^<_
(3) ()
dij
= F(()
dij
, vitheFDI
j
, nghiencuu
dij
, trinhdo
dij
)
C. !B!' &(56 d ^<_ ,- 6$p Zz!' 7p !'$"/! ,0( 6e, 78!' 6C! ,j% O 62" Z?%!$
!'$"f36?!'!A2,\C,-6$p4"#!7y"7pab.a‚66e,78!'6C!6$p$"f!Y(%\"f,c]%,$+!7I"
cA`!'7?Œ\>6$#Ž,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3O6?!'!'C!$e,78!'6C!,$ˆab.!$Aa(56$"f!!#(
4"#!Œ\>6$#Ž!C),-9!$$Ad!'62"!B!'&(56S6$p$"f!Y(%Z5(\C.0,m!'$s%6$J!';/,j%
4"#!6?!',e, 3$}!6L,$7>!$cA`!' /!6$], 6# ,9 ae,7>!$\C6e,$4I,$6e,78!'6C!,j%
,e,;/!$6()X!6e,78!'cC56;$-
'?C"7?cAH!'6e,78!'6],6"#3S.x$r!$^<_,$?3$‚3ab.a‚69!$$Ad!',j%.86
&J)#(6
J
;$e,
4"p(6$>;$9!B!'$536$u6e,78!'6C!,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3G&d7p;"p.7>!$
Z]% \C?;#6Y(9,
j
%
!$"X(
!'$"/!,0( ,$?t!'S6e,78!'6C!,n!'!$A .0, 78,j% !- 3$u
6$(8, !$"X( \C? ;$9 !B!' $53 6$u $%) ;$9 !B!' 7"X( ,$ˆ!$ ,j% Z?%!$ !'$"f3
;$"a(56 $"f!
3$L%!A2,!'?C"%")#(6JY(%!6+!'$%)7A`,!$•,7#!cC6r!$78,x!'
!'$f\Cc%?78!'
,-6r!$78?!'.x$r!$^<_Snghiencuu
dij
cC,$"6"/(,$?!'$"/!,0(\C6"p! ;$%" ,j%Z?%!$
!'$"f36?!'!A2,6?!'!'C!$7A`,Zz!'7p7?!B!'c],,x!'!'$f,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3'?C"
%S,$"6"/(,$?!'$"/!,0(\C6"p!;$%",[!6$p$"f!“
cC .86 7I" cA`!' 6e, 78!' 6],
6"#3 62" !B!' &(56 c%? 78!' ,j% Z?%!$ !'$"f3 •"#!
trinhdo
dij
,n!',-m!'$s%6AG!'6]!$A
4"#!nghiencuu
dij,
\w%6e,78!'62"!B!'&(56S\w%;"p.&?e6\%"6[,j%c%?78!';‘!B!'62"Y(e
6r!$6I?%6e,78!'6C!
$(!';$y 3$}! 6L,$ 6r!$ 4C) d 6/!cC ,G&d 7p6"#! $C!$ 3$}! 6L,$ 7>!$ cA`!' 6e,
78!'6C!,j%O7#!6B!'6Ad!'?;$9!B!'e3Zu!',j%,e,.x$r!$cm6$()#63$u6$(8,
c2!\C? &J c"f( 6$(6$q37A`,S!/!,e,.x$r!$7>!$cA`!'&i,-!$g!'4"#!7y"!$567>!$7p
3$z$`3\2""f6%.\C6q!Zu!'6J"7%&Jc"f(.C!$ 6e,'"96$(6$q37A`,
2. Giới thiệu các nghiên cứu trước đây có liên quan
(6A6],6"#3!A2,!'?C"^O?b"'!"b,6!\b&6.b!6‹O_,-6$p9!$$Ad!'62"!X!
;"!$6#d.+"cs!$\],;"!$6#S\B!$-%\Cah$8"()!$"/!d7})6%,$ˆa‚67#!6e,78!',j%
O7#!6J,786B!'6Ad!'!-",$(!'S7h,-56!$"X(4C"!'$"/!,0(a?%)Y(%!$7X6C"!C)S7l,
<-6$p&~Zu!',e,,$ˆ6"/(;$e,!$%(7p7?Œ\>6$/Ž!$A6Š6+!'Z?%!$6$(,j%656,9Z?%!$!'$"f3O&?\2"
6y!'Z?%!$6$(,j%!'C!$\\
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
7
MNOPQR
4"f6cC,e,!'$"/!,0(&}(\X,e,!$}!6J9!$$Ad!',j%O7#!6J,786B!'6Ad!'B.UVV<S
1%(%c•%?^I"$+,%\%Z_7h\"#64C"!'$"/!,0(,$ˆ%.J"Y(%!$f'"g%O\C&]6B!'
6Ad!'4t!',e,$;"p.6%Y()c(q6Z[!'O7-!'\%"6[6$E,7@)6B!'6Ad!'6?!'4%6$C!$
3$ !,$L!$,j%!X!;"!$6#S,u6$p7-cCcs!$\],,G49!6$"#6)#(S&9!a(56\CZ>,$\u,j%’|
Y(J,'"%;$e,!$%(6?!'4C"!'$"/!,0( Foreign Direct Investment and Growth: Does the
Section Matter?#!!B.UVV=S.864e?,e?!'$"/!,0(,j%!$ 6e,'"96$],$"f!Z]e!,$?
y,$0,$`36e,3$e66"p!Y(J,6#$u)"p! ^_ScC'()*!$>(f!$^Ad!'
!$ _S$n•(}!'()f6K!'S$ !?C!$•!'S'()*!I!$9"S!'$"/!,0(
&}($G!\X!$g!'!$}!6J9!$$Ad!',j%O7#!6J,786B!'6Ad!';"!$6#6?!'7X6C"Tác
động của đầu tư trực tiếp nước ngoài tới tăng trưởng kinh tế ở Việt Nam.9$%"4C"!'$"/!,0(
6/!7X(0!'Zu!'.x$r!$$K"Y()6$p$"f!6e,78!',j%,e,!$}!6J9!$$Ad!',j%O7#!6J,
786B!'6Ad!';"!$6#
3. Nội dung chính các nghiên cứu trước đây có liên quan
1%(%c•%?^UVV<_7ha})Z]!'.x$r!$$K"Y()6$p$"f!&]6e,78!',j%!B.!$
4"#!78,cq37#!4"#!3$u6$(8,cC6J,786B!'6Ad!'?!'7-!B.!$ 4"#!78,cq34%?'K.
!$ 4"#!\X4%!7 (‹INNITIAL GDP–7 (6AY(J,!8"6?!'Z%!$&e,$4"#!;"p.&?e6S;L
$"f(CONTROLS–O6?!'4%cs!$\],cs!$\],,G49!6$"#6)#(^FDI
P
_Scs!$\],&9!a(56
^FDI
M
_\Ccs!$\],Z>,$\u^FDI
S
_k"!$ 4"#!cC,e,4"#!78,cq36$p$"f!,e,7l,6A!',j%
!$ 4"#!S,$"6"#6,e,!$ 4"#!&i7A`,6r!$4C)d3$ !.x$r!$&~Zu!'e,Y(%!&e66?!'
.x$r!$7A`,c5)6wZgc"f(—\C˜?cZ!\b&6.b!6b3?6,j%’|Y(J,'"%\C6$(6$q3&J
c"f(6$b?'"%"7?I!WT{W‹WTTTw;#6Y(9.x$r!$!C)S1%(%c•%?7h7A%%.86&J3$}!6L,$
\X.0,78\C,$"X($A2!'6e,78!',j%,e,4"#!78,cq36$(8,!B.!$ 4"#!c/!6J,786B!'
6Ad!';"!$6#,j%.86Y(J,'"%
'$"/!,0(,j%!$ 4J!6e,'"9cC '()*!$>(f!$^Ad!'!$ _S$n
•(}!'()f6K!'S$ !?C!$•!'S'()*!I!$9"6$],$"f!Z]e!,$?y,$0,
$`36e,3$e66"p!Y(J,6#$u)"p!^_^UVV=_Sa})Z]!'.x$r!$$K"Y()6$p$"f!6e,
78!'Z[!'O62"6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#.86Y(J,'"%6$x!'Y(%;/!$7 (6A\C;/!$6e,78!'
6C!x$r!$$K"Y()6?!'!'$"/!,0(\X6e,78!'Z[!'O62"6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#6$x!'Y(%
;/!$7 (6A'K.!B.!$ 4"#!78,cq36e,78!'7#!4"#!3$u6$(8,cC6J,786B!'6Ad!'g
t
?!'7-!B.!$ 4"#!78,cq34%?'K.!$ 4"#!FDI
t
6$p$"f!7 (6A6],6"#3!A2,!'?C"–
H
t
cC4"#!4"p(6$>,$?6C"&9!\J!,?!!'AH"!$t.7e!$'"e6e,78!',j%\J!,?!!'AH"62"6B!'
6Ad!'–4"#!(FDIxH)
t
7A`,,?"cC.867I"cA`!'4"p(6$>;$9!B!'$536$uO,j%!X!;"!$6#–
4"#!hoinhapkt
t
6$p$"f!9!$$Ad!',j%\"f,$8"!$q3\C?!X!;"!$6#;$(\],\C6$#'"2";X
t
cC
6q3$`3,j%,e,4"#!78,cq3;$e,,-9!$$Ad!'62"6B!'6Ad!'!$A,$"6"/(,$L!$3$jS\J!7 (
6A6?!'!A2,\2"6A,e,$cC.867I"cA`!'ae,7>!$6B!'6Ad!'\C;#6Y(9,j%$?I678!'a(56
!$q3;$@(3$9!e!$78.d,j%!X!;"!$6#™e,Y(%!&e66?!'.x$r!$7A`,c5)6w&Jc"f(
,$L!$6$0,Z?y!'u,6$J!';/\Cu, (6AA2,!'?C"‹•8#$?I,$\C (6A,(!',53
6wWT{{‹UVV<[!6e,78!'Z[!'O7#!6J,786B!'6Ad!',j%.86Y(J,'"%6$x!'Y(%;/!$
6e,78!'6C!7A`,3$}!6L,$4t!'$%",e,$cC7>!$cA`!'\C7>!$6L!$$AG!'3$e37>!$6L!$
Z]%\C?&Jc"f(6w"X(6%Z?%!$!'$"f3!B.UVVW,j%y!',u,$J!';/\C;#6Y(97"X(6%
<<Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,S=VZ?%!$!'$"f3,-\J!7 (6A!A2,!'?C"7pab.a‚6,e,Z5($"f(
\X6e,78!'6C!d,e,;/!$;$e,!$%(?.o(7"X(6%!$ƒ!/!&Jc"f(!C),$ˆe3Zu!',$?
3$}!6L,$7>!$cA`!'S!$t.7A%%.8640,6%!$;$e"Y(e6\X,e,;/!$;$e,!$%(,j%6e,78!'
6C!$ !3$}!6L,$7>!$cA`!'$?C!6?C!&~Zu!'&Jc"f("X(6%Z?%!$!'$"f3,j%y!',u,
6$J!';/!B.UVVW\2".o(6/!•=!'C!Z?%!$!'$"f3\C4%?6z.$ ($#6,e,$+%678!',j%
!X!;"!$6#Y(J,Z}!S7A`,,$"%cC.UV!$ !'C!$^U&J_;$e,!$%(x$r!$$K"Y()\X7e!$
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
8
MNOPQR
'"e6e,78!'6C!,j%Oc/!6B!'6Ad!',j%.86Y(J,'"%7A`,6$p$"f!Y(%.x$r!$O\C
!B!'&(56c%?78!',j%Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,\C!-",$(!'x$r!$$K"Y(),j%O\C!B!'
&(56c%?78!',j%Z?%!$!'$"f3!-",$(!'6$p$"f!Y(%6e.!$ 4"#!78,cq36e,78!'c/!4"#!
3$u6$(8,cC!B!'&(56?!'.x$r!$!C)S4"#!3$u6$(8,nangsuatcC7I"cA`!'7?!B!'&(56
c%?78!',j%Z?%!$!'$"f3–4"#!trinhdo6$p$"f!,$56cA`!',j%c%?78!'6?!'Z?%!$!'$"f3–
4"#!quimo 4"p(6$>,$?Y().xZ?%!$!'$"f36?!'!'C!$\C.0,7878,Y()X!,j%Z?%!$
!'$"f36?!'!'C!$–4"#! cuongdovon 7?,AH!'78&~Zu!'\J!6/!Wc%?78!',j%Z?%!$
!'$"f3ScC7I"cA`!'7?6C"&9!\J!\q6,$56.CZ?%!$!'$"f36I?%6?!'Y(e6r!$7 (6Ae,
4"#!,[!cI"cC4"#!'"9S6?!'7-,e,4"#!Dluongthuc, Ddetmay \C Ddientu!$t.;"p.&?e69!$
$Ad!',j%6w!'3$}!!'C!$62"!B!'&(56,$(!',j%;$(\],Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'.o(&Jc"f(
,$‚?–4"#!Dsohuu6$p$"f!$r!$6$0,&d$g(,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3O–4"#!'"9Dtinh6$p$"f!,e,
Z?%!$!'$"f3,-6u&d,$L!$6I",e,6ˆ!$,-.q6787 (6A!A2,!'?C",%?$?l,6$(8,,e,\z!'
;$e,J"\2".x$r!$$K"Y(),j%O\C!B!'&(56c%?78!',j%Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,6$p
$"f!Y(%49)!$ 4"#!78,cq36e,78!'c/!4"#!3$u6$(8,cC!B!'&(56^nangsuat
i
_"p.;$e,
4"f6c2!!$56,j%.x$r!$!C)&?\2".x$r!$d3$ !!B!'&(56cC4"#!78,cq3tytrong6$p$"f!
&],-.l6\CY().x,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3OS3$9!9!$.0,78&š!,-,j%&Jc"f(–4"#!'"9
hopdong
i
6$p$"f!Z?%!$!'$"f3,-$%);$x!',-Y(%!$f\2"7J"6e,!A2,!'?C"$g!'!$
4"#!,-6?!'.x$r!$!C)!$Acuongdovon
i
, trinhdo
i
, quimo
i
, Dtinh
i
, 6AG!'6]!$A!$g!'!$
4"#!7A`,!/(d.x$r!$O\C!B!'&(56c%?78!',j%Z?%!$!'$"f3!-",$(!'9.x$r!$
7>!$6L!$co!7>!$cA`!'7X(3$9!e!$\X!$g!'!$}!6J9!$$Ad!',j%O7#!6J,786B!'
6Ad!';"!$6#d.86Y(J,'"%
4. Đánh giá, nhận xét chung
%"4C"\"#67h7A%%$%".x$r!$$K"Y();$e,!$%(\2"$%",e,$6"#3,q!;$e,!$%(
J"\2"4C"\"#6Foreign Direct Investment and Growth: Does the Section Matter?j%
1%(%c•%?^I"$+,%\%Z_•C"!C)ab.cI".J"Y(%!$f'"g%O\C&]6B!'6Ad!'4t!'
,e,$;"p.6%Y()c(q6Z[!'O7-!'\%"6[6$E,7@)6B!'6Ad!'6?!'4%6$C!$3$ !,$L!$,j%
!X!;"!$6#S,u6$p7-cCcs!$\],,G49!6$"#6)#(S&9!a(56\CZ>,$\u•C"\"#67h&~Zu!'.86
&J3$}!6L,$6$],!'$"f.&~Zu!'Zgc"f(,$‚?,j%,e,Y(J,'"%6?!''"%"7?I!WT{W‹WTTT7p
,$ˆ%t!'6y!'O7h7b.cI"!$"X(9!$$Ad!'7#!&]6B!'6Ad!'$b?.x$r!$,j%4C"\"#6
!C)S6e,'"97h&~Zu!',e,4"#!cCO6?!'4%cs!$\],cs!$\],,G49!6$"#6)#(^FDI
P
_Scs!$
\],&9!a(56^FDI
M
_\Ccs!$\],Z>,$\u^FDI
S
_!$t.,$0!'."!$&e!'›.u,7L,$,n!'!$A
'"96$"#6,j%4C"\"#6e,4"#!d7})cC78,cq3S&JcA`!'7jc2!\CcC&Jc"f(6$0,53\2"!'(K!
,(!'%!6?C!cCZgc"f(—\C˜?cZ!\b&6.b!6b3?6,j%’|Y(J,'"%\C6$(6$q3&Jc"f(
6$b?'"%"7?I!WT{W‹WTTTv(%4C"\"#6!C)S6%,-6$p6$5)7A`,.86,e,$!$r!6y!'Y(%!\X.J"
Y(%!$f'"g%O6?!'6w!'cs!$\],;"!$6#7J"\2"&]6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#w7-'"E36%7>!$
$A2!'3$}!4y!'(K!7 (6AO6?!'6w!'cs!$\],()!$"/!S4C"\"#6!C),$ˆZw!'cI"d.0,
786y!'Y(%!S,$?6%,e"!$r!4X.l64/!!'?C",j%\5!7X6e,78!'O7#!&]6B!'6Ad!',j%
;"!$6#•C"\"#6;$x!'6$p$"/!›6e,78!'4/!6?!'\5!7XS,G,$#6()X!Zo!ScC.6$#!C?O
6e,78!'7#!&]6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#
•‚6\X3$AG!'3$e3!'$"/!,0(SLaura Alfaro (2003) 7h&~Zu!'3$AG!'3$e3,$+!.o(
3$}!!$ 7p3$}!6L,$\2".o(7]?,,$+!cC’|!A2,4%?'K.,e,Y(J,'"%;$(\],—S
;$(\],$e"•"!$AG!'S$}($"S‘1%"!$S\z!'4"p!%"4b\2"Zgc"f(7A`,c5)6$b?
!$"X(;r;$e,!$%(7pcC.›7A`,6e,78!',j%O7#!6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#,j%,e,Y(J,'"%
6/!6$#'"2"
•C"\"#6&~Zu!'3$AG!'3$e37>!$cA`!';#6$`3,e,.x$r!$$K"Y(";"!$6#cA`!'Z]%
6/!&Jc"f(7A`,6$(6$q36w!$"X(!'(K!;$e,!$%(˜‹˜?cZ!\b&6.b!6b3?6SZgc"f(
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
9
MNOPQR
6$b?!'C!$,j%,e,!A2,—S;$(\],$}($e"•r!$AG!'S$}($"S‘1%"!$S
\z!'%"4bœ6w!B.WT{V7#!,(J"WTTTS$ˆJ$e6"p!j%'}!C!'$#"2"\X,e,
Y(J,'"%,-6?!'.o(7"X(6%™
x$r!$$K"Y("7A`,&~Zu!'6?!'!'$"/!,0(.x$r!$$K"Y(";"!$6#cA`!'\2"$ (
$#6,e,4"#!6?!'$K"Y()\C,e,'"e6>7A%\C?.x$r!$7X(cC7I"Z"f!,$?6(!'4r!$,j%6$H"
;F!'$"/!,0(e,4"#!$K"Y("4%?'K.0,&9!cA`!'\C6B!'6Ad!'S^!'(K!6w,$ˆ&J
3$e66"p!,j%'}!$C!'$#'"2"UVVW_S7 (6A6],6"#3!A2,!'?C",j%,e,!A2,6?!'.o(S™
'$"/!,0(&~Zu!'3$AG!3$e33$}!6L,$6$],!'$"f.&~Zu!'Zgc"f(,$‚?,j%,e,Y(J,'"%
6?!''"%"7?I!WT{W‹WTTT
2",e,Y(J,'"%7A`,7A%\C?.o(!$A"f6%.S•,S(!'v(J,S$q6•9!SC!
v(J,S‘%!%Z%S!$S8!'[%,bc%!ZS1C?Sž!8S™d!$"X(6$H";r;"!$6#;$e,!$%(S
.o(.C6e,'"9c]%,$+!,$?!'$"/!,0(7h6$p$"f!7A`,;$e›!‚6\X6e,78!',j%O7#!
6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#,j%,e,!A2,6/!6$#'"2"Y(%!$"X(;$L%,I!$,$()p!'"%?,x!'!'$f\C
3$AG!'6$0,Y(9!cmS7 (6A!A2,!'?C"\C?&9!a(56\CZ>,$\uS
'$"/!,0(!C),$ˆ›.J"Y(%!$f'"g%O\C&]6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#4t!',e,$;"p.
6%Y()c(q6Z[!'O7-!'\%"6[6$E,7@)6B!'6Ad!'6?!'4%6$C!$3$ !,$L!$,j%!X!;"!$
6#S,u6$p7-cCcs!$\],,G49!6$"#6)#(S&9!a(56\CZ>,$\u!$A6$/!C?e,c`"L,$6$AH!'
Y(b!6$(8,,n!'7h7A`,7X,q3!$A,$()p!'"%?,x!'!'$f\C3$AG!'6$0,Y(9!cmS'"2"6$"f(
3$AG!'3$e3;$?%$+,;s6$(q6.2"S\C7C?6I?!'(K!!$}!c],$A2!'7#!cs!$\],&9!a(56
,x!'!'$"f3S;s6$(q6!$"X($G!cC!x!'!'$"f3\C;$%";$?e!'S™
$g!'7"X(6/!7h7A`,;$•,3$u,6?!'4C"\"#6ŽTác động của đầu tư trực tiếp nước
ngoài tới tăng trưởng kinh tế ở Việt Nam” ,j%!$ ’6e,'"9cC '()*!$>(f!$\C
,8!'&]•C"\"#6!C)7h7"&}(3$}!6L,$!$g!'6e,78!',j%O7J"\2"&]6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#
6$x!'Y(%U;/!$cC;/!$7 (6A\C6e,78!'6C!J"\2"6w!';$L%,I!$6e,78!'S!$ 6e,'"9
7h6$C!$cq36w!'.x$r!$3$z$`3\2",e,$3$}!6L,$\Ccq3c(q!,j%!'AH"\"#6z)6w!'4"#!
!$ 6e,'"97A%%Zgc"f(3$z$`3?!'4C"\"#6S6e,'"97h7A%%U!$ Zgc"f(,97>!$
6L!$\C7>!$cA`!'?!'4C"!'$"/!,0(S!$ 6e,'"97hc5);L,$6$A2,.o(;$ec2!\C,-
!$g!'7"X(,$ˆ!$\X.o(7p79.49?\X,$56cA`!',$?Zgc"f(!$t.7A%%.x$r!$6J6!$56
,$?6w!'\5!7X2",e,$cq3c(q!S3$}!6L,$,n!'!$A\"f,7A%%6w!'.x$r!$7J"\2"6w!'
6e,78!'S4C"\"#67h,$?,$E!'6%6$5)6w!'6e,78!',j%O7J"\2"&]6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#})
cC.86,G&dY(%!6+!'6?!'\"f,7Xa(56!$g!',$L!$&e,$3$z$`37p&~Zu!'!'(K!\J!O
7I6$"f(Y(96J6!$56()!$"/!S6?!'4C"\"#6,[!,-.86&J$I!,$#$A!$ 6e,'"97h7X
,q36?!'4C"\"#6S\5!7XŒ6e,78!',j%O7J"\2"&]6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#ŒS6?!'4C"\"#6!C)
,$ˆ'"9"Y()#66?!'3$I.\"!'$s%$‡3S;$x!'7X,q3.86&J\5!7X;$e,!$AO'})e3c],
4(8,!A2,&d6I"3$9"!}!',%?!B!'c],,I!$6%!$Y(J,'"%.C6A2,$#6cC,9"6$"f!.x"6AH!'
7 (6ASY(%7-cC.'"9.,$"3$L'"%?Z>,$,$?,e,!$C7 (6A!A2,!'?C"S6B!'$"f(&(56,j%\J!
\CJ6,(8,cC6e,78!'6L,$,],62"6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#86&Jm;"#!,[!,$?t!'O,-6$p
cC.6B!'7 (6A6?!'!A2,6$x!'Y(%6B!'7 (6A,j%,e,Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,S7l,4"f6cC
!$g!'Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,,(!',53!'()/!c"f(,$?Z?%!$!'$"f3O$+B,6"/(6$u&9!
3$@.6w,e,Z?%!$!'$"f3OK!'6$H"S,e,,$L!$&e,$,9"6$"f!,G&d$I6 !',j%,$L!$3$j
!$t.6$($E6!$"X(\J!O$G!,n!'6$E,7@),e,Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,$r!$6$C!$\C3$e6
6"p!
v(%3$ !!$q!a‚67e!$'"e6/!\C.u,7L,$!'$"/!,0(7hae,7>!$d3$ !.d7 (S
!$ ,$E!'6x"Y()#67>!$3$}!6L,$!'$"/!,0(6$b?4C"\"#6ŽTác động của đầu tư trực tiếp
nước ngoài tới tăng trưởng kinh tế ở Việt Nam” ,j%6e,'"9 '()*!$>(f!$\C,8!'
&]
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
10
MNOPQR
TÓM TẮT TÀI LIỆU THAM KHẢO
Đề tài Câu hỏi nghiên cứu Dữ liệu
Phương
pháp
nghiên cứu
Kết quả
1%(% c•%?
^UVV<_
O6I?%$"f(0!'c%!
6ƒ% 6L,$ ,], ,$? !A2,
7A`, !$q! !- $%)
;$x!'„ C O 6e,
78!' !$A 6$# !C? 7#!
6B!' 6Ad!' ;"!$ 6# „
1s!$ \], !C? cC 6$"#6
)#(„
$b?
!'C!$ ,j%
,e, !A2,
—S
,$}(
3$"S˜S
ŸS
™
x$r!$$K"
Y()1S
$}! 6L,$
6$],!'$"f.
&~ Zu!' Zg
c"f(,$‚?
e,78!',j%O7"6$b?,9U$A2!'
6L,$\C6"/(,],S6()!$"/!S.l66L,$,],
\o! !$"X( $G! \C ZAH!' !$A c5! e6
!$g!'6"/(,],.C!-'})%
O,-6e,78!';$e,!$%(7#!6B!'
6Ad!';"!$6#6?!'4%cs!$\],cC,G
49!6$"#6)#(S&9!a(56\CZ>,$\uu
6$pSO6?!'cs!$\],,G49!6$"#6)#(
,-a($A2!'9!$$Ad!'6"/(,],7#!&]
3$e66"p!S6?!';$"7 (6A6?!'cs!$
\],&9!a(56cI"6$b?,$"X($A2!'6L,$
,],?!'cs!$\],Z>,$\u6$r;$x!'
›C!'
'()*!
$>(f!$
\C ,8!' &]
^UVV=_
J"Y(%!$f'"g%O
\C6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#cC
'"„
O6e,78!'7#! 6B!'
6Ad!';"!$6#"f6%.
Y(%!$g!'.l6!C?„Tác
động tràn .CO.%!'
cI",$?"f6%.cC'r„
y!' u,
6$J!' ;/S
u, (6A
A2,!'?C"
‹ •8 #
$?I,$ \C
(6A
x$r!$$K"
Y()U1
1C.›7A`,6e,78!',j%O7#!6B!'
6Ad!';"!$6#"f6%.
A%%7A`,,e,!$}!6J6e,78!'6w
O7#!6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#6$x!'Y(%
;/!$7 (6A\C6e,78!'6C!
1C.›6e,78!'6C!,j%OZ#!6B!'
6Ad!';"!$6#"f6%.S!$A!'&Jc"f(
.o(;$x!'7j7p3$}!6L,$7>!$6L!$\X
6e,78!'6C!,j%O7#!6B!'6Ad!'
;"!$6#
VI. PHƯƠNG PHÁP NGHIÊN CỨU
W Đối với kênh đầu tư
% Mô hình
x$r!$6?!'3$ !\"#6!C)Z]%6$b?.x$r!$6?!'4C"\"#6,j%6e,'"9'()*!$>
(f!$\C,8!'&]$b?7-.x$r!$,-ZI!'
g t ‰f (FDI
t
SH
t
S^FDIxH_
t
Shoinhapkt
t
SX
t
)
•"#!3$u6$(8,g
t
4"p(6$>,$?6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#S7?4t!'6J,786B!'6$],6#6/!
7 (!'AH"\CcC$C.&J,j%.86c?I64"#!78,cq3e,78!',j%,e,4"#!78,cq362"6B!'6Ad!'
;"!$6#7A`,6$p$"f!Y(%,e,$f&JA2,cA`!'SZ5(,j%,$E!'\C.0,m!'$s%6$J!';/FDI
t
cC
4"#!6$p$"f!7 (6A6],6"#3!A2,!'?C"S7?4t!'6Šcf\J!O6$],$"f!&?\2"H
t
cC4"#!
4"p(6$>,$?6C"&9!\J!,?!!'AH"!$t.7e!$'"e6e,78!',j%\J!,?!!'AH"62"6B!'6Ad!'
•"#!^FDIxH_
t
56,-m!'$s%6?!'.x$r!$!C)!$t.;"p.7>!$.J"6AG!'6e,'"g%O\C\J!
,?!!'AH",n!'!$A\%"6[,j%\J!,?!!'AH"7J"\2".0,787-!''-3,j%O62"6B!'6Ad!'
•"#!!C)7A`,7A%\C?.x$r!$Z]%\C?'"96$()#67h7A`,;"p.7>!$d!$"X(!A2,S7-cC7-!'
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
11
MNOPQR
'-3,j%O62"6B!'6Ad!',[!3$u6$(8,\C?c%?78!',-6r!$78,j%.86!A2,?!'.x
$r!$!C)S4"#!^FDIxH_
t
7A`,,?"cC.867I"cA`!'4"p(6$>;$9!B!'$536$uO,j%!X!;"!$
6# X cC6q3$`3,j%,e,4"#!78,cq3;$e,,-9!$$Ad!'62"6B!'6Ad!'$x!'Y(%,e,6C"c"f(
6$%.;$9?ŒFDI and Economic Growth: Does WTO Accession and Law Matter Play Important
Role in Attracting FDI? The Case of Viet NamŽ,j%!$ 6e,'"9'()b!"!$$"b!S $%!'
b $?!'“%!$""%!'–ŒForeign direct investment and economic growth in VietnamŽ,j%
U6e,'"9%”"Z!¡%%\C1%!$"'()b!S!$ ,$E!'6x"Y()#67>!$&~Zu!',e,4"#!7p7I"
Z"f!,$?•cCGE,$"6"/(,j%,$L!$3$j?!'7-,$"6$AH!'a()/!;$x!';p,$"69!`\C\"f!
6`S,[!,$"7 (6A;$x!';$x!'7X,q362"\J!6L!Zu!'\C7 (6A,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3!$C!A2,
•"#!3$u6$(8,
g
t
Log(GDP bình quân) 6$],6#6/!7 (!'AH"
•"#!78,cq3
FDI
t
FDI/GDP
Tỷ lệ đầu tư trực tiếp nước ngoài – A`,7?4t!'
6ˆcf\J!O6$],$"f!&?\2"
H
t
(Vốn con
người)
HS
t
Lao động đã tốt nghiệp phổ thông cơ sở‹A`,7?
4t!'6Šcfc%?78!'7h6J6!'$"f33$y6$x!',G&d
HBC
t
Dân số biết chữ‹A`,7?4t!'6ŠcfZ}!&J4"#6
,$g
HP
t
Lao động đã tốt nghiệp tiểu học và đang làm việc‹
A`,7?4t!'6Šcfc%?78!'7%!'cC.\"f,6?!'
!X!;"!$6#7h6J6!'$"f36"p($+,
Hoinhapkt
t
Hội nhập kinh tế^4"#!'"9_
(FDIxH)
t
(khả năng hấp
thụ FDI của
một nước)
(FDI*HS)
t
Mức độ đóng góp FDI của lao động đã tốt nghiệp
phổ thông cơ sở
(FDI*HBC)
t
Mức độ đóng góp FDI của lao động đang làm việc
trong nền kinh tế đã tốt nghiệp cấp tiểu học
(FDI*HP)
t
Mức độ đóng góp FDI của dân số biết chữ
X GE Chi thường tiêu chính phủ
•"#!hoinhapkt
t
cC4"#!'"9!$q!U'"e6>V^;$"756!A2,,$A%$8"!$q3_\C4t!'W^;$"
756!A2,$8"!$q3_
w;#6Y(9!'$"/!,0(,j%6e,'"9'()*!$>(f!$\C,8!'&]SZ5(;F\+!',j%
,e,4"#!78,cq37A`,,$?d49!'&%(
Gỉa
thiết
Biến độc
lập
Dấu kì
vọng
Giải thích
H
1
FDI t ¢
B!'6Ad!';"!$6#7A`,7?cAH!'4t!'6$],$r!,$(!'S
6Šcf\J! O6$],$"f!&?\2",C!',%?6$r6J,786B!'
6Ad!';"!$6#,C!',%?
H
2
HS t ¢ J"Y(%!$f'"g%O\C\J!,?!!'AH",-6e,78!'6L,$,],62"
6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#d,e,!A2,7%!'3$e66"p!Šcfc%?78!'7h
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
12
MNOPQR
6J6!'$"f33$y6$x!',G&dd.86Z?%!$!'$"f3,C!',%?S6$r;$9
!B!'$536$uO,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3,C!'c2!SZo!7#!6B!'Z?%!$
6$(S6B!'6$],'-33$ !6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#
H
3
HP t -
r!$78c%?78!',C!'6$536$r;$9!B!'$536$uO,C!'6$53
Zo!7#!'"9.!B!'&(56c%?78!',j%Z?%!$!'$"f3ScC.
6$],6#'"9.SZo!7#!6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#'"9.?!'4C"!C)S
4"#!HS
t
6$p$"f!›!$566e,78!'O7#!6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#
H
4
HBC t -
H
5
hoinhapkt
t
+
"f,$8"!$q3\w%6e,78!'6L,$,],co!6"/(,],6B!'6Ad!';"!$
6#6$p$"f!Y(%\"f,6B!'S'"9.$f&JFDI
t
. J"\2",e,!A2,7%!'
3$e66"p!!$A"f6%.S$8"!$q3.%!'7#!!$"X(,G$8"$G!&?
\2"456c`"$(q!c`"cC6B!'\J!7 (6AOS6B!'\J!,?!!'AH"
\C;$9!B!'$536$uO,j%.86!A2,()!$"/!S\o!,-W&J
456c`"!$A,I!$6%!$S,$()p!'"%?c%?78!'™!$A!'!$r!,$(!'
$8"!$q3\o!.%!'c`"!$"X(6e,78!'"L,$,],$G!
H
6
GE +
"!$6#"f6%.,-Y(".x6AG!'7J"!$ƒS,$",$?'"e?Zu,\C)
6#7I66Š6+!',%?S9!$$Ad!'6],6"#37#!\J!,?!!'AH"'-3
3$ !6$E,7@)!B!'&(56c%?78!'S6B!'6$],
4 Cách trích xuất số liệu cho mô hình từ nguồn số liệu thứ cấp:
Jc"f(&~Zu!',$?.x$r!$cC48&Jc"f(6$b?,$(k"6$H"'"%!6wWT{{‹UVV<c5)6w
!$"X(!'(K!;$e,!$%(Jc"f(\X6J,786B!'6$],6#6/!7 (!'AH"g
t
\C&Jc"f(FDI
t
6$],
$"f!
’
7A`,6$(6$q3\C6L!$6?e!Z]%\C?&Jc"f(,$L!$6$0,Z?y!'u,6$J!';/\Cu, (6A
A2,!'?C"‹•8#$?I,$\C (6A,(!',53
•%4"#!HP
t
, HS
t
\C HBC
t
7A`,c5)6w!'(K!,j%•81%?78!'‹$AG!'4"!$\C•h$8"
\C!$"X(!'(K!;$e,
Jc"f(\XGE7A`,c5)6w!'(K!y!',u,$J!';/\C•e?,e?;"!$6#"f6%.!B.
UVV<,j%"f!'$"/!,0(Y(9!cm;"!$6#
U Tác động tràn:
2.1 Một số phân tích định tính tác động tràn
#6Y(93$}!6L,$7>!$6L!$,j%6e,78!'6C!Z]%\C?&Jc"f(6w"X(6%Z?%!$!'$"f3
!B.UVVW,j%y!',u,$J!';/•8&Jc"f(!C)$ 6e,'"9'()*!(f!$\C,8!'
&]7h6"#!$C!$7"X(6%<<Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,\C=VZ?%!$!'$"f3,-\J!7 (6A!A2,
!'?C"7pab.a‚6,e,Z5($"f(\X6e,78!'6C!d,e,;/!$;$e,!$%(()!$"/!Z?.o(7"X(6%
!$ƒS&Jc"f(7"X(6%!C),$ˆ,$?e3Zu!',$?3$}!6L,$7>!$cA`!'S!$t.7A%%.8640,6%!$
;$e"Y(e6\X,e,;/!$;$e,!$%(,j%6e,78!'6C!$}!3$}!6L,$7>!$cA`!'$?C!6?C!&~Zu!'
&Jc"f("X(6%Z?%!$!'$"f3,j%y!',u,6$J!';/
•9!'$ƒ"7A`,6$"#6;#Z]%\C?’;/!$6()X!6e,78!'6C!7h6r!$4C)d3$ !cm6$()#6
&i7A`,6r!$4C)d3$ !&%(()!$"/!SZ]%\C?;#6Y(9!'$"/!,0(c?I"!C);$-,-6$p;$£!'
’$ !'$"/!,0(;$x!',-7A`,\J!O6$],$"f!,j%"/!'3$L%!A2,!'?C"6$b?,$(k"&Jc"f(G!!g%S\"f,
4-,6e,$!#(;$x!',$L!$ae,,-6$pZo!7#!&%"cf,$!$"X($G!r\q)S7p7G!'"9!d7})'"97>!$6Šcf\J!6$],
$"f!,j%3$L%!A2,!'?C"&?\2"6y!'\J!O6$],$"f!cC;$x!'7y"2"'"97>!$!C)6$r;#6Y(9$K"Y("&~Zu!'
&Jc"f(O6$],$"f!6y!'cC,-6$p,$53!$q!7J"\2"3$AG!'3$e33$}!6L,$cA`!'
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
13
MNOPQR
7>!$7A`,&]a(56$"f!,j%6e,78!'6C!\C.0,789!$$Ad!',j%,e,6e,78!'7-S.l6;$e,
\2"&JcA`!'.o(7"X(6%;$x!'!$"X(!/(6L!$7I"Z"f!6$53r\q)S;#6Y(9d3$ !!C)cC
!$t.4y&(!',$?3$ !3$}!6L,$7>!$cA`!'6?!'3$ !&%(
UU Phân tích định lượng tác động tràn
x$r!$6?!'3$ !\"#6!C)Z]%6$b?.x$r!$6?!'4C"\"#6,j%6e,'"9'()*!$>
(f!$\C,8!'&]?!'4C"\"#6S!$ 6e,'"9&~Zu!'$%".x$r!$3$}!6L,$,$?$%"6AH!'
$`3cC7J"\2"Z?%!$!'$"f3!-",$(!'\CZ?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,
FDI và năng suất lao động của doanh nghiệp nói chung
% Mô hình
$x!'Y(%.x$r!$O\C!B!'&(56c%?78!',(9Z?%!$!'$"f3!-",$(!'S,$E!'6x"
.(J!;"p.7>!$'"96$()#6&]a(56$"f!,j%;$(\],Z?%!$!'$"f3O,-6e,78!'cC.6B!'
1,$(!',j%656,9Z?%!$!'$"f3d"f6%.$%);$x!'„
x$r!$6?!'3$ !\"#6!C)Z]%6$b?.x$r!$6?!'4C"\"#6,j%!$ 6e,'"9
'()*!$>(f!$$b?7-.x$r!$,-ZI!'
nangsuat ‰f ^cuongdovonSquimoStrinhdoSDtinhSDsohuuSDluongthucSDZb6maySDdientu_
Biến phụ thuộc
nangsuat '"e6>'"%6B!'¤c%?78!'
7?!B!'&(56c%?78!',j%
Z?%!$!'$"f3
Biến độc lập
trinhdo
c%?78!',-4t!',%?7£!'\C6(!'
,53ZI)!'$X6dc/!¤&Jc%?78!',[!
cI"6?!'Z?%!$!'$"f3
,$56cA`!',j%c%?78!'
6?!'Z?%!$!'$"f3
quimo
7?4t!'6ŠcfZ?%!$6$(,j%Z?%!$
!'$"f36?!'6y!'Z?%!$6$(,j%3$}!
!'C!$’&J
•
Y().xZ?%!$!'$"f36?!'
!'C!$
cuongdovon \J!,J7>!$4r!$Y(}!6/!Wc%?78!'
,AH!'78&~Zu!'\J!6/!W
c%?78!'
Dluongthuc &],-.l6,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3cAG!'6$],^4"#!'"9_
Ddetmay &],-.l6,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3Zf6.%)^4"#!'"9_
Ddientu &],-.l6,j%Z?%!$!'$"f37"f!6~^4"#!'"9_
Dtinh \>6L6u&d,$L!$^4"#!'"9_
Dsohuu
$"3$?"W
$r!$6$0,&d$g(,j%Z?%!$
!'$"f3OcCc"b!Z?%!$
^4"#!'"9_
$"3$?"U $r!$6$0,&d$g(,j%Z?%!$
• $E6$L,$3$}!!'C!$’&J6$b?$f6$J!'!'C!$;"!$6# ,j%"f6%.UVV|^"b6%.6%!Z%Z!Z(&6"%c
c%&&"•",%6"?!UVV|:UVV|_7A`,y!',u,$J!';/a})Z]!'6/!,G&d$}!!'C!$,$(@!Y(J,6#^3$"/!49!
’V_7h7A`,N)4%!$J!';/1"/!$`3Y(J,6$x!'Y(%6I";F$+36$e!'<!B.UVV=,$"6"#67#!’,$g&J^ISIC
Rev.4_
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
14
MNOPQR
!'$"f3OcCWVV¥\J!
!A2,!'?C"^4"#!'"9_
?!'7-
‹ e,4"#!c(?!'6$(,cC4"#!'"9!$q!$%"'"e6>4t!'W;$"Z?%!$!'$"f36$(8,!$
cAG!'6$],4t!'V;$"6$(8,!$ ;$e,S6AG!'6]7J"\2",e,4"#!Zb6.%)\CZ"b!6(
‹ •"#!Z6"!$cC4"#!'"9Dtinh ,-'"e6>cCW!#(Z?%!$!'$"f3,-6u&d,$L!$6I",e,6ˆ!$
,-.q6787 (6A!A2,!'?C",%?\C!$q!'"e6>V!#(6$(8,,e,\z!';$e,e,6ˆ!$!C)
4%?'K.C8"SK$L"!$SCš!'\C,e,6ˆ!$a(!'Y(%!$,e,6(!'6}.,x!'
!'$"f3c2!^4%?'K.A!')/!S9"ZAG!'S9"3$[!'SC})Sv(%!'"!$S•C>%
n!'C(SK!'%"\C•r!$AG!'_
$b?.x$r!$,j%4C"\"#6!$ 6e,'"9'"9'()*!$>(f!$S•"#!Dtinh 7A`,
7A%\C?!$t.$%".u,7L,$^W_;"p.&?e69!$$Ad!',j%6$%)7y"\X\z!';"!$6#\C^U_;"p.
&?e69!$$Ad!',j%.0,786q36(!'Oco!6q36(!'$+%678!',x!'!'$"f3J"\2"4"#!
&?$((S6$"4"#!!C)!$t.ae,7>!$$r!$6$0,&d$g(,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3dZsS7A%$%"4"#!
,$"3$?"W\C,$"3$?"U7I"Z"/!,$?4"#!&?$((!$t.7e!$'"e6e,78!',j%O\C?&]6B!'
6Ad!';"!$6#6$x!'Y(%6e,78!'6C!7#!!B!'&(56()!$"/!S,-U$r!$6$0,Z?%!$!'$"f3&~
Zu!'!'(K!O7-cCZ?%!$!'$"f3c"/!Z?%!$\CZ?%!$!'$"f3,-\J!WVV¥!A2,!'?C""f(
Y(9&~Zu!'\J!\C6e,78!'7#!&]6B!'6Ad!'cC;$e,!$%('"g%$%"$r!$6$0,Z?%!$!'$"f3
!C)r\q)S!$t.7e!$'"e7E!'\2"6$],6"*!7-S!$ 6e,'"97h&~Zu!'$%"4"#!,$"3$?"W\C
,$"3$?"U?!'4"#!Y().?S!$ 6e,'"9'"96$()#6t!'6Š6+!'Z?%!$6$(,C!'c2!6$r,C!'
,-c`",$?Y().x
w;#6Y(9!'$"/!,0(,j%!$ ’6e,'"9'()*!$>(f!$S6$rZ5(;F\+!',j%
,e,4"#!78,cq37A`,,$?d49!'&%(
Biến độc lập Dấu kì vọng Lý giải
Trinhdo ¢
$"6r!$78,j%,x!'!$}!\"/!,j%,x!'6),C!',%?
9!$$Ad!'6L,$,],7#!!B!'&(56
Quy mô ¢ Y().x9!$$Ad!'6L,$,],7#!!B!'&(56
Cuongdovon ¢
B!'7 (6A,$?,G&d$I6 !'S.e) ,6$"#64>&i6B!'
!B!'&(56
Dluongthuc ¢
$"Z?%!$!'$"f3O6$%.'"%S\2"\J!c2!\C,x!'
!'$f,%?&i6e,78!'.I!$7#!!B!'&(567J"\2"!X!
!x!'!'$"f3,[!$I!,$#\X,x!'!'$f\C.x$r!$!$A
$"f!!%)
Ddetmay ‹
'C!$6q36(!'c%?7x!'c2!S6?!';$")/(, (\X\J!
\Cc%?78!';‘!B!'6$53$G!$%"!'C!$,[!cI"SZ?7-&]
6$%.'"%,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3O;$x!'6e,78!''r!$"X(
Ddientu ¢
})cC!'C!$7["$ƒ",x!'!'$f,%?,n!'!$A,$56cA`!'
c%?78!'r\q)!B!'&(56,%?\C7}),n!'cC!'C!$
Y(%!6+!',j%!X!;"!$6#
Dtinh ¢ e,6ˆ!$6q36(!'O$ (!$AcC,e,6ˆ!$6+!'7"p.S,-
;$(,x!'!'$"f3c2!r\q)S,e,Z?%!$!'$"f36?!',e,
6ˆ!$!C),-\>6L6$(q!c`"S,G&d\q6,$566J6SZ?7-,-
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
15
MNOPQR
6$p6"#6;"f.,$"3$LS6B!'!B!'&(56
Chiphoi1 ¢
e,Z?%!$!'$"f3,-!'(K!\J!O,-c`"6$#\X!'(K!
\J!c2!Z?7-,-;$9!B!'7 (6A,x!'!'$fS6$($E6c%?
78!'cC!$!'$X6J6?7-6e,78!'6$(q!,$"X(\2"!B!'
&(56
Chiphoi2 ¢
4 Cách trích xuất số liệu cho mô hình từ nguồn số liệu thứ cấp
e,&Jc"f(7A`,c5)6w49!Œ"X(6%Z?%!$!'$"f3Ž,j%y!',u,6$J!';/})cC.86
,(8,7"X(6%c2!6$],$"f!\C?!'C)W6$e!'|$?l,!'C)W6$e!'’$C!'!B.^6L,$6C"c"f(Œ
e,78!',j%7 (6A6],6"#3!A2,!'?C"62"6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#d"f6%.Ž,j%’6e,'"9
'()*!$>(f!$^Ad!'!$ _S$n•(}!'()f6K!'S$ !?C!$•!'S
'()*!I!$9"
FDI và năng suất lao động của doanh nghiệp trong nước:
% Mô hình
?!'.x$r!$!C)S,$E!'6%&i'"9"Y()#6\5!7XcCŒ!'?C"&]6$%.'"%,j%,e,Z?%!$
!'$"f3,-\J!O6$r6e,78!'6B!'!B!'&(56c%?78!',j%,e,Z?%!$!'$"f3!-",$(!',-,[!
Z?7-!''-3,j%6e,78!'6C!6L,$,],!g%$%);$x!'„Ž
/!6$],6#S\"f,!'$"/!,0(6e,78!'6C!,-UZI!'.x$r!$7A`,&~Zu!'S7-cCZI!'
!'$"/!,0(dY().x!'C!$\CZI!'!'$"/!,0(6$b?Y().xZ?%!$!'$"f3
()!$"/!S\"f,!'$"/!,0(6$b?Y().x!'C!$,-!$A`,7"p.cC7e!$'"eY(e,%?$?l,
Y(e6$536e,78!'6C!"X(!C)a9)%;$",-6e,78!'U,$"X('"g%!%!'&(56!'C!$\C!B!'
&(56,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3O$"Z?%!$!'$"f3O,-,AH!'78\J!c2!6$%.'"%\C?!'C!$,-
!B!'&(56,%?6$r;$"7e!$'"e6$b?.x$r!$6%,-6$p!$q!a‚6Z?%!$!'$"f3O7h6e,78!'cC.
!}!',%?!B!'&(56!'C!$S6()!$"/!7e!$'"e6e,78!'6C!6?!'6AH!'$`3!C)ZAH!'!$A7h
7A`,7e!$'"eY(%,%?.C4ƒY(/!)#(6J!B!'&(56,j%!'C!$!C)7h,%??!'6AH!'$`3
;$e,S;$"Z?%!$!'$"f3O6$%.'"%\C?.86!'C!$cC.,$?!$g!'Z?%!$!'$"f3)#(4>3$e
&9!ScE,!C)a9)%6e,78!'6C!6"/(,],S!$A!'a‚6\X!B!'&(566(!'4r!$!'C!$6$rcI"6B!'
c/!•d"\r&JcA`!'Z?%!$!'$"f3,-!B!'&(566$53'"9.S7K!'6$H"Z?%!$!'$"f3O,-!B!'
&(56,%?6$%.'"%\C?6$>6AH!'2"!$g!'cq3c(q!!$A6/!S!$ 6e,'"97hY()#67>!$7"
6$b?3$AG!'3$e3!'$"/!,0(6$b?Y().xZ?%!$!'$"f3
x$r!$.C!$ 6e,'"9'()*!$>(f!$7h7A%%cC
!angsuat "‰f( cuongdovon i, tytrong ij, trinhdo i, quimoi, hopdong i, Dtinh i, Dnganh i)
Biến phụ thuộc
nangsuat i '"e6>'"%6B!'¤c%?78!' 7?!B!'&(56c%?78!',j%
Z?%!$!'$"f3
Biến độc lập
cuongdovon i \J!,J7>!$4r!$Y(}!6/!Wc%?78!' ,AH!'78&~Zu!'\J!6/!W
c%?78!'
tytrong ij 7A`,6L!$6$b?6+!'&JS^6+!'&JcC6(y"
6$+,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3O_
6Š6+!'c%?78!',j%,e,
Z?%!$!'$"f3O6?!'
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
16
MNOPQR
!'C!$’&J
trinhdo i c%?78!',-4t!',%?7£!'\C6(!',53
ZI)!'$X6dc/!¤&Jc%?78!',[!cI"
6?!'Z?%!$!'$"f3
,$56cA`!',j%c%?78!'
6?!'Z?%!$!'$"f3
quimo i 7?4t!'6ŠcfZ?%!$6$(,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3
6?!'6y!'Z?%!$6$(,j%3$}!!'C!$’&J
Y().xZ?%!$!'$"f36?!'
!'C!$
hopdong i Y(%!$f\2",e,Z?%!$!'$"f3!A2,!'?C"Y(%;/!$a(56!$q3;$@(^4"#!
'"9_
Dtinh i \>6L6u&d,$L!$^4"#!'"9_
Dnganh i 4"#!'"97l,6A!',$?!$ !'C!$,u6$p6?!'!'C!$”
?!'.x$r!$!C)S7"p.;$e,4"f6c2!!$56&?\2"6e,78!'6C!7J"\2"Z?%!$!'$"f3!-"
,$(!'cC4"#!6)6?!' ij.2" 6)6?!' ijcC&~Zu!'6Š6+!'c%?78!',j%,e,Z?%!$!'$"f3O
6?!'!'C!$’&J•"#!6)6?!' ij 7A`,6L!$6$b?6+!'&JS6+!'&Jd7})6(y"6$+,j%Z?%!$
!'$"f3Ov(%,e,$6L!$!C)S!$ 6e,'"9.(J!;"p.7>!$'"96$()#6Œ\2",e,,$ˆ6"/(;$e,
!$A!$%(S6?!'$%"Z?%!$!'$"f3O;$e,!$%(Z?%!$!'$"f3!C?,-6$H"'"%!$?I678!'6?!'
!'C!$”c}($G!&i,-6$p6I?%6e,78!'6C!c2!$G!Ž'?C"%S6?!'.x$r!$!C)S!$ 6e,
'"9,[!7A%%4"#!'"9cChopdong i !$t.c?I"4ƒ6e,78!'6C!,j%\"f,!'?I"6$AG!'•d"ci;$"
,e,Z?%!$!'$"f36$%.'"%$?I67x!'!'?I"6$AG!'\2"Z?%!$!'$"f3!A2,!'?C"6$r,e,Z?%!$
!'$"f36?!'!A2,,-6$p$+,$ƒ"S,9"6$"f!$?I678!';"!$Z?%!$S.d8!'&9!a(56S,-78!',G
6B!'!B!'&(56c%?78!'r\q)S!$ 6e,'"97h7A%%4"#!'"9hopdong i !$q!$%"'"e6>4t!'
W!#(,-Y(%!$f\2"456;F7J"6e,!C?cCZ?%!$!'$"f3!A2,!'?C"\C4t!'V,$?6AH!'$`3
,[!cI"
w;#6Y(9!'$"/!,0(,j%6e,'"9'()*!$>(f!$\C,8!'&]S6$rZ5(;F\+!'
,j%,e,4"#!78,cq37A`,,$?d49!'&%(
Biến độc lập Dấu kỳ vọng Lý giải
cuongdovon i ¢
B!'7 (6A,$?,G&d$I6 !'S.e) ,6$"#64>&i
6B!'!B!'&(56
tytrong ij ¢
2"&]6$%.'"%,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3O6?!'ZC"$I!
,-6$p!}!',%?,x!'!'$fS6I?!/!.x"6AH!',I!$
6%!$SZ?7-4(8,,e,Z?%!$!'$"f33$9"6B!'!B!'
&(56"f,6$%)7y",x!'!'$f3$9"a‚66?!'ZC"$I!
trinhdo i ¢
;$"6r!$78,j%,x!'!$}!\"/!,j%,x!'6),C!',%?
9!$$Ad!'6L,$,],7#!!B!'&(56
quimo i ¢ Y().x9!$$Ad!'6L,$,],7#!!B!'&(56
hopdong i ‹ 1?I"4ƒ6e,78!'6C!,j%a(56!$q3;$@(
Dtinh i ¢
,e,6ˆ!$6q36(!'O$ (!$AcC,e,6ˆ!$6+!'7"p.S
,-;$(,x!'!'$"f3c2!r\q)S,e,Z?%!$!'$"f3
6?!',e,6ˆ!$!C),-\>6L6$(q!c`"S,G&d\q6,$56
6J6SZ?7-,-6$p6"#6;"f.,$"3$LS6B!'!B!'&(56
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
17
MNOPQR
Dnganh i ¢S‹SV z)6$b?.k"!'C!$,u6$p&i,-6e,78!';$e,!$%(
4 Cách trích xuất số liệu cho mô hình từ nguồn số liệu thứ cấp
e,&Jc"f(7A`,c5)6w49!Œ"X(6%Z?%!$!'$"f3Ž,j%y!',u,6$J!';/})cC.86
,(8,7"X(6%c2!6$],$"f!\C?!'C)W6$e!'|$?l,!'C)W6$e!'’$C!'!B.^6L,$6C"c"f(
Œe,78!',j%7 (6A6],6"#3!A2,!'?C"62"6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#d"f6%.Ž,j%!$ ’6e,
'"9'()*!$>(f!$^Ad!'!$ _S$n•(}!'()f6K!'S$ !?C!
$•!'S'()*!I!$9"
, Phương pháp nghiên cứu đã được sử dụng:
&'()*!$>(f!$\C,8!'&]^UVV=_;$"6$],$"f!!'$"/!,0(!C)7h;#6$`3,9
$%"3$AG!'3$e33$}!6L,$7>!$cA`!'\C3$}!6L,$7>!$6L!$;#6$`3&~Zu!',e,&Jc"f(6$J!'
;/&G,53\C6$0,53
p!'$"/!,0(.%!'6L!$6$()#63$u,$G!S4/!,I!$\"f,3$}!6L,$6e,78!'6],6"#3,j%
O7#!6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#"f6%.Y(%;/!$7 (6AS&'()*!$>(f!$\C,8!'&]
^UVV=_7h,$ˆ›,9!$g!'6e,78!'6C!:6e,78!''"e!6"#3,j%O7#!;"!$6#"f6%.56
,u6$pŒbên cạnh tác động trực tiếp tới tăng trưởng của cả nền kinh tế, sự có mặt của các
doanh nghiệp FDI còn tác động gián tiếp tới các doanh nghiệp trong nước như tăng áp lực
cạnh tranh, buộc các doanh nghiệp trong nước phải tăng hiệu quả kinh doanh, thúc đẩy quá
trình phổ biến và chuyển giao công nghệ v.v. Các tác động này còn được gọi là tác động tràn
của FDI ”‹4t!'\"f,;#6$`3&~Zu!',e,.x$r!$;"!$6#cA`!'7l,4"f6cC.x$r!$;"!$6#
cA`!'\2"3$AG!'3$e34r!$3$AG!'!$ƒ!$56$"3$}!6L,$6e,78!'6C!,j%O7#!6B!'
6Ad!';"!$6#"f6%.S,e, 3$}!6L,$ 7>!$ cA`!' $?C! 6?C! &~ Zu!' &Jc"f("X(6%Z?%!$
!'$"f3,j%y!',u,6$J!';/Z]%6/!;$(!';$ycm6$()#6&~Zu!'.x$r!$6B!'6Ad!'!8"
&"!$
'$"/!,0(,[!&~Zu!'3$AG!3$e3,$+!.o(3$}!!$ \2".o(7A`,,$+!'K.
<<Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,\C=VZ?%!$!'$"f3,-\J!7 (6A!A2,!'?C"7pab.a‚6,e,Z5(
$"f(\X6e,78!'6C!d,e,;/!$;$e,!$%(
Z Nhận xét
/!6$#'"2"7h,-;$e!$"X(!'$"/!,0(7e!$'"e6e,78!',j%O62"6B!'6Ad!';"!$
6#\C6$AH!'&~Zu!'3$AG!'3$e33$}!6L,$7>!$cA`!'7p;"p.7>!$\CcA`!'$-%,e,6e,
78!'!C)Q"f6%.,e,!'$"/!,0(\XO!-",$(!'cC;$e!$"X(S6()!$"/!,$ˆ,-.86&J
!'$"/!,0(7"&}(ab.a‚66e,78!',j%O62"6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#'()*!I"^UVV<_S
Obb.%!^UVVU_\C'()*!$>$AG!'?%^UVVW_7h!'$"/!,0(6y!'Y(e6$?I678!'Od
"f6%.,$?62"!B.UVVU?C!'+,$E,^UVV<_3$}!6L,$6$],6I!',j%O6?!'6$H";F
WT{{‹UVV<\C;#6c(q!6B!'6Ad!';"!$6#d"f6%.3$u6$(8,!$"X(\C?;$(\],,-\J!
O™•‚6\X3$AG!'3$e3!'$"/!,0(S$ ($#6,e,!'$"/!,0(\XOd"f6%.&~Zu!'
3$AG!'3$e33$}!6L,$7>!$6L!$S6y!';#66r!$$r!$O\C?"f6%.Z]%\C?&Jc"f(6$J!';/
'$"/!,0(,j%'()*!$>$AG!'?%^UVV’_cC.866?!'&J56L6!'$"/!,0(Zz!',9$%"
3$AG!'3$e37>!$6L!$\C7>!$cA`!'()!$"/!S!'$"/!,0(!C),$ˆcA`!'$-%7A`,6e,78!'
,j%O62"6B!'6Ad!',j%,e,6ˆ!$"f6%.!$t..u,7L,$,(J",z!'cC6r..J"Y(%!$f
'"g%O\Ca-%7-"'"9.!'$†?e,!'$"/!,0(7>!$cA`!';$e,7p;"p.7>!$6e,78!'6C!
,j%O$ (!$A56L6]6$"#(\•!',e,!'$"/!,0(&~Zu!'3$AG!'3$e33$}!6L,$7>!$cA`!'
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
18
MNOPQR
6$x!'Y(%.x$r!$$-%,-6$pcCZ?6$"#(,e,Zgc"f(, !6$"#6$?l,¤\C6$"#(6"!6Ad!'\C?&J
c"f(&š!,-^&'()*!$>(f!$\C,8!'&]UVV=_
p;$•,3$u,7A`,,e,7"p.)#(6/!S&'()*!$>(f!$\C,8!'&]^UVV=_7h&~
Zu!',e,$6"#3,q!8!'$G!S;#6$`3,9$%"3$AG!'3$e3cC3$}!6L,$7>!$6L!$&~Zu!'&Jc"f(
6$J!';/6$0,53\C&G,53\C3$}!6L,$7>!$cA`!'"f,c]%,$+!&~Zu!';#6$`3,e,3$AG!'
3$e36/!6$p$"f!&];$-;$B!6?!'&~Zu!'7G!c¦,e,,x!',u7>!$cA`!'6?!'6AH!'$`3
,j%"f6%.Z?&Jc"f(Zz!',$?3$}!6L,$6$AH!',$A%7 )7j\C786"!,q);$x!',%?
?!'Y(e6r!$7"X(6%,$+!.o( &'()*!$>(f!$\C,8!'&]^UVV=_7h c]%
,$+!3$AG!'3$e3,$+!.o(3$}!!$ !$t.79.49?6L!$6$],6#,$?!'$"/!,0(()!$"/!
Z?.o(7"X(6%!$ƒS&Jc"f(7"X(6%!C),$ˆ,$?e3Zu!',$?3$}!6L,$7>!$cA`!'S!$t.7A%%
.8640,6%!$;$e"Y(e6\X,e,;/!$;$e,
!$%(
,
j
% 6e, 78!'6C!$}!3$}!6L,$7>!$ cA`!'
$?C!6?C!&~Zu!'&Jc"f("X(6%Z?%!$!'$"f3,j%y!',u,6$J!';/
$b?,e,!'$"/!,0(6A2,7});$"7e!$'"e6e,78!'6C!,j%O,-6$p7A`,6$],$"f!
4t!',9$%"3$AG!'3$e37>!$6L!$\C7>!$cA`!'$?l,;#6$`3,9$%"()!$"/!S;#6Y(9,j%
7e!$'"e7>!$6L!$,$j)#(.%!'6L!$.x69Sae,7>!$;$9!B!',-$%);$x!',-,e,4"p($"f!
,-6$p6I?%6e,78!'6C!S!$A!';$x!'7e!$'"e7A`,6e,78!'6C!,-6$],&]a(56$"f!$%)
;$x!'\C.0,78,j%,e,6e,78!'7-e!$'"e4t!'3$AG!'3$e37>!$cA`!';$•,3$u,7"p.
)#(!C)6/!,G&de3Zu!',e,.x$r!$;"!$6#cA`!'7A`,&~Zu!'!'C),C!'!$"X(
&'()*!$>(f!$\C,8!'&]^UVV=_,n!'7h;$•,3$u,7A`,7"p.)#(!C)4t!'\"f,
&~Zu!',x!',u3$}!6L,$7>!$cA`!'\2"3$AG!'3$e31w7-,-6$pE6%!$g!';#6
Y(9,u6$p$G!\C\r\q),-m!'$s%7J"\2",e,!$C$?I,$7>!$,$L!$&e,$
VII. DỰ KIẾN CẤU TRÚC BÁO CÁO KẾT QUẢ
W l6\5!7X
U y!'Y(%!6C"c"f(
% e,cm6$()#6c"/!Y(%!
4 e,6C"c"f(6$%.;$9?
<$AG!'3$e3!'$"/!,0(
% "96$()#6!'$"/!,0(
4 x$r!$!'$"/!,0(
, gc"f(
’#6Y(9\C6$9?c(q!
•#6c(q!\C7X!'$>
=C"c"f(6$%.;$9?
VIII. TÀI LIỆU THAM KHẢO
W '()*!$>(f!$^Ad!'!$ _S$n•(}!'()f6K!'S$ !?C!
$•!'S'()*!I!$9"S^UVV=_SŒTác động của đầu tư trực tiếp nước ngoài tới
tăng trưởng kinh tế ở Việt Nam”.
U 1%(%c•%?S3"cUVV<SŒO?b"'!"b,6!\b&6.b!6%!Z?¡6$?b&6$bb,6?
%66b„Ž
< %”"Z!¡%%!Z1%!$"'()b!S§%!(%):3"cUVWVSŒForeign direct investment and
economic growth in Vietnam”S Ÿ!"\b&"6) ?• 6$b (!&$"!b ?%&6S (&6%c"% %!Z
Ÿ!"\b&"6)?•?(6$(&6%c"%S(&6%c"%–%6"?!%c—,?!?.",&Ÿ!"\b&"6)S"b6!%.S&"%
%,"¨,•(&"!b&&b\"b¡S?cW=S?&W:USW{<:UVU
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
19
MNOPQR
’ $663¤¤¡¡¡$&a\!¤$&a¤Ÿ3c?%ZbZ¤UVWU¤V=¤UU¤"b(¥UV,$"¥UV3$%!¥UV!'%!$¥UV,(%
¥UV—3Z•_
• b6b (!!b!;%.3 %!Z §(c"(&3%6• ^§(!c)UVV<_S Foreign Direct Investment and
Economic Growth in Developing Countries: How Relevant Are Host-country and
Industry Characteteristics?S3%'bWU
= U%"% %;?\", %!Z ?&& 1b\"!b S Does Foreign Direct Investment Accelerate
Economic Growth ? page WT{
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
20
MNOPQR
KHẢO SÁT CÁ NHÂN
+\C6/! B.&"!$%.¤g
?%!$!'$"f3
W !$¤$>7%!',x!'6e,d483$q!!C?6?!'Z?%!$!'$"f3
•83$q!&9!a(56 •83$q!;#6?e!
•83$q!;"!$Z?%!$ •83$q!%;b6"!'
•83$q!4e!$C!' •83$q!;$e,
U y!'&J!B.,x!'6e,
U‹< ’‹• =‹| J;$e,
< !$¤$>!'$s'r\X6J,786"#36$(\C3$e66"p!,x!'!'$f,j%?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,„
56,$q.
AG!'7J",$q.
•r!$6$AH!'
$e!$%!$
$%!$
’ !$¤$>7h6w!'cC.\"f,dZ?%!$!'$"f3,-\J!7 (6A6],6"#3!A2,!'?C"6A2,7})„
- $x!'
#(Œ-Ž\("c[!'69cH"6w,}(•7#!,}({#(Ž$x!'Ž\("c[!'7"6"#3,}(T
• !$¤$>7h,x!'6e,d483$q!!C?
•83$q!&9!a(56 •83$q!;#6?e!
•83$q!;"!$Z?%!$ •83$q!%;b6"!'
•83$q!4e!$C!' •83$q!;$e,
= !$¤$>cC.d483$q!!C)dZ?%!$!'$"f34%?!$"/(c}(^!B._
W U < ’ J;$e,
| 1mZ?!C?!$¤$>H";$ƒ"Z?%!$!'$"f3
-.86Z?%!$!'$"f3;$e,3$z$`3$G!
?,$L!$&e,$,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3
1mZ?,e!$}!;$e,
{ !$¤$>,-!'$st!',-&],$/!$cf,$,x!'!'$f'"g%?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,\C?%!$
!'$"f3,-\J!7 (6A6],6"#3!A2,!'?C"„
- $x!'
T '(K!,(!'!'()/!c"f(,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3%!$¤,$>,$"#.6Š6+!'4%?!$"/(6?!'<!'(K!&%(
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
21
MNOPQR
W wZ?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,
U wZ?%!$!'$"f3O
< w!'(K!;$e,^!$q3;$@(_
WV ],$/!$cf,$,x!'!'$f!C)!'$"/!'\X
?%!$!'$"f3,-\J!7 (6A6],6"#3!A2,!'?C"
?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,
WW !$¤$>!'$st!'!'()/!!$}!!C?Zo!7#!&],$/!$cf,$7-„
0,78Y(%!6}.,j%$C!A2,7J"\2"&]3$e66"p!!'C!$
$L!$&e,$,$"6"/(,$?7 (6A3$e66"p!,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3
r!$78$+,\5!,$()/!.x!S;"!$!'$"f.,j%!'AH"c%?78!'
©!$$Ad!'6w!X!,x!'!'$"f36$b?cJ"6()X!6$J!'
'()/!!$}!;$e,
WU 2"6$%!'7"p.6wW7#!WVS%!$¤,$>$h)7e!$'"e&0,‚3,I!$6%!$\X
W $>3$ !
U 9!3$@.
< x!'!'$f
’ 1%?78!',-6%)!'$X
W< $b?!$¤$>S!'(K!\J!O,z!'\2"?%!$!'$"f3,-\J!7 (6A6],6"#3!A2,!'?C",-
!$g!'6e,78!'!C?7#!&]3$e66"p!,j%?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,„
Xin chân thành cảm ơn sự hợp tác của các Anh/Chị!
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
22
MNOPQR
KHẢO SÁT DOANH NGHIỆP
W ?!'4J",9!$$8"!$q3S.0,78,I!$6%!$,j%,e,?%!$!'$"f3!-",$(!'S,e,?%!$
!'$"f36?!'!8"48!'C!$!-""/!'!'C),C!''})'•6l,4"f6$G!cC&],I!$6%!$6?!'
\"f,7y".2",x!'!'$fq)Sv(m?%!$!'$"f3,-6$p,$?4"#66Šcf,$"6"/(,$?7 (6A3$e6
6"p!\C7y".2",x!'!'$f7%!'d.0,!C?„
U 0,78c(}!,$()p!c%?78!',j%?%!$!'$"f36?!'!$g!'!B.' !7})„
< '(K!!$}!c],.2",j%?%!$!'$"f3,$j)#(7#!6w7}(„?%!$!'$"f36?!'!A2,SZ?%!$
!'$"f3,-\J!7 (6A!A2,!'?C"S,GY(%!!$C!A2,S;$(\],Z}!,A$%)6w;$(\],;$e,„
’ ?%!$!'$"f3,-7e!$'"e!$A6$#!C?\X6r!$78,$()/!.x!,n!'!$A;"!$!'$"f.cC.
\"f,,j%!'(K!c%?78!'6?!'?%!$!'$"f3„'(K!c%?78!',n\C.2"„
• v(m?%!$!'$"f3,-6$p,$?4"#6Œ-&],$/!$cf,$!C?;$x!'S'"g%Z?%!$!'$"f36?!'
!A2,\CZ?%!$!'$"f3,-\J!7 (6A6],6"#3!A2,!'?C"„l,4"f6cC6?!'\"f,$536$u\C
7y".2",x!'!'$f„Œ
= '?C"%SZ?%!$!'$"f3,-6$p,(!',53›$G!\X!'(K!'J,a(56a0!'()/!\q6c"f(.C
Z?%!$!'$"f3Zz!'6?!'$?I678!'&9!a(56,j%Z?%!$!'$"f37A`,;$x!'„
| $g!'6"/(,$L!C?7l6%;$"c]%,$+!!'()/!c"f(7 (\C?„}(cC6"/(,$L7 (6"/!.C
Z?%!$!'$"f3!'$s62";$"c]%,$+!!'()/!c"f(7 (\C?3$u,\u$?I678!'&9!a(56,j%.r!$
cC 'r„
#(7A`,6]Z?c]%,$+!Y()#67>!$7 (\C?S'"g%!'()/!\q6c"f(6?!'!A2,\C!'()/!\q6
c"f(!'?I"!$q36$r&iA(6"/!,$?c?I"!C?„
{ ?!'7"X(;"f!6$>6AH!',I!$6%!$!'C),C!'6d!/!'%)'•6S!'()/!6•,$C!'7 (6?!'
$?I678!'&9!a(56;"!$Z?%!$,j%Z?%!$!'$"f3cC'r„
T pZ()6r\C;$x!'!'w!'3$e66"p!$?I678!'&9!a(56;"!$Z?%!$,j%Y(mZ?%!$!'$"f3
6?!''"%"7?I!7%!'Z"*!%&],%!$6%!$'%)'•6$"f!!%)SZ?%!$!'$"f3$A2!'62"y!7>!$
\>6$#6/!6$>6AH!'S6I?c[!'6"!d;$e,$$C!'c}(ZC"4t!',$56cA`!',e,&9!3$@.S,e,
$?I678!'&%(4e!$C!'$%)7 (6A\C?S6"#36$>Sc"/!6u,6(!'%6$>6AH!',e,&9!3$@.
.2"7p;$x!'!'w!'.d8!'6$>3$ !„
WV $"6(!'%6$>6AH!'!$g!'&9!3$@..2"S7J"6A`!';$e,$$C!'.u,6"/(.CZ?%!$!'$"f3
!$•.62"cC%"„
$"$?I678!'d6$>6AH!',I!$6%!$$"f!!%)S&0,‚3c2!!$566e,78!'62"Z?%!$!'$"f3cC'r„
AH!'I"$+,"!$#$C!$3$JK$L"!$
23
MNOPQR
