Externalities
and
Public Goods
18
!"#!$%& '
!"#!$%& '
('( )*+,-
(' ))./0$12
3
45
+6
('7 8$)9-)
(':)*+,- ;<=/,
><*
('? )@<A <<*
('B <9CC
3
('D E,F)2;/<9C
!"#!$%& '
GHIJK
('(
● ! "#L<-.M#<)<*NOP+6
AQ2*+, A)<*NOP+6A
Q$)+$C.+RF;<)5+6
● $ "#%EST#M.U;5F.+RO
.54-) <#T#MP/.U;5FFV.5
.W
●$&'
(
%L<XFA4*NO;<
FA4-)
)
!"#!$%& '
GHIJK
('(
)-)AS;<FA
3
=*
Y9-8A
SZFN[M
A"E \U
FA"
ESA ]< <
F-)
A
,Z<*NO
V.9 R^-
._#=(U#<#8
)`;\F
A"
a_#]=*.W <
=bU#<)`;\
FN[MA
"E
$ "*
+,*
!"#!$%& '
GHIJK
('(
)-)AS;<FA
3
=*
F-)
"8* +R-
4< <c(
-._#>
.+6";<
.+6Wd
;^#8* +R
V+cb -OU
cb.+RN).5--
._#>.+6
Wd;<.+6F
N[MA"E
$ "-./
+,*
0
!"#!$%& '
GHIJK
('(
G-)FS;<FA
3
=*
● 12$ "#%LRFT
A#.V;\>+6$)Q
# e;8$(CT
A##C
3
.U;5
● 12$&'
(
%X R
F)2AM;\ R
F-)A
3
!"#!$%& '
GHIJK
('(
G-)FS;<FA
3
=*
+,*
12$4 "#
Y9-)Z RF
N[MA"Ef \U
RFAd
ES$)]<F <
RF-)A
"f
g#8)(8;\
#8* +R./0
=("8)OUb
* +R8T
A=b
!"#!$%& '
GHIJK
('(
+,*
565
G@.M &N
]=* <#2`
F*#*A;\
F-)A
a+6F*#*
A< <( -)
+\#h+\ ]
;]ij>
$e^*#*$)
7$8*$9:2$49%
(
565
;
!"#!$%& '
)./0$12
3
5+6
('
+,*)
<=#5%
(
>5
"8)*A
3
=*4
<#) <#8#<,.9
F-)A"
` RFk;\F
._9#8Cl#O
U"
"8A
3
=*(.U;5 <
._#b
?
!"#!$%& '
)./0$12
3
5+6
('
m)*
● @#5L<\-R)#<[.+R
n*
+,*
@59:$55
! "#
$%&'
(&)*
+,&' /
01&)23%45
%&),
! &'
67%,&'%
68*
%"0%9
! "#,(
&)%,!
&):;< 01*
!"#!$%& '
)./0$12
3
5+6
('
F)*
●$#5FA#h.U;5)*4<
#)
m)*F)*
+,*0
AB 2$#5
o\ +RC9\-
)<SA
3
F)
p*.V#T
3
;\;A
3
q
8F)*T
3
m
)*O*)[
"8Fr7 <#X#8
*#*;\(:.U;5sU
#8mD.U;5)*
#h<#)
o\F)*<#)<
9.+6F*#*O
Ut[up*#*
/U[9.+6
F*#*Ut[(u
!"#!$%& '
)./0$12
3
5+6
('
+,*3
AB 2@#5*
YF49=)FC
;/F;< RF4;A
3
*#
Cl#Zm)*T
3
F)*9_.+RF
4FU
m)*.+R+F$
.+6F-)A;<
.+6F*#*A <
+U.V*
vw.2#8V(?x
;A
3
.T
3
my.1FN[
C
3
TA#F <W#
)d
EVz+US+
;A
3
).T
3
F)*2
FTA# <W#
)f
m)*;\F)*
!"#!$%& '
)./0$12
3
5+6
('
HOn)*9__+R.+R
● C D # 5 E F F 2 G2 ] V O
n9_.XA5+6.+R2V)<#)
.P])On9#8)*O9_.+R)<
C
3
HOn)*9_.XA5+6-5+6
)-)+U)1^5+6<Oy,;Z9
$1R#M;<+._#4]Vm)*;\ R1F
4]VF)*
7$8*56#5HIJKL*
)
!"#!$%& '
)./0$12
3
5+6
('
#4 CD#5EFF2 G2
+,*
7$8* CD#5EFF2 G29:
M' M$"*
H)4On9__+R)* &N
.M{r\7r{T#(7\7.9T#-
.-?|B.)8WTA##hOnG
.9#8).M=;5F:r}?r%O
!"#!$%& '
)./0$12
3
5+6
('
+,*;
12 #N8 %
(
>5
V +RTA#
41 ].+RNi
~F)2A
"T A+,0
]OU/;\
FN[MA"E
a+6F)i
jA"0
`$V +R1
].+RNi ~*#
+R1*T A
F)ijA
T A
)ij
0
!"#!$%& '
)./0$12
3
5+6
('
L+R)ij)*
A
3
=* < +R#<-.9
FN[C
3
A4;A
3
)
*1 A
3
"E`;\
FA4;A
3
)ij
•"
L+R1 A
3
*
A
3
=*,#8#b€U
+Rp)5
+6+2#(
F< <#TF
Ni ~))2p*#
*);<T)ij\
$ #8V+4N[C
3
#b
)ij
+,*;
12 #N8 %
(
>5
-./
3
!"#!$%& '
)./0$12
3
5+6
('
+,*?
AO2EF:"
q4A
O.+R_l <
.+6S
v
;<.+6
q4)ij <
S
r.
a+6X_A5
+6E <X4.+6
</
d.9)5+6*#C
3
4 <;<._#
2`44
)ij <"
(
AO2EF:"
!"#!$%& '
)./0$12
3
5+6
('
f`;A
3
TF+U
.V4;A
3
*);<
$1$F)ij
/+R9_< - <#
T4)i
j{H
P
.1H
P
•
;<
.+6X{E.1E•
HF44*#
NV• +R4)
1T A"b;< <#*#
+R)4.+R*
+,*?
AOQEF:"-./
AO2EF:"
;
!"#!$%& '
)./0$12
3
5+6
('
G/+\$).[h S$1$F)ij
U*,"‚
"C
3
V$15.+R.+._$1$F)
ij,"‚@#/+R9_< -F$_#
);<kC
3
2 -
oA
3
2 -kC
3
9 pF.+R+FO+U)
"C
3
+6R,$ ;O+UZ)i
jS19# -A
3
=*+\$SA
3
#C
3
+UZ$1R*7.C
3
U$1.[.+R#C*ZX +R
O*k <?D7O#hT#.+R*Y+UZ<
.+RSA
3
Z +RO*.[*#NVƒ(7'O*#
?xY1=* <<V.[1$A
3
#.+Rr#hT#
F.X)
7$8*)RO.C5KG'S
?
!"#!$%& '
8$)9-)
('7
● "#$TY1=*4)<.C
3
4#C
3
<*NOT
3
+6AQ
#T
3
Q$C.+R-);<)5
+6+ -*+,\<*NO
T
3
+6AQ$)
!"#!$%& '
8$)9-)
('7
X1F z;<*+,49
X14#C
3
SCl#p.X6+1<„
o\ +R)* AjX1p.+RF z+#C
3
WX1…
w
p5#O#h#T#
G+;2
3
*.5X1k.W{V$CT#.WA
X14Cl#tEup0 <V +R)*4T#.9
tu†
G9X1O$‡T#Z.+RF, +R)*-
T#.9C
3
;\WX1$C5A4T#+\
G1)*,#8ˆ A
3
<T#ZGT#X14C
_#p <†
YG1\;CQZX1p #82`<-%…
1 1
S E=
1
(1 )
t t t
S E S
δ
−
= + −
2 1
[1 (1 ) (1 ) (1 ) ]
N
N
S E
δ δ δ
−
= + − + − +×××+ −
!"#!$%& '
•$)9-)
('7
HU%
(
*('(†OX1F z+1<6
•~ <(T#X1p A\#8:77D.U;tG1
1•)*,#8<#[#[ZX1pW #8%…
‰(%‰?.U;5u
X1F z;<*+,49
!"#!$%& '
8$)9-)
('7
X1F z;<*+,49
a_N).5N# A
3
#C
3
F)#<Š‹#Œ9~e•
*))5A
3
-4F<T#4r(?A
3
;\)5
A
3
-4F<T#{;A
3
*#X1Cl#
2 99
NPV
( 1.5 .198) ( 1.5 .296) ( 1.5 4.337)
( 1.5 .1)
1
(1 ) (1 )
R
R R
− + − + − +
= − + + + +×××+
+
+ +
f*('OGo+ <#C
3
8T4 [NO1$OG9z
O)Go4F)Š‹#Œj•;& [NO
1$O…G1… <OUZ)X1F z4Cl#p .1
#8U;<2/A
3
-/$1U;Z;2
3
> RF
+U 4;A
3
*#*p \U
)
!"#!$%& '
8$)9-)
('7
●AV%
(
.MC&'
(
FUC
3
<N[C
3
<O*>Z
2
3
.+R{ RF$1+U 8
$C*,A
3
-
o/Akˆ A
3
1$ON[C
3
jC
3
;<
71V†t(uˆ A
3
S$1T+,$1S
tu#8.C
3
-4<N[C
3
t7uˆ A
3
+A6+F<C
3
N[C
3
!"#!$%& '
8$)9-)
('7
L+R$F*N;<)$F<$F
$).[T A.)$_1$ˆ=.[ W
+Ry.1ST@.M4)$F<
$FP)$F<$F$F=_
oO./F;A
3
*#$F*<$Fp < \<+
RF{;A
3
T*#$F*<$Fp$C09?T##<
ƒ/U>
F)*# +R)09~eZ$C„a_* 62€
<•*F))5A
3
-4ƒ RF)#<j
C
3
;<jC
3
O/;<ˆ A
3
1$O)<$1$C
.@~;/)ˆ A
3
.[ij;<)$1=*Z#.+Rq$C.@~
;/>ZW.+RSA
3
;/;O./9 A<W
!
7$8*!E %:W